A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Amanpour's view on Afghanistan


Posted: Oct 30, 2009

She's been reporting on Afghan since 1996. She certainly knows the region and explains the Taliban and al Qaeda. Not a long read; worth reading.

==========================

(CNN) -- October has been the deadliest month for the US and NATO militaries fighting in Afghanistan as well as UN workers trying to organize an election runoff. Surely the surge in deaths serves to underscore why Afghanistan matters.

For all the debate happening away from the battlefield, here are a couple of important bottom-line questions:

Is the world prepared to see the Taliban and their opportunistic allies al Qaeda return to power in Afghanistan? Are people prepared for the terrorists' dream- photo-op of Mullah Omar and Osama Bin Laden sitting smiling together in Kabul?

And here's what's at stake:

The West fortunately has been free of terrorist attacks on its major cities in the last few years, but it was not so long ago that the London Tube bombings; mass murder in Madrid; mayhem in Mumbai in 2008; the murders of Benazir Bhutto and Daniel Pearl; the Bali bombing; the shoe bomber and, of course, 9/11 and the attacks on the World Trade Center changed our world and our way of life.

Together, those events created pervasive fear and anxiety, not to mention a change in our lifestyle caused by security measures in airports, trains, banking transactions and office buildings.

What all of these events have in common is that the perpetrators all came from, visited, were financed by, or were led by terrorist organizations operating in Afghanistan and Pakistan, especially the ungovernable territories on those countries' border. The Bush administration, in the view of some, may have gone too far in responding to these events by creating an all-encompassing "war on terrorism."

However, for the eight long years America and NATO countries have been at war in Afghanistan, this war, uniquely in modern history, is still supported by all the world's major powers, the neighbors of Afghanistan, and mostly by the people of Afghanistan, who dread both insecurity and a return to the brutal horrors of the Taliban.

If the threat of new terrorist attacks is not enough, what about the threat of a nuclear catastrophe?

Look at Pakistan this week. Horrific bombings in the frontier town of Peshawar and elsewhere have also killed scroes of people, just as U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton arrives to firm up security and development co-operation with that country.

While foreign policy and intelligence experts continue to worry that terrorism, Islamic extremism, the continued threat of renewed war between Pakistan and India, plus the presence of nuclear weapons in the arsenals of both countries, could prove a combustible mix in the not-too-distant future. This is not scare-mongering; it's simply the reality that what happens in South Asia could affect all of our lives. That's why all of us must be concerned by the outcome of the war that is being fought today in mountains of the tribal areas in Pakistan and the plains of Afghanistan.

Many of the soldiers and officers I speak to in Afghanistan say the best way to beat back the threat of Taliban insurgents is with boots on the ground and additional military resources, as well as a proper development assistance for the Afghan civilians. The Afghan people need protecting and enabling.

I have been reporting from Afghanistan since 1996 and the one thing I've noticed over the years is that every Afghan asks foremost for security. Then next on the list is development to help them earn a decent living and raise their families. They also want a decent government. They know this will take years of patience and effort. They know it will be a hard slog. After all, they have been at war for 30 years now, during which the traditional, honor-bound society they had for decades has all but vanished.

Though it is true that fierce tribal traditions mean some Afghans distrust even the tribe next door, not to mention foreign troops, over and again, Afghan men, women and children have told me they do not see the U.S. and NATO forces as occupiers, rather as armies from countries who came to help them ... but who have fallen short of their promises.

This fear and disenchantment is what the Taliban feeds on today. They want the U.S. and NATO out, they try to convince the people those outsiders are occupiers bent on harming them. And yet, if you look at the current trends and the latest polls in Afghanistan, despite massive governmental corruption, abuse and dysfunction, the majority of the people want nothing to do with the Taliban.

Polls show only a tiny minority support them. And that is mostly because they are desperate for security and safety, something the West has failed to follow through on after roundly defeating the Taliban and al Qaeda in seven weeks after 9/11.

And across the border in Pakistan surveys show Osama Bin Laden has lost his luster among Muslim youth. Support for Islamic extremists is dropping. The Pakistani government is finally fighting back against the extremists who threaten the future of this mostly moderate Muslim country. Under pressure, the militants are lashing out in parts of the country.

See Christiane Amanpour's special report on "Generation Islam"

Unfortunately, at this crucial moment, people in America and Europe are tiring of their governments' support for the war in Afghanistan and the battles in remote parts of Pakistan. The agonized debate over strategy in Washington hides the sad fact that since sending the Taliban and al Qaeda packing, shortsighted U.S. vision snatched defeat from the jaws of victory.

The Bush administration mostly ignored Afghanistan while diverting its attention and resources to Iraq. Now that the U.S. is finally refocusing on the war in Afghanistan it's an opportunity to look at what is at stake: the urgency of finishing the job in Afghanistan pitted against the real war-weariness of western voters. This is the dilemma of the modern world where the latest of life's challenges such as the financial crisis, unemployment, new flu pandemics, health care, and the housing market dominate daily life.

Getting the job done in Afghanistan will take years in time and resources. It will require faith and patience. The mass media is not the best place to reflect that. It does not usually focus on the hard slog, instead it is constantly in search of the new and the now.

But the next time there is a major terrorist attack, in all likelihood it will have been generated by an organization somewhere near the border of Pakistan and Afghanistan. Again, people will ask: Why weren't our leaders and the media there to warn us of the dangers?

As a member of the media I believe that's our job: to report the facts.

;

Clinton's strong words - NJ

[ In Reply To ..]
When Secretary of State Clinton spoke out about Pakistan and al Qaeda, some thought her words too strong. I thought, "It's about time!"

We've helped corrupt regimes come to and retain power, and then we run into brick walls trying to deal with them. They're corrupt for crying out loud. Clinton called it like it was. Will this help or hurt? I don't know, but I'm glad we're not playing nice-nice anymore. A little honesty was certainly needed.

NJ

Similar Messages:


Why Are We Still In Afghanistan?Oct 17, 2009
And contemplating sending more troops? There's no boogieman thereThere's no false imminent threatThere's no made up connection to 9/11.There's no fake yellow cake ...

AfghanistanDec 02, 2009
Thoughts on our plans for Afghanistan anyone? I'm never pro-war, but a sudden pullout could be very dangerous for us as well as the Afghan people. I would very much like to see American aid based on "performance". Karzai may have been elected, but he's corrupt and inept.  Hawks are uncomfortable with a timetable being announced. I like it, myself. It gives the Afghan government an incentive to get their poo together, get people trained. It puts the cards on the table for everyon ...

Obama Goes To AfghanistanMay 25, 2014
When you make a mess of things at home, you get to leave town and go somewhere else, where everyone is required to salute you. ...

The Great One Speaks On AfghanistanNov 21, 2013
On November 20 (yesterday) George W. Bush (AKA "The Great One") was on Jay Leno. Here what he said about DRAWING DOWN IN AFGHANISTAN: “I don’t know how big the footprint needs to be, but I do know that if we leave too early, women and young girls will suffer a lot,” Bush said of U.S. troops’ exit from the country. I just do not understand why the Republicans are not happy. ...

2 More Soldiers Killed In Afghanistan ProtestsMar 01, 2012
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/afghanistan/story/2012-03-01/nato-troops-killed-afghanistan/53312346/1 When are we going to get the heck out of there? ...

Attack On CIA Base In Afghanistan May Have Had Inside HelpJan 03, 2010
By Daniel TencerFriday, January 1st, 2010 -- 3:14 pm An historic blow against CIA -- Intel official promises revenge on Taliban -- Two of the dead were Blackwater employees The suicide bombing Wednesday that took the lives of seven CIA officers and contractors in Afghanistan may have had help from an informant close to the spy agency, and may have been carried out on behalf of a Taliban warlord family that was once an ally of the CIA, news reports say. Citing an unnamed "Western official," th ...

The President Goes To Visit Troops In Afghanistan...Dec 03, 2010
Good for him!  Around the holidays is a a great time for face time with your commander-in-chief when you are deployed. ...

Oh, Great -- Now We Have An Even Better Reason To Stay In Afghanistan SmJun 14, 2010
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/14/world/asia/14minerals.html?emc=na ...

Report: 40% Of Weapons Sent To Afghanistan Are Unaccounted ForJul 28, 2014
I wish I could understand what was happening and why... ...

Reminder: Obama Promised War In AfghanistanAug 23, 2017
On Monday, President Donald Trump laid out his strategy for the war in Afghanistan going into 2018 and beyond. While reaction to the strategy was somewhat mixed, there was one thing that stuck out: Wait, didn't former President Barack Obama say that we'd be done with this by now? Why yes, yes he did. Let's take a trip in the way-back machine and look at some now-regrettable tweets, dug up by Fox's Stephen Miller: FACT: Unlike President Obama, Romney has no plan to ...

Keith Olbermann Special Comment - AfghanistanDec 01, 2009
This is for those who like and understand Keith Olbermann. It's about our occupation and war against Afghanistan. There's very little, if anything, that I disagree with him about. I hope those who do not care for Olbermann will at least listen to the comment and then give their opinions so we can have a real debate on this thread and not just drive-by one-liners like "I hate Olbermann" or "I hate MSNBC" or other comments along those lines. This is an OPINION piece by Keith Olberm ...

U.S. Identifies Vast Riches Of Minerals In AfghanistanJun 14, 2010
Think of the potential! Amazing! The war, the terrorists--all of it. WASHINGTON — The United States has discovered nearly $1 trillion in untapped mineral deposits in Afghanistan, far beyond any previously known reserves and enough to fundamentally alter the Afghan economy and perhaps the Afghan war itself, according to senior American government officials. The previously unknown deposits — including huge veins of iron, copper, cobalt, gold and critical industrial metals like lithiu ...

Afghanistan And Horse Comment By Obama Last NightOct 23, 2012
Here's a story and link of the following: Although the glory days of the United States Cavalry are long gone, horses still serve the military. At Smith Lake Stables, adjacent to Fort Bragg, N.C., 36 horses are owned by the U.S. government and serve their country in two assignments. In one assignment, they act as equine ambassadors, linking the civilian public to the military. The horses are used in an annual summer camp program and in weekly day camp activities for home-schooled kids. But ...

State Department Leaves Contractors In Afghanistan WithoutAug 15, 2016
Surrounded by increasing violence and instability, U.S. contractors left behind in Afghanistan are raising alarm about the potential for another Benghazi tragedy, saying the State Department isn't sharing with them a plan to evacuate if insurgents launch a debilitating attack. The concerns are heightened by the fact that many of those civilians doing the security and nation-building work of the U.S. government hold sensitive security clearances, making them an attractive target for the e ...

U.S. Buying Russian Helicopters To Give To AfghanistanJun 02, 2013
      http://en.rian.ru/military_news/20130405/180451358.html ...

Top CIA Officer In Afghanistan Mistakenly Named By White House: ReportMay 26, 2014
This is what I call a critical error. Link: http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/05/26/us-usa-afghanistan-obama-cia-idUSBREA4P01820140526 ...

Funny Or Serious - As You View It!Jun 17, 2010
Well, I read this article (a male perspective about male circumcision) on a forum for moms (http://healthmad.com/addiction/circumcision-of-males-in-america-and-how-it-is-viewed-by-american-women/). To be honest - I found this article funny, however, I do know the topic isn't funny. So, was curious - what is your view on this? Do you agree with the comments in the article - supposedly made by women?  ...

The View Is Getting More Disgusting Than EverOct 11, 2016
Monday: Joy Behar uggested that Democrat presidential nominee former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton could have said, “I would like to apologize to those tramps that have slept with my husband.” Tuesday: Whoopie calls Hillary the victim because some women slept with Bill knowing he was married.  Really, Whoopie?  What about all the sexual assaults and rapes? Those women didn't sleep with Bill willinginly, so are they tramps? I guess so to your way of ...

Did He Get To View The Instructions BeforeMay 28, 2017
Inclusion in the Saudi club with all the dancing and smiling. I'm sure the royalty aspect appeals to him. Now how about that heightened mysogyny. http://en.abna24.com/service/middle-east-west-asia/archive/2016/05/17/754798/story.html ...

Can't Stand The View Anymore...is It Just Me?Jan 14, 2011
I don't know about you, but I think it's time for some changes on The View.  I think it's time for Joy and Barbara to go.  I like Barbara, but she has gotten a little to intrusive and interrupts too much, and goes on and on redundantly.  Joy...well, all she does is bash people.  It's funny how she calls herself a comedienne, but she's actually not.  Very few comedians left these days in my opinion....Ellen, Seinfeld, can't think of another&# ...

In View Of The Recent Action By The SC-ain't It The Feb 04, 2010
...

The View...anyone Sick Of Joy Behar?Oct 15, 2010
I think it\'s time for Joy Behar to leave the View.  Need some new blood in her slot.  Her humor is based mainly on gay bashing, gossip and put downs to anyone who doesn\'t agree with her.  The view is getting a little stale anyway with the same gals in there too long so she would be a good one to replace, in my opinion.  Any other thoughts from anyone? ...

Jon Stewart On O's The View Appearance AndAug 01, 2010
http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/thu-july-29-2010/leader-s-digest ...

President Obama On The ViewJul 30, 2010
I am reminded why I voted for him and still have confidence in him, even if I don't always agree with him.  Bash me all you want, I don't care.  It reflects on the bashers more than the bashee, and he is great man.  http://www.fancast.com/blogs/2010/tv-news/behar-and-hasselbeck-praise-obamas-view/   ...

Mexican Point Of ViewOct 26, 2012
Great video. ...

Mexican Point Of View (try Again)Oct 26, 2012
Great video.  http://www.youtube.com/embed/wM0dX3x1TQ0?rel=0   ...

Gingrich View Of TrumpJun 11, 2016
Gingrich view of Trump....really interesting "Understanding Donald Trump" From The Washington Times, by Newt Gingrich Donald Trump is a genuine phenomenon. He may or may not become the Republican nominee for president. He may or may not win the presidency even if he becomes the nominee. Yet it is clear that he is a phenomenon and that any history of the 2016 presidential race will have to spend a good bit of time analyzing Trump and his impact. From the time he announced o ...

Please View This Video About HillyMay 18, 2016
Review this and tell me why on God's green earth anyone would vote for her. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kypl1MYuKDY ...

A Woman's View On TrumpOct 27, 2016
A Woman's view on Trump There is an old rock and roll song by Stealers Wheels. One of the lines is "Clowns to left of me, Jokers to the right and here I am stuck in the middle with you." That just seems to fit. A Woman's view on Trump Someone asked a woman how she could vote for Trump, a “misogynist, a racist and a bigot”. Here is her answer: Because I use my head to research and find out what candidates really are, not what the media wants me to think. Because D ...

FYI: Obama Will Be On The View Today For Anyone Interested (NM)Jul 29, 2010
. ...