A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Maybe it is time to talk abortion? Facts: @31% of implanted embryos abort naturally.


Posted: Oct 22, 2012

To put it mildly, we disagree going in. A majority of voters have supported Roe v. Wade as it stands. Many are uncomfortable with the law as it exists and would like it tightened up, limited to earlier term pregnancies. Many others are sure it is murder of babies no matter when performed. Some who believe it is murder nevertheless condone it in certain circumstances, such as for victims of rape or when incest is involved. Some believe no exceptions should be made for the health, and even the life for some, of the mother.

Of special note, there is a significant movement in this election to define personhood as beginning at conception, which is supported by the GOP presidential and vice presidential candidates. Our decision of our next president will likely determine whether Roe v. Wade stands  and whether a definition of a personhood as beginning at conception is adopted.

Let's discuss our views about what a law on this subject should say and what its possible ramifications for men and women might be. 

For instance, in future, what should the penalty be for abortion if it becomes illegal? As Mr. Ryan said, when asked what he felt the penalty should be and dodging a specific answer, "but if it's illegal, it's illegal." 

If life begins under the law at conception: If a woman were ordered to bed by her physician for fear of miscarriage in the 4th month and miscarried after going skiing in the 6th month, should she be charged with manslaughter?

I included the natural abortion data because, in a very real world, we have to consider practical issues. Given that in nature some 50 percent of all fertilized eggs are lost before a woman's missed menses would have given a clue, should the law be able under any circumstance to charge women with manslaughter before them? How much later would be appropriate? Remembering that legal decisions are human products and thus themselves imperfect and frequently very inconsistent.

 

;

Apples and oranges... - SK1

[ In Reply To ..]
Miscarriages happen because of a host of natural causes -- lack of viability of the fetus, inability of the mother to carry, etc. It's not a mechanical disruption of an otherwise viable pregnancy.

Sorry, but it's not a fair comparison.

I agree. Absolutely. But it goes to where we can and should draw a - line under secular law. At conception anyway?nm

[ In Reply To ..]
x

Aren't there more important issues? - sickofhearingabout it

[ In Reply To ..]
Why oh why does this issue have to be brought up at every election??? There are way more important issues in this country that need to be taken care of, i.e. the economy, joblessness, gas prices, etc. How about let's get people working again and not worry about what is going on inside a woman's body. That is up to the individual to decide. Not a bunch of men in suits!!!!

Similar Messages:


20/20 On Med Student Giving Part-time Girl AbortionSep 27, 2013
Guy pre-med, met, went with dancer/stripper type although had long time gal might have wished to marry. The not love of his life got pregnant (dancer lady). She's excited, he's not at all. He is not even taking calls from her. She texts him with the ultrasound pic of already named baby with her at 7 weeks pregnancy. He sets up appointment with her to see his fertility doctor father for check and then the guy steals prescription pad, writes for Cytotec, gives to gal saying she has infec ...

Security Officials See Renewed Interest In Implanted ExplosivesJul 07, 2011
Washington (CNN) -- Terrorists intent on striking commercial aircraft have shown renewed interest in surgically implanting explosives or explosive components in humans to conduct attacks, a U.S. security official tells CNN. The idea of implanting bombs has been discussed in the past, but the United States has obtained fresh intelligence about the desire of terrorists, and there is new intelligence about a possible technique that could be used, according to the official, who declined to e ...

Who Made It About Abortion? Aug 22, 2012
After Republicans regained control in the 2010 elections Troy Newman said: ''I feel like a little boy on Christmas morning -- which package do you open up first?'' said Troy Newman, the leader of Operation Rescue, an anti-abortion group. Already, abortion opponents were considering pressing for new regulations in New Mexico, Iowa and Kansas, where Sam Brownback, the Republican governor-elect, follows Democratic governors who vetoed some abortion limits approved by the Republ ...

The Fight On Abortion Is Not OverJul 17, 2013
Sorry for those of you who believe taxpayers should pay for abortions and believe 26-weeks is still okay. Read this article and tell me you still believe it: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/eye-witnesses-to-abortion-reveal-its-horrors ...

Abortion Pills......Jun 30, 2014
Hobby Lobby does not want to pay for someone's abortion - this is about abortion folks, not about birth control......and it is about freedom to follow one's religious beliefs - do we prevent a certain other religion from taking time off for prayers during the day?  No - because we don't want to infringe upon someone's religion - but somehow because it is the Christian faith in this case - we think it's wrong for them to ask to practice their faith?  This issue ...

GOP Against Abortion, Against Birth Control, AgainstMar 05, 2012
equal pay.  They just want to keep women where they belong...barefoot and pregnant.  ...

If Abortion Becomes Illegal Across The Land.... Nov 24, 2009
should the women and provider/Dr. be jailed, charged with first-degree murder and depending on the state....receive the death penalty?Interesting exchange on yesterday's Chris Matthews show with a Catholic Bishop. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QV7xBh5Q8Lc&feature=player_embedded ...

Abortion Survivor - One Whom Hussain Would (sm)Aug 28, 2012
throw in the trash - launches campaign ad in Missouri.  Good for her!  Hope we see it all over the U.S. ...

Abortion. Can We Really Afford To Be Wrong?Sep 05, 2012
My personal journey to an answer for this difficult question has been neither one of religious discovery nor a form of moral evolution.  It is this conclusion--which, while difficult to come to for me personally as a former pro-choice advocate, has been as inescapable as it has been wrenching: It isn't necessary to argue religion.  It isn't necessary to examine moral systems of thought.  From a purely scientific and medical standpoint, there is absolutely no point in th ...

ND Gov. Approves 6-week Abortion BanMar 26, 2013
It also bans abortions based on genetic defects after the 6-week period. ...

Oregon Abortion Happy LawAug 19, 2017
And Liberal Fascists wonder why no one believes they respect life at any stage!!!  I am sick to death of these murderers, and them using my tax dollars to kill innocent babies.  BTW - since I am sure many will be too lazy to research further, this allows abortions throughout the entire pregnancy, including late term up until delivery.  The Liberal Fascists must be so proud their evil and hatred that is now law for the world to see.  Since the Liberal Fascists think it is okay ...

Abortion :: The Truth Behind Tebow's Tale Feb 01, 2010
The truth behind Tebow's tale The star athlete's "pro-life" story has a dark underbelly By Tracy Clark-Flory APQuarterback Tim Tebow during practiceFor just a moment, forget the debate about whether advocacy ads belong in the year's biggest night in sports. The Center for Reproductive Rights has taken an entirely different tack in fighting Focus on the Family's scheduled Super Bowl spot: Countering the personal anti-abortion tale Tim Tebow and his mother are expected to deliv ...

Let Me See, What Is Your Position On Abortion, Your Postion On Nukes,Mar 31, 2016
How many times can you flip-flop in just a day? ...

Democrats Block 20-week Abortion Ban.Sep 22, 2015
blocked a Republican bill that would ban most abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy. The measure failed to advance in a 54-42 vote, falling short of the 60 vote threshold needed. Democratic Sens. Bob Casey (Pa.), Joe Donnelly (Ind.) and Joe Manchin (W.Va.), who all oppose abortion rights, joined Republicans in voting to advance the bill. Republican Sens. Susan Collins (Maine) and Mark Kirk (Ill.), who support abortion rights, voted against it. The vote comes amid a roiling debate over Pl ...

Our Government, Well, Sucks Big Time. Congress Plays Hooky ALL THE TIME!Oct 16, 2009
I work my butt off for practically pennies and our congress plays hooky? Basically they work 2-1/2 days a week?  FIRE THEM ALL, DANG IT!!!!!  THEY SUCK AT THEIR JOBS!!!! If you call it a job.  Shows a picture of inside congress and guess what?  NOT ONE PERSON AT WORK!  Congress building empty and usually on Thursdays too.  How much do they get paid to work 2-1/2 days a week.  They do not even listen to the PEOPLE.   Congress Plays Hooky on Fridays Despite ...

Santorum: Pre-natal Testing Leads To AbortionFeb 20, 2012
I'm glad Santorum is getting a lot of attention so Americans can see he is friggin nuts. Rick Santorum said on Sunday he believes specific types of pre-natal testing leads to a greater number of abortions. "A lot of pre-natal tests are done to identify deformities in utero and the customary procedure is to encourage abortions," he said. "We know that 90 percent of down syndrome children in America are aborted, so to suggest, where does that come from?" His remarks on CBS's "Fa ...

OK Abortion Law: Details To Be Publicly Posted OnlineOct 15, 2009
Oklahoma Abortion Law: Details To Be Publicly Posted OnlineThe Huffington Post | Elyse Siegel First Posted: 10- 8-09 11:05 AM | Updated: 10- 8-09 03:28 PM A new Oklahoma law requires physicians to disclose detailed information on women's abortions to the State's Department Of Health, which will then post the collected data on a public website. The controversial measure comes into effect on November 1 and will cost $281,285 to implement, $256,285 each subsequent year to maintain. Oklaho ...

No Exception: Banning Abortion For Rape The New RepublicanOct 27, 2012
No Exception Todd Akin and Richard Mourdock aren’t outliers. Banning abortion for rape victims is the new Republican mainstream. By William Saletan|Posted Thursday, Oct. 25, 2012, at 4:18 AM ET Mitt Romney with Richard Mourdock in August Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images. First it was Todd Akin. Then Steve King. Then Joe Walsh. Then Richard Mourdock. One after another, Republican congressional nominees opened their mouths, inserted their feet, and embarrassed ...

To Those Who Are Pro-abortion (incl.late Term Infanticide) (sm)Apr 04, 2013
have you watched the video?  Would you like it posted? ...

Corporate Profits Just Hit An All-Time High, Wages Just Hit An All Time LowJun 22, 2012
Good ol' United Corporations of America!!   ...

Guess Who Likes The GOP’s 20-week Abortion Ban? Women.Aug 05, 2013
[For conservative antiabortionists, I've always said, including here, that antiabortionists could always have saved many of the unborn lives they said they cared about if they'd joined with others to roll abortion dates back, instead of supporting villification and divisiveness. Maybe never too late to change strategy?] From the Washington Post: The war over the “war on women” rages on these days, as Republicans seek to tar Democrats with the scandals of Anthony ...

Perry's Abortion Bill Shot Down By Federal Judge.Oct 28, 2013
“The admitting-privileges provision of House Bill 2 does not bear a rational relationship to the legitimate right of the state in preserving and promoting fetal life or a woman’s health and, in any event, places a substantial obstacle in the path of a woman seeking an abortion of a nonviable fetus and is thus an undue burden to her." ...

New Oklahoma Abortion Law Violates Patient Privacy, Critics ChargeOct 20, 2009
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2009/10/20/new-oklahoma-abortion-law-violates-patient-privacy-critics-charge/   The floor is open for discussion/debate. ...

EBay Refuses Auction For Accused Killer Of Abortion DoctorOct 29, 2009
Online auction house eBay has blocked an auction that would have raised funds for Scott Roeder, the man accused of killing abortion doctor George Tiller in Wichita, Kansas, earlier this year. According to a report at the Kansas City Star, Iowa anti-abortion activist Dave Leach had been organizing the auction, which would have sold off items such as a manual that instructs, among other things, on how to bomb abortion clinics, as well as a prison cookbook written by a person jailed for abortion c ...

Classy Annie Coulter Tweets Rape And Abortion Jokes After Sep 06, 2012
"Bill Clinton just impregnated Sandra Fluke backstage." "They're spicing things up with a live abortion on stage." Any women who thinks this is funny stuff or sees it as an acceptable was to debate these issues, particularly alleged undecideds who assert the DNC is "using" women and making them feel less self-sufficient or "independent," kindly step the right side of the aisle, stay there, take yours just desserts and meet your new mentor, whose line you will be expected to toe...or else! ...

Oregon Just Passed The Free Abortion Bill Along Party LinesJul 06, 2017
The governor is expected to sign it into law. It gives every women in Oregon free abortions, paid by their health care provider (wonder how many will pull out of Oregon now). Insurance companies in Oregon would be required to cover abortions and other reproductive services at no cost to the patient regardless of income, citizenship status or gender identity under a measure approved Wednesday by lawmakers. The Oregon bill is unique in that patients would have access to the procedur ...

First Time Ever (long-time Voter) Had This ProblemFeb 16, 2016
Every one of them has serious flaws, either of character, personality, world view, experience, or philosophy - and in most cases more than one of these - that I simply cannot stomach. In my experience, it's always a choice between the lesser of two evils, but this election cycle seems to have brought out a spectacularly miserable collection of candidates.  And yes, Sanders and Trump supporters, I mean them too - or perhaps especially them too. It looks like I'll be sitting on my ...

People, It's Time - And Way Past Time - To Get Our Together.Jul 19, 2016
If we haven't learned yet not to be drawn into the power struggl in which the parties seek to make us their political pawns, we must learn it now before it's too late.  It's a more perilous world than we have ever known before, and perverts and liars cannot save this nation. #NEVER_PERVERTS_NEVER_LIARS         ...

What A Waste Of Committee Time And This Isn't The First TimeOct 11, 2013
  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=INRV9Jvlkn8&feature=player_detailpage#t=2 ...

The TalkOct 06, 2011
Anybody watch The Talk?  Do you like it now that Holly Robinson Peete and Leah Remini have been fired?  I thought it was great when it first started, the chemistry between the ladies was so fun.  Leah was over the top sometimes but she was funny, interesting and brought a lot to the table, same for Holly.  I can't stand watching it anymore.  Molly Shannon is just plain weird the way she talks with her claw hands.  The woman who sits in Leah's seat has abso ...