A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

"I agree - the Gosnell trial does deserve more coverage...as an indictment of the outcome


Posted: Apr 12, 2013

The Anti-Choice Monster

Blog ››› April 12, 2013 1:28 PM EDT ››› ARI RABIN-HAVT

Kermit Gosnell

Kermit Gosnell, currently on trial for murder, appears to be a monster. There are no adjectives strong enough to describe the horrors that a grand jury says took place at the Women's Medical Society.

In recent weeks, anti-choice media figures have been agitating for more coverage of the Gosnell trial in the mainstream press, hoping to inject into public discourse the idea that all clinics performing abortions are the monstrous dens depicted in stark detail in the grand jury report.

I agree - the Gosnell trial does deserve more coverage. Not as a stain on abortion providers but as an indictment of the outcome if the anti-choice movement achieves its goals. Far from the practices of well-established medical facilities, the Women's Medical Society was the modern-day back alley, like those in the pre-Roe era where desperate women were butchered.

The Women's Medical Society's "real business," the grand jury report explicitly states, "was not health; it was profit. There were two primary parts to the operation. By day it was a prescription mill; by night an abortion mill."

To achieve his ends"Gosnell's approach was simple: keep volume high, expenses low - and break the law. That was his competitive edge."

Conservatives are making the argument that "the reason the media and pro-abortion politicians are ignoring Gosnell's trial is because Gosnell was an abortionist. Seven of his victims were killed after they had been aborted, and one died after she had aborted. Why would people who believe in legalized abortion want to shed negative light on bad things that happen during legalized abortions?"

But these were crimes, not "bad things that happened" within legal structures. What the grand jury established is that Gosnell preyed on poor women, performing illegal abortions in unsanitary conditions. Those on the right have spent ample pixels reciting all the abhorrent practice, but have failed to note the critical component - that the actions they cite are illegal.

Pennsylvania, like other states, permits legal abortion within a regulatory framework. Physicians must, for example, provide counseling about the nature of the procedure. Minors must have parental or judicial consent. All women must wait 24 hours after first visiting the facility, in order to fully consider their decision. But Gosnell's compliance with such requirements was casual at best. At the Women's Medical Society, the only question that really mattered was whether you had the cash. Too young? No problem. Didn't want to wait? Gosnell provided same-day service.

As the anti-choice movement seeks to close the last remaining clinics in North Dakota, Mississippi, Kansas, and Arkansas, the ultimate result of its action will be to drive women into the hands of more Kermit Gosnells.

The fact the right refuses to face is that, as the grand jury explicitly stated, "the real key to the business model, though, was this: Gosnell catered to the women who couldn't get abortions elsewhere."

Those who will be taken advantage of are not the wealthy who can afford to travel to an alternative state where they can receive care, but the low-income who feel trapped by their circumstance. Remove legal and safe options, and women like the victims the right purports to be speaking for will turn to the Kermit Gosnells of the world. And it's the policies of the anti-choice movement that will drive them there.

;

Media Matters - warning......sigh - Anne Hedonia

[ In Reply To ..]
nm

What? YOu don't agree with the content of - the article? You SM

[ In Reply To ..]
don't think this will happen to women if safe legal abortion facilities are closed down? This is the same thinking with abstinence only teaching to young people. Somehow, if we don't teach them about birth control and teach them that the only option is to not have sex, then they won't have sex. No worries, right? Complete lack of common sense.

Similar Messages:


Gosnell Trial - Check Out "media Row" At The Trial. (sm)Apr 12, 2013
This is pitiful - absolutely pitiful.  Don't even bother posting me links to "all over the internet" and "all over the media" coverage it is getting.  Don't waste your time or mine.  This picture says it all.  Link ...

While Ignoring Gosnell Trial, NY Post Condemns 'Liberal Media' Apr 15, 2013
While Ignoring Gosnell Trial, NY Post Condemns 'Liberal Media' For Ignoring Gosnell Trial Blog ››› April 12, 2013 12:06 PM EDT ››› ERIC BOEHLERT Conservative media critics have been adamant this week in accusing news organizations of ignoring the trial of Dr. Kermit Gosnell, who is charged with killing seven babies and a mother. According to the grand jury report, Gosnell  was runn ...

Gosnell Update--judge Dismisses NINE Charges.Apr 23, 2013
I have to say that I know we are all innocent until proven guilty, but I hope this guy goes DOWN in a big way, despite the fact that so many charges against him have been dropped. ...

Gosnell: The Untold Story Of America's Most Prolific Jan 26, 2017
Later this year, producers Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinny (FrackNation) and director Nick Searcy (Justified) will bring the story of notorious Philadelphia abortionist Kermit Gosnell to the big screen. Gosnell — who has been called America’s “most prolific serial killer” — operated what the 300-page grand jury report later called a “baby charnel house,” in which he regularly killed babies born alive at his clinic, which itself was staffed with inexperienced nurses and littere ...

GOSNELL Found Guilty On 3 Counts 1st Degree MurderMay 13, 2013
One not guilty and 1 involuntary manslaughter. I thought there were only 4 murder counts of the babies, but these counts add to 5 babies. Don't know about the woman unless that's the manslaughter count.  ...

No Prediction As To Mid-term Outcome--Oct 16, 2014
These senate races are really close.  I got this article in my news feed and figured it might be of interest to me, but probably not a lot of people, but it really caught my eye when it opened with   The Libertarian in Iowa Senate race died in airplane crash....could change the election results.  Reading on, I saw how close many of these elections really are.   So, anyway, I will leave the predictions of winning and losing to the pros, but I predict recounts!   htt ...

No Indictment!Nov 24, 2014
Double YAY!! Let's move on and let there be peace. ...

For Those Mourning The Outcome Of Yesterday's ElectionNov 07, 2012
Turn off Fox and turn on your brains. It really isn't as bad as you think. Untwist the lies and manipulations and you will find a middle-of-the-road president who represents all of us -- conservatives, liberals, moderates -- to the best of his ability, with the aid (or hindrance) of the House of Representatives and Senate. People need to stop clinging to the ridiculous falsehoods that Obama is a socialist (or communist or terrorist or whatever the latest figment of someone's imaginati ...

Would The Petraeus Affair Have Affected Outcome Of The Election If Nov 13, 2012
it had been public knowledge before the election?  What a huge scandal to have surfaced immediately after the election! ...

Excellent Outcome Over The Behar Calling Angle NamesOct 27, 2010
This was an excellent article.  Behar went way too far.   http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/5943062/joy_behar_on_sharron_angle_behar_lacks.html?cat=2     ...

Fox News Apologizes For Falsely Reporting Clinton Faces IndictmentNov 05, 2016
Trump has repeated this false story numerous times   see link ...

THEY Deserve A Vote!!!!Feb 12, 2013
You tell it Mr. President! Also:  No person who works full-time in this country should have to live in poverty.     ...

Obama To Americans: You Don't Deserve To Be Free!Jan 01, 2014
http://www.forbes.com/sites/harrybinswanger/2013/12/31/obama-to-americans-you-dont-deserve-to-be-free/   Obama To Americans: You Don't Deserve To Be Free   President Obama’s Kansas speech is a remarkable document. In calling for more government controls, more taxation, more collectivism, he has two paragraphs that give the show away. Take a look at them.   there is a certain crowd in Washington who, for the last few decades, have said, let’ ...

Do LGBTQ Students Deserve Protection From Jul 14, 2015
All but a few Republicans voted no. The Democrats all voted yes. Democrats human---for the most part Republicans inhumane. http://www.thenewcivilrightsmovement.com/davidbadash/did_your_us_senator_just_vote_to_allow_lgbt_students_to_be_bullied_here_s_the_list ...

Hillary Doesn't Deserve Americans' AdmirationJan 13, 2013
Americans, Gallup tells us, admire Hillary Clinton more than any other woman in the world -- again. This latest accolade marks the 17th time Gallup has found Clinton to be the Most Admired Woman (MAW?) since she became first lady nearly 20 years ago. Only Eleanor Roosevelt (13 MAWs) comes close. Only Mother Teresa (1995 and 1996) and Laura Bush (2001) have interrupted Clinton’s winning streak, and even then, Clinton came in second. And therein lies America’s cosmic flaw. A country t ...

Edwards TrialApr 12, 2012
Let the games begin!  The former VP candidate and poster boy for the Democratic party (whew-that was a close one, huh?) finally gets his day in court.  http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/jury-selection-set-begin-john-edwards-trial-16122251#.T4cMaVst3Sg Jury Selection Under Way in John Edwards Trial After years of investigation, denials and delays, jury selection began Thursday for the criminal trial of former presidential candidate John Edwards. Edwards sat at the defense table a ...

Zimmerman Trial.Jun 30, 2013
Okay, he had no right that I know of to shoot this man, but I'm so sick of them trying to make Trayvon out to be a good kid when he was in a gang, sold drugs, fighting was his favorite pasttime and he had been expelled from school many times.  Why are they not allowing his past into court? ...

Casey Anthony TrialMay 30, 2011
They did a whole day of going over the trial and testimony on HLN today.  Just wondered if anyone here buys the defense story that the child drowned in the pool but because Casey was sexually abused by her father she showed no emotion and did not report it. Watching her string of lies, theft and partying, I can't imagine how she is going to get out of this even if a member of the jury believes her behavior was because of sexual molestation by her father.  Wha ...

Navy Seals Being Put On Trial?Nov 25, 2009
Just caught a bit of this story. They arrested a terrorist and he's claiming they punched him? Now they are on trial????? Where's the justice??? This is the type of lop-sided politics that is killing our country. As for the Gitmo trials, they don't belong in NY. They weren't arrested in NY. They were arrested in another country by the military. U.S. Law does not cover this. Military law does. They are being held in a military prison  Read up on it. They should go to tri ...

Unfit To Stand Trial, Yet Fit To Have A Gun?May 29, 2011
arlier today, Jared Loughner, a troubled young man who is accused of shooting 20 innocent people, including my colleague, Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, was found unfit to stand trial for his actions. Mr. Loughner's mental and emotional troubles have been well documented and were well known among classmates, professors and acquaintances well before Mr. Loughner opened fire on that fateful January day. Yet, despite the belief that Mr. Loughner could be a danger to himself and others, our fe ...

Casey Anthony TrialJul 04, 2011
This trial has just been going on too long.  As with so many sensationalized things these days (too much in my opinion) it is just going on and on and on too long, with the hopes that a reasonable doubt is created on the part of the defense.  I  have tried to catch a bit of testimony on a daily basis, though I have not allowed my life to revolve around this case.  I have just wanted to see what evidence each side had and how it was presented and form in my own mind whether or ...

Any Other Arias Trial Followers?May 02, 2013
So, besides "I'm a mom again!" from the gardening/bird thread below and myself, has anyone else been following the State of Arizona versus Jodi Arias trial?  If so, I'd love to hear everyone else's thoughts now that the trial is wrapping up with closing arguments.   ...

Now That The Zimmerman Trial Has Started, I'm (sm)Jun 24, 2013
O should have kept his comments to himself.  His goal is always to incite.  ...

Trump Pays Rather Than Going To TrialNov 18, 2016
Trump pays 25 million in settlement for Trump University fraud. I guess that's better than being a president on trial for fraud eh? ...

Casey Anthony Trial SurveyJun 06, 2011
Following this trial and listening to commentary there is very little doubt it seems that Casey Anthony murdered her child and disposed of the body. I think a lot of the bias is because she is a pathologic liar.  Aside from the lying can anyone take a leap and think she may not be guilty of murder or that the state is not proving it beyond a reasonable doubt? Does anyone believe she was molested by her father/brother which caused her psychopathic lying? I heard Geraldo Rivera comment ...

Anyone Know If Casey Anthony Trial Is On TV Today? May 25, 2011
? channel ...

Reached A Verdict In The Trial Of The Century Jul 05, 2011
Waiting for parties to return to court house to read the verdict.  Tune in.    I think guilty but no death penalty.   She will be awful lonely for the rest of her life as she will not make it in general population.  What do you think?  ...

To Anyone Who Watched Anthony Trial TodayJun 24, 2011
He wasn't invited to a baby shower so he didn't go to the hospital?  And he is still fretting about it enough to cry on the witness stand in front of millions of viewers?  Gah.  Lee is very weird, although I guess I should have expected as much coming out of that environment.  I just didn't realize it till today. ...

Question About Casey Anthony TrialJun 23, 2011
In reading the posts below regarding the prosecution's case and the duct tape as the murder weapon, I recalled seeing last night that a syringe was found, I believe with Caylee's remains, and it contained a mixture of chloroform and something else . . . can someone please fill me in on this?  It seems like it was a hormone mixed with chloroform, but I cannot remember, and I'm also thinking this information just came to light (to the public) when presented in co ...

Casey Anthony Trial In My Dreams. Jun 19, 2011
This is the most fascinating trial I have ever followed and apparently millions are watching to see what happens to this crazy lady because there are reruns of the trial and commentary on the trial almost 24-7. The trial has infiltrated my dreams last night and I need for her to go away but can't look away while the trial is going on. My questions Did she kill her child?  Why?  Did the child drown and she and her father covered it up?  Why?  Did her father ...