A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Raising the Medicare eligibility age would cost patients about twice as much,


Posted: Dec 6, 2012

"When economists and policymakers worry about the long-term fiscal crisis, what they’re mostly worried about is Medicare. That’s why a persistent idea during this fiscal cliff season is raising the Medicare eligibility age from 65 to 67.

It’s an idea that appears superficially to have many virtues. Bringing the Medicare retirement age into line with the Social Security retirement age seems logical. The change is simple to describe to journalists and the public." 

 

Unfortunately it’s also a terrible idea that cloaks a staggering giveaway to hospitals, doctors, and other health care providers.

The Kaiser Family Foundation has found that lifting the eligibility age from 65 to 67 would reduce federal spending by about $5.7 billion in its first year of full implementation. But that would be offset by $11.4 billion in spending by other parties. That includes $3.7 billion in higher costs for 65- and 66 year-olds, $4.5 billion from employers through company-sponsored insurance, $0.7 billion from state governments, and $2.5 billion in higher average prices for third parties once younger seniors are shifted out of the Medicare risk-pool and into the general population  [i.e., everyone's group policy premiums go up].

That’s an absurd means of saving the fderal government money—akin to raising $12 billion in taxes and then setting half the money on fire. The only people who actually benefit from this shift are health care providers who get to charge higher prices to 65- and 66-year-olds."

 

"There are two separate fiscal issues around the government and health care spending. One is the scope of the government’s responsibility for footing the bill for health care financing. The other is the price the government has to pay for the health care services it’s responsible for financing. Conservatives often imply that government health care spending is expensive because the government is somehow purchasing inefficiently or offering bloated benefits. This fits well with stereotypes about public sector waste and thus plays to popular prejudice. But it ignores the big reality about government health care purchases, which is their enormous scale. Medicare, in particular, is the biggest bulk buyer of health care services in the country, and so the fees it offers health care providers are much lower than what normal insurance companies pay.

Why do providers put up with those stingy payments? For the same reason any vendor offers discounts to any bulk purchaser: volume. In big, rich cities, it’s not all that unusual for some providers to eschew Medicare patients and simply fill their dockets with better-paying private customers. But the vast majority of doctors, hospitals, imaging centers, and other providers need those patients. There are a lot of old people in America, and old people consume a lot of health care services. So when Medicare offers the health care industry a low-margin payment and huge scale, most providers have no choice but to say yes.

That’s why raising the eligibility age is such a poor policy. Moving a patient off the Medicare rolls and onto the private market doesn’t just shift costs from the government to the patient. It also entails a massive increase in costs."

;

interesting points - thanks for posting

[ In Reply To ..]
I am not happy with changing the eligibility age. I don't believe we will see true progress in affordable healthcare until we reign in the private insurers. I don't believe the cost of private insurance will ever go down, and it is currently untenable.

Agree. Plus, any profit system that depends on people getting sick - then getting as cheap care as possible...nm

[ In Reply To ..]
x

I may be naive but my greatest hope is that...sm - VTMT

[ In Reply To ..]
one of the effects of Obamacare will be healthier people because everyone is covered and focus is directed more to preventative care. It will be interesting to see how everything will shake out with Obamacare over the next several years.

Why? They'll be under ObamaCare until they're of eligible age for Medicare - Truthhurts

[ In Reply To ..]
unless Kaiser if thinking ObamaCare is going to be repealed.

Obamacare was a compromise with Pubs. Hope is competition - by government-backed insurance will impact

[ In Reply To ..]
premiums and coverages, but most will still have private, for-profit insurance through their employers. NOT some Medicare equivalent.

I personally plan to qualify for federally sponsored insurance, as soon as it's available in my state, if I have to quit my current employer and go to work for a smaller company that doesn't offer insurance. No sacrifice there, believe me.

Either way, under Obamacare, prepare for long waits, - doctor shortages, a big mess... guaranteed.nm

[ In Reply To ..]
nm
no reason to believe that will be the case - (just folklore)
[ In Reply To ..]
EXACTLY! - nm
[ In Reply To ..]

Similar Messages:


President Obama Says No To Raising Medicare EligibilityFeb 11, 2013
This is a National Journal (a moderate Washington insider publication) article on the "sausage-making" side of this issue, the maneuvering--not the socioeconomics of it. The people who read this journal also read many others, and it's not the last word on anything, but I thought the "what's going on here?" is interesting as part of an ongoing series of maneuvers. It's worth noting that an eligility age increase could be put right back on the table just as quickly. Also, the "chai ...

Medicare Patients...bringing This To The TopJan 06, 2010
In response to a post well below this..... http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2010/01/06/medicare_and_the_mayo_clinic/ Yes, fact is many places are not accepting Medicare patients and it will get worse. This is an opinion piece, but one cannot argue the FACT that Mayo Glendale has stopped accepting Medicare patients as have many other facilities and that the number will continue to grow with the passage of the reform. What will happen to our country's senior ...

Uh-oh - Walmart Raising Cost Of Healthcare. (sm)Nov 12, 2012
Healthcare costs will go up between 8% and 36%.  Obamacare will save us money - sure it will.   Gullible people - who voted for this liar?  Not me. Link ...

Medicare Fines Hospitals For Too Many Re-Admitted PatientsOct 01, 2012
Is this how Obamacare is going to "pay for itself?" What about those complications that are not the hospital's fault? How are they going to rate which complications are due to hospital care and which are due to patient noncompliance? I would think this is a really tough decision to make. _______________ WASHINGTONIf you or an elderly relative have been hospitalized recently and noticed extra attention when the time came to be discharged, there's more to it than good customer service. ...

Kaiser Study: Romney/Ryan Privatized Medicare Would Cost 6 Out Of 10Oct 22, 2012
From U.S. News and World Report: "Nearly six in 10 Medicare recipients would pay higher premiums under a hypothetical privatized system along the lines of what Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney has proposed, according to a study released Monday. The report by the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation also found striking regional differences that could lead to big premium hikes in some states and counties. That finding instantly made it ammunition in the presidential campaign. ...

Shocking Info RE Obama's EligibilityJul 02, 2011
Riveting info in this video.  Spread it far and wide!! ...

Anybody Ever Pray For Patients?Apr 08, 2012
I do reports for a big hospital in the midwest and see a lot of cancer reports, anorexia, car accidents and sometimes I just feel so overwhelmed by it that I have to stop and pray for the people in the  report. I don't know if this helps them, but it makes me feel less depressed.  Anyone else do this?    ...

Do You Pray For The Patients?Jan 09, 2011
I sometimes find the patient's I type for in very sad situations and cannot help but stop in my tracks and offer a prayer for them. Other times, sad or not, I just feel compelled to stop and pray for them. ...

Does Anyone Pray For The Patients.Jul 30, 2014
Sometimes I get so touched by some of these reports that I have to stop and pray that the Lord will heal these patients and give peace of mind to the families who are going through such heart wrenching times with a loved one. Especially touching are the young ones going through cancer treatments or trauma. Sweet babies. ...

ASR Blooper.....doc Who Gets WAY Too Friendly With His Patients.Jul 06, 2013
ASR put "The next patient is ON MY KNEE". Doc was actually dictating the patient's name. ...

Obamacare Funding Running Low For Patients Feb 16, 2013
Tens of thousands of Americans who cannot get health insurance because of preexisting medical problems will be blocked from a program designed to help them because funding is running low. Obama administration officials said Friday that the state-based “high-risk pools” set up under the 2010 health-care law will be closed to new applicants as soon as Saturday and no later than March 2, depending on the state. But they stressed that coverage for about 100,000 people who are now enrolled ...

Insulin Therapy Beneficial To Alzheimer's PatientsSep 13, 2011
Intranasal insulin therapy appears to provide some benefit for cognitive function in patients with amnestic mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer disease Funding for this study has been provided by the National Institute of Aging, the Nancy and Buster Alvord Endowment and the Department of Veterans Affairs. (the NIA is a division of the National Institute of Health, a government program, as is the DoVA). I wonder how many people realize that important studies like this are done by our F ...

Critical Physician Shortage Already. Plus 30 Mil More Patients Under Obamacare.Dec 13, 2012
From the AMA's amednews.com: (Where will your doctor be next year?) Will a “silent exodus” from medicine worsen doctor shortage? Many physicians, nervous about the impact of health system reform and dispirited by trends in medicine, are exploring career options that involve treating fewer patients. By KEVIN B. O'REILLY, amednews staff. Posted Oct. 8, 2012.  Frustrated by mounting regulation, declining pay, loss of autonomy and uncer ...

Doctors Required To Ask Patients About Their Sexual HistoryOct 15, 2013
It'll be a cold day in hell before I tell ovomit and his satanic HHS director Sebelius anything about my sex life.  Doctors are now required to document in the health record how many sexual partners a patient has had.  I go back and forth between saying "Oh, maybe 37,000" and "none of the F-ing government's business."  Ovomit has gone past the point of no return with his total intent on turning America into a socialist or even communist country. http://politix.topix.com ...

Frustrated Patients Walk Out Of Hospitals WITHOUT TreatmentJan 04, 2014
Knew it would not be if, but when. 'They had no idea if my insurance was active or not!': Obamacare confusion reigns as frustrated patients walk out of hospitals without treatment http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2532869/They-no-idea-insurance-active-not-At-Virginia-hospitals-Obamacare-confusion-reigns-frustrated-patients-walk-out.html ...

Doctors Begin To Refuse ObamaCare PatientsAug 08, 2014
"Obamacare plans have shrunk payments t physicians so much that some doctors say they won’t be able to afford to accept Obamacare coverage.  Many of the 8 million sign-ups in Obamacare exchanges nationwide already face more limited choices for physicians and hospitals than those in the private insurance market. But with low physician reimbursement rates, the problem could get even worse." This is just ONE of many Obama headlines today.  Is anyone surprised? ...

Question About Raising ChickensMay 07, 2011
I have always wanted to have a small farm where we could grow/sell plants/vegetables, among other things and have a place with chickens.  I am just curious to know how much it would cost to raise maybe half a dozen or so chickens.      ...

Landmark Ruling May Ensure Poor Patients Around The World Will Apr 01, 2013
BIG ONE FOR THE GOOD GUYS! Wish we wore the white hats here, but hopefully we'll follow. Contact your representatives? Note that the pharmacy industry makes huge profits, among the most profitable of all industries, because people will pay all they have for a drug to save themselves or loved ones. WE would because these days "poor patients" include anyone without particularly good insurance. Excerpts from the Washington Post, link below. "NEW DELHI — India’s Supreme Court o ...

MTs: Expect In Future To See Far Fewer Patients Popping Vicodin.Oct 28, 2013
From the NY Times F.D.A. Shift on Painkillers Was Years in the Making By BARRY MEIER and ERIC LIPTON Published: October 27, 2013 FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ SAVE E-MAIL SHARE PRINT SINGLE PAGE REPRINTS   When Heather Dougherty heard the news last week that the Food and Drug Administration had recommended tightening how doctors prescribed the most commonly used narcotic painkillers, she was overjoyed. Fourteen years earlier, her father, Dr. ...

Raising The Debt Limit. A Little Bit Of HistoryApr 14, 2011
After World War II ended, the debt limit was reduced to $275 billion. Because the Korean War was mostly financed by higher taxes rather than by increased debt, the limit remained at $275 billion until 1954. After 1954, the debt limit was reduced twice and increased seven times, until March 1962 when it again reached $300 billion, its level at the end of World War II. Since March 1962, Congress has enacted 74 separate measures that have altered the limit on federal debt. Time Line from 1958-2011 ...

Six Costs Of Not Raising The Debt CeilingJul 26, 2011
What started as hot air has now become a thunder cloud. Should Congress fail to reach a compromise to raise the debt ceiling, a multitude of economic sectors could take a hit—if not come to a screeching halt. We review the effects as forecasted by economists and ask “Should you worry?” The answer, in short: Yes, probably so. 1. Global economy: Asian and European stocks “shuddered,” on Monday, as William Alden of the Huffington Post put it, after Congress f ...

Golf And Fund Raising Have Been Cancelled.Oct 15, 2014
I guess BO finally decided he has to work during a crisis and not be off flittin' about. ...

Raising Minimum Wage To $15 An Hour? Dec 08, 2016
Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton wanted the minimum wage raised and that was part of their platform.  Does anyone think raising the minimum wage will help the economy?  My soon to be ex-company, Nuance, fired the California MTs because of minimum wage higher than average in California. Will other companies avoid high minimum wage requirements and avoid doing business in those states?  Do you think if the minimum wage is higher, costs to the consumers will be higher.  If ...

AIDS Patients In Obamacare Limbo As Insurers Reject ChecksFeb 08, 2014
See link. ...

Why Raising Taxes In Poor Economy NEVER Good IdeaAug 01, 2010
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100801/ap_on_bi_ge/us_wealthy_cut_back   Taxes should NOT be raised on anyone right now... less spending, fewer jobs for the rest of us. However, with all of the outrageous Obama spending, he may end up raising taxes on us ALL, not just the wealthy.... lets wait and see. ...

Does Anyone Know How Much An MRI Or X-ray Would CostMar 26, 2010
I have only catastrophic insurance and have to pay for everything out of pocket.  For months my arm has been bothering me.  Can't move it out to the side or front (can't even do a full heil hitler salute (LOL).  It just won't move and I get pains in the infraspinatus muscle and then shooting pains down the outside of the arms.  It doesn't bother me all day, but if I jerk my arm fast, or bump it I get the pains down my arm.  Can't lift my arm up o ...

What Bin Laden Has Cost UsMay 07, 2011
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/05/the-cost-of-bin-laden-3-trillion-over-15-years/238517/   Interesting article...kinda long...but worth the read. ...

Cost Of Getting Braces Going UpJan 11, 2013
Obamacare Medical Device Tax: As of Jan.1, Obamacare imposes a new tax of 2.3 percent on medical device manufacturers, including those who make dental braces. The tax is imposed on gross sales -- even if the company does not earn a profit in a given year. While the tax will be paid to the IRS by the manufacturer, the tax will be passed along as a higher cost of the product, ultimately to be borne by the parent buying the braces for their child. With the cost of braces being as high as $7,625 ...

Cost Of Eyeglasses??Dec 23, 2014
I need single-vision glasses. I have the frames. My eye doctor charges $192 for the eyeglass lenses only. Does anyone know what Costco and/or Walmart charges? TYIA. ...

Do Doctor's Visit Really Cost This Much?Sep 08, 2016
So, I'm one of those people generally don't go to the doctor unless they are spurting blood across the room, but... A couple months ago, I found a lump in my breast, so I made an appointment with a GYN. I went there, they had me leave a urine sample, he felt the lump, wrote me a referral to a breast surgeon and for a mammogram/ultrasound and told me it would definitely need to be biopsied (freaking me out some more) and that was it. I had the mammogram/ultrasound. His office call ...