A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry
Charleston church victims' families forgive Roof
Posted: Jun 20, 2015
I wasn't going to post or comment this weekend, but on this stormy Saturday, I just listened to some of the most powerful words from the families of the Charleston victims. They said:
"I will never be able to hold her again, but I forgive you," a daughter of Ethel Lance said. "And have mercy on your soul. You hurt me. You hurt a lot of people but God forgives you, and I forgive you."
Felicia Sanders -- mother of victim Tywanza Sanders and a survivor of the church shooting herself -- said that "every fiber in my body hurts, and I will never be the same. As we said in the Bible study, we enjoyed you," she said of Roof. "But may God have mercy on you."
Roof stood with a smug, unrepetent, blank expression.
The CNN report I watched stated that police claim that he almost didn't go through with because of their kindess to him, but he felt it was his duty to "start a race war."
Then, I watched one of the most inspiring things I've seen in a long time, white and black, locked in arms and singing "we shall overcome" together, at the memoriam for the victims.
It was then that it dawned on me: If his goal was to start a race war - he failed miserably:)
Because there are no riots nor even protests. Just grief, tears, hugs between black and white and forgiveness.
So though racism and hate may have won the battle, they ultimately lost the war.
I am SO sorry these people had to die, but they didn't die for nothing - they are heroes, whose deaths somehow brought us at least momentary unity :)
And just 1 month ago, we viewed comments on here about "blacks being more aggressive". Not long before that, Christians like me who didn't agree with other Christians "shunning" rather than showing grace - we were called "Christian haters" and "christians in name only".
Both were clearly desparate regurgitations of what their politicians and their media have brainwashed them with, over power and money.
But the beautiful African-American Christian people of Charleston have proven you wrong on both counts, those of you spewing your regurgitated political nonsense - because THIS is how real African Americans AND real Christians behave :)
You may have hidden under the American flag and "Mock Christianity" for a while, but in the end, truth was revealed. So you lose, racism and hatred. YOU. LOSE:)
Like Joseph said in Gen 50:20: "But as for you, ye thought to do evil to me, but God turned it into good"
http://www.cnn.com/2015/06/19/us/charleston-church-shooting-main/
;
Their forgiveness gives everyone some peace - but we cannot accept
[ In Reply To ..]the forgiveness of the individuals as an excuse or acceptance of the racism and hate that caused this event.
Over the past 12 months, many, many cases of racism and hate have been brought to light both in murders, killings, police actions, citizen actions, in physical terms and in reactions and words spoken by our elected and selected officials. We must assure changes in the people effecting these racist and hate actions by education, exposure, demonstration, resistance (if necessary), and election. Everyone needs to stand up for what is right, not just those being persecuted.
Oh I agree, consequences and justice are still necessary. But forgiveness is the only known cure - for hatred ~Julia Sugarbaker
[ In Reply To ..]I didn't mean to imply that Roof shouldn't receive consequences, thanks for pointing that out so I can clarify.
Allowing him out of consequence would be loving our neighbor MORE than love ourselves, not AS ourselves.
Forgiveness has little to to do with others, really, or consequences or even justice, those still must go on. But forgiveness is actually an emotion, one that frees the self - it's the only known antidote after someone has attempted to infect us with their hate disease:)
IMO, it is easier to see things objectively and stand up against injustice, racism and hatred once we are sure we have rid ourselves of that hate infection attempt - and the only way to do that is to forgive.
Lead us on, Charleston :)
"Lead Me On" - Amy Grant, 1987
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHlTzyGY72g
(Hush that snickering, you in the back lol - if not your cup of tea, disregard)
That phrase actually reminded me of an old Amy Grant song about racism and antisemitism I haven't heard in years, written by Michael W. Smith. (You know, back when at least some white, Christian right wingers had stopped embrace racism.) It's about how singing often comforts us, frees us and unites us all:)
Sorry, this is how we got to this point, the hatred - has to be fleshed out and removed
[ In Reply To ..]Kumbayah is not going to solve this and never has.
This is tantamount to, if the black people would just forgive those for being racist, they will stop being racist--NOT.
I have a feeling this is going to devolve into a bible study...and I don't feel safe--pun intended. (too soon?)
Not what I said or meant. I believe forgiveness keeps appropriate anger from evolving into hate - lest we catch their disease ~ JS
[ In Reply To ..]I didn't say any of that about forgiveness stopping racism, I said forgiveness frees the self of (counter) hate, and I believe it is what keeps righteous anger from turning into hate - but only when a person is ready. I speak from personal experience.
Anger is appropriate, hate isn't - and if anger becomes hate, we've now caught their disease - sorry if you don't agree.
PS - I am not twisting words or mocking what people think and believe (except in self defense), so I would appreciate the same courtesy.
Because when done by the right OR the left, it looks like the exact same behavior to me, despite party hat. (Thank God I don't pigeonhole and penalize everyone on the entire left or right for it, though)
Whups, I said God. Well, if that's the most offensive thing ever said on this forum, not sure what to say except perhaps not reading what I have to say is the solution - I had no idea I was talking to the same person as yesterday until now, btw, almost everyone is anon.
Sorry, I'm not purposely trying to offend, but I won't walk on eggshells and tailor my responses for certain commenters, especially when everyone's anon and I have no idea who's who.
My response may not be directly to the subject - of forgiveness
[ In Reply To ..]I understand that forgiveness does more for the forgiver, particularly in this case.
My point is that with all of the excuses for this racist action out there
1 Attack on Christianity -- not racism (Fox, Santorum).
2. He is mentally ill -- thus not really racist or representing any racist ideas (any MSM any time).
3. For goodness sake, Rick Perry has labeled it an "accident" caused by drugs -- not racism.
and now...Now, we have the victims themselves forgiving him. Some will say, case closed. If the victims' families can forgive, then so can we and we will move on as though this is just an anomaly.
P.S. Last (probably not), but not least, and one of most aggravating for me --- if they had only been armed to protect themselves this would not have happened -- everyone wants to carry a gun in church -- Huckabee, LaPierre.
I am so fed up with the hypocrisies of religion in my world, my personal experiences, I will not even begin to discuss biblical meanings for this. I respect your place in your time with your religion.
And the NRA blamed the pastor of the church - because he didnt allow guns in church.
[ In Reply To ..]Idiots.
Agreed, too much focus away from racism. But too much racial outrage & Roof wins - He admittedly wanted "race war"/JS
[ In Reply To ..]Roof admittedly wanted a race war and thought he would stir up the outrage of African Americans and liberals outrage again.
He wanted us to become enraged because that's what people like Roof, and his enabling media and other bullies do - attack, we get upset/mad, then say WE'RE the ones with the problem and "naturally" full of hate and rage.
But that's not what happened - we are too full of sadness to be too mad - proving they are wrong about us.
There's some anger there, sure, it's okay to be angry and appropriate. But through my tears and anger, I saw those families leading the way. And they're right - the only way to legitimately and genuinely soften anger - both with Roof and racism (as well as his enablers, Fox and others) - is to find a way to forgive.
And like you say, if the victims' families can do it this soon, we can too. They're showing us the way - and they probably have a lot more practice at how to handle such things than we do:)
Education, awareness and changes in - laws and attitudes-not race war
[ In Reply To ..]xx
Similar Messages:
Funny, The Difference Between Charleston's Response To The Church IncidentJun 23, 2015
Wonderful how the community came together - people of alll races, political persuasions, etc. After Ferguson, etc., it was the most amazing display I think I've seen of this type in a pretty long lifetime. Here, the incident has been used as an opportunity for hateful political posturing. And, incidentally, let's be real honest. Anyone can call themselves a conservative, a liberal, or a liverwurst sandwich, but that doesn't make it so. Roof wasn't a ...
Prayers Going Out For The Shooting Victims And Their FamiliesDec 14, 2012
This is so horrible! I am praying for all families involved. ...
You Own The Red Roof Inn Thanks To The Fed. SmMay 07, 2010
I know some do not like Grayson, but he is doing the right thing concerning transparency. What on earth have they done with the rest of our money? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pE3oiKuU8UI ...
How Do You Forgive Yourself?Apr 05, 2012
How do you forgive yourself when you have done something terribly wrong? I had a dog, the joy and sunshine of my life. I had had him for 16 years. He had a few medical problems, a collapsing trachea and congestive heart failure. He was on meds for the trachea which I gave him every day to help control the coughing. I also had meds for storms, as he was deathly afraid of them. I gave him his food Monday morning with his medicine in it. About an hour later ...
ASR - Please Forgive This For Being Crude...Dec 30, 2014
ASR heard and typed: Information given to Dr. bowel movement.. Should have been: Information given to Dr. Bxxx. Again, I apologize for the crudeness of this, however, I had a good laugh. ...
I Have A Dumb Question. Forgive Me, But I Do Not KnowJun 02, 2012
if you have an appt with a dr and it is in suite 6000, does that mean the 6th floor? TIA ...
Forgive And Forget Vs. An Eye For An Eye, Plus InterestSep 28, 2012
If Romney and Obama team up to eat a bag of live puppies during the debates, the only difference in the two parties will be which candidate they think did a better job eating those puppies. So, this brings me to a conundrum. How many people on either side believe our differences are resolvable? I.e., if you don't get 100% your way, will you be miserable for all eternity? It sounds like most people on both sides will be. Romney creates universal health care and ...
Please Forgive Me If This Is In The Wrong Spot, But I NeedMay 11, 2014
help asap. I have a heart condition and have known for years I cannot tolerate the heat well at all. I live in a VERY hot and humid state (trying to move asap). DD graduates in 2 weeks., How do I tell her I cannot go because the heat could give me a heart attack and I could die? I do not want to scare her but I want her to know how bad I want to go, but cannot risk my life:( I have been out in the heat only once and almost ended up in the ER. I had to be ...
Please Forgive Me In Advance If I Come Across Like A Wet NoodleMar 20, 2016
How do you get someone to get their belongings out of your house without legal repercussions?? Backstory: Ex-H and I divorced September 2015. He "let" me have the house, which I bought in 2008 but when I refinanced in 2014 he added his name. He said something to the effect that he legally had so many days to have his things out of the house. Fine by me, I didn't want to cause waves. He did take some things out but left a lot. Well we ended up reco ...
Alleged Dylann Roof Blog Reveals CCC's Influence, Donations To Ted Cruz, Rand Paul AndJun 22, 2015
Like the victims' families, many of us were crying "why" when this first happened. We now know more about his motivaton for the crime. If the blog currently being investigated is authentic, Dylann Roof claims he was heavily racially AND politically influenced by Earl Holt (president of the CCC) and the Council of Conservative Citizens website (self-removed since this story broke). The alleged "Roof manifesto" is very specific about his hatred for blacks, hispanics AND Jews (did ...
My 5-yo Grandson Wanted To Help 911 Victims.Sep 12, 2011
My daughter's college roommate lost both of her parents on Flight #93 a month before her wedding. Truly said even though we did not actually know them. My daughter has kept in touch with this roommate. They live close to one another and their kids go to the pool together a lot. When my daughter was watching some of the 9/11 memorials yesterday she became a little teary and her son asked her what was wrong. She tried to explain things to him on his level.& ...
Please Everybody Pray For The Shooting Victims...Dec 14, 2012
.....at the elementary school in Connecticut and their families! ...
Prayers Go Out To Colorado Massacre Victims. Jul 20, 2012
Upon awakening this morning I turned on news and could not believe what I was hearing. I thought at first maybe this was the anniversary of Columbine shooting. Then on further listening and waking up, I realized this was entirely different setting and present day. Tragically enough, 12 had died at a theater in Aurora, Colorado while watching Batman sequel Dark Knight Rising. Strangely the audience in theater thought this was part of the showing and were not alarmed at fir ...
Seen The Furious Sandy Victims ShoutingNov 30, 2012
Obama said there would be no red tape... no one left behind... blah blah blah. Just more of his lies to make sure he was reelected. Oh well, he got his photo op and LOOKED like a hero. Admit it, Dems, if Bush was still in office, you would be villifying the man over and over again, hypocrites ! ...
Fire Victims In Washington StateJul 19, 2014
Prayers are asked for the residents of Pateros, WA and other communities in North Central Washington State. Due to dry weather, winds and ligthning, we are having the worst fire season in years. Many homes have been destroyed by fire and people have been left homeless, other communities in our area are threatened. Hopefully we will get rain and the firefighters will get a break. Also, ask God to bless the men and women on the front lines working to keep us safe, thank you ...
GOOD NEWS! Ebola VictimsAug 21, 2014
nm ...
Pray For FamiliesJan 27, 2011
My family has been struggaling financially for a long time. My husband has worked hard at terrible jobs to keep a roof over our heads. Part of it is our own choices and part just trying to find a good steady job. I stay at home with the kids and am trying to get a work from home job as an MT to help out and still not send our kids to the babysitters. I am not complaining because we are so blessed. My husband just has an immense burden and I do not know how to help h ...
Victims Abandones So He Can Go Back On Campaign TrailNov 05, 2012
My heart goes out to the victims of the storm. If any of you are reading this my prayers are with you. More than I can say for a someone who claims to care. Here's a video calling attention to how President Obama abandoned those who are recovering from Hurricane Sandy to go back on the campaign trail: http://weeklystandard.com/blogs/video-sandy-victims-beg-help_660345.html If he at least cared maybe he'd get more votes. ...
Parents Of 2 Benghazi Victims Sue Hillary ClintonAug 09, 2016
The parents of two of the four Americans who died in the Benghazi attack in 2012 filed a lawsuit Monday against Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton, alleging her "reckless handling" of classified information contributed to their deaths. The case was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia by Larry Klayman of Freedom Watch USA on behalf of Patricia Smith, the mother of Sean Smith, and Charles Woods, the father of Tyrone Woods, for allegedly wrongfully causing ...
The NRA Is Robocalling Newton FamiliesMar 25, 2013
Nothing like a little pro-gun propaganda to interrupt your dinner, right? ...
Woman Arrested For Boston Victims Fund ScamJul 22, 2013
http://www.wmur.com/news/national/woman-arrested-in-boston-victims-fund-scam/-/9857926/21079648/-/52lfbqz/-/index.html ...
To Vets And Families: Happy Veterans Day; Thank You.Nov 11, 2009
n/m ...
President Just Vetoes The Bill That Gives The 911 Families Sep 23, 2016
the right to sue Saudi Arabia. Nothing like waiting till the last minute....especially when Congress isn't working today. ...
Did President Obama Tell The Truth When He Said FamiliesSep 07, 2012
Yes. (This is from the Washington Post. The "through W's terms" are my words. His are below. Note the graph--that vertical axis is our debt as we try to maintain, not yet realizing that falling or stagnant wages are not just a temporary aberration.) TRUE. President Obama: "By 2008, we had seen nearly a decade in which families struggled with costs that kept rising but paychecks that didn’t; racking up more and more debt just to make the mortgage or pay tuition; to put gas in th ...
Ban Worse For Business, For Families, For EnvironmentFeb 25, 2013
Bloomberg's ban prohibits 2-liter soda with your pizza and some nightclub mixers The city Health Department last week began sending brochures to businesses that would be affected by the latest ban, including restaurants, bars and any “food service” establishment subject to letter grades. And merchants were shocked to see the broad sweep of the new rules. “It’s not fair. If you’re gonna tell me what to do, it’s no good,” said Steve DiMaggio of Caruso’s in Cobble Hil ...
Migrants Families Met By Protesters On All SidesJul 03, 2014
This is a video and print link from San Diego's CBS affiliate. Note the last sentence, "They will have 15 days to report to an ICE agent." They won't report. They never do. They will be here along with all the 11 million illegals. They will be living on taxpayer money. SAN DIEGO (CBS 8) - Protestors are planning additional demonstrations on both sides of the immigration debate, as more undocumented migrants are set to arrive Friday. Supporters gathered outside the San Ysidro ...
Pray For All The Drug Addicts And Mostly Their FamiliesJan 14, 2017
My brother died from Crack addiction 30 years. Now my son has the same problem. This is a living hell to go through for the families. Instead of just asking for prayer for me and my family I ask that you pray for all the drug addicts and their families. If it could help any of them it would be so great. I see no end in site for my family and I know there are probably families going through worse than mine. If there was a cure for this the person who invented ...
Thank You To All Veterans And Their Families Reading This Forum.Nov 11, 2016
Thank you for your service in honoring and protecting America and her people. Happy Veterans Day and may God bless you always. ...
Fox Tells Newtown Families To Shut Up About Stronger Gun LawsApr 15, 2013
As I sat crying while watching Francine Wheeler give the White House Weekly Address, I tried to put myself in her shoes and imagine what I would do in similar circumstances. Probably just curl up in a ball and want to die myself, but if I ever came out of it, I would imagine that I would put whatever energy I had into exactly the same kind of efforts that she and her husband and other Sandy Hook families are now doing. It is indeed a "disservice" to these families to imply they are mere pr ...
Military Families Redeemed Over $100 Million In Food Stamps.Mar 05, 2014
Should we cut their benefits? http://money.cnn.com/2014/02/17/news/economy/military-food-stamps/ ...