A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

"Disconnections: Observations From Yesterday's Gun Rallies"


Posted: Apr 20, 2010

Paul Helmke

Paul Helmke

Posted: April 20, 2010 12:25 PM

I spent three hours yesterday attending the "Second Amendment March" on the Mall in D.C. and the "Restore the Constitution" rally at Gravelly Point National Park in Northern Virginia, across the Potomac River from DC.
2010-04-20-Ft.HuntVAVanderboegh3smaller.jpg

It's hard for me to make sense of people who want to bring loaded guns with them all the time, wherever they go. The main impression I have of the two events is one of disconnectedness.

The dichotomies were everywhere:

•  "Don't Tread on Me Flags" on the Mall framed by flags at half-staff around the Washington Monument in memory of victims of terrorism since yesterday was the 15th anniversary of the Oklahoma City bombing by an anti-government NRA member who made the money to make his bomb by selling weapons at gun shows;

  • Military-style assault weapons in the National Park as opposed to fake black styrofoam AR-15s on the Mall;

  • Speeches that seemed to have more to do with "restoring" the type of system we had under the Articles of Confederation than with "restoring" the Constitution (indeed, I heard very little discussion about the Constitutional system's reliance on elections and the legal process as the cornerstone of resolving disputes through our system of checks and balances, representative democracy, and access to courts);

  • No real complaints about any federal laws that have been passed to restrict access to guns (there haven't been any, that are still on the books, since the Brady Bill was passed in 1993);

  • No real complaints about how the Second Amendment has been handled by the Courts (the DC vs. Heller decision two years ago seemed to give the "gun rights" crowd what they wanted, unless they wanted to show their opposition to Justice Scalia's language that the right is "not unlimited" and that the Second Amendment allows restrictions on who can get guns, where they can be taken, how they are sold and stored and carried, and what kinds of guns they are - but I didn't see any anti-Scalia posters);

  • Speeches that focused less on guns and more on health care, the federal deficit, bailouts, and other decisions with which they disagreed with the very express implication that the reason they were carrying (or wanting to carry) their guns was because "the guys with the guns make the rules" (as stated by the NRA boss Wayne LaPierre last Spring after Obama took office);

  • Seeing guns carried in an area where Confederate troops may once have marched within view of the Capitol Dome which was being constructed when Lee and Davis and the Southern states decided that they wanted to "restore" a different understanding of the Constitution than that endorsed by Lincoln and the voters who elected him;

  • Seeing guns carried close enough to the Reagan National Airport (named after a president who was shot by a gunman in DC in 1981) where a 50-caliber sniper rifle (legal in this country and now allowed in national parks) might easily take out airplanes on the ground (or about to land or take off);

  • Hearing references to a selected history of the U.S .which emphasized the shooters at Lexington and Concord but ignored the Continental Congresses that supported their efforts as well as the Shays Rebellion put down about the time the Constitution was written and the Whiskey Rebellion put down in 1794;

  • And finally, being treated (for the most part) politely by people on a beautiful sunny day whose level of fear and paranoia seemed to reflect a dark view of society and our nation.

  • With all of these "disconnections", my hope is we can all start focusing on what we can do to prevent gun violence by making it harder for dangerous people to get guns as well as focusing on the risks and responsibilities of gun ownership.

  • ;

    Amen to that, sister. I have no problem with - gun ownership per se

    [ In Reply To ..]
    but I wonder sometimes about how much things have changed, and how much guns have change since the Constitution was written. Let's face it, when it was written society was completely different. Guns were MUCH simpler and no where near the technology there is now. And with the internet, it seems to have REALLY brought out the crazies and those are the people that concern me. I wonder if the right to bear arms would exist if society and weaponry had been then what they are now, or if they would have been excluded entirely. Who knows, just a thought.

    Have to say though, when I heard about the new law forcing or trying to force women to have a mental evalution before having an abortion, I wondered how American gun owners would feel if the same were required of them prior to buying a gun. I personally think it would be a great idea.

    I really like that idea about a mental evaluation first LOL - WTH?

    [ In Reply To ..]
    I think that would, indeed, eliminate of lot of those weapons licenses -- including my own brother.

    Might I also add that back in our founding fathers' time, they had to risk coming across a bear just traveling to their neighbor's house. And guns were obviously important tools to have back then in order to put food on the table. Other than for the purposes of defending one's own property, or for sport hunting, I see no reason to own a gun. Going down the street to Starbuck's should not necessarily require one to be packing.

    The whole idea of the "bible and guns" crowd I find very perplexing . . .

    Similar Messages:


    Observations - Tired Of It AllMar 25, 2010
    The hatred on this board toward anyone who is a conservative has been absolutely rampant and so unnecessary.  It has become so bad here, the only way to describe it is a disease.  People have become totally obsessed with hating conservatives.  There are accusations of violence, yet no proof.  No videos, no voice clips, not even an iphone video or picture…nothing.  All you have is someone telling you things were said and done by conservatives, yet nobody can collab ...

    Just A Couple Of Observations AboutAug 28, 2012
    Rick Santorum's speaking style reminds me of a preacher/minister.  That's not a good/bad judgment...just my impression.  His speech was the most passionate of the night.   Ann Romney's speech was likable enough.  She seems like a sweet lady who, of course, loves her husband.     Chris Christie: Angry, scoldy, mean, yelling.   Aside from Ann Romney speaking lovingly about Mitt Romney, I didn't feel like there was enough reference to MITT R ...

    Interesting ObservationsJan 20, 2013
    I have friends and family in Canada.  I read this to them and they said, er, yup, that sums it up of what we see.  Yes, it's an email, yes it was really written by a Canadian, no I con't care if it's a "chain email" because it doesn't mean its not true, yes every statement is true, no I don't know the name of the original writer is, yes, I've check snopesm, yes have fun reading, no don't have fun reading I don't care, no I will not "provide a sou ...

    A Few Observations About The Tax Issue.Oct 03, 2016
    The first thing to note is that any business, and especially those that do business in multiple states and even in other countries, operates in landscape of tax obligations, of which the federal income tax is only one element and might even be much less significant than others. Second, "tax" refers to every and any monetary obligation that any and all taxing authorities levy on a business and sometimes certain particular operations that it conducts.  For instance, fees for building permits ...

    Nobody Has Observations On The Bombing Suspects?Apr 21, 2013
    What's your take on it? Getting bored seeing all the copy pastes here. ...

    What Is Trump Doing Having Campaign Rallies?Feb 18, 2017
    He has no national security advisors, hundreds of important jobs have not been filled and he's going off looking for adoration from his fans.  I'm sure he'll get in some more golf as well but since he's not Obama, that's okay. ...

    Trump Is Carrying The Bible At His Rallies NowOct 27, 2015
    I would laugh if not so pathetic.  He is also starting the backhanded insult of The Seventh Day Adventist. Republicans do see through this, don't they? ...

    Hillary And The DNC Are Responsible For Violence At Trump RalliesOct 28, 2016
    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lqfwpuILI9Q Narrative in part: Hillary Clinton and the mainstream media would like you to believe the violence at these (Trump) rallies was caused by Donald Trump's rhetoric, the fact that he wanted to have a border wall, the fact that he said criminals were coming across the border from Mexico, that these words are what incited the violence at these rallies, and Hillary Clinton even came out and said, 'I don't condone this whatsoever, that Dona ...

    Hillary Scared Spitless - Starting To Shriek And Scream At Rallies.Nov 02, 2016
    Wutta mutt. She also visited an early voting site today. I thought that was illegal, but hey...with the Clinton ANYTHING GOES. ...

    Heads Are Rolling Over The Video Showing Paid Agitators At Trump RalliesOct 19, 2016
    Two top Democratic strategists have exited the presidential campaign after explosive undercover videos showed them discussing voter fraud and their roles in planting paid agitators at campaign events for Republican candidate Donald Trump. Robert Creamer, founder of Democracy Advocates and the husband of Rep. Janice D. Schakowsky, Illinois Democrat, stepped down from the campaign Tuesday, a day after Scott Foval was fired from his post as national field director of Ameri ...

    Undercover Video Shows Democrat Operatives Admitting They Incited Violence At Trump RalliesOct 19, 2016
    https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2016/10/undercover-video-shows-democrat-operatives-admitting-they-incited-violence-at-trump-rallies ...

    Pro-gun ‘patriot Groups’ Plan Dual Rallies In Washington On Disputed April AnniversaApr 06, 2010
    By Stephen C. WebsterMonday, April 5th, 2010 -- 8:16 pm Update (at bottom): Pro-gun ads appearing in this report not directly linked to RAW STORY The date April 19 seems to have a strange echo in American history. According to the media, a pro-gun group planning a rally in Washington, D.C. on that day is doing so because it is the anniversary of the Oklahoma City bombing. While technically correct, that's not half the story. The controversy surrounds two groups: Oath Keepers and Second ...

    I Got My Ballot Yesterday...Oct 10, 2012
    And it's in my old name (I got married this year).   Can I still vote?  I don't know what this means.  Score 1 for Romney, I guess.  LOL ...

    Here's What Happened YesterdayNov 24, 2012
    The Obama administration proposed 80 new regulations… today posted at 2:11 pm on November 23, 2012 by Erika Johnsen "The Obama administration proposed at least 80 new regulations the day after Thanksgiving (go ahead and give ‘em a scroll-through for some good times), adding to the now 1,773 proposed in the last thirty days. …But tax hikes on the wealthy and more government spending are what we need to get our economy going again. Uh-huh." http://hotair.com/greenroom/archives/2012 ...

    Yesterday My Dog Was Barking Out The Window At...Jan 23, 2012
    ...

    Yesterday.....and Today! The Rich Are DifferentOct 23, 2009
    Today: And the American International Group is contractually obliged to make bonus payments of nearly $200 million in March 2010. The company has promised to try to reduce that amount by 30 percent. But once again, there is nothing Mr. Feinberg can do because those bonuses were already written into contracts — and there is a high likelihood that the bonuses will create another furor in Congress, just as they did earlier this year. A year ago: For instance, it is critical for General Mot ...

    I Was Actually Shocked Speechless YesterdayNov 24, 2009
    I know it's hard to believe, but I was actually shocked speechless yesterday. I went into store that just opened up a few months ago in the town next to me. It is an accessories store. They sell knockoff designer handbags, sunglasses, scarves, jewelery and other things. I was talking to the man who owned the store as I was browsing the items. I had picked out a few things I liked and was planning on purchasing them. Then, as we were discussing the handbags he had in the store, he showed me ...

    Obama On The Golf Course Yesterday, Followed By DHS Aug 19, 2016
    president can't be everywhere."     ...

    Did Anyone See Yesterday's Parade Section In The Sep 03, 2012
    If you did and still have it, there is an article about mich and B.  I won't read it, of course, I couldn't really even stand to look at them, but open it up and look at the pic on the inside.  Does anything look at all strange to you about Michelle's chest?  Or is it my paper? ...

    Obama Just Cracks Me Up. Yesterday He's Out There (sm)Oct 05, 2012
    calling Romney a liar.  He's like a little schoolyard bully.  All mouth when no one is around to knock his little self down.   He's a joke. ...

    My Husband And I Voted Yesterday.Oct 31, 2012
    And now that it's over (on our end, anyway), somehow comments on this board are not so frustrating.  I don't think my blood pressure has gone up a single digit today. I hope you all find the same peace after you cast your ballots.  :D   (just kidding!) ...

    Regarding The Post About The NYT Article Yesterday (sm)Jun 07, 2013
    They wussed out.  Figures.  Back to carrying the Great One's water. Link ...

    For Those Who Were Frothing At The Mouth Yesterday - Sep 10, 2013
    LOL ...

    Big Doins At The WH Yesterday, Too Bad Cops Were Dec 02, 2014
    This administration is such a farce.  Yes, it's Commie Obammie at the helm. ...

    Could Really Use Some Prayers Right Now. Yesterday MorningAug 25, 2015
    we had to do a most agonizing task... put our almost 16-year-old fur baby to sleep. It's like losing a family member, because our fur babies do truly become family members. Since starting working at home about 15 years ago, she has spent almost all day every day with me. It may sound silly to some, but the pain of her loss is almost unbearable. I think I'm doing okay, but then something triggers that pain again and I can't help but just sit and cry. I would really appreciate your ...

    Big Dip In The Stock Market YesterdayMar 22, 2017
    Hillary and Obama must have done something. ...

    Preibus Gone. Resigned Yesterday. Jul 28, 2017
    That's okay. He was a bit weak anyway. Haven't heard a lot from him lately. John Kelly will be the new COS guy on Monday. Now they'll need to asign someone for head of the DHS. Hope it's someone as good as Kelly.What's going on now must be a 6-month shakeup but usually most shakeups and resignations happen closer to a year into a new administration. Still okay that this one is earlier because the earlier it happens, the sooner things will start working smoother. ...

    So, Here's USA Today And Tweets About YesterdayAug 13, 2017
    Check out the article. i copied some of the tweets but there is video to go along with a lot of these.The #UniteTheRight rally has started in #charlottesville. A counter protester threw a punch calm was quickly restored.Ahead of the rally, another group has joined - chanting "blood and soil" as they approach Counterprotesters are throwing water balloons filled with pink paint at white nationalists - as seen on this police car And on cue, another all out brawl. Antifa firing pepp ...

    Did Anyone Watch Sheila Jackson-Lee Yesterday?Jan 20, 2011
    Neil Cavuto interviewed her later on his show.  I couldn't believe my ears! She equated mandatory health insurance with mandated car insurance......again. When will some of these representatives understand that if you drive a car, you need to buy car insurance, but if you don't drive a car, you don't need the insurance? The MSM, so far, has not picked up on this story, as to be expected so, unfortunately, all I can give are blogs, which I really don't like to use. ...

    My Goofy Skecher Sneakers Came In Yesterday And...May 13, 2010
    Holy crap do I love these sneakers!  I don't care if they look retarded--they feel FANTASTIC!  I have a bum knee and I can no longer fully extend my right leg to walk normally.  Well, the minute I put these shoes on I was able to just go with it...and I mean within the minute!  They came pre-laced with white laces with a spare black set.  They have little sparkle dots on them near the holes where the laces go that I didn't even notice until the sun hi ...