A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

One penny holds up insurance benefits, leukemia patient claims


Posted: Jul 8, 2010

July 06, 2010 5:34 PM

BARBARA COTTER

The Gazette

La Rosa Carrington has more than enough to worry about. She’’s a single mother with two teenage daughters, she’’s fighting a type of leukemia that requires five days of chemo a month for four months, and she lost her job in May.

So the last thing she needed was news that her health insurance benefits would be terminated because she hadn’’t paid her premium in full. The shortfall? One penny.

""My medical bills are coming in like locusts, and you’’re holding up my benefits because of one red cent?"" an incredulous Carrington said from her hospital bed last week as she recalled her conversation with a customer service rep at Discovery Benefits, an employee benefits administrator based in North Dakota.

The problem started after Carrington, 52, lost her job as an admissions representative with Alta Colleges and COBRA kicked in. Under the federal COBRA law, people who lose their jobs under certain circumstances can temporarily keep their group health insurance from their employer, but they have to pick up a larger share of their premium —— in her case, a little over $471.87 a month.

However, under the 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, those who meet the eligibility requirements pay just 35 percent of the full COBRA premium. Because Carrington had not yet received a bill showing what her payment would be with the discount, she whipped out a calculator, figured out that she owed $165.15 a month and sent a check for that amount to Discovery Benefits.

But Discovery Benefits determined she owed $165.16, and last week, she received a letter from the company telling her she was short on her premium and her coverage "has not been reinstated with your insurance carrier(s)." The letter, however, did not tell her how much she owed. She called Discovery Benefits and was aghast when she heard the amount.

""I said, ‘‘Are you kidding?’’ How am I going to pay you a penny’’""?

Carrington said she talked twice to a customer service representative, who told her it was policy that the penny be received before the benefits could be reinstated. Write a check or send a money order, Carrington said the representative told her.

""‘‘I’’m in the hospital receiving chemotherapy; I can’’t get you a money order,’’"" Carrington said she told the rep. ""If this is how you treat people, you need spiritual training.""

Carrington then asked to speak to a supervisor, who reiterated the company’’s policy and wouldn’’t budge on the penny. Carrington also threatened to take her case to the media, and that’’s why she thinks the supervisor called her back with some good news: The supervisor had pulled out her own calculator, done the math —— and determined that Carrington was correct.

Suzanne Rehr, executive vice president for Discovery Benefits, offered a slightly different account. She wrote in an e-mail that COBRA software rounded up from $161.1545 —— which is 35 percent of $471.87 —— while Carrington rounded down, and said that ""our staff member reached out to her supervisor and immediately received approval to pay the penny ... due to the rounding difference.""

No matter which account is accurate, Carrington has her health insurance back for now, but she said it took three hours out of a day when she wasn’’t feeling good, and upset her so much that she got a headache and had trouble sleeping. She’’s outraged, and when she gets well, she wants to push for a policy to prevent people going through what she went through.

There are, indeed, others who have had the penny-owed experience, said June Harryman, supervisory benefits adviser for the federal Employee Benefits Security Administration regional office in Kansas City.

"We’’ve seen it before," said Harryman, whose agency works on COBRA issues. "It’’s not the first, and it won’’t be the last."

It turns out that employers that carry the coverage or their benefits administrators can legally waive a penny, or any shortage less than 10 percent of the premium, and she’’s not sure why many don’’t.

"It costs more to mail the notice than get the penny back," she said.

But if the company decides it wants that penny, the person had better pay up, Harryman said.

For Carrington, the issue wasn't whether she could afford to pay a penny, but the principle.

"I'm so outraged and angry about this kind of pettiness in a billion dollar industry," she said.


http://www.gazette.com/articles/rosa-101227-carrington-threatened.html#ixzz0t5KvqBoc

 

;

Similar Messages:


Bachmann Falsely Claims She Never Made A Penny From Jun 28, 2011
Before attacking Karl Bremer, be sure to check out Bachmann's own financial disclosure forms (conveniently linked to in the article) which tend to back up every single claim he makes.  There are a ton of alternate sources out there reporting on this, but I chose this piece because it is thorough yet concise, well referenced and very much to the point.  By Karl Bremer Michele Bachmann kicked off her presidential campaign in the farm state of Iowa by lying about the federal f ...

Possible Diagnosis Of Feline Leukemia In A YoungAug 27, 2015
situation? This is my daughter's young cat and blood reading was 6, should have been 30. Not sure about CBC, hemoglobin or just what as I do not have the report in front of me. Anyway, call from doctor today and stated possibly feline leukemia, wants possible bone marrow aspirate. Have any of you had similar situation, did the cat overcome or what treatments did you do? Thanks so much. ...

Well...it's Happening...hope MT Holds OutMay 23, 2017
And hope your children and grandchildren aren't special service learners ...or want to go to college.         "Trump told Israeli officials in a meeting that he 'just got back from the Middle East.' The Liberal Resistance™ immediately proceeded to make fun of Trump for being an ignorant buffoon, but his comment is actually very insightful: it is a perfect reflection of how Israel is a colonial extension of US/UK imperialism. Off-the-cuff remarks lik ...

GOP Holds Minority/women Outreach Conference At Former Jan 18, 2013
The "Discussion on Successful Communication With Minorities and Women" convened in the Burwell Plantation room, named for the powerful slave-owning/slave-trading Burwell Family.  On questioning by media on their outreach efforts to minority candidates, Rep Greg Walden was able to name one Hispanic woman by name who had been invited to co-chair the event, then added that Reps Tom Cole and Marwayne Mullin, both from Oklahoma, were helping out with the "Native American effort."   When as ...

Obama Holds News Briefing Today On Benghazi (sm)May 10, 2013
BEHIND CLOSED DOORS!!!!!!!!!!!!!  The Transparent Snake ...

Darrell Issa Holds Absurd IRS Hearing In Which He Is The Only One Allowed To SpeakMar 06, 2014
Issa actually reached over and turned off Cummings' mic.   That breaks the rules, by the way. I don't think the RW Machine is reporting this, so just wanted to be sure Cons see what a wonderful, ethical, respectful public servant Issa is. The video in link shows it all in link below.  Please watch even if you don't like the source or the read the article.  It's really shameful and all the facts are right there on the video.  Disrespect at its finest ...

The Patient Was Bit By The EMTJun 29, 2011
n/m ...

This Patient Must Be An MT.Jun 22, 2010
Doc says "this patient only wakes up to hit the examiner".  I'm thinking she must be an MT.  You go girl and hit him once for me too! ...

Patient NameOct 04, 2012
Typing a report on a patient named "Patsy". Doctor called her "Pasty" ...

Patient ComplaintJun 28, 2010
Patient presents to ER with "trimmers" (tremors). Cut them shrubs, man! ...

Re. Nursing Home Patient(s)Oct 15, 2009
Several family members while in nursing homes have been approached by religious "Zealouts" trying to push the "right faith" by staff or so-called "visitors" on them. I am so sick of it! My Dad was presented with a Bible of different faith at 81 and dying. Now another member at 85 in failure was presented with 3 different "faiths" by the "staff" and I am enraged. Being asked questions by 85-YO as to what is "B'hai" and what is "Spiritualism." I am so sick of it. Keep your Bible(s) off their ...

The Patient Is Served In The Creatinine War.Oct 14, 2011
:) ...

Patient Being Transferred To HellJul 28, 2014
Doctor said the patient was being transferred to Health____ (name of facility), and VR said the patient was being transferred to hell. My tired old mind found that amusing.   ...

Trying To Fill Out A New Patient Form For A Sep 22, 2014
And it asks about PMH, PSH, HPI and under social history it asks: Sexual partners: one or multiple. Would you answer truthfully or do as I did. N/A: Should be asked by OB-GYN if even then, IMO ...

We Are Not Allowed To Talk About Any PatientOct 15, 2014
I am just reading this morning about the nurse who has tested positive for Ebola in Texas after taking care of Eric Duncan. Nurse understood the risks of working so close to one of the world’s most feared viruses and tried to reassure her family that she would be safe. When nurse’s mother learned her daughter was caring for Thomas Eric Duncan, nurse told her: “Mom, no. Don’t worry about me,” family friend said. How would the mother have known had the daughter not told her? Is that ...

"The Patient Has Asthma....Oct 26, 2014
...has had difficulty catching her breasts." I do hate it when that happens.  She needs to use one of those leash things...whaddya call it?  Oh, yeah - a bra. ...

Controversy Over Dr.s Remarks About Patient's WeightNov 21, 2009
My husband told me he read somewhere on the Internet about an ophthalmologist telling an extremely obese patient that he was refusing to do her eye exam since she was going to lose her sight anyway because of her uncontrolled (apparently she's been noncompliant with her diabetic care) diabetes and obesity.  He told her she was obese and had better ose some weight What are your thoughts? He's just a jerk. He cares about his patients and knows her obesity is going to kill he ...

The Patient Is A Well-manned, Pleasant Male. -- LOL!! -- NmMay 28, 2010
...

Communication And Ebola Patient In DallasOct 01, 2014
Today's Ebola news shocker (not!!) is that information obtained from a diligent and thorough nurse failed to make into clinical decision making, and the patient was sent home with antibiotics for undiscovered Ebola. Properly handled, the patient would have gone into isolation at that time, and been treated with appropriate supportive measures, and not spent 2 additional days exposing others to the virus. If many more Ebola cases occur as a result of this totally commonplace error on the p ...

The Ebola Patient In Dallas Has Passed Away.Oct 08, 2014
. ...

Doc Spelling Patient's Name, Says S As In Satan, Then Laughs...Oct 22, 2014
I was glad he spelled the name!   ...

Funny Excerpts From Patient ChartsOct 29, 2014
I saw the following on Facebook; some are just funny phrasing by the dictator, but sadly most of them are MT errors - either way, still good for a few giggles http://www.quickmeme.com/news/?p=5517 ...

Once The Patient Was Anesthetized And Asleep, She Was Propositioned. NMOct 30, 2014
xxxx ...

Poor Renal Patient Smells Like FishMar 05, 2013
He said: "She has a fistula in her left upper extremity." VR wrote: "She has a fish odor." Can you imagine if that wasn't corrected and left as is, and another doctor comes along and says, "Tell me about your fish odor." I had another report today where the dictator had momentarily stopped speaking, and VR just threw in, "He was born skinny." ...

New Oklahoma Abortion Law Violates Patient Privacy, Critics ChargeOct 20, 2009
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2009/10/20/new-oklahoma-abortion-law-violates-patient-privacy-critics-charge/   The floor is open for discussion/debate. ...

Insurers Push Plans Limiting Patient Choice Of Doctors Jul 18, 2010
(These are the insurance companies, folks, NOT OBAMA.) Insurers Push Plans Limiting Patient Choice of Doctors   Sandy Huffaker for The New York Times By REED ABELSON Published: July 17, 2010 As the Obama administration begins to enact the new national health care law, the country’s biggest insurers are promoting affordable plans with reduced premiums that require participants to use a narrower selection of doctors or hospitals. The plans, being tested in places like San Diego ...

Salaries And BenefitsAug 19, 2011
Our country is spending more money than it is taking in....and has for quite some time now.  Because of this...this administration has threatened older folks with no SS check unless the debt ceiling was raised.  Now they are talking about changing benefits for the military.  There has also been talk about taking away from Medicare and Medicaid.  Both parties have talked about taking away from Medicare...even the president's healthcare takes away from Medicare to pay for ...

Military BenefitsAug 26, 2010
My first husband (a military man) killed himself years ago.  I was (am) entitlted to death benefits and have received them for the past 12 years.  I am now in a common law relationship (2 years), but ready to end it.  He is being very difficult and wants everything, including for me to sell MY home and split the money from that.  I've spoke to a lawyer who says that my state recognizes common law relationships and we will actually have to go through a divorce. My q ...

Yesterday's "test" Posting About Not Being Able To Post Still Holds TrueSep 26, 2012
I can answer posts but not post new messages. I did a virus check, malware, registry, disk defrag, etc. you name it. I did it. This morning, same thing. "You have been permanently banned from posting on this site." So I did a Restore back 5 days. Still got the same message. Up until yesterday afternoon, I had no problem. So, if THIS message posts, all I can say is bye-bye since I won't be able to contribute any new posts and do not want to just answer posts. It's been fun sparring w ...

OBAMA GOLFS FOR 4 HOURS, 40 MINUTES ON SATURDAY, THEN HOLDS NIGHTTIME EBOLA MEETING--WHICH NEW EBOLAOct 19, 2014
nm ...