Speaking of censorship
Posted: Feb 21, 2013
DENTON, Texas -
A Denton teacher allegedly refused to grade two student reports because they were about guns. Now one mother is demanded answers and an apology.
Marshall Williams said he and his classmates were told by Mr. Dewey Christian at Denton High School to write a report on anything that they were interested in using different types of sentence structures. He chose to write about the Fort Worth gun show.
But then he said his English teacher told him he would get a zero on the assignment because of the topic.
Williams' mom confronted the teacher. She asked him if he had outlined any criteria for the topic and posted a video of his response on YouTube.
"So because it had guns in it you refused to grade it?" Kimberly Williams asked.
"Not just guns, but you see we've had a certain amount of violence and things in schools…" Christian replied.
"I'm not asking you about that. I'm asking you about the subject matter of his paper and why you took issue with it," the mother said.
"The problem was not the subject matter…" the teacher said.
"You just told me it was the subject matter," the mother said.
The family demanded an apology.
The Denton Independent School District said in a statement, "The teacher has accepted the paper and apologized to the student for misperceptions. The teacher's intent was for guns not to be trivialized in any school situation because of recent events."
"I don't feel like I've gotten an apology yet. I feel like he has just stomped on our right to free speech. He told us we would not be allowed to express ourselves and didn't even consider what we had said. He didn't have a clue of the content of my paper before he told me… he just knew that my paper was about guns before he told me that I would be getting a zero on the assignment," Marshall Williams said.
His mother called it blatant censorship based on personal moral beliefs.
"If it went against any district policy I would support it completely, but it doesn't. It's just his own moral beliefs trying to be put in his classroom and I disagree with that," Kimberly Williams said.
Her son said he wrote about going to the gun show because it was something he enjoyed, the paper didn't mention anything political about guns or even shooting guns.
Read more: http://www.myfoxdfw.com/story/21291400/teacher-refused-to-grade-report-on-guns-mom-says#ixzz2La1wsnvY;
Sounds like an overbearing mom. - RC
[ In Reply To ..]
How embarrassing for the poor kid. The teacher accepted the paper and apologized to him... it's over. For his mother to be going to the news over this is ridiculous.
Teacher didn't accept the paper - -
[ In Reply To ..]
until after the mom stood up for her son. Family is still waiting for an apology that's more than a rationalization. Sounds like a teacher with an agenda.
When my teachers were unfair, we didn't - demand news coverage.
[ In Reply To ..]
Thank God.
In my home state, a family bypassed - sm
[ In Reply To ..]
the teacher and the school, went right to CAIR with a complaint based on what a middle schooler told the parent that the teacher said, which naturally meant media coverage. So, it happens on both sides, politically. And it's all unnecessary. The school is standing by the teacher.
Sounds like the teacher needs a leave of absence - Unpaid - teacher embarrassed the school
[ In Reply To ..]
What an embarrassment to the school because of the teachers personal beliefs.
If he didn't specifically outline what subjects could and could not be written about he has no leg to stand on, and neither does the school. Nothing worse than a teacher with a personal agenda. He said write about something you enjoy. Students wrote about something they enjoyed. Sounds pretty plain and simple to me. If he wasn't going to accept their papers he should have been specific like write about anything you like like unicorns and candy canes but don't write about anything I don't like or believe in.
Teachers should have graded the paper, shut his mouth and kept his personal opinions to himself. Just do your job teach! He needs to be suspended. We don't need teachers like that teaching our kids.
Sounds like both - Fanatical Hypocrite
[ In Reply To ..]
the teacher and the mother went too far. The teacher should have graded the paper based on quality, not content. On the other hand, it's hard not to be too sensitive or not sensitive enough to what the kids are saying. All teenagers are disturbed little creeps. I know I was. So it's easy to see malice where there's only rebellion, angst and benign macabre interests. Yet we can't ignore potential signs of future violence. It's a hard balance to strike and a lot of teachers have a problem either way. Especially if it's something outside of their political views or comfort zone.
Also, RC is right. How embarrassing to have your mother turning the whole thing into a media worthy crusade about being able to write papers about your love of guns after a rash of school shootings that have left everyone overly nervous.
Both parties need to calm down and realize that it's over. The injustice has been corrected. I don't call in the cameras every time someone does something wrong to me, then fixes the problem and gives an unconvincing apology. People have to move on.
Similar Messages:
Speaking Of Feb 09, 2015 Can't get the URL/Link to work, sorry.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1B3jMNYcsc ...
Speaking Of IranFeb 11, 2010From Tehran Times:
Iran knows the location of U.S. missile defense shields in region: generalTehran Times Political Desk
TEHRAN -- Iran is fully aware of the locations of the U.S. missile defense shields in the region, Brigadier General Ahmad Miqani said on Tuesday.
The missile shields have been based around Iran for some time now, Miqani told reporters. He said the establishment of the missile shields is part of the plan to promote Iranophobia among regional nations, adding that the ...
Speaking About Teeth AgainNov 30, 2010I am the one that posted about the caps. The other thing I find interesting with my dentist and his digital x-rays is that for probably 12 years I have not had a cavity and I did get x-rays from my regular dentist that retired and also from a periodontist I went to but when I switched dentists a year or so ago I seem to always have something he finds. Not only the capping situation and pulling off caps and redoing them but also he redid a filling he said was leaking and now he finds ...
Speaking Of WinesMay 23, 2011I understand that some taste better at room temp while others are better chilled.My question is how do you know which should be chilled & which should not? ...
Speaking Of Polls . . . Aug 21, 2012Among Entrepreneurs, Romney Leads By 20 ;)
http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/elections/election_2012/election_2012_presidential_election/august_2012/among_entrepreneurs_romney_leads_by_20 ...
Speaking Of ArroganceOct 11, 2012Biden flashback: “I think I probably have a much higher IQ than you do”
http://washingtonexaminer.com/biden-flashback-i-think-i-probably-have-a-much-higher-iq-than-you-do/article/2510443#.UHcCam_A-Zh ...
Islamists Speaking Out Nov 09, 2012WASHINGTON (CBSDC/AP) — Islamists in the Middle East are speaking out following President Barack Obama’s re-election Tuesday night.
The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood feels that the only foreign policy change Obama can bring is by “accepting the will of the Arab people.”
“We must rely on ourselves and on our resources and build our country,” Issam Al-Aryan, a top Muslim Brotherhood official, said, according to The Times of Israel. “In the absenc ...
Speaking Of Gun Control...Jan 15, 2013Newt Gingrich was asked about gun control. It was interesting to note that Obama’s home town is the murder capital of the US. Gingrich also said that it’s illegal to have all the guns that are killing people in Chicago. He followed by saying, “If gun control works, Chicago ought to be safe.”
That's a common sense statement if I ever heard one. ...
He's Speaking Again Now. I Have One Question (sm)Jan 17, 2014What difference at this point does it make what he says? You can't believe any of it anyway. He just stands there and lies - about everything. If he says he is going to fix something (like the HC website), rest assured it's a lie. If he says those who are responsible in his administration will be "brought to justice" (one of his favorite lines) you can be sure they will either "resign" with a full pension and spend the rest of their days on a beach (Lois Lerner) ...
Speaking Of MSNBCJun 29, 2015Did you see Chris Hayes issue an apology to Bill O'Reilly for twisting his words around last week when he (Chris) was on his race-baiting rant?
I wonder how Brian Williams is going to enjoy being aligned with that bunch of racists and liberal zealots. It'll be interesting. LOL ...
Speaking Of People Not To RespectMay 12, 2011The whole story of the Ensign affair is disgusting enough, but the fact that Tom Coburn helped with the coverup and hasn't been kicked out of office just amazes me.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/12/tom-coburn-john-ensign_n_861287.html
...
Assange Is Speaking To MSNBC Right NowDec 22, 2010He calls it an attack on free speech. I call it something else that I can\'t express on here. ...
Generally Speaking UpdateMay 28, 2010Just wanted to let you know that I asked the question below (Would you be comfortable with another woman discussing her marital problems with your husband) because I actually had the unfortunate experience. A mom on our son's ball team started complaining about her husband to my husband (he coaches). My husband told me about it as soon as it started, but we really didn't think much of it. As the season progressed, her complaints progressed and the flirting started.&nb ...
Speaking Of Secret Service...Mar 26, 2013Obama appoints the first female Secret Service director, Julia Pierson. I agree that it's a smart move to clean up a known good ole' boys club. ...
Speaking Of Smart Texans (sm)May 03, 2013Tweet from Steve Stockman:
15 year olds who want birth control are adults, but 26 year olds who want health insurance are children. Good one, Steve! ...
Is This Man Even Capable Of Speaking From The Heart? (sm)Jun 07, 2013I mean, does he even have a clear thought in his head that he can say without having to read it? This is ridiculous.
link ...
Seriously Speaking Of Toilet PaperAug 05, 2013
List of Lies
Below is a list of Obama’s documented lies so far with the most recent lies first. If you see we are missing a documented lie Submit the lie here.
Lies During Fourth Year
“The sequester is not something that I’ve proposed. It is something that Congress has proposed.”Politifact.com
“Mitt Romney raised nursing home fees eight times.”Politifact.com
“Mitt Romney called the Arizona law a model for the nation.”Politifact.com
&l ...
President Speaking Now On SyriaAug 30, 2013The unclassified report shows the chemical weapons were used by Assad. He has not made a final decision. He is not considering any open-ended or military action that involves boots-on-the-ground but will be a limited, narrow act that would help make sure that Syria and others around the world know that using chemical weapons are not acceptable.
You'll have to look up newspaper reports. I don't know if there's any as of yet.
...
Speaking Of Vacuums And FloorsMay 20, 2014I'll be moving in a couple months, from a house with hardwood floors and carpet, to a new house where I've elected to have vinyl "fake hardwood" due to aging dogs who are becoming less housebroken the older they get.
What's the best way to take care of vinyl? My only experience with it is the linoleum I have in my current kitchen, which needs waxing, and I understand the newer stuff is much easier to take care of. ...
Well, Well, The Hilldabeast Will Be Speaking In Front Of The (sm)Mar 10, 2015UN on empowerment for women, and yet the Clinton foundation accepted tons of money from those same countries that abuse women. Go figure. Another one with no morals or class. ...
Speaking Of Special Needs Kids, An Oil PaintingJun 09, 2011on display at the govrnor's mansion was removed by Governor MyWayOrTheHighway and replaced with the image of a bald eagle. David Lentz, the artist who created the piece, "Wishes in the Wind," says he never intended to make a political statement, and speaks thougthfully of how he conceived his work, which depicts three children of different races at play on a snowy sidewalk.
"...I tried to walk a tightrope politically," the artist said in ...
Rep. Lisa Brown Barred From Speaking...Jun 18, 2012Michigan legislator Lisa Brown was barred from speaking on the house floor last week after using the word "vagina" in a statement about proposed abortion regulations.
If you haven't heard about it, the story can be found in any of the major news outlets. I particularly enjoyed this tongue-in-cheek piece:
http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2012/06/the_word_vagina_it_s_time_to_regulate_against_it_.html ...
SPEAKING OF NOT WANTING TO DISCUSS ISSUESAug 15, 2012moderators for the upcoming presidential debates a list of "acceptable" topics that can be discussed. This came after video, in November 2009 (not the only video before flamers start), of Obama talking about the $ 700-billion cuts he made to Medicare. Democrats said they want to "provide" the questions and "subject matter" that would be "acceptable" for discussion. Removing all questions about the $700-billion in cuts Obamacare made to Medicare, the lack of budget by ...
I Hear Sandra Fluck Is Speaking At The DNC (sm)Aug 30, 2012Do you think she will be bringing those screaming Code Pink Vaginas with her on stage? ...
Obama Speaking In My Town Today (sm)Sep 01, 2012You can only get a ticket if you are a union member. EQUALITY FOR ALL!! Liar. ...
OMG- Had To Post One More Incredible Idiot SpeakingNov 07, 2012Michael Moore thanks ‘Mother Nature’ for sending Hurricane Sandy to help Obama
November 7, 2012 | 2:59 pm
Charlie Spiering
Commentary Staff Writer
The Washington Examiner
@charliespieringCharlie on FB
This morning, liberal filmmaker Michael Moore wrote a joyful blogpost this morning celebrating President Obama’s victory.
In his post, he thanked a number of people who helped make the president’s re-election possible, especially &ldquo ...
Behind Bill Clinton Speaking EngagementJul 11, 2016But they were "dead broke."
What difference at this point does it make? ...
Speaking Of The Administration Being Scared Of Fox News (sm)Feb 28, 2014they really must be. They let Valerie go on O'Reilly last night. Of course, she did duck and dodge, but that was to be expected. I'm glad the administration is finally realizing the impact Fox news is having on people hearing the truth ever since the Superbowl interview. They are at least putting on a show to go along with them. If you watched the show last night though, you'd have to see that Bill O really is a moron if he thinks this admin ...
POTUS Is Speaking At Kennedy Center-CNNMar 30, 2015Nm ...
Speaking Of The Whiny New Republican PartyOct 29, 2015Have all of you noticed that when they don't get their way, they throw temper tantrums? They will not discuss, debate, negotiate, or otherwise consider any other view but their own and, if they don't get their way, they take their ball and go home.
This is so dangerous for our country. I hope they self-implode, and it looks like that's what they are in the process of doing. ...