A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Contrary To GOP Claims, U.S. Has Second Lowest Corporate Taxes In The Developed World


Posted: Jul 6, 2011

During negotiations regarding raising the nation’s debt limit, congressional Republicans have defended tax loopholes for corporations, claiming that America has a high corporate tax rate that is stifling economic growth and job creation. But the Center for Tax Justice (CTJ) has crunched the most recent data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the Office of Management and Budget, and the Census Bureau, and finds that “the U.S. is already one of the least taxed countries for corporations in the developed world.”

As a share of GDP, the U.S. had the second lowest tax rate, behind only Iceland. This statistic flips on its head the often-repeated Republican charge that America has the second highest corporate tax rate in the world (which is only true on paper). In 2009, U.S. corporate taxes had fallen to only 1.3 percent of GDP, from 4 percent in 1965.

Conservatives love to point out that other OECD countries have lowered their corporate tax rates in recent years, but they conveniently ignore that “these countries have also closed corporate tax loopholes while the U.S. has expanded them.” As CAP Director for Tax and Budget Policy Michael Linden has noted, the U.S. is actually a very low-tax country across the board.



Recently, conservative commentator Bill Kristol chastised his own party for pretending that lowering the corporate tax rate is a cure-all for America’s economic woes. On Fox News Sunday, he interrupted a panelist who again tried to assert the U.S. is suffering from a high corporate tax rate: “Republicans are making a mistake if they focus on big businesses and corporate tax rates. Corporations have a ton of cash. The corporate tax rate is not killing big business in America.”


The GOP presidential candidates have almost uniformly introduced proposals to radically lower the U.S. corporate tax rate. For instance, former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty (R-MN) wants to reduce the corporate tax rate to 15 percent and eliminate all taxes on capital gains, dividends, interest income and inheritance. CTJ put the issue succinctly in a tweet this morning: “Dear US Corporations: You pay 2nd LOWEST tax rate in industrial world, so quit whining or move to Iceland.”
http://thinkprogress.org/economy/201...second-lowest/

;

Once again ... - anon

[ In Reply To ..]
These charts show taxation rates versus GDP. Why many of the countries seem to have high tax rates is because they have low GDPs (e.g., Luxembourg). Certainly, you can argue whether US corporations should pay more taxes, but using these charts as some sort of comparison or evidence they should is completely incorrect and pointless.

Again, we need to look at these problems intelligently, not with mindless rhetoric designed only as propaganda to persuade the unintelligent.

Excuse me. Low GDP by what measure? - Per capita nominal and PPP GDPs? Or

[ In Reply To ..]
The more frequently cited and highly skewable nominal and PPP GDPs that only measure dollars and cents values and do not account for the more detailed per capita measures used in the other two? The GOP DOES tend to overlook human factors when formulating their big-business-friendly initiatives, both in terms of contributions they make and the price they pay for GOP-generated economic policies. They like to stick to the bottom line. But I digress.

I am using your example of Luxembourg to illustrate the fallacy of your low GDP claim. I have to wonder if you bothered to even look at the names of the countries you so summarily relegated to bottom of the GDP totem pole.

When subjected to GDP nominal per capita formulations, in 2010 they were ranked #1 by the IMF and OECD and #3 by the World Bank and CIA World Fact Book.

Using GDP PPP per capita measures, Luxembourg was ranked #1 by the World Bank and OECD and #3 by the IMF and CIA World Fact Book. Since you favor dollars and cents measures, its population generates $81,383 for each of its 515,840 citizens (based on 2011 estimates), one-third of whom are too young or too old to work.

Luxembourg rankings using GDP nominal minus per capita factors are as follows:
IMF - #70 out of 181
World Bank - #68 out of 188
CIA World Fact Book - #70 out of 191

Using GDP PPP minus per capita factors
IMF - #95 out of 184
World Bank - #89 out of 178
CIA World Fact Book - #95 out of 197

As you can see, even in your select monetary-values-only GDP groups, Luxembourg is still in the top half, and cannot accurately be described as a low GDP country. Other things you obviously do not realize about this country is that it enjoys a uniquely prosperous economy when compared to other developed industrialized countries. Size-wise, it ranks 175 out of 194, 998 sq miles, or slightly smaller than Rhode Island. Therefore, one might reasonably conclude that it is positively ASTONISHING that a working population of approximately 340,000 has figured out how to out-produce more than half the world countries in terms of total GDP.

You picked the WRONG example. Speaking of mindless rhetoric designed only as propaganda to persuade the unintelligent, when lecturing folks on looking at these things intelligently, might want to check out GOP smoke and mirrors arguments a bit more closely and arm yourself with a few facts. To be clear, this red herring you introduced is a perfect example of GOP head-in-the-sand logic that is almost always meant to deceive. The fact is that the US does have the second LOWEST corporate interest rate in the developed world.

Stats came from here
World Economic Outlook Database-April 2011, International Monetary Fund. Data for 2010.

World Development Indicators database, World Bank. Data for 2009.

GDP (official exchange rate) & Population, The World Factbook, Central Intelligence Agency,

World Economic Outlook Database-April 2011, International Monetary Fund. Data for 2010.

World Development Indicators database, World Bank. Data for 2010.

GDP - per capita (PPP), The World Factbook, Central Intelligence Agency.

International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook Database, April 2011: Nominal GDP list of countries. Data for the year 2010.

"Gross domestic product (2010)". The World Bank: World Development Indicators dattabase. July 2011. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/DATASTATISTICS/Resources/GDP.pdf.

Field listing - GDP (official exchange rate), CIA World Factbook

International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook Database, April 2011: Nominal GDP list of countries. Data for the year 2010.

"Gross domestic product (2010)". The World Bank: World Development Indicators database. World Bank. 01 July 2011. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/DATASTATISTICS/Resources/GDP_PPP.pdf.

Field listing - GDP (PPP exchange rate), CIA World Factbook

nice - good post

[ In Reply To ..]
yg

Similar Messages:


New Jobless Claims Lowest Level In 4-1/2 YearsOct 11, 2012
I missed this earlier today.  This supports the 7.8% unemployment number that came out last week.  Good news for all working Americans.  WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The number of Americans filing new claims for jobless benefits slid last week to the lowest level in more than four and a half years, ...

4-week Average Unemployment Claims Lowest Level Since August 2008Dec 16, 2010
Fewer jobless claims cap strong week for economy Strong week for economy ends with report of fewer people applying for unemployment benefits Christopher S. Rugaber, AP Economics Writer, On Thursday December 16, 2010, 11:13 am EST WASHINGTON (AP) -- A further decline in the number of people applying for unemployment benefits capped a strong week for the economy. Factories are producing more, shoppers are spending more and business executives and consumers are more optimistic. The latest ...

Supreme Court Signals Support For Corporate Religious ClaimsMar 25, 2014
Maybe there is hope after all... ...

Cool. For Those Of You Arguing That Corporate Isn't Paying TaxesApr 11, 2011
The WH has graciously placed some charts on this website:   Table 2.2 has the receipts from individual and corporate taxes paid from 1934 to present. There are plenty of other graphs if you want to spend the time. ...

CSpan 3 Is "investigating" Shifting Corporate Corporate Profits OffshoreOct 12, 2012
Right now, they are questioning Bill Sample, Microsoft's Corporate VP. Missed the beginning since I was at the grocery store, so I don't know when it started. ...

For All Of You Who Suddenly Have Developed AJun 07, 2013
case of amnesia, here is the link "reminding" you what your hero, Bush, did. Now go ahead and slam Obama again, as usual! http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/16/politics/16program.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0   ...

Have A Look At This Website Developed By...smNov 09, 2013
three young men as a fix to the ACA government website to aid people in their decision making.  CBS news did a piece on them this morning.  They have constructed it so you can look up the available options and then deal directly with the insurance company without ever going through the government website.  Have a look. http://thehealthsherpa.com ...

I've Developed A Trigger Thumb!Dec 19, 2012
Anybody got any words of advice for me?  Fortunately it has not affected my typing (yet anyway), but I almost cried when I tried to straighten it this morning!  :-( ...

Anyone Out Here With Trigger Finger? Mine Developed In The Last May 11, 2014
This came on quickly.  One morning a couple weeks ago I woke up and found that my ring finger on my left hand seemed to be stuck when I tried to open my hand up.  Since then it has gotten a little worse, hurts mostly in the morning and feels like it is popping out when I open my hand all the way.  I looked up trigger finger and what it says is exactly what is happening to me.  Unfortunately it looks like there is nothing to be done about it until it gets so bad you have to ha ...

Before The Nuclear Deal With Iran, The US Had Developed Jun 13, 2017
to thwart terrorist financing operations. As Obama pressed ahead with the Iran deal, those operations lost funding and were “systematically disbanded,” according to former U.S. State Department official Dr. David Asher. Asher’s stunning testimony before the House Foreign Affairs Committee last Thursday was ignored by the MSM. Now the biggest sponsor of terrorism in the world is on the brink of a nuclear weapon thanks to Obama. ...

My Lowest Of Lows On Nov 11, 2016
I know this is nobody elses fault but mine, but I just feel down and had to write.  Today is veterans day.  As a veteran married to a veteran, father, uncle, and many others in my family are veterans. So here's my low of the day.  Never in my wildest dreams it would come to this.  I went into the grocerty store, swiped my debit card and it didn't work.  She said her machine is acting up today, asked me to swipe again cos she had just opened her register.  ...

Unemployment Now 6.6, Lowest Since 2008Feb 22, 2014
. ...

98,000 New Jobs In March, Lowest In Ages. NmApr 08, 2017
. ...

Gallup: Obama Plummets To Lowest Annual Approval Rating Ever: 01/20/2015Jan 20, 2015
Link:  http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/barack-obama-annual-approval-ratings/2015/01/20/id/619663/ ...

Obama's Popularity Dips With Lowest Pre-convention PopularitySep 05, 2012
Looks like he's going to need a miracle.  Didn't see anything positive tonight though, maybe tomorrow. http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/09/obamas-popularity-dips-underwater-for-romney-a-faint-favorability-bounce/   ...

No More Corporate Welfare!Apr 08, 2011
I know it's not realistic to think that we could ever get to the point where people would pay the taxes they are supposed to pay, but that would solve our budget problems and nobody would go hungry. The middle class would have more money to spend and we would buy things from the big companies who make them. We would all save money because we would be driving on better roads, not tearing our cars apart, children will be getting a better education and not have to move in with their parents wh ...

Top 10 Corporate OutragesJul 02, 2010
You might have heard this: BP is so well connected in Washington that even after being cited for 760 different safety and environmental violations, the company still got environmental waivers for the Deepwater Horizon rig that's now destroying the Gulf.1   But BP's not alone in using its DC influence. Check out the list below of other companies' outrages—then pass it along.  And be sure to sign our new Fight Washington Corruption Pledge to support 3 key measure ...

Sick Of CORPORATE EVERYTHING...Jul 20, 2016
now a corporate president, either repub or democ?  Ayn Rand would be very happy... I once had an Indian doctor (whom I admired very much) tell me people from other countries before coming here read "Atlas Shrugged" and Ayn Rand's books.  This is their view of our country.   I read the book and was sickened at the ruthlessness and worship of money as a god...  kind of like, well, now.   ...

Corporate Drag?Mar 17, 2016
I am about to leave the MT world (please, Lord, soon--I cannot stand seeing NJA all day, and my budget is sunk) and am applying for a job with some law firms. One of them is a really corporate kind of thing. I have always been more of a casual gal, but casual would not cut it with this firm. I am not fat, not skinny, just average build, average looks. Not a show-stopper, not ugly, either. Just an average woman you wouldn't look at twice. If you needed to present a good corporate imag ...

Top 10 Corporate Tax Dodgers.Jan 30, 2016
See link. ...

Time For A Corporate SpringMay 26, 2012
A common complaint in today’s world is one of disconnection. Our industrialized world has resulted in less contact with community — we don’t know our neighbors or who grows our food. In the same way that we’ve lost touch with a deeper sense of belonging and place, many of us have become disconnected from the soul of our work. The corporation-worker structure today is a master-servant relationship. We’re slaves to the company, working longer hours for less wage ...

Inversion/Corporate DesertersJul 28, 2014
Government only gets 10% of its revenue from corporations now-- in 1950s it was about 30%, in 1960s it was down to 25%.  See link ...

DEMOCRATS HAUNTED BY CORPORATE TIES...Apr 21, 2010
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0410/36118.html ...

Unions Versus The Corporate MachineOct 30, 2015
Republican candidates are unionizing against the RNC.  Is the media next?   Republican party imploding all over the place.   The other day I was shocked when Paul Ryan admitted the House was broken.  I guess the first step is to hit bottom and confront denial.    ...

Corporate Profitability At Six-Year HighAug 01, 2017
Make sure you read everything so you will understand. I expect to get flamed for this, but I really don't care. Enjoy! #MAGA ...

Unemployment Claims Up.. AGAINJul 21, 2011
http://www.burlingtonfreepress.com/article/20110721/BUSINESS04/110721020/Unemployment-claims-up-again?odyssey=nav%7Chead ...

Okay, Exactly Who ARE The 47% Mr. Romney ClaimsSep 19, 2012
Link to Factcheck.org's analysis below. BTW, Mr. Romney's 47% of people who end up paying NO FEDERAL INCOME TAX is already out of date. It has dropped to about 46% under current policies and is expected to fall to 44% in 2013, under current policies.  @50% are employed people, but low income, who do pay employment taxes. (No doubt many MTs fall in this group he won't be bothering about these days.)@22% are seniors, i.e., most retired workers, living on limited incomes. (Mos ...

Trump's Claims Are Getting Beyond Aug 09, 2017
He is now taking credit for our updated arsenol.  LOL  It's never-ending humor with this guy. ...

DNC Finally Reveals It's List Of Corporate InfluenceSep 28, 2016
Even the New Republic called the Democratic National Convention 'one big corporate bribe,’ as Trump-phobic donors threw in big money. Corporate interests and influences have gained a great deal of ground in the Democratic Party under Hillary Clinton’s candidacy. For example, Clinton’s 2008 campaign co-chair, former Democratic National Committee (DNC) Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz rescinded a DNC ban enacted by Barack Obama in 2008 on donations from lobbyists and SuperPACS. The dec ...

Bank And Corporate Political Contribution HistoryMay 06, 2015
There was some debate below about whether America's biggest bankers supported Republicans or Democrats, so I looked it up myself. The link below is the "Top Organization Contributor" list from the site "opensecrets.org". It is a bipartisan organization that was founded in 1983 by U.S. Sens. Frank Church (D-Idaho) and Hugh Scott (R-Pa.) and publishes its work tracking money in politics in extensive reports; at first via books, now via the internet. I cannot guarantee its legitimacy, ...