A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Is discrimination in our public schools acceptable?


Posted: Feb 21, 2014

I am appalled that in 2014 this question even is asked.  Apparently there are those that do not think the government should be involved in matters of discrimination.  If not the federal government, then who?  Anti-discriminaton is a federal law and needs to be enforced just like any other law. 

Below on this board there is a post regarding an article of outrage because the Departments of Justice and Education sent out a letter to schools regarding discriminatory punishment in the schools. 

Here is a link to a copy of the entire actual letter that was sent to the schools:

http://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/letters/colleague-201401-title-vi.html

In a nutshell, here is a bit:

Dear Colleague:

The U.S. Department of Education and the U.S. Department of Justice (Departments) are issuing this guidance to assist public elementary and secondary schools in meeting their obligations under Federal law to administer student discipline without discriminating on the basis of race, color, or national origin. The Departments recognize the commitment and effort of educators across the United States to provide their students with an excellent education. The Departments believe that guidance on how to identify, avoid, and remedy discriminatory discipline will assist schools in providing all students with equal educational opportunities. . . .

. . . The Civil Rights Data Collection (CRDC),5 conducted by OCR, has demonstrated that students of certain racial or ethnic groups6 tend to be disciplined more than their peers. For example, African-American students without disabilities are more than three times as likely as their white peers without disabilities to be expelled or suspended. Although African-American students represent 15% of students in the CRDC, they make up 35% of students suspended once, 44% of those suspended more than once, and 36% of students expelled. Further, over 50% of students who were involved in school-related arrests or referred to law enforcement are Hispanic or African-American.

The Departments recognize that disparities in student discipline rates in a school or district may be caused by a range of factors. However, research suggests that the substantial racial disparities of the kind reflected in the CRDC data are not explained by more frequent or more serious misbehavior by students of color.

;

Neither is reverse discrimination - this is a CYA letter. - nm

[ In Reply To ..]
nm

I hope you read the case examples near the end - enlightened

[ In Reply To ..]
If you have some factual concrete examples of reverse discrimination, that would be interesting.

I'd rather see how it plays out like another poster suggested. - nm

[ In Reply To ..]
nm
there's really no need to explore the facts - nm
[ In Reply To ..]

equal punishment for equal misbehavior - is not reverse discrimination

[ In Reply To ..]
on this planet or any other.

Similar Messages:


Tammy Duckworth Credits Govt Assistant, Public SchoolsSep 04, 2012
her achieve her remarkable accomplishments in her adult years.  She's such an inspiration for women, minorities, veterans and "wounded warriors," all of whom got short shrift or ignored in last week's RNC.  Her speech was a knockout. ...

Age DiscriminationAug 21, 2013
fiance has been having problems with a co-worker.  This co-worker punctured one of our car tires and has made threats to both fiance and to me (through him).   what a piece of work.  He has talked to HR and his union rep who do nothing.  Now, the co-worker has started a campaign taking it upon himself to get my fiance fired for not doing his job.  Fiance works in a meat packing plant throwing boxes of meat.  He is 47 years old.  The co-worker is 35.  ...

Age Discrimination And Employment RightsMar 01, 2011
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/01/job-applicants-age-disclosure-requirement_n_829637.html We have had some discussion about the chipping away of child labor laws.  Here is an example of the chipping away of age discrimination laws.  Some people here have made the argument there are laws to protect us.  My answer--not if the Republicans have their way and defund and deregulate the concerned agencies that do the protecting.  A chip here, and a chip there. ...

Gay Discrimination Legislation In A RepublicanFeb 27, 2014
Will the Republican Right win the anti-gay battles in Missouri, Kansas, Ohio, Mississippi, Idaho, South Dakota, Tennessee, and Oklahoma? We know that is what the Republicans really want, or will it crumble from the pressure of Big Business or the bean/vote counters? A Missouri state senator on Monday introduced legislation like Arizona’s that could provide cover for businesses to deny service to same-sex couples. In Georgia, two versions of a similar bill in the state House and Senate are ...

Fed Findings--Systematic DiscriminationMar 03, 2015
Maybe Michael Brown didn't die completely in vain.  Maybe something will change.    Ferguson City email system reveals racially charged jokes.   Perhaps a court ordered decree for supervision of Ferguson Police Department.     ...

DT Is Dangerous--Blanket DiscriminationJan 10, 2016
The only thing she did was dress differently.  She did not speak, she did not do anything that was forbidden.  I cannot understand why anyone would support a man who allows this sort of discrimination at a campaign event for the office of President of the United States.  She was interviewed later and recounted some of the things the Trump supporters said to her.  Obviously, they have little to no experience with anyone who does not look just like them and have the ...

Arizona Passes Bill To Allow LGBT Discrimination By BusinessFeb 24, 2014
. ...

Comcast And Al Sharpton Hit With $20 Billion Racial Discrimination LawsuitFeb 23, 2015
http://closedpress.com/comcast-and-al-sharpton-hit-with-$20-billion-racial-discrimination-lawsuit/ ...

Schools Are Blunt About New Pot Law: Not On Our CampusNov 10, 2012
Colleges in the land of legalized pot say they still won't allow students to smoke marijuana. 12:08PM EST November 10. 2012 - Social media is abuzz with future college students dreaming of doing bong hits openly on the greens of universities in Colorado and Washington state. But those dreams may go up in smoke. "If someone thinks they are going to walk around campus smoking a joint, it's not going to happen," says University of Washington spokesman Norman Arkans. Although voter ...

NRA Wants Armed Guards In SchoolsDec 21, 2012
Of all the ways in which we could respond, this, in my opinion, is the most stupid. It should be noted that "good guys with guns" are not impermeable to gunfire. Fighting fire with fire is not the way for our society to evolve. The CDC is barred - legally BARRED - from releasing data on gun deaths because the NRA is such a strong lobby. Until which time this data is made available, the NRA should keep both sides of their mouths shut. And shame on all the spineless legislators who bow to the ...

OBAMA Schools GOP On TranportationMay 15, 2014
MAKES me furious - Congress funded war for 10 years and rebuilt Iraq but repair our damaged infrastructure?  No we don't use funds for THIS COUNTRY!!Get with it GOP!   USE FUNDS FOR defense of our land (borders etc.) AND INFRASTRUCTURE.  And this goes for Democrats, too. ...

Colbert To The Rescue - SC SchoolsMay 07, 2015
Comedian Stephen Colbert announced Thursday that he would fund every existing grant request South Carolina public school teachers have made on the education crowdfunding website DonorsChoose.org. Colbert made the announcement on a live video feed Thursday at a surprise event at Alexander Elementary School in Greenville. Colbert partnered with Share Fair Nation and ScanSource to fund nearly 1,000 projects for more than 800 teachers at over 375 schools, totaling $800,000. ...

Punishment In Schools Must Be Proportionate According To Race. Feb 20, 2014
There are more blacks in prisons than whites, so this must be the reason, according to this administration.    Link ...

Iran Foreign Minister Schools GOP....Mar 10, 2015
on international law. ...

Schools Dropping Out - Kentucky Students To Michelle - Aug 27, 2013
Schools across the country are dropping out, not just these.  These are just the descriptive letter-writing ones.  LOL - No, I'm not providing a link for those.  I can only post one. Link ...

NY Schools And Second Largest District In Chicago DropSep 06, 2014
Let her kids eat them!  LOL ...

This Is Why We Can't Let Liberals Run Amok. Schools Implanting IUDs In Jul 03, 2015
Seattle, the 2nd or 3rd most liberal city in the US, where minimum wage is $15 with businesses moving out of the city limits, and socialists get elected to the city council.  Meanwhile, over the past 15 years the place has become a dump and a haven for the Great Unwashed, just like San Francisco. Absolutely nothing this city does surprises me anymore.  Honestly, I have no idea how liberals can stand to look at themselves in the mirror these days. ...

Threats Prompt Lockdowns At 8 High Schools In Sep 17, 2015
Phoned in threats were received at eight schools within 15 minutes, officials said. Eight high schools in San Diego received threats Thursday, prompting lock downs at all eight schools facilities and an immediate response from San Diego and district police officers. nbcsandiego.com ... ...

Randie Paul Schools Howard University StudentsApr 11, 2013
Randie Paul's assumption that African American college students know nothing of their history was not well received. I'm not sure if this was the right approach to start covering his  tracks regarding a 2010 interview where he said essentially that the Civil Rights Act should not apply to private businesses: PAUL: I like the Civil Rights Act in the sense that it ended discrimination in all public domains, and I’m all in favor of that. INTERVIEWER: But? PAUL: You had to a ...

New York City Schools Close For Muslim Holiday.Sep 24, 2015
Big Bird is bowing down. ...

Just Yesterday, MI Passed Bill Allowing Concealed Weapons In Schools, Dec 14, 2012
This is beyond insane.  I am speechless.  Perhaps they should add hospital nurseries to that list.  http://www.emptywheel.net/2012/12/14/the-day-before-gun-rampage-in-elementary-school-mi-passes-bill-allowing-guns-in-schools/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=the-day-before-gun-rampage-in-elementary-school-mi-passes-bill-allowing-guns-in-schools    The Day Gun Rampage in Elementary School MI Passes Bill Allowing Guns in Schools Posted on Decem ...

Obama Says NCAA Should Require Schools To Give Guaranteed ScholarshipsMar 22, 2015
Add President Obama to the list of people who thinks college athletes deserve more than they get. In an interview with the Huffington Poston Friday, the president said that the NCAA should require schools to offer guaranteed athletic scholarships “no matter what.” "Students need to be taken better care of because they are generating a lot of revenue here," Obama said. "An immediate step that the NCAA could take – that some conferences have already taken – is if you ...

Public Option Hot Again?Oct 12, 2009
The group, America's Health Insurance Plans, released a report claiming that the new health care reform bill will drive up insurance premiums because not everyone will be forced into the system. Without a very large pool that includes healthy people, the insurance companies insist, they will have to pay out too much. (I'm crying crocodile tears here.) This might bring the public option back strongly if the dems finally say, "Enough of this crap!" We can only hope. NJ ...

Want A Public Option?Oct 25, 2009
If you want to send Obama a message to fight for the public option, MoveOn.org has a way. Go to this page and see how. You will need a printer (or make a sign of your own). Wear your Obama gear (shirt, button, whatever) and take a picture of yourself. Upload it at the site and they will send it along for you. It's a great way to remind him why we elected him ^^ NJ ...

Wish They Could Show This In The Public Apr 21, 2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NmPfSIZWwKs&feature=related ...

Public Breastfeeding - Yay Or Nay?May 23, 2011
Big Controversary coming up here in a little town outside Atl about Breast feeding in public What's the deal here ? Do you feel the Breast should be covered or exposed? This is what God gave us Breasts for Mother's to feed our Babies ..... When that milk comes in oh my !I never Breast fed did yall and if you did .... did you you ever have a problem ? It is such a natural thing ! ...

Public Option Looks Good!Oct 23, 2009
Public option vs. bloated insurance companies. Link at bottom, clicky clicky. NJ ...

Pajama Pants In Public -- Is It Just Me?Apr 16, 2010
What is this?!?!  Why, oh why, do people (men and women) wear these horrible pajama pants out in the world.  They're everywhere!  Dirty, flannel, ripped, ugly, lazy -- only to be topped off by wearing slippers, too!  Making me crazy, but still not as bad as "pants on the ground."  whew --- better after vent -- thanx ...

I Want To Make A Public Apology To TheAug 11, 2014
Moderator for having my suspicions about censorship. I received a very nice note from her, explaining problems she's recently been having (which I don't care to disclose), and I appreciate her reply very much. Thank you, Moderator, and I apologize for ALL of the snarky remarks I made. ...

President's Strategist Goes PublicFeb 17, 2015
Barack Obama has a reputation for being one cool customer. But underneath that aloof exterior lurks a hot temper and foul mouth capable of hurling obscenities, according to someone who knows him very well. More at link... ...