A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Not political, but applicable to this board.


Posted: Mar 13, 2013

A short article highlighting how rude comments tend to polarize and make people dig into their opinion even more, a phenomenon which we probably all know quite well!

 

 

More than 1,000 subjects reviewed the blog post from a Canadian newspaper that discussed the water contamination risks of nanosilver particles and the antibacterial benefits.

Half saw the story with polite comments, and the other half saw rude comments like, "If you don't see the benefits of using nanotechnology in these products, you're an idiot."

"Basically what we saw," Brossard says, "is people that were exposed to the polite comments didn't change their views really about the issue covering the story, versus the people that did see the rude comments became polarized — they became more against the technology that was covered in the story."

Brossard said they chose the nanotechnology topic so that readers would have to make sense of a complicated issue with low familiarity. She says communication research shows that people use mental shortcuts to make sense of things they don't understand.

"We need to have an anchor to make sense of this," she says. "And it seems that rudeness and incivility is used as a mental shortcut to make sense of those complicated issues."

;

Umhm. Also, a while ago I posted on a study showing that - people who learned their favorite ideas

[ In Reply To ..]
were probably NOT true, or just plain not true, tended to fight more passionately FOR them, not less. This was without the polite/rude factor, too. The defensiveness is triggered by the bad news of being wrong, and whatever that means for each issue, independent of the bearer.

I suspect the best one can do on a board like this is to offer information and discussion for those who happen to be interested in the topic and fairly similar in orientation. Actually changing minds? Uhuh. It's hard enough for me to nudge myself out of a rut going the wrong direction, those I've actually acknowledged, and I like to think I'm relatively open minded.

We are the human race... :)

"The truth will set you free. But first it will piss you off." Gloria Steinem

Just goes to show - anon

[ In Reply To ..]
Like mama always said... You catch more flies with honey than vinegar. =]

That is so true, and yet - sm

[ In Reply To ..]
we seem to have such a problem controlling ourselves sometimes that we go directly against common sense and get snippy with people who disagree with us (as if THAT is going to make them listen to us). And what does it accomplish? Not a thing! I don't know about anyone else, but when I lose my cool, I never feel good about it afterwards. The end result is always a complete lack of accomplishment.

Similar Messages:


Messages On The Political BoardMar 27, 2012
Reading through the posts I would like to ask everyone again to please stick to issues and discuss politics and leave out the name calling and insulting.  The posts are getting personal again.  People can get into heated discussions.  That is understandable, but would like to remind everyone this board is for discussing politics, not insulting other posters.  If there is a post that has nothing to do with the topic being discussed, but is just to inflame other posters those ...

I'm Not Sure I Can Handle A Political Board, LOLApr 21, 2011
I always enjoy dropping by here for a break, between tasks. I'm learning that I get cranky about politics. Obviously I need an outlet from stressful work, but I'm just not sure I can handle politics. I'm never cranky around people that I see in person. Why is it so hard to do on forums! I admire those who are able to be statesmanish, even on forums such as this. That is a goal I am setting for myself. ...

Should This Board Be For Political AND Social Issues? Dec 11, 2012
x ...

I've Noticed On This Board Regarding Political TopcsJan 07, 2013
If a conservative posts an article or a concern the liberals will ridicule and make fun of the poster or article instead of ether not contributing or not shutting up (i.e. if you can't contribute intelligently to the conversation then don't contribute at all). The conservatives/indpependents on this board seemt to the be only ones able to handle differences of opinion with intelligent conversations. Conservatives bring up issues that are of real concern.  They are faced with rid ...

A Few Thoughts About The Political Discourse On This BoardJun 30, 2015
1.   Pigeonholes, prejudices and labels:  It's the natural tendency of the human mind to simplify reality.  This is an adaptive mechanism by which we seek to make sense of a world that is overwhelmingly complex and constantly changing.  Even our physical sensory organs (and their respective brain centers) are designed in a way to filter OUT the vast majority of the millions of bits of sensory data that impinge on us constantly. If not, we'd be so inundated with ...

To All My Political Friends-not Political But I WishOct 26, 2012
and hope all of you stay safe up and down the East Coast during Sandy's battering. If it's as bad as last year, it's gonna be a lot of trouble for a lot of people. In some places, there are still a lot of leaves on the trees and Halloween last year brings back some ugly memories. Take precautions and stay safe. ...

Do I Have The Right Board? Is It A Politics Board For Adults? (sm)Aug 12, 2012
Oh, teacher, teacher, he was mean to me.  I can't even believe this.  I was going to say a bunch of lightweights, but I'll change to whiners.    Wow. ...

And Now It Becomes Even More Political...Jul 14, 2013
I know many of you don't like Breitbart, but there's no commentary, just a statement from the DOJ. http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/07/14/DOJ-investigate-Zimmerman?utm_source=BreitbartNews&utm_medium=facebook ...

Political HumorOct 28, 2009
Thought we could all use a laugh.  I got this email.....   The Pentagon announced TODAY the formation of a new 500-man elite fighting unit called the:   United States Redneck Special Forces (USRSF)   These mostly Southern boys will be dropped off into Afghanistan and will be given only the following facts about the Taliban and terrorists:  1. The season opened today. 2. There is no limit. 3. They taste just like chicken. 4. They don't like beer, pickups, co ...

I Guess This Is Political, If Not, SorryNov 10, 2009
So, I'm a conservative pretty much to the core.  Not as far right as Rush, definitely nowhere near Michael Savage, more kinda like Sean Hannity.  This whole thing about the DC Sniper being put to death tonight kinda has me bugged.  The death penalty is supposed to be a conservative belief.  I realize he killed 10 people in cold blood but who are we to play God and take his life too?  I do understand the Bible saying "an eye for an eye". I read a lot of true crime, ...

Some Political HumorDec 03, 2009
This is funny whether you like him or not.  I'll bet Obama would laugh at this.   http://www.theonion.com/content/video/obamas_home_teleprompter?utm_source=videoembed     ...

Political CartoonFeb 21, 2010
...

Political Scandals Apr 03, 2010
http://www.comcast.net/slideshow/news-politics-politicalsexscandals/ ...

Political HumorMar 18, 2012
I thought this was funny about politicians - Its neutral.    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40owQ7mQRok&feature=related ...

What Would Be The Political Implications Of This In Apr 20, 2010
 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1267136/Father-banned-driving-getting-wheel-toy-Barbie-car-drunk.html ...

SR With Political Leanings? Sep 10, 2010
Dictator said:      He is aware that Obama is the president. System typed:  He is aware of the vomitus the president. ...

BP Oil Spill Becoming PoliticalMay 26, 2010
I never saw James Carville so furious and I don't blame him. This is oil spill is absolutely unforgiveable. The marshlands are being destroyed and probably the whole fishing industry for a few years, if not more than decades. I was reading other reports yesterday and I always read the poster's comments. Some say stop depending on oil and depend on nuclear, solar, and wind. That's easier said than done. Solar and wind are expensive and not a guarantee for northern climates. N ...

Some Political HumorMay 23, 2012
This is funny.  Thought we could all use a laugh.   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QjNTAna0IU0&feature=g-logo ...

Here's A Political ParodyAug 10, 2012
It's titled: "The Obama That I Used To Know." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJnAp3YxCCw It rings true for the disenfranchised Americans who now realize they were sold a bill of goods at the last election. See what you think of it. ...

VR Political FunnyAug 20, 2012
Spoken:  She continues to run down the halls. VR:  She continues to Ron Paul's.  ...

Some Political HumorSep 19, 2012
Thought this was cute.  Humor or relaity?  Think I've had these kind of conservations here.  LOL http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGwtG8nVpUU&feature=related     ...

Some Political HumorOct 04, 2012
To lighten the mood, this guy is a crack up.  I think Obama must have watched him and used the taking no questions one.  LOL  The whole routine about politicians is funny. http://www.comedycentral.com/video-clips/2vzxrg/stand-up-brian-regan--brian-regan---politics     ...

Political RantsOct 06, 2012
Why does it seem like only the narrow-minded right wingers post on this forum? I hate to tell you, but Romney lies as much if not more than Obama. He will sit there and say he wants to create jobs in the US while having profited greatly from offshoring. That's just the tip of the iceburg. ...

Political PunditsJul 23, 2013
Is anyone else here put off by political pundits? I don't care if they're democrat or republican, they all get under my skin. Half the time, they're just spouting crap to get their troops all riled up and boost ratings. They often yell, cut people off and mock their callers. I enjoy reading the news and don't need it spoonfed to me by some partisan blowhard. I don't care who they are! Anybody else agree? ...

Is This Political? Does This Mean He Can't Handle The Job?Oct 07, 2013
  link ...

Hilarious Political Ad -May 28, 2014
See it on YouTube:  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LS8P8dfbPzE ...

So Political Favorites Aside Just For FunApr 05, 2016
I predict outsiders Trump and Sanders.  ...

Political SongNov 14, 2016
Excellent song and fitting.   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cTjmhA0kiA4 ...

Now The Oscars Have Become Political!Jan 23, 2016
Congressional Black Caucus member supports Oscars 'diversity' boycott http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2016/01/22/congressional-black-caucus-member-supports-oscars-diversity-boycott.html Are Asians, Hispanics and Arabs boycotting also? ...

Political HumorFeb 09, 2016
1. President Donald Trump and Vice President Marco Rubio are sworn into office. 2. In a rare event on inauguration day, Congress convenes for an emergency meeting to repeal the illegal and unconstitutional Socialist healthcare farce known as Obamacare. The new Director of Health and Social Services Dr. Ben Carson announces that an independent group of healthcare management professionals is hired to handle healthcare services for poor and low income people. They are also assigned the duty o ...