A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

I have a friend who had a birthday \"dinner\" for her


Posted: Mar 28, 2011

20yo son.  I\'m not family or anything.  I know her from high school and we occasionally socialize.  She has these parties every year for him like he\'s still 5 years old.  My 19yo son attended these parties when both boys were kids, but refuses to go now because he said it is odd and the boy is odd because he\'s not embarrassed that \"his mommy is still throwing him birthday parties.\"  My son and my friend\'s son have never been good friends.  We live in two different towns, so they didn\'t go to school together and they never really gelled.  And truthfully my friend\'s son is an odd duck.  He has no friends, doesn\'t date, and spends all of his time hanging out with his mom and dad.  My friend still sends out pictures of him to all her friends like he\'s a child.  It\'s bizarre.

I too think it is strange to have a party inviting people outside of your family to come expecting them to give gifts.  I mean I still have cake and ice cream for my son and sometimes we have family birthday dinners that we invite the grandparents to, but that\'s basically it. 

This boy is 20 freaking years old!  His mom invited family, but she also invited a bunch of her friends and her husband\'s friends, who don\'t have kids that actually grew up with her son or even know her son.  She also actually told people when she invited them that money and gift cards would make great gifts!  Well, I decided since my son was not going to come with me to this party, I wasn\'t going to go.  So I called her up and told her I wasn\'t coming to which she said \"Oh that\'s okay, you can just mail him a card.  He\'s happy with just a gift card to Wal Mart.\"  I told her I was sending him a birthday card and ONLY a birthday card.  And she instantly got very snippy, saying \"Ohhhhkaaaay, I guess if that makes you feel good.\"  What the heck does that mean?  

Am I wrong here?  Does anyone else think first it is odd to have these birthday parties for your 20yo son and extremely rude to expect people to bring money or gift cards?  I think she should limit these birthday parties to family only.  Or maybe I\'m just being a bwitch. 

;

To each their own - anon

[ In Reply To ..]
Do I think it's odd for her to throw a party for her son (at any age) - No. I would't do it, but then again I hate throwing parties. This is obviously her tradition if she's done it for 20 years. Let it be.

Now, do I think it's rude for her to instruct people on gifts - Absolutely! If that's the only reason she's inviting all these people is to get a bigger pile of gifts, then yes I'd certainly pass on the party & the gift. Is it odd - no. Rude - yes.

see message - anon2

[ In Reply To ..]
Personally, I think you are being very judgmental. What do you care if she has birthday parties for her son? It's none of your business and your post is bordering on implying their relationship with their son is obscessive or worse. Maybe she only got "snippy" when she sensed your attitude. It sure oozes out of even this post. ugh!

I don't think it's weird, unless she has a clown - Kendra

[ In Reply To ..]
If she wants to have a birthday party for her son, so be it. Why do you care? If you don't want to go, you don't have to. If you don't want to send a gift, you don't have to. If you want to go without a gift, you can do that, too. I do think it is a little strange that it bothers you so much, but to each their own.

LOL - just had a picture in my mind of an adult having - a clown at a b-day party

[ In Reply To ..]
Nothing surprises me anymore. Maybe the parents just want everything they can for their son. Who knows. If it were me I just wouldn't go.

If that is their family tradition, who are you to - sm

[ In Reply To ..]
say anything?? You and/or your son are not required to go, so drop it.

Re: ''I have a friend...." - mtinvt60

[ In Reply To ..]
It is always a pleasure to have birthday parties for both my grown (30-something) kids. (Guests are welcome with or without gifts, though.) What a strange, bitter attitude and post yours is. Proves that old saying: ''With friends like that, who needs enemies!''

Similar Messages:


Birthday PartyDec 11, 2009
My son, who is turning 14 on Sunday, invited 12 of his friends from school over tonight for a sleepover pizza/birthday party.  I figured that out of the 12 he invited, at least a few wouldn't be able to make it.  The last few years he has only invited 6 or 7.  Can you believe that all 12 showed up!  The noise level is ridiculous, but everybody is having a lot of fun.   Gonna go take some pictures in a minute.      ...

Clinton's BirthdaySep 04, 2016
Her birthday, incredibly, is October 26.  She just might end up with one whopping big birthday present.  Karmic upheaval for sure. ...

Birthday Month!Aug 03, 2010
Three of my kids celebrate birthdays this month. One turns 14, one 11 and one 4. It is like Christmas time around here. lol... Where does the time go? ...

Happy Birthday, Aug 04, 2012
May your 51st bring you the best belated B-day gift ever....many happy election returns this fall, all wrapped up neat and tidy in a big shiny blue satin bow.     ...

Okay, How About Best Birthday Suprise!Sep 13, 2012
xx ...

Today Was My BirthdayApr 16, 2014
Here's how my b-day went. Got up early to work.  Had work today, so not complaining about that, but was working on my b-day, instead of doing something nice for me.  I sat and thanked God at least I had work, and told myself its just another day. Then taxes were due.  We owe.  Lovely! Husband slept all day.  While I'm glad I had work, I would have loved to be sleeping all day.  Heard him snoring all the way to the other side of the house.  Lovely! ...

Happy Birthday To Someone Deceased- I Just Jan 19, 2010
Reading the obit column this morning from my home town. There was a lady who was killed about a month or so ago. She must have been well loved because so many have posted about her. This morning I am reading again and she is wished a "Happy Birthday." i see this time and time again in the papers and wondering, how do you have a happy birthday when deceased? I think writing something in rememberence about the person a much better way than wishing them a happy. ...

Grandchild's Birthday DilemaFeb 16, 2010
My son and DIL want to have my their son's third B-day party at my home this year.  This is the first time that I have my g-baby in town (they are a military family) for his birthday and I am going all out.  My daughter is coming in to town too, so it's doubly sweet for me as both my son and daughter hardly ever are able to visit at the same time.  I'm so excited, BUT... my very estranged ex also lives in my town.  He is a pot head, big drinker, crude, rude, c ...

PWOP Birthday PartyMay 29, 2011
Recently My Granddaughter who is now 20 attended a PWOP birthday party where everyone paid for their own food. Most birthday patys I know of, no matter what the age, the host/hostess provides the food.Have You done it? heard about it? what do You think?I guess I still have a lot of my Mother inside of me. She would have Never ask nor accepted money for a "social " get togther. She would have said "Bless Your heart, You keep it Yourself", this is My party.She told me that PWOP stands for "Party W ...

Bloomberg's Birthday PresentFeb 14, 2013
Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz introduced Mayor Bloomberg for his annual State of the City address. In honor of Bloomberg's birthday: "And that’s what makes today so hard, what do you get the man who has everything? Everything – I thought long and hard. A cake? Mayor, I tried to bring a cake from Junior’s but they wouldn’t let me. A bottle of wine? I can’t afford what you drink. Nets tickets? Guess what, he’s already got a box. A plane ride? Hey, he flies himself ...

Happy Birthday, President Obama!Aug 04, 2011
nm ...

Birthday Party Etiquette For Twins. Nov 06, 2010
My daughter was invited to a birthday party for twins.  Each girl was allowed to invite two friends to the party.  So my daughter was invited by one of the twins.  My question is this, am I obligated to get both girls a present or just the one that invited her? ...

Ann Romney's Early Birthday PresentApr 17, 2012
I feel so soiled. The TV said Mrs. Rmny was delighted when she attacked her. Why do  the politician not just say what they think.  It is like your husband. You always have to guess what he really wants because when you ask he says everything is fine   ...

Gift Ideas For Little Girl's First Birthday? - SmMar 12, 2013
My friends' little baby girl is having her first birthday next month, and I was invited to her birthday bash!  I don't have kids, and am pretty clueless as to what would be a good gift idea for her.  Does anyone have any ideas for something that would be fun (and safe!) for Baby, and/or useful for Mom?  Or something for both of them?  Meerkat =^..^= ...

Today Would Have Been My Husband's 66th Birthday.Nov 11, 2013
I've been sitting her bawling all night, crappy job, crappy life.  Can't wait to retire, just over 2 years to go but who's counting. ...

Does Anyone Have A Good Birthday Cake From Scratch Recipe?Dec 22, 2010
Hi All - I'm looking for a birthday cake recipe, white or chocolate - doesn't matter, for my mother's birthday this weekend.  Does anyone have any that are relatively easy for someone who has never baked a birthday cake (not even from a box!) in her life?  Frosting suggestions welcome also! Thanks in advance for any help with this one!  It's been so crazy around here that I forgot to order one.  Call me the terrible daughter. ...

Ideas For 60th Birthday Special For HubbyJan 20, 2013
Let me give some background on this guy. He is a very shy, not wanting to have surprises, do not buy him anything stay in the background type of person. He is turning the big 60 at the start of this next month. We go out to dinner quite frequently. He does love food and good food, not your average McDonald's or Burger King type man. He really has no special restaurant he likes above others although we both like Carrabba's. I would like to have something a little different than our usua ...

Happy 30th Birthday, Central AmericanJul 17, 2014
It's been fun to watch the media discuss the border crisis in real time, improvising their arguments on the fly. Let's try A, and if that doesn't work, we'll try B. First, they said there was no surge at the border -- it was a phony crisis manufactured by the Drudge Report. The facts on the ground quickly made that argument inoperable. Next, liberals told us these "undocumented migrants" (the PC phrase for "illegal aliens" -- because we'll never figure out what t ...

What's For Dinner?Oct 09, 2011
Today we're having Italian stuffed peppers in the crockpot and potatoes.  Not sure yet if I want baked, mashed or fried potatoes.  I made pumpkin cookies earlier and am getting ready to frost them.  I love the smell of cooked peppers! What's for dinner in your home? ...

Mmm DinnerFeb 19, 2015
"Hamburger Helper" actually came up on VR for a suicidal patient.  The doc has a heavy accent  and I actually have no idea what she is saying but I know it's not THAT.   ...

Bakers Refused To Make Pro-Trump Birthday Cake ForAug 08, 2017
A boy whose letter to President Trump made national headlines last month reportedly wanted a pro-Trump cake for his birthday party, but his mother was unable to find a baker willing to fulfill the order. At the July 26 White House press briefing, Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders read a letter from a boy named Dylan who said Mr. Trump was his favorite president. When she later released the letter publicly, the boy’s last name was blacked out. The only identifying clue was that everyone ...

Thanksgiving DinnerNov 18, 2010
Do you have a dish you serve that is traditional for your family but not your typical run-of-the-mill Thanksgiving fare?   Looking forward to next Thursday.   ...

Whats For Dinner?Apr 24, 2010
With a big skillet of Spanish rice in progress, I'm gettin' a Texas-size hankering for some beefy, cheesey stuffed bell peppers.  It never has made much sense to me to put rice over rice, so I don't want to use rice in the stuffing mix.  Does anyone know if cheese by itself can serve as the only recipe binder?  I'm not crazy about the texture eggs produce either and do not plan to use bread crumbs.  I like the middle of the peppers to be on the ...

Looking For Dinner Idea - Here's What I've GotAug 24, 2013
I'm looking to make something for dinner and at a loss for ideas.  I've got a zuccini from my garden and a little bit of brocoli left.  We were sauting the zuccini and brocoli in olive oil, garlic and basal (yum). Other stuff around my house is I've got rice, a couple potatoes.  Got cans of various kinds of beans (cannoli, white, kidney, pinto, garbanzos, and black) and I've got cans of tomatoes.  I've also got some tortillas (flour and corn).  ...

Happy 68th Birthday Tomorrow To Daryl Hall, Still My Fave! NMOct 10, 2014
nm ...

OMG! Alfred E. Smith Dinner....Oct 18, 2012
If you didn't see the candidates' speeches, do yourself a favor and find the video.  It just aired, so I doubt it's on-line yet or I'd post a link. Both of them were terrific and funny. Please, no snarks or jabs.  They came together for a good cause.  Let's just enjoy it for what it was. Thanks for the laughs, fellas! ...

Ambassador Of Libya Having DinnerOct 29, 2012
On the night that Ambassador Chris Stevens was killed he had just finished having dinner with the Turkish diplomat to Libya   http://www.examiner.com/article/newly-disclosed-cia-intel-disputes-white-house-account-of-libyan-attack ...

Same Old Turkey Dinner Every Year.Nov 13, 2012
Every year I make turkey, dressing, sweet potatoes, green bean casserole, deviled eggs, cranberry sauce, homemade bread and pumpkin pie.  The daughters will bring another dessert or two.  These are all traditional foods that my family enjoys, but I am so bored with it.  I need some new, fresh, and different ideas.  Even if I did something different with the beans or potatoes.  Maybe a fruit salad? I still want some of the traditional foods, but does anyone have any idea ...

What Are You Making For Dinner Tonight?Jul 29, 2013
I'm totally tapped out of ideas for dinner.... Who has some yummy plans? ...

Having Guests For Christmas Dinner, Do Not NormallyNov 10, 2015
to get some ideas about easy to fix, non-fill up items we might have prior to the dinner. We have had company arrive before, nothing fixed and dinner not completed so this year will go with appetizers. Ideas, recipes welcomed. ...