A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Family situation


Posted: Jan 11, 2015

I have a great aunt who came into quite a bit of money years ago and she shared lots with her granddaughter.  Her granddaughter has not been one to make much of herself, partied alot in college, didn't finish and was given a job as a secretary at her mother's place of employment.  She bought her granddaughter a couple of cars and eventually had a house built for her, which her granddaughter got absolutely free. After grandmother bought her the house, she and her boyfriend got married and had a baby.

So, my daughter, went to college as well, got a job on her own after leaving college.  She met a guy and they married and had a child.  My daughter has not felt that they are financially sound enough at this time to purchase a house, so they rent.  I don't know if they are saving for a house or what they are doing, but regardless, they choose to rent.

So, at Christmas dinner, my great aunt made the comment that her granddaughter did things the "right way" by buying a house FIRST and then having children.  She went on to say she couldn't imagine anyone being stupid enough to throw away money renting a house when they should be investing in their children's future with a house.  She looked over at my daughter and husband when she said this.

I didn't say anything and neither did my daughter.  Well, after Christmas, my daughter told me it really bothered her what she said, especially in light of the fact that her granddaughter hadn't worked for one single thing she has adn my daughter and her husband have worked for everything that they have.  I agreed and told her I was sorry I didn't speak up and my daughter agreed that would have been inappropriate to do at a family Christmas gathering.

So, now holidays are over and I really feel I should call up the great aunt or go visit her and let her know that I think what she said was of very poor taste, to glorify her granddaughter who was given everything and never worked for anything and put my daughter down.  The tricky part, is this is a dramatic aunt and she is the type that I could say it as nice as could be to her and she could possibly call everyone in the family and say I cussed her out or something, just to get the attention.  If it were me she was talking about, I probably wouldn't care, but I almost feel like I am letting my daughter down if I don't say anything and on top of that, I don't want her to feel free to put my daughter down at future gatherings.

So, am I kinda on the right track here, would you say anything or would you let it go and wait until the next family event and see what happens?

;

You could speak up and say something and get same - response I did, with my aunt

[ In Reply To ..]
My aunt was in assisted living. We were extremely close for years and years. I went to visit her, she wanted me to buy something for my kitchen to hang up to use, a towel to dry your hands with that her new close friend there made. I do not use cloth towels, only paper ones for the kitchen and she was so upset, made what I consider nasty remarks to me regarding the use of the towels and to bottom line, I just left hurt and we never spoke again. She lived a few years longer but gone is gone. Same could happen with you and the great-aunt. You can choose if it is worth mentioning anything.

let it go - clyde

[ In Reply To ..]
I don't see this ending well if you bring it up. Your family knows the truth. If it helps bring you closure, write your ain't a letter and then tear it up, but I wouldn't send it.

If the aunt makes another comment at the next family gathering, interrupt her with an obvious interruption like, "would anybody like more wine" and then quickly change the subject. If the aunt doesn't take the hint, interrupt her again and just say, "I think we should discuss this in private later."

let it go - clyde

[ In Reply To ..]
I don't see this ending well if you bring it up. Your family knows the truth. If it helps bring you closure, write your ain't a letter and then tear it up, but I wouldn't send it.

If the aunt makes another comment at the next family gathering, interrupt her with an obvious interruption like, "would anybody like more wine" and then quickly change the subject. If the aunt doesn't take the hint, interrupt her again and just say, "I think we should discuss this in private later."

My Take - see msg

[ In Reply To ..]
You did the right thing by not saying anything, especially at a family gathering, and double-especially at Christmas.

I'm guessing that everyone in the room and in the family knows how this aunt is and knows that she gives her granddaughter freebies.

You could say something if you want, but this woman sounds like trouble and could seriously cause trouble. However, I would not let her step on you or your daughter.

If there's another gathering where this comes up, I would treat it with a sense of humor: "Oh, auntie--you are toooo much. Your granddaughter is sooo lucky to have someone like you in her life to purchase her a house!"

Trust me, her mouth will drop open. What is she supposed to do with a compliment?

I would have grown a spine and said something - to the old bag then, but privately. SM

[ In Reply To ..]
If you're so concerned for your daughter, why not speak up and say something to her right then? You wouldn't have to say it at the dinner table in front of everyone, but could have said it to her afterwards, privately, in another room.

If she's a drama queen and chances are good she'd make a fuss over it, then you're damd if you do and damd if you don't, so why not speak your mind. By the next event, she'll think she's obviously buffaloed you into silence and likely let out with an even worse insult.

Unless you're very close and loved with this person, I'd speak up and say something to her. As long as she looked directly at the person she was cutting down, I'd feel perfectly free to cut loose myself.

I dont know why everyone is so afraid and worried about what the rest of the family thinks. They're the worst ones who will cut you down in a split second and not think twice about it.

Yes, this is an unpopular opinion and will probably gain many dislikes. I don't really care. I've spoken up and said whatever I want for years and always feel much better for it. I dont go out of my way to hurt people, but if someone feels welcome to say something unpleasant to or about me, they're certainly going to hear my side of it, like it or not.

I think it is a great opportunity to affirm to your daughter--sm - anon

[ In Reply To ..]
how proud you are of her. The only thing that matters is that your daughter is making the best decisions for her family and her circumstances and it matters not one fig what other people think of her money matters. There are conflicting viewpoints on whether or not it is better to rent or purchase a home and both view points are valid.

I would not confront your great-aunt about this. She is naturally inclined to think better about her own granddaughter and she will likely go on the defensive for her granddaughter's decisions. It is not a competition between who has done better.

If something like that were to come up again, where it starts off, "Well, my granddaughter did it right/better, etc." you can respond with "I dont know anything about that, but I do know I am very proud of my daughter, her family and who she is. I could not ask for better than what I have now and being a grandmother is the bees knees." Or something to that effect.

Similar Messages:


Family SituationApr 27, 2011
Hello:  Just need somewhere to get this off my mind. I had it out with my youngest niece today over her not going to her GED classes. "I have a headache, I'm tired."  Just all sorts of excuses.  I told her that I was angry with her, that attending classes is mandatory, that I was tired of her excuses.  She basically told me to F--- off and stormed to her room.  Background:  Niece is 18. She moved here with her mother (my sister) and my other niece in ...

Need Some Advice About A Family Situation. SMAug 06, 2014
Six months ago, I filed for divorce. At that time, my daughter and I moved in with my sister and her family at my sister's invitation. I did not ask to move in and was going to stay with my mother until I found a place to rent, but my sister offered and since my sister lives in the same small town as I do, close to my daughter's school and friends, I accepted. So my 13yo daughter and I moved in with my sister, brother-in-law, and 20yo nephew. Everything was going fine. I was paying t ...

Need Ideas For A Family Reunion Family Tree Display Or Art Or????Nov 20, 2010
My grandma's side of the family has a biannual family reunion and it's a pretty big party.  Every reunion a different families "hosts" the reunion.  Hosting generally means they pick a location for everyone to gather, book the facility and caterers, send out the newsletter, and contact local motels and campgrounds for special group rates, etc.  Then of course their in charge of the events at the dinner like giving prizes for who traveled the farthest, the oldest, the you ...

Car SituationOct 31, 2011
Okay, I have an issue here. My mom come into some money a few months ago. She knew how I LOVED VW Beetles, so she took me to pick out a nice used one, and I did. I got a red 2010 VW Beetle. The one stipulation she had was my husband could not drive the car unless I was with him. He doesn't take care of his truck and so she said he wasn't allowed to drive it without me in the car. Well, today he came home and said I don't have any gas in my truck so I'm gonna have to tak ...

Anyone Have Experience With This Situation?Sep 09, 2011
Although I'm making a pretty decent income between my full-time and part-time IC jobs, I'm looking to not only make a bit of extra money but also just to have something fun (and a bit more social) to do on the side. Without naming names (which I believe is against board rules here), I'm checking into two Swavorski crystal independent distiributorship opportunities.  I can't name names, but I believe someone on this forum posted a few months ago about repping for one of ...

Some Opinions On This Situation Jul 29, 2011
I live in a semidetached neighborhood and the neighbors on one side constantly burn a fire pit with wood pallets and whatever in it all the time at least 4 to 5 times a week.  Well our cars next door are covered with ashes from their fire pit and we have new cars.  We have talked to them about this but it does not good.  Any sugestions.  It isnt even worth washing these cars anymore and also you need to keep your windows closed because all the smoke comes in the house.  ...

A Little Update On My Situation Described Below...Jul 24, 2016
My son called me today to disinvite me to dinner at their house this evening.  He said his GF was still upset and felt like he didn't defend her.  He told me he was trying to be neutral, but she took as he was on my side and now they've been fighting.  So now I'm banned until she "cools off."  All because I said he was too young for a vasectomy.  I also said she was too young to get her tubes tied, but whatever!  When I expressed concern about being a ...

Need Some Advice On A Situation While Out For 4thJul 06, 2014
I went out to 4th celebrations with an old friend who was in town.  We decided to hit a couple of bars after the fireworks.  We dated many, many moons ago right out of high school.  I really liked him then.  Since then he's had problems with the law and drinks quite a bit.  The night seemed to go okay at first.  But he got more and more drunk.  He began to wander away at the bar and chat up lots of women.  He would occasionally wander back to me almos ...

Prayers Please, If Anyone Could. Very Bad SituationMar 22, 2016
soon, situation very grim.  May even have to euthanize pets because of nowhere to go,  no way to take them with me. Please,  I beg you,   I need all the prayers I can get right now.  I keep reciting to myself   Psalm 25:5,  that's all I have to hang on to right now.  ...

Job, Financial & Housing SituationFeb 16, 2010
Hi, first I wanna say I think it's awesome that there is a prayer request area on here.  :) Anyway, I'm going through a lot of trials right now, and I really need God to show me what to do.  My house is in foreclosure ("under review" for a workout plan so I'm in limbo and at their mercy), my health is not good right now (IDDM, hypothyroidism, et. al.), I am very unhappy at my job (full time orthopedic transcription but lots of stress and mean people; wanting to go ...

Needing Prayers For My SituationNov 02, 2011
I am in severe financial distress.  I am not going to be able to dig out of this one.  The bank will take my car and I have no job.  It will probably only be a few weeks before I am homeless. ...

Prayer For Financial SituationJun 19, 2011
Please pray that I get relief from financial siituation in which I am losing everything.  My house is being foreclosed on, I have bad credit, a car that is barely drivable, relatives who need help and I am getting terrible stomach problems over this worry.  Please agree with me in prayer that God will lead me out of this mess.  Thank you!  ...

Prayers For Driving SituationMay 13, 2012
I would like to ask for prayers for my step-mom who is going for her driver's license renewal tomorrow.  She has macular degeneration but drives daily with no problems.  Since her eye doctor filled out a form for the DMV with her vision results on it, she has been told it will not meet the requirements to renew her license, but she is going to try anyway. She is an independent lady and does so much for others.  If she doesn't get her licensed renewed I'm ...

I Am Going To Request Prayers For My SituationOct 16, 2014
I just need prayers I do the right thing in my situation.  Please pray for me! ...

How Does The FBI Investigate An Ongoing SituationMar 22, 2017
I understand how the FBI investigated Clinton's use of email. That was in the past by the time they got involved and there were records, people, and documentation they could look into. How does the FBI investigate an ongoing situation, like the Trump campaign's involvement with Russia, without surveillance? If they're not monitoring communications, how could they say there is no evidence of collusion? If the FBI is involved (as we know they are) then Obama's Justice D ...

Prayers Needed For Financial SituationDec 06, 2010
I am desparately in need of prayers for my financial situation.  I cannot pay my rent this month and doubt that I will be ableto pay it in January despite not paying other bills.  Thanks for much! ...

Needing Serious Prayers As My Financial SituationSep 26, 2012
is worse than ever!!  No way to pay bills at all this month!! ...

In Case Of Being In A Mass Shooting SituationFeb 01, 2013
SCISSORS!  Yeah... that'll work!  I feel so much better now!  ...

Yipee! Got The Eye Situation Under Good ControlApr 01, 2013
What a big relief! Wrote below about the situation with previous physician with apparently him having a personal issue with me, not the other way around. To make a long story short, saw another eye doctor this morning. First saw his intern, personable, filled me in on information wish I had from the start regarding the fact anyone who had Lasik previously can have a challenge with cataract surgery, not like a virgin eye to start with. He tells me it normally takes a little longer to so call "twe ...

John Stewart's Analysis Of The Cow SituationApr 22, 2014
as foolish.  Clip can be found by searching for Apocalypse Cow, John Stewart.  I think Stewart should give the nightly news. He can make news funny and informative at the same time. ------------------------------------ ...

If The Border Situation Isn't Brought Under ControlJun 11, 2014
Make no mistake.  The Cantor defeat last night was a wake-up call to ALL the politicians who think they'd like to push immigration reform while the absolute calamity on the border goes unchecked. Republicans who cave to amnesty will suffer, but no less so than Democrats who mistakenly believe that Americans don't care about the influx of illegals along the southern border. What happened to Cantor wasn't a "Republican" thing.  It was a response to the catastrophe that i ...

This Is Our Pathetic Border Situation, Folks.....Jun 12, 2014
http://www.wnd.com/2014/06/ex-border-agents-immigrant-flood-orchestrated/ ...

Good News Or Bad? Employment Situation For JuneJul 10, 2010
Total nonfarm payroll employment declined by 125,000 in June, and theunemployment rate edged down to 9.5 percent, the U.S. Bureau of LaborStatistics reported today. The decline in payroll employment reflected a decrease (-225,000) in the number of temporary employees working on Census 2010. Private-sector payroll employment edged up by 83,000.In June, the number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27weeks and over) was unchanged at 6.8 million. These individuals madeup 45.5 percent of u ...

Need Some Advice On How To Handle A School Situation With My Daughter.Oct 31, 2013
My daughter is 13 and in the 7th grade.  A few days ago, she tells me that she is in a "blue" mood because there are rumors being passed around about her.  I ask her what the rumors are and she said her friends won't tell her because they don't want to hurt her feelings.  Clearly, my daughter was upset.  My daughter is a straight A student, very kind hearted, and well liked.  She has lots of friends and tries to be nice to everyone.  So someone spreading r ...

“The Last Thing We Need In The Situation Room Is A Loose Cannon Who Can’t Sep 04, 2016
I couldn't agree with you more, Mrs. Clinton. So tell me, why haven't you resigned from this campaign? ...

FamilyFeb 03, 2012
Love. ...

FAMILYDec 24, 2010
Ok.  I am not sure what I need here but maybe some opinions would be great!!! I moved against my parents wishes (about a yr ago), I am 35 y/o and took my son (13 y/o)with me.  They wanted me to move to be near them after my divorce.  I did not want this and wanted to take my son  and make it on my own.  However the problems do not end there, my parents then tried to take my son from me.  I have been disowned by my mother after a strongly worded email stating if she ...

Family. Sep 12, 2012
I recently had the misfortunate opporunity to answer the phone from one of my family.  She started talking about things going on in her life and then felt the need to "dump" on me.  We are of the Caucasian race and she has a child who married a different race.  She proceeded to tell me (and I'm talking about almost to the point of yelling at me) how ashamed she is to belong to the race of white trash where nobody cares about anybody else but themselves.  The other race i ...

Does Your Family Smash The Pig?Nov 24, 2009
I only just learned about this tradiotion,  I guess it's a northeast thing.  But I thought it was a charming little thing.  Just wondered if anyone on the board did it. ...

Family Guy FunnyNov 26, 2009
Happy Thanksgiving to all, especially those who are working! Here's the Family Guy funny: They're doing a parody with Michael Jackson eating Frosted Mini-Wheats. In the parody, Jackson says: "The kid in me likes the frosted side but the adult in me likes the kid in me".       ...