A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

No exception: Banning abortion for rape the new Republican


Posted: Oct 27, 2012

No Exception

Todd Akin and Richard Mourdock aren’t outliers. Banning abortion for rape victims is the new Republican mainstream.

149813169
Mitt Romney with Richard Mourdock in August

Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images.

First it was Todd Akin. Then Steve King. Then Joe Walsh. Then Richard Mourdock. One after another, Republican congressional nominees opened their mouths, inserted their feet, and embarrassed their party. Akin, a congressman running for U.S. Senate in Missouri, said rape survivors don’t need abortions because “if it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.” King, an Iowa congressman up for re-election, deflected a question about abortions for 12-year-old rape victims by saying, "I just haven't heard of that being a circumstance that's been brought to me in any personal way.” Walsh, a House incumbent in Illinois, asserted that “with modern technology and science, you can't find one instance” where abortion is necessary to protect a woman’s life or health. “There is no such exception as life of the mother,” Walsh concluded. “And as far as health of the mother, same thing.” Mourdock, the Indiana state treasurer and Republican nominee for U.S. Senate, opined that “even when life begins in that horrible situation of rape, that it is something that God intended to happen."

For Mitt Romney, these episodes have been a two-month headache. First, he had to override Paul Ryan’s opposition to abortions for rape victims. Then he had to apologize for Akin’s comment. Then he had to apologize for Mourdock’s. And the apology tour might be just getting started, because Akin and Mourdock are hardly alone. Their view—that abortion should be prohibited even in cases of sexual assault—isn’t just the party’s official position. It’s the most commonly held position among new Republican nominees for the U.S. Senate.

Thirty-three Senate seats are at stake in this election. Five of them are held by Republican incumbents whose nominations were never seriously contested. In the remaining 28 states, three nominations (ConnecticutHawaii, and Rhode Island) were won by pro-choice candidates. Maine Republicans nominated a guy who said he’s “pro-choice specifically for three reasons: rape, incest, life of the mother.” New Jersey Republicans picked a state senator who advocated “pro-life initiatives” and “reasonable restraints” but said abortion should be legal early in pregnancy and for rape victims. Eight nominations (ArizonaCaliforniaFloridaMontanaNevadaNew MexicoVirginia, andWisconsin) went to candidates who said abortion should be outlawed except in cases of rape or incest. Three (Delaware, Maryland, and Minnesota) went to pro-lifers who haven’t clarified their stance on exceptions. The rest—12 nominations—went to candidates who would ban abortion even for survivors of sexual assault. That’s a plurality of the party’s primaries.

Advertisement

Akin and Mourdock are the best-known cases. But Ted Cruz, the former solicitor general of Texas, also opposesrape exception.* So does Pennsylvania nominee Tom Smith. So does West Virginia nominee John Raese: “I will proudly stand against the destruction of innocent human life unless the life of the mother is in jeopardy.” In Vermont, the state right-to-life committee certified Republican nominee John MacGovern as “fully pro-life.” When MacGovern was asked whether “a woman should be forced by the government to give birth to a rapist’s baby,” he answered: “I’ve always in my career and to this day been loyal to the principle of life. I’m pro-life. I’m profoundly pro-life. I’m pro-life to my core.”

In Nebraska, state Rep. Deb Fischer was pressed for her position on the Republican platform’s call for “a constitutional amendment banning all abortions with no exception for rape or incest.” She responded: “I am pro-life, and I believe in the sanctity of life. I do believe that there should be an exception made for the life of the mother.” In Ohio, state treasurer Josh Mandel rejected a rape exception and declared, “I’ll do everything I can to protect innocent life.” In Michigan, Rep. Pete Hoekstra was asked whether a woman should have to bear her rapist’s child. Hoekstra, who was already on record against a rape exception, replied: "I believe life is a gift.”

In New York, Wendy Long, a member of Romney's Justice Advisory Committee, boasted during her primary that she was “100 percent pro-life,” whereas her opponents would grant “exceptions” to an abortion ban. In Washington, state Sen. Michael Baumgartneradmitted that “rape is a tragedy” but concluded: "I still believe life begins at conception. That is consistent with my Catholic beliefs. And I believe we must protect life." In North Dakota, a reporter asked Rep. Rick Berg: “You would not make an exception for rape?” Berg replied: “No.” The reporter asked about punishment for a woman who has such an abortion: “Should we put her in jail? Should we fine her?” Berg answered: “Those are things that need to be worked out through the legislative process.”

Three of the party’s candidates seem not to have addressed the rape question. Kevin Wade, the nominee in Delaware, has repeatedly said he opposes “taking human life.” Dan Bongino, the nominee in Maryland, opposes federal funding of embryonic stem-cell research and believes “life begins at conception and should be protected.” Kurt Bills, the nominee in Minnesota, reportedly sidestepped a rape question but opposes embryonic stem-cell research and boasts that he’s been a “co-author on every … bill” backed by Minnesota Citizens Concerned for Life. Late Wednesday, Slate reached out to these three candidates to ask about the rape scenario. We haven’t heard back yet. But given what they’ve said already, it’s a good bet that at least one of them would refuse the exception.

Judging by polls, most Republican voters don’t share this view. And I haven’t tried to nail down where the party’s hundreds of House nominees stand. But the Senate numbers are striking. Of the 28 nonincumbent nominees, 12 to 15 share the view of Akin, Mourdock, and the party platform. They believe a rape victim should be forbidden to terminate her pregnancy. This is no longer a fringe position. It isn’t a couple of gaffes by renegade crackpots. It’s the predominant view among Republican nominees for the nation’s highest legislative body. It’s what the Republican Party is.

FWIW, although a liberal and pro abortion in the first trimester, I've never understood the exceptions most so-called "pro-lifers" make for rape, incest, and all but the most grave risks to the mother's health. Early abortion is either murder or it's not. And at some point long before birth it's murder in all cases. So, for this ONE issue, I actually find myself on the same page with these knuckle-draggers.

 

UNFORTUNATELY, what they're really after is erasing the separation of church and state and reversing most of the civil rights advances of the past 50 years, including those for women. And, peculiarly enough, because it's not in either the Old or the New Testament, making sure the interests of the people in general don't get in the way of those of business.

;

Why Thinking Women are Very Concerned (Facts About Rape) - see message

[ In Reply To ..]
Partial list of 50 Things You Didn't Know About Rape... :

Chances that a woman in the U.S. is raped versus gets breast cancer: 2 to 1
Chances that a victim is "Emergency Raped" by a stranger versus percentage of victims who consider their rapes emergencies: 7 percent versus 100 percent
Percentage of victims of rape who report the use of a weapon: 11 percent
Prison sentences for four men found guilty of participating in gang rapes of two teenage girls in France over two years: one year, six months, suspended sentence
State where in 2012 a doctor is facing the loss of her medical license for providing an abortion to a pregnant10-year old incest rape victim: Kansas
Country where doctors (but not the rapist) were excommunicated for performing a life-saving abortion to nine-year-old incest rape victim: Brazil
Country where major party's vice-presidential candidate wants to criminalize all abortions including rape-related ones, because rape is just "another method of conception": U.S.

YES !!! *Some* Christian men and some others seem to think that a little girl should carry her "gift from god" - even if it's her daddy's baby. Neat Trick! I think that Jesus would be ashamed, and I don't mean the guy washing dishes at El Torito...

Similar Messages:


Classy Annie Coulter Tweets Rape And Abortion Jokes After Sep 06, 2012
"Bill Clinton just impregnated Sandra Fluke backstage." "They're spicing things up with a live abortion on stage." Any women who thinks this is funny stuff or sees it as an acceptable was to debate these issues, particularly alleged undecideds who assert the DNC is "using" women and making them feel less self-sufficient or "independent," kindly step the right side of the aisle, stay there, take yours just desserts and meet your new mentor, whose line you will be expected to toe...or else! ...

The Terms "legitimate Rape" Or "forcible Rape" Are Just...smAug 22, 2012
code words to narrow the definition of rape.  These people do not believe married women should have the right to accuse her husband of rape.  Women must just endure and cleave to her husband's desire for his "marital rights".  Rape is rape.  It needs no adverb to define it. ...

Banning Happy Meal ToysApr 28, 2010
What do you think of this county's plan? Happy Meal toys and other promotions that come with high-calorie children's meals will soon be banned in parts of Santa Clara County unless the restaurants meet nutritional guidelines approved Tuesday by the county Board of Supervisors. "This ordinance prevents restaurants from preying on children's' love of toys" to sell high-calorie, unhealthful food, said Supervisor Ken Yeager, who sponsored the measure. "This ordinance bre ...

Republicans For RapeOct 21, 2009
This makes me ill. I know there will be responses on this thread from Republicans who are going to tell me they aren't for rape. Well, 30 of your Senators are! All men, oddly enough. So, what are you going to do about this one? Click here for the video: http://www.themudflats.net/2009/10/2...cans-for-rape/ If you have not heard of the horrible story of Jamie Leigh Jones, a 19-year old woman working for KBR in Iraq, you won’t believe it. She was brutally raped by coworkers, evidence w ...

Ryan: Rape Is Just Another Aug 27, 2012
In an interview with Josh Smith, WJHL-TV out of Richmond, VA, when asked where he stands on the question of legal abortions for rape and incest victims, Paul Ryan replied: "I'm very proud of my pro-life record, and I've always adopted the idea that, the position that the method of conception does'nt change the definition of life."   Lah-dee-dah.  Rape is just another legitimate method of conception.  This should erase any doubts on where he stands, and demolish an ...

Video Regarding Rape And PregnancyNov 01, 2012
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BqeBHTxPkeA&feature=youtu.be ...

Franken's Anti-rape Amendment Becomes LawDec 22, 2009
By Stephen C. WebsterMonday, December 21st, 2009 -- 7:35 pm Over the unexplained objections of 30 Republican Senators, an anti-rape amendment authored by Senator Al Franken (D-MN) became law Monday with President Obama's signature on the Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2010. The provision was sparked by the gang-rape of a 19-year-old Kellogg, Brown & Root employee by her coworkers in Iraq. After returning to the United States, Jamie Leigh Jones found she couldn't sue th ...

Bogus Trump Rape CaseNov 05, 2016
This is a sham lawsuit brought by someone who desires to impact the presidential election. ...

When Does Trump's Rape Trial Begin?Oct 17, 2016
It's not being covered in the media. ...

How Many Clintons Does It Take To Rape An Innocent Woman?Oct 08, 2016
Bill to rape them & Hillary to silence them! ...

CNN And MSNBC Mum On Rape Of 14-year-old GirlMar 23, 2017
I have one word for them. Despicable! It's no wonder the liberals...no, never mind... ...

Article On Media Matters Re: Obsession With RapeNov 20, 2009
There is an article on media matters listing many examples of the right wing commentators obsession with using the word rape to describe government policies. Warning - its rather lengthy reading!  Makes me think back to psychology classes . . . and what this says about such individuals.     ...

Obama 'Redefined Rape' In January 2012Aug 23, 2012
Ryan is being falsely accused of this, but any blame goes to Obama: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/07/us/politics/federal-crime-statistics-to-expand-rape-definition.html http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2012/08/23/Actually-It-Was-Obama-Who-Redefined-Rape ...

GOP US Senate Candidate Thinks Pregnancy From Rape Oct 23, 2012
it just so happens that a few hours before he revealed this in a state candidate debate forum, Mitt Romney voiced his support in a local ad release:  "There's so much at stake, I hope you'll join me in supporting Richard Mourdock for US Senate."  Until today, the race to replace Senator Lugar (who is not conservative enough to suit the Tea Party) was at a stalemate with Mourdock's democratic challenger, Joe Donnelly, having a hairline lead....despite obscene infusions of ...

When Does Bill Clinton's Rape Trial Start?Oct 17, 2016
nm ...

US Soldiers Disciplined For Stopping Rape Of ChildrenSep 21, 2015
My father, who saw some pretty terrible sights during World War 2, used to frequently tell me that bad things happen in war, but I don’t think he ever ran into anything like this. A story breaking over the weekend reveals that our “Afghan allies” have been engaged in a sick practice referred to as “boy play” in the common parlance. This essentially translates into abducting, imprisoning and raping young boys, keeping them as sex slaves. As if that wasn’t shocking enough, it’s appar ...

Bill Maher Defended Statuatory Rape In 1998 OfFeb 23, 2017
having sex with a 12-year-old boy. ...

Afghan Immigrants To Sweden Stream 3-hour Rape Jan 26, 2017
Do what you need to do to keep animals like this out of our country, Mr. Trump. ...

Kathy Shelton Rape Case: Hillary Has No RemorseNov 03, 2016
Kathy Shelton tells her story about how she was raped when she was 12 years old. Hillary Clinton was the attorney for the child rapist. The rapist plea bargained and served less than a year. Hillary says that all survivors of sexual assault deserve to be listened to and believed. There are countless women who accuse her husband, Bill, of sexual assault, and Hillary is an enabler of Bill’s conduct. Hillary has learned to manipulate the law, learned how to use insider allies to help c ...

GOPers Want Franken To Defend Them In Opposing Anti-rape AmendmentDec 04, 2009
By Daniel TencerWednesday, December 2nd, 2009 -- 9:20 pmSome Republican senators are taking heat for voting against an amendment that would allow employees of military contractors to sue their employers if they are raped at work -- and they want the Democratic senator who wrote the amendment to help them fight off the bad publicity. In October, 30 Republicans voted against Sen. Al Franken's amendment to a defense appropriations bill that would de-fund contractors who prevent their ...

Hillary Clinton Is A Liar Claims Child Rape VictimOct 17, 2016
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sJvTPrT4fxs ...

Who Made It About Abortion? Aug 22, 2012
After Republicans regained control in the 2010 elections Troy Newman said: ''I feel like a little boy on Christmas morning -- which package do you open up first?'' said Troy Newman, the leader of Operation Rescue, an anti-abortion group. Already, abortion opponents were considering pressing for new regulations in New Mexico, Iowa and Kansas, where Sam Brownback, the Republican governor-elect, follows Democratic governors who vetoed some abortion limits approved by the Republ ...

The Fight On Abortion Is Not OverJul 17, 2013
Sorry for those of you who believe taxpayers should pay for abortions and believe 26-weeks is still okay. Read this article and tell me you still believe it: http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/eye-witnesses-to-abortion-reveal-its-horrors ...

Abortion Pills......Jun 30, 2014
Hobby Lobby does not want to pay for someone's abortion - this is about abortion folks, not about birth control......and it is about freedom to follow one's religious beliefs - do we prevent a certain other religion from taking time off for prayers during the day?  No - because we don't want to infringe upon someone's religion - but somehow because it is the Christian faith in this case - we think it's wrong for them to ask to practice their faith?  This issue ...

GOP Against Abortion, Against Birth Control, AgainstMar 05, 2012
equal pay.  They just want to keep women where they belong...barefoot and pregnant.  ...

If Abortion Becomes Illegal Across The Land.... Nov 24, 2009
should the women and provider/Dr. be jailed, charged with first-degree murder and depending on the state....receive the death penalty?Interesting exchange on yesterday's Chris Matthews show with a Catholic Bishop. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QV7xBh5Q8Lc&feature=player_embedded ...

Abortion Survivor - One Whom Hussain Would (sm)Aug 28, 2012
throw in the trash - launches campaign ad in Missouri.  Good for her!  Hope we see it all over the U.S. ...

Abortion. Can We Really Afford To Be Wrong?Sep 05, 2012
My personal journey to an answer for this difficult question has been neither one of religious discovery nor a form of moral evolution.  It is this conclusion--which, while difficult to come to for me personally as a former pro-choice advocate, has been as inescapable as it has been wrenching: It isn't necessary to argue religion.  It isn't necessary to examine moral systems of thought.  From a purely scientific and medical standpoint, there is absolutely no point in th ...

ND Gov. Approves 6-week Abortion BanMar 26, 2013
It also bans abortions based on genetic defects after the 6-week period. ...

Oregon Abortion Happy LawAug 19, 2017
And Liberal Fascists wonder why no one believes they respect life at any stage!!!  I am sick to death of these murderers, and them using my tax dollars to kill innocent babies.  BTW - since I am sure many will be too lazy to research further, this allows abortions throughout the entire pregnancy, including late term up until delivery.  The Liberal Fascists must be so proud their evil and hatred that is now law for the world to see.  Since the Liberal Fascists think it is okay ...