A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

A Soldier Criticizes His Army Comrades' Tea Party Ideology


Posted: Oct 24, 2013

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/10/a-soldier-criticizes-his-army-comrades-tea-party-ideology/280788/

A Soldier Criticizes His Army Comrades' Tea Party Ideology

Does the movement's rank and file want to be misinformed by conservative media, or are they the unwitting victims of unscrupulous propagandists?

Chumsdock/Flickr

 
Regular readers know I have a love/hate relationship with the Tea Party. What I love is all the good people participating in the civic process for the first time; the determination to challenge corruption in the GOP establishment; the effort to bring civil-liberties concerns and skepticism of foreign wars back under the Republican tent; the commitment to a republic where people are free to pursue happiness as they see fit; the healthy skepticism of central planning that subverts markets with cronyism and corporatism; and alarm at our national debt. 
 
What I hate about the Tea Party is the epistemic closure that plagues it; the unthinking embrace of obviously unqualified politicians like Herman Cain; the notion that "real American" culture is something other than pluralistic; the unseriousness about governing; its frustrating inability to distinguish between mutually beneficial compromise on one hand and betrayal of principle on the other; the veneration of hucksters like Glenn Beck and blowhards like Rush Limbaugh; the double-think that characterizes its attitude toward the safety-net; and the subset of its rank and file that expresses personal disdain for all non-conservatives even while casting themselves as disrespected victims. 
 
I've always been far more sympathetic to the Tea Party's rank and file than to its elites. In my experience, an American who shows up to a community protest rally tends to be earnest and well-intentioned, whereas the ideological entertainers they tune into on the way home tend to be cynical, opportunistic hucksters who constantly misinform while selling cheap anger and gold at obscene markups.  
 
I've argued in many posts that right-wing media regularly and egregiously misinforms its Tea Party audiences, whose trust in talk radio and Fox News is misplaced, and called on conservatives who know better to affirm as much. As I see it, Tea Partiers would be furious if they understood the degree to which they're misled, and would manage a better movement if better served by conservative media.
 
Today's correspondent, an Army veteran, argues that I am too easy on the rank and file:
I've been thinking a lot about your critiques of right-wing media, and feel I could add something. My grandfather was a war hero, and even though I'm educated, urban, and not particularly interested in giant nation building projects in Afghanistan and Iraq, I enlisted (that is, enlisted rather than becoming an officer) as a special operations soldier in the Army. Before, after, and in between deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan, I was stationed in Fayetteville, North Carolina, where I lived with the same white male southerners who make up the majority of the GOP base. They seethe listening to Rush every morning on their commute to the base, they seethe during the day where Fox News often plays in the office from 9-5, and they come back fully believing everything Glenn Beck told them that evening (I left the army in February, and remember Beck having a demonstrable affect on the moods of some of Army leadership while he was still on Fox).  I lived with the Tea Party like Barbara Ehrenreich living with the poor, like that dude who changed his skin color and wrote Black Like Me. I know them, drink with them, and count them as my friends.
 
Before I get into what I think you're missing in your writing about the Tea Party, I want to elaborate where I stand on certain things. I'm a registered Democrat who strongly favors green tech and neoliberal redistribution, as well as drone strikes against Al Qaeda operatives. I'm not very troubled by CIA torture. In other words, my politics are almost completely opposite of yours.  Yet I read you regularly without becoming enraged or offended, because I appreciate your perspective and enjoy smart challenges to my beliefs. The way I engage in thinking about public policy is either out of an earnest attempt to improve my country or an intellectual curiosity that causes me to seek the truth.  
 
This is fundamentally different from the way that Tea Partiers are engaging politics. For them, it's a kind of therapy. A lot of the men I knew who were Tea Partiers were angry for a variety of non-political reasons.  The didn't like military service, but did not feel they could gain employment out of the army or complete a Bachelor's degree (even though their education would be fully funded by the post-911 GI Bill) . Their girlfriend or wife slept with their Facebook friends while they were deployed (sexual inadequacy is a huge part of this. I never met a Tea Partier that got laid a lot).  In short, they are angry folks with problems, and rather than address their own problems they vent through talk radio and Fox News.  It's not their lack of a college education that's holding them back. 
 
It's "nigbama".
 
It's not their lack of charisma and the fact that they live in a town with many more men than women that is preventing them from attracting a female. It's "feminists."   
 
These people really don't care if they are being lied to. Rush, Glenn and Roger Ailes are responding to a market demand for scapegoating. Presumably, they couldn't just bash unnamed liberals for ten years and keep making money, so they expand their targets: immigrants, women on birth control, and now apparently every senator but Ted Cruz and Mike Lee. It's like the old debate about sexuality in art and music. Mass media reflects human promiscuity, it doesn't drive it. Rush and company are reflecting the beliefs that Tea Partiers crave.
 
They are responding to the market need for bullshit.  
 
Before you say, perhaps the Tea Partiers I knew in Fayetteville are not representative, and perhaps they were just more gullible than your average fellow, consider this: My job in the army, and their job as well, was what's known as a 37F, or Psychological Operations Specialist (we are now known as Military Information Support Operations because PSYOP sounded sketchy). In other words, manipulating information to influence a target audience and producing propaganda WAS OUR PAID PROFESSION.  If anyone should be able to realize that Steve Doocy is full of shit, it would be the generators of information warfare. It would be like a UFC fighter not knowing that Professional Wrestling is fake. They all, on some level, know they are consuming bullshit from these media figures, but they not only accept it, they demand it.
 
I'll give you a perfect example.
 
Before the shutdown, one of my friends texts me and says "I bet you're really upset to see [extremely racist terms for Obamacare] about to go away," and we talked shit to each other for a while like army veterans deployed together often do. A few days into the shutdown, I saw Ted Cruz on Hannity seething about how the shutdown—Obama and Harry Reid's shutdown—was screwing military families (who had soldiers that didn't come home from Afghanistan) out of there death benefits. I know the Tea Partiers understood it was Ted Cruz who was responsible for the shutdown, because they were texting me about it before it even happened! I bet your median Fox viewer knows that Ted Cruz was behind the shutdown, because he planned it not in backrooms but openly on talk radio and Fox News. But I bet all of them watched that interview and seethed, "oh that Obama, screwing the troops!"  
 
Even though they know on some level it is bullshit.

What do I have to say in response? I take these to be an intelligent fellow's earnest observations, which isn't to say that he is correct in all his assertions. (It would be fascinating to hear a rebuttal from his Tea Party buddies.) But let's say, for the sake of argument, that he has given us a substantially accurate portrayal of the particular subculture where he lived, worked and socialized. It's totally possible. I've certainly interacted with Tea Partiers like the ones he describes, and he isn't the only reader to insistently tell me that this is the true face of the Tea Party.

But I don't think the Tea Party has any one true face.

I've just seen too many other Tea Party subcultures to agree that the one he describes is representative. By virtue of where I live and where I grew up, I am most familiar with Tea Partiers in Orange County and the Inland Empire, the two "red" enclaves in greater Los Angeles. The Tea Partiers I know are mostly happily married college graduates, no more or less familiar with the opposite sex than anyone else, and more likely to own a small business than to have served in the military. They aren't representative of the movement as a whole either, which exists in enough different regions that no Tea Party subculture is entirely representative. There is, however, one generalization about the Tea Party that's true across regions: They're older than the population as a whole, and I would argue that, like older people of every ideology, they're less media-savvy than younger cohorts and less likely to go beyond newspapers, TV, and radio for news.

There are lots of exceptions—lots of grandparents who use the Internet with ease, and a thriving Tea Party-affiliated blogosphere, as any Instapundit reader can attest. Still, there is a large cohort of non-Internet using, older Tea Partiers who are particularly vulnerable to the information bubble surrounding Fox News and talk radio. Consuming the Sean Hannity show or Rush Limbaugh's radio program, they aren't unwitting naifs, and they deserve some censure for tuning in and applauding even through the ugliest, least defensible segments. Some of why they listen is nothing more than signaling and venting.

There are also Tea Partiers who listen because they want to think about politics. They regard conservative media as a place to get facts that inform their civic participation, and many talk-radio hosts regularly take on the persona of educators. I maintain that lots of conservative media is misleading and brazenly mendacious in particular ways that non-news junkies, especially non-news junkies who don't use the Internet, can't be expected to figure out on their own.

As an example, consider Sean Hannity's much maligned interview segment on Obamacare. Take it away, Eric Stern:

I happened to turn on the Hannity show on Fox News last Friday evening. “Average Americans are feeling the pain of Obamacare and the healthcare overhaul train wreck,” Hannity announced, “and six of them are here tonight to tell us their stories.”  Three married couples were neatly arranged in his studio, the wives seated and the men standing behind them, like game show contestants.

As Hannity called on each of them, the guests recounted their “Obamacare” horror stories: canceled policies, premium hikes, restrictions on the freedom to see a doctor of their choice, financial burdens upon their small businesses and so on.

“These are the stories that the media refuses to cover,” Hannity interjected.

But none of it smelled right to me. Nothing these folks were saying jibed with the basic facts of the Affordable Care Act as I understand them. I understand them fairly well; I have worked as a senior adviser to a governor and helped him deal with the new federal rules.

I decided to hit the pavement. I tracked down Hannity’s guests, one by one, and did my own telephone interviews with them.

First I spoke with Paul Cox of Leicester, N.C. He and his wife Michelle had lamented to Hannity that because of Obamacare, they can’t grow their construction business and they have kept their employees below a certain number of hours, so that they are part-timers.

Obamacare has no effect on businesses with 49 employees or less. But in our brief conversation on the phone, Paul revealed that he has only four employees. Why the cutback on his workforce? “Well,” he said, “I haven’t been forced to do so, it’s just that I’ve chosen to do so. I have to deal with increased costs.” What costs? And how, I asked him, is any of it due to Obamacare? There was a long pause, after which he said he’d call me back. He never did.

There is only one Obamacare requirement that applies to a company of this size: workers must be notified of the existence of the “healthcare.gov” website, the insurance exchange.

That’s all.

Did Sean Hannity's viewers realize what was going on? Did they tune in wanting to be misinformed in that way? (The rest of the article goes on in that same vein.) 

Occasionally I'll engage in political debate with a particular Tea Partier. He'll assert what he thinks is a fact, based on something that he saw on Fox News or heard on talk radio. When I tell him, "You're wrong," I am not saying, "I am smarter than you are," or "my ideology is more sound than yours" or "I am more wise or discerning than you." I'm saying, "I spend hours on the Internet every day for my job. As a result of doing so, I have certain knowledge of this specific, narrow question of fact that I wouldn't expect a non-news junkie to have, because while I was digging into this question you were busy doing your day job." 

But it's hard to get that across, because the Tea Partier is predisposed to think everyone in the mainstream media is lying to him, and that Hannity, whose day job is theoretically the same as mine, isn't just straight-up misleading him.

I get it. If you watch Hannity, he doesn't seems like an incompetent or a mendacious huckster. I don't know myself what explains the atrocious quality of his program, just that it frequently broadcasts egregiously misleading content. Fox News higher-ups exploit the fact that there really is some bias and misinformation in the mainstream media; it uses the most sophisticated methods available to identify the personas that the rank and file finds trustworthy; and it misinforms more brazenly than people of good will would think.  

You'd have to suspect that Roger Ailes is a bad person to think he put Glenn Beck on the air for months on end knowing that he was broadcasting wild conspiracy theories with no basis in fact. I don't know if Ailes is a bad man. But does anyone doubt that he knowingly broadcast wild conspiracy theories for profit?

For that, I blame the propagandists, not the propagandized. And I don't think it means that the propagandized are dumb, any more than I think rank-and-file Democrats are dumb when I point how mainstream-media organs or think tanks misinform them about drone-strike casualties or the politics of intervening in Syria. I am not suggesting perfect symmetry; I'm just pointing out that the vast majority of Americans assume the media they consume isn't regularly filled with obvious untruths. While there is media bias across the ideological spectrum, talk radio and Fox News engage in a special kind of misinformation.

The Tea Party rank and file deserves better.

;

that was a really interesting and intelligent article - thanks

[ In Reply To ..]

Agree. Well worth reading. Results of my observations - are the same as the Army vet's, yet the

[ In Reply To ..]
people of the conservative communities I've lived 40 years among are more like the people the author knows.

I'm afraid for social conservatives, especially, but any hard right personality, my observations are exactly in line with the Army vet/propagandist.

I have had lots of very conservative friends (key: never discuss this stuff!) and acquaintances who are simply too smart, too educated, and too experienced to believe the often totally unbelievable lies served up to members of what's currently called the Tea Party. Yet they choose to and seethe in enjoyable outrage against...almost everything.

They suffer from a frequent inability to share their outrage in person with their fellows, so they turn on radio programs created to serve this need by telling them what to be against that day and reassuring them that they're not alone, that THEY know the truth.

This is my observation, but it's not just an opinion. Research into this phenomenon shows this again and again. (Yes, I have tried to find out what on earth is going on with people who can be sensible, responsible and generous one moment and quite the opposite when the topic turns to national policy.)

Note that, whenever they are pushed to say what they want in a future society -- instead of just complaining about this one -- it always requires fighting others in order to destroy/dismantle most of the genuine traditions that make America America. It never starts with building and cooperation. That is a seminal characteristic.

Abraham Lincoln (or someone who lost the credit) said, "Some people can be fooled all the time." I know know, regardless of where they lie on the political spectrum, that he wasn't talking about clueless innocents. He was talking about the many people who INSIST on being lied to.

This is a personality thing. And certainly an integrity thing. Not just an ignorance thing.

Similar Messages:


When The Army Uses "Enhanced Interrogation" On An American SoldierApr 14, 2010
Joshua Kors, Investigative Reporter for The Nation   I had been covering veterans' issues for several years and thought I'd developed a thick skin. But the pain on the other end of the telephone line was difficult to stomach. Sergeant Chuck Luther, now back from Iraq, was describing his journey to hell and back. The worst part, he said, wasn't battling insurgents or even the mortar blast that tossed him to the ground and slammed his head against the concrete — it was ...

Good Morning, Comrades!Oct 17, 2013
nm ...

Dem Operative Criticizes Ann RomneyApr 13, 2012
Hilary Rosen, a Democratic operative with SKD Knickerbocker, touched off a Twitter storm tonight after she went on CNN and said that Ann Romney has "never worked a day in her life."The statement was tweeted and retweeted, with a number of people condemning the statement as an attack on the candidate's wife, who was a stay-at-home mom who also raised the couple's five boys, and who has suffered from MS and breast cancer.Ann Romney, who is widely praised as her husband's most effect ...

Arizona Police Chief Criticizes Immigration LawApr 30, 2010
"I don't really believe that this law is going to do what the vast majority of Americans and Arizonans want, and that is to fix the immigration problem," he said. "This law ... adds new problems for local law enforcement." For those of you afraid of links: http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE63T5G220100430 ...

Mayor Bloomberg Endorses Obama And Criticizes Him At The Same Time. Nov 02, 2012
In a surprise announcement, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg said Thursday that Hurricane Sandy had reshaped his thinking about the presidential campaign and that as a result, he was endorsingPresident Obama. “The devastation that Hurricane Sandy brought to New York City and much of the Northeast — in lost lives, lost homes and lost business — brought the stakes of next Tuesday’s presidential election into sharp relief,” Mr. Bloomberg wrote in an ...

White House Criticizes Ruling On Obama's Immigration ActionApr 09, 2015
A federal judge has wrongly prevented "common-sense policies" from taking effect by blocking President Barack Obama's executive action that seeks to shield millions of immigrants from deportation, and the federal government plans to continue its fight in a higher court, the White House said Wednesday. White House spokesman Josh Earnest said the policies are in the best interest of the economy and supported by businesses, faith leaders and local law enforcement across the country, "includ ...

Soldier SonMar 31, 2014
My son has just left for basic combat training in Oklahoma. It's going to be a real culture shock for him.  Please keep him in your prayers.  My other son has been through this and served in Afghanistan.  Being an Army mom is also a hard job. ...

Can You Spot The Gay SoldierSep 23, 2010
Can you spot the gay soldier? ...

According To The ACP Gender Ideology Harms ChildrenFeb 28, 2017
Gender Ideology Harms Children Updated January 2017  The American College of Pediatricians urges healthcare professionals, educators and legislators to reject all policies that condition children to accept as normal a life of chemical and surgical impersonation of the opposite sex. Facts – not ideology – determine reality. 1. Human sexuality is an objective biological binary trait: “XY” and “XX” are genetic markers of male and female, respective ...

For Those Who Think Waterboarding Is Peachy Keen, Soldier Uses It ToFeb 08, 2010
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,585070,00.html http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/2010/02/08/2010-02-08_us_soldier_joshua_taber_waterboarded_his_daughter_4_because_she_couldnt_recite_a.html ...

Obama: Politics And Ideology Should Not Trigger ShutdownApr 05, 2011
 Note: During Boehner's statement, he said, "We don't have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem." Obama said they are close. There is NO agreement as of yet. Democrats are still at $33B. The White House is insisting the top number is $73B but that ALSO includes the $43B already cut in the short term budgets to keep the government running. The budget cuts the Democrats want are not cuts at all according to the Republicans. "It's just smoke and mirrors." It looks lik ...

President Obama Apologizes To Family Of Fallen SoldierJun 25, 2011
I'm waiting for the apology to the nation for the total ineptness of this witless wonder. Is game 74 of golf on his agenda today?   President Obama today apologized to the family of a Medal of Honor recipient whom he erroneously said was still alive. On Thursday at Fort Drum, the president told troops from the 10th Mountain Division that he previously "had the great honor of seeing some of you because a comrade of yours, Jared Monti, was the first person who I was able to award th ...

US Army And UPS V. USPSAug 10, 2012
I don't know how long it takes to learn this, but apparently when you ship things to soldiers at US bases, it is REALLY BAD to use the good ole federal US Postal Service. My nephew is at Ft Sill.  I sent him a laptop via USPS Priority mail on Monday. They are still waiting to "give it" to him.  Apparently he simply does not just get his mail as a normal civilian would.  The officers can hold on to it as long as they wish. Now I know.  They only have control over ...

Anyone Watch Army Wives?Mar 27, 2011
I can not believe how sad tonight's episode was!  I have watched shows and say that is really sad, but I actually had tears running down my face tonight.  I have two sons, both ready to turn 18 and 21 in May.  I can not even image what it would be like to lose one of them.  Thank God both are safe and at home.  My heart goes out to all that have loved one in the Service and especially those who have lost ones in the Service.  It is so sad that this world has to ...

Does Army Consider Christians, Tea Pary, Oct 24, 2013
Does Army Consider Christians, Tea Party, a Terror Threat? by Todd StarnesTodd Starnes // Oct 23 2013 // 5:27pm Soldiers attending a pre-deployment briefing at Fort Hood say they were told that evangelical Christians and members of the Tea Party were a threat to the nation and that any soldier donating to those groups would be subjected to punishment under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. A soldier who attended the Oct. 17th briefing told me the counter-intelligence agent i ...

US Army Trains To Confront TPTsMay 02, 2010
US Army trains to confront Tea Party Terrorists ...

I Applied For Salvation Army Bell Ringer JobOct 17, 2012
I thought some of you  might get a kick out of that.  Benefits:  It's outdoors, you can watch the sky, study the clouds (I'm drawing now, and I want to draw clouds, so why not study them all day?) - you're raising money to help people in trouble - you get to ring a bell - holiday spirit.  Also, I want practice drawing faces, so you can look at people's faces all day long.  Also, can write some poems & research for novel.  Downside - pay is lo ...

Army Wedding Moved At The Last Minute Because Of Obama's Dec 29, 2014
Let's hear some rousing applause for our president who does not always put himself first.  The Sounds of Silence. ...

He Invites Army Deserter And Illegal Alien To Speech.Jan 21, 2015
nm ...

The Tea Party (disgusting And Full Of Vitrole And Hatred) Are Not The Republican Party HopefullyApr 17, 2011
I hope with everything I have in me that the Tea Party does not represent the Republican Party. This is what the Tea Party stands for. They are full of vitriole and hatred. This is not what the Republican party stands for. See comments by Republican Party of Orange County Chairman Scott Baugh, "It's just highly inappropriate, it's a despicable message, it drips with racism and I think she should step down from the committee," said Baugh. "Davenport, a tea party activist, represents t ...

Army Mom Confined To Base After Skipping Deployment To Care For BabyNov 16, 2009
This is a tough one. Do you think they should go ahead and send her to Afghanistan? Single-mother Alexis Hutchinson refused to deploy to Afghanistan on Nov. 5, she said, because she didn't have anyone to take care of her infant son. Now she's confined to the Georgia base where she is stationed, facing criminal prosecution by the Army.Hutchinson's civilian lawyer told the Huffington Post that Hutchinson, 21, initially planned for her 10-month-old son to stay with his grandmother in ...

Increasingly Bizarre Story Of Dick Army's (former GOP House Majority Leader)Dec 26, 2012
(I put Tea Party in quotes, because its original grass roots base has become a sad joke.) From the Washington Post, December 25: "The day after Labor Day, just as campaign season was entering its final frenzy, FreedomWorks, the Washington-based tea party organization, went into free fall. Richard K. Armey, the group’s chairman and a former House majority leader, walked into the group’s Capitol Hill offices with his wife, Susan, and an aide holstering a handgun at his waist. The aim ...

Iran Deal On Nukes Could Boost Tehran’s Cyber-terror Army, Says ReportApr 17, 2015
Why doesn't our government think before acting? Never mind, I know why. What a bunch of brainless numbskulls! ...

The Democratic Party Is Certainly The Working Woman's Party.Sep 05, 2012
So many great speakers. ...

Sockpuppet Army Deployment. Brooks Bros Riots, 2008 Town Hall Disruptions Mar 03, 2011
This links to a fascinating yet long article well worth the time it takes to read it.  Many of the posts on this forum over the past couple of days help to lend much credence to the concerns raised in this piece.  Here are a few choice highlights from it.   HBGary people are talking about creating "personas", what we would call sockpuppets. But for a defense contractor with ties to the federal government, Hunton & Williams, DOD, NSA, and the CIA -  whose enemies are ...

Mosul Falls: Iraqi Army Says Mosul Victory Jul 08, 2017
Earlier on Saturday, a military spokesman said the insurgents' defense lines were collapsing, state television reported. "We are seeing now the last meters (yards) and then final victory will be announced," a presenter said, citing correspondents embedded with security forces fighting in Islamic State's redoubt in the Old City by the Tigris. "It's a matter of hours," she added. ...

NO TEA PARTYApr 07, 2010
nm ...

The Party's Still OnApr 09, 2013
Tuesday night, the White House throws open its doors for a celebrity packed concert celebrating Memphis soul music. Justin Timberlake, Al Green, Queen Latifah, Cyndi Lauper, Sam Moore, Charlie Musselwhite, and others will be performing at the exclusive event. Maybe they can get a tour of the White House while they are there, because it remains closed to the public.  In reaction to the automatic sequester cuts, Barack Obama shuttered the public, self-guided tours of the White ...

Buh Bye Tea PartyMay 21, 2014
!!! ...

A Lil' Message To The Tea PartySep 16, 2011
This was an excellent response to the recent Tea Party debate about healthcare for those who can't afford it.  ...