Elizabeth Warren Bought Foreclosed Homes
Posted: May 27, 2015
Nearly two years after Veo Vessels died, her daughter, 70-year-old Mary Frances Hickman, decided to sell the home her mother had left to her. A sprawling brick house in Oklahoma City’s historic Highland Park neighborhood, it was built in 1924, just a year after Mary’s birth.
Decades later, one of Vessels’ great-grandchildren fondly recalls the wood and tile floors, the fish pond, the butler’s quarters, and the multi-car garage where children played house.
“It was really, really nice,” says Hickman’s granddaughter, Andrea Martin. That’s part of the reason she’s so surprised her grandmother sold the home in 1993 for a mere $30,000. Despite a debilitating stroke, Martin says Hickman remained sharp, and she had always been business-savvy. As an Avon saleswoman, she had at times ranked among the top ten in the country. “So I don’t know why,” Martin says. “Maybe she just wanted out from underneath it, but to sell it for such a low number — I don’t know. Maybe she got bad advice, maybe she was just tired.”
The home’s new owner: Elizabeth Warren, today a Massachusetts senator who has built a political career on denouncing the sort of banking titans and financial sophisticates who make a buck off the little guy. Five months after purchasing Veo Vessels’ old home, Warren flipped the property, selling it for $115,000 more than she’d paid, according to Oklahoma County Property Assessor records.
Warren rose to political prominence in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis as a crusader against big banks and a dispenser of common-sense economic advice. She campaigned for the creation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, intended to shield people from the predations of the mortgage and credit-card industries, among others. In her 2006 book All Your Worth, co-authored with her daughter, Amelia, Warren lists as a top myth the idea that “you can make big money buying houses and flipping them quickly.” She has made a career out of telling people how to behave in financially responsible ways, and out of creating laws that will make it illegal for them to do otherwise.
Five months after purchasing Veo Vessels’ old home, Warren flipped the property, selling it for $115,000 more than she’d paid.
But Warren bought and sold at least five properties for profit at a different time in her life, before the cratering economy and a political career made her a star. Her life story has been the subject of much interest, and her 2014 memoir, A Fighting Chance, chronicled her rise from humble beginnings in small-town Oklahoma and her struggle to make ends meet. It didn’t much mention, though, the early 1990s, years when her children were teenagers and she was once again happily married. These are years when she wasn’t yet the multimillionaire she is today, and, she has said, she was voting Republican.
As a professor of law at the University of Pennsylvania, and later as a visiting professor at Harvard Law School, she was doing well for herself, building both her professional profile and her wealth. She owes at least part of her considerable financial success, it seems, to snapping up these properties in her native Oklahoma and turning them for a profit — though today that’s not a practice she endorses for the many people looking to emulate her success.
(By our deadline, Warren’s office did not respond to our request for an interview with the senator or for a request for comment from the senator’s spokesperson about the home sales.)
Hickman’s granddaughter Martin says of the home flip: “I don’t think it’s right, but I don’t really know much about it. . . . You flip houses to make a profit, so I can’t really fault [Warren] much. I think my grandmother made a mistake by selling it for so cheap. . . . She had worked hard all her life and was a self-made woman.”
Don Vessels — a grandson of Veo Vessels, and the nephew of Mary Frances Hickman — said he had not known that Warren had purchased the family home, but “my reaction is that it’s kind of par for the course.” He added: “What’s said and what’s done in politics are two different things. Mary Hickman, being the executor of the estate, should have sold it for the highest price on the market, which I’m not sure she did. But the house was not in fantastic shape, I can tell you that. It was a very nice house when it was purchased, but my grandmother kind of let it fall into disrepair.”
Records show Warren bought the house Hickman inherited from her mother, located at 200 N.W. 16th Street, in August 1993 and quickly obtained permits to do plumbing and electrical work, selling it five months later for a 383 percent gain.
House flipping is commonly defined as the practice of buying and selling a home within six months, as the future senator did with the Hickman property. Warren held onto at least four other properties for longer periods, sometimes waiting a year before relinquishing ownership and, at other times, as long as seven years.
Warren bought two homes after they’d fallen into foreclosure. And though she spent money fixing up the Hickman home before selling it, records suggest she sold others at a significant profit without making any meaningful upgrades.
In 1993, Warren bought a foreclosed property on N.W. 14th Street in Oklahoma City for $4,000. National Review attempted to contact the couple who had owned it. No phone number or email could be found on record for them, and they did not respond to a letter mailed to their last known address, in Colorado. No public records could be found elaborating on the events that led to the foreclosure of their home.
Warren bought two homes after they’d fallen into foreclosure. Records suggest she sold them at a significant profit without making any meaningful upgrades.
In 2004, Warren transferred the home to her brother, John Herring, and his wife, who sold it for $30,000 in 2006, a 650 percent increase over what Warren initially paid for it. Neither Warren nor her brother filed any permits to make improvements.
In June 1993, Warren bought another foreclosed property in Oklahoma City, this one on West Wilshire Boulevard, for $61,000 from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Because properties purchased from HUD are sold as is, and because foreclosed homes can have damage ranging from simple poor upkeep to stripped copper, “the only reason you do that is for profit,” says Steve Stout, residential field supervisor at the Oklahoma County Assessor’s Office.
On the national stage, Warren has been outspoken about the dangers of home foreclosure. In a 2002 book, The Fragile Middle Class, co-authored with Teresa Sullivan and Jay Lawrence Westerbrook, she wrote that foreclosures are “notorious for fetching low prices.” And as a professor at Harvard Law School, in the wake of the financial crisis, Warren served as a member of the congressional panel overseeing the Troubled Asset Relief Program.
The panel produced, among other things, a report on the foreclosures taking place across the country. It began with a paean to the place of the home in American life: “Foreclosures are about the home,” it said, which is “the physical and emotional nexus of many households as well as the centerpiece of many Americans’ finances.” Foreclosures, it concluded, “can harm other homeowners both by encouraging additional foreclosures and by reducing home sale prices, while decreased property values hurt local businesses and reduce state and local tax revenues.”
A year after buying the foreclosed property on West Wilshire Boulevard, Warren also bought the house next door for $72,000. Despite filing no building permits to renovate at either property, Warren pocketed $34,000 in profits when she sold the first house in December 1994, and she and her husband, Bruce Mann, made an additional $32,000 when they sold the one next door in 1998.
That same year, Warren sold another home she and Mann owned for a sizeable profit. The couple had purchased the property, at 4721 Dove Tree Lane, in 1991, filing permits for mechanical and plumbing repairs, according to Oklahoma County Assessor’s Office records.
“We’re talking about more than just painting or minor repairs,” says Stout, adding that it could add up to tens of thousands of dollars. “It’s serious work.” Still, the investment seems to have paid off: Warren and her husband paid only $50,000 for the house and sold it for $109,500, a 119 percent gain.
The profits from these flipped homes adds up: Even excluding the property sold by her brother, Warren and her husband have made at least $240,500 flipping homes (before deducting the unknown sum they invested in remodeling). In her 2014 autobiography, Warren wrote of the events that precipitated the financial crisis that “everyone seemed to have a story about someone they knew who was getting rich by flipping houses.”
She omitted a crucial one.
nationalreview.com
;
So she's does engage in capitalism for her family but - wants socialism for everyone else. nm
[ In Reply To ..]
nm
Dare I say it, "you didn't build that." Perhaps if she starts making - money through a process
[ In Reply To ..]
other than govt she will start to like it.
I know, right? - sm
[ In Reply To ..]
It's just stories like this that put everything into keen perspective. The liberals expect outrage for Josh Duggar while they're pulling this type crap. Pay no attention to capitalism libs, but go off on the God fearing Duggars and poor Josh for molesting his sisters and some other young girls and pile on that nice Christian family.
And so it begins, right? You just know Hillary put this story out to discredit Elizabeth Warren who is closing in on her in the polls.
sarc alert ;)
I've never what that Duggar show. I'm sorry for what happened, but - in the overall scheme of things
[ In Reply To ..]
I've forgotten about it.
Bernie Sanders' wife was implicated in loan fraud - back in March. Another
[ In Reply To ..]
"capitalist pig" I guess.
Jeremiah Wright's daughter was put in prison for money - laundering, lying to a grand jury,
[ In Reply To ..]
and hey that reminds me of a senator (Obama) who got a million dollar grant for the hospital his wife (Michelle) worked at and they gave her a $250,000 raise per year for four years equaling....one million dollars!
Elizabeth - Warren
[ In Reply To ..]
Just one more reason I am getting on Bernie Sanders bandwagon ...
Well, and, uh, Elizabeth Warren isn't running - really, she isn't running
[ In Reply To ..]
xx
Neither is the wife of Ted Cruz, but that doesn't stop - the leftist media. NM
[ In Reply To ..]
nnnnn
Similar Messages:
Elizabeth WarrenSep 06, 2012Wish I lived in Massachusetts, just so I could vote for her. A true class act. ...
Elizabeth WarrenApr 25, 2014Could she be an viable alternative to Hilary? Although I think it's more likely than not we'll get a GOP president (its their turn) and of course we don't really decide. ...
Rethinking Elizabeth Warren???May 13, 2014Interesting! President Obama was against Elizabeth Warren???
Link: http://www.bostonglobe.com/news/politics/2014/05/12/former-treasury-secretary-timothy-geithner-book-details-turmoil-over-elizabeth-warren/F6gSMN8pWlDNzVRrieryBI/story.html ...
From 2004--Elizabeth Warren On HRCFeb 06, 2016IMO this is probably the tip of the iceberg, but it is right there on video, way before this election cycle. Think just maybe that money from big banks/credit industry had some effect? Just maybe? ...
We MTs Need Senator Elizabeth Warren In Our CornerSep 21, 2016The attached link to video is Senator Warren reading the riot act to the CEO of Wells Fargo. Sure would love to have her give a talking to to some MTSO CEOs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8HfGAx8coE ...
Women In Elizabeth Warren's Office Make Less Than Men.Apr 06, 2017What a hypocrite! ...
Elizabeth Warren's Cherokee Backtround - FALSEApr 29, 2017She would be part of the Eastern Cherokee tribes BUT the Eastern Cherokee Nation does NOT recognize blood quantum as a means of ancestry. They go by the mother of a clan. If your mother is Cherokee, you belong to her clan. If the clan is not known, then that clan has been lost. Some nations, such as the Navajo Nation, do use blood quantum for tribal enrollment. All members of the Navajo Nation must be at least one-quarter Navajo in order to be enrolled members of the tribe. Similarly, the S ...
Elizabeth Warren Introduces Bill To Prevent EmployersDec 18, 2013I can't for the life of me understand why this was ever legal in the first place. If you have bad credit, you really need a job, right? No brainer. Also, what business is it of your employer's if you have a bad credit rating and why would it make any difference to what kind of job you do? Craziness and another example of stuff that happened when Bush was in office.
Witness the drug companies benevolently deciding they will not pay doctors to push their drugs anymore. How the heck was ...
Left Jab: Elizabeth Warren, Liberals Hammer Obama On Treasury NomineeJan 05, 2015Confirmation in doubt as emboldened progressives take on so-called Wall Street Democrats ...
Remy: People Will Die! Remy Channels His Inner Elizabeth Warren Jun 29, 2017Short but sweet--funny video at link.
Every time I hear Warren says this I think of Sixth Sense and "I see dead people." ...
Foreclosed On Or Refused Loan Modification In 2009 And 2010Apr 09, 2013Just wanted to share some good news. If you applied for a loan modification and were refused one and/or were foreclosed on (or threatened with foreclosure) in 2009 or 2010 you are more than likely getting some restitution from your lender, anywhere from $500 to $125,000, depending on the circumstance. As part of the Independent Foreclosure Review, payments will start to be sent out on April 12th. Go to http://www.occ.gov/topics/consumer-protection/foreclosure-prevention/correcting-for ...
Fear In The Streets And In Our HomesAug 15, 2016After perusing a large sample of postings on the political board, the greatest fear I have is the ignorance of the American public. ISIS, ISIl, and Putin are running way behind in my list of organizations to fear. ...
I Guess Elizabeth And Bernie Know What May 20, 2015Citicorp, JPMorgan Chase & Co., Barclays PLC, The Royal Bank of Scotland plc and UBS AG – have agreed to plead guilty to felony charges. Citicorp, JPMorgan Chase & Co., Barclays PLC, and The Royal Bank of Scotland plc have agreed to plead guilty to conspiring to manipulate the price of U.S. dollars and euros exchanged in the foreign currency exchange (FX) spot market and the banks have agreed to pay criminal fines totaling more than $2.5 billion. A fifth bank, UBS AG, has agreed to plead guilt ...
WI Troopers Sent To Dems Homes To Find Them.Feb 24, 2011http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110224/ap_on_re_us/us_wisconsin_budget_unions;_ylt=Aij2_NW4BxuPLjqKG3JAY_is0NUE;_ylu=X3oDMTNyOTA2dXEzBGFzc2V0A2FwLzIwMTEwMjI0L3VzX3dpc2NvbnNpbl9idWRnZXRfdW5pb25zBGNjb2RlA21vc3Rwb3B1bGFyBGNwb3MDMwRwb3MDMTMEcHQDaG9tZV9jb2tlBHNlYwN5bl90b3Bfc3RvcnkEc2xrA3dpc3Ryb29wZXJzcw--
Thanks Dems, you cowards!!! This is pathetic.... run, run, run away from your problems. Wow, you set a great example for others, NOT ! ...
People In Wash DC Lose HomesSep 08, 2013People in Wash DC having been losing their homes over small property tax debts. ...
Senator Who Owns 3 Homes Rales Against AmericansMar 21, 2017The Socialist senator from Vermont, Bernie Sanders, set off a Twitterstorm yesterday with a tweet that was hard to believe.
We are living in a nation which worships wealth rather than caring for the poor. I don't think that is the nation we should be living in.— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) March 18, 2017
Needless to say, this towering hypocrisy did not go unnoticed in the Twitterverse:
@BernieSanders Says the man who owns 3 homes one which cost over $600,000. I'm guessin ...
People In Nursing Homes Have The Most To Fear From Ryan's PlanApr 14, 2011Those in nursing homes have the most to fear from Paul Ryan's plan, but their families will have to try to support them. That means they will give up (1) retirement funds including 401Ks, IRAs, (2) college funds , (3) homes (4) plans for the future. This is a cruel plan. The part that hurts the elderly effects me as I think of my parents and my grandmother, but it doesn't stop there. ...
Not Political But A Great Lady Has Died. Elizabeth Edwards (nm)Dec 07, 2010. ...
Warren ObamaFeb 10, 2012Cha-ching!
Warren Buffett’s stake in Bank of America Corp. increased in value by $154 million after President Obama and the U.S. Justice Department announced a $25 billion foreclosure abuse settlement with the five largest U.S. banks Thursday, records show.
Buffett invested $5 billion [1] in Bank of America (BofA) on Aug. 25, 2011. As part of his investment deal, Buffett gained warrants that allow him to buy 700 million shares of Bank of America stock at a strike price of $7.14 a sh ...
RCP: Warren Hit The Magic 50 Number And LeadsOct 24, 2012nm ...
Biden Floats Warren For VP Choice.Oct 06, 2015...digging up Karl Marx.
Democrats have spun around to the dark side of the moon for sure.
Ground control to Major Tom...
...
Gillibrand And Warren Will Petition For Filibuster ReformNov 16, 2012Not sure of this has a chance, but certainly is quite an aggressive "here I am" by Warren.
I have feeling that many of her colleagues on the right side of the aisle are now wishing she'd been appointed to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, her brainchild, which they opposed at the time.
She will be exciting to watch for sure. ...
Bought Myself A Kindle. I Love It!!! I Will Never Be Jan 03, 2011x ...
For Anyone Who Has Ever Bought A Home, When MovingMay 04, 2015any construction or upgrades of any kind? My child is in the process of buying a home. I have bought 2 in my lifetime. The first one was built in the 40s. It was a HUD, repossessed and nothing was needed to make it livable. The second was a fairly new home, 4 years old, and it also was move in ready. My daughter has had a terrible time trying to get the people selling to turn on utilities so it could be inspected. Yesterday told me inspection day. No water on, the inspector could not check the A ...
Downsizing - The Things I Bought And Never NeededFeb 07, 2011I finally realized I do not need to follow Martha Stewart or those other people around and need to have everything in the world to show how great my housekeeping and entertaining abilities are (and they are both still terrible anyway). I have 2 relatives who live a long way away, a brother and a niece and she has no children. I have no children. I have been a widow for 30 years.
Now tell me why I need 3 full sets of dishes (nice china, etc.) with service for 12.&nb ...
Stupak's Vote Bought For $726,409 Airports?Mar 22, 2010Yet another whore politician selling his vote. What a surprise (not!).
Obviously there is not a single principled person in Washington.
http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/blogs/beltway-confidential/Pro-Life-group-withdraws-award-scheduled-for-Stupak-88785507.html ...
What's Your Favorite Thing That You Bought Secondhand?May 18, 2011Right now, mine would have to be my $1.50 "Snuggie." It's chilly in here, but not bad enough to need to turn up the heat.
Second, currently, would have to be my $3.50 Earth shoes. ...
Bought My Website. Taking Some Pics.Jul 13, 2014I also joined Etsy, using my domain name. May I say...I wasn't terrifically impressed with quality of items for sale on Etsy. There were some phenomenal things....and then not so phenomenal...and the not-so-phenomenal stuff was selling too (maybe they just sold to their friends. I don't know. It didn't seem like it). So I guess that's a hopeful sign...
...I also have a *fun* job now, part-time, it is great to punch in, work, and voila! you get p ...
I Love Barbecue And Husband Just Bought A Nov 03, 2014how do you like it? I have never had food from one before and really can hardly wait to see what we can make. ...
I Wish It Would Snow This Year, Bought A Faux Fur CoatNov 10, 2009a few years ago and it is really heavy and alas, our weather here is usually too warm to even put it on. I have had it about 2 years now and have worn it about as many times. I am wishing for cold and snow this year, fingers crossed here. ...