A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

South Carolina Republicans claim of 900 "dead"


Posted: Jul 25, 2013

of facts to deceive the public into supporting new voter-suppression laws. (But did anyone actually doubt this?)

From the Washington Post

(Video of false claims on TV and copy of the official report of the state investigation are at the link.)

The case of ‘zombie’ voters in South Carolina

 “We just recently learned that there are over 900 individuals who had died before the election (and had voted) and at least 600 of those individuals had died way outside the window that an absentee ballot could have been sent, so we know for a fact that there are deceased people whose identities are being used in elections in South Carolina.”

— South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson (R), on Fox News, Jan. 21, 2012

“We found out that there were over 900 people who died and then subsequently voted. That number could be even higher than that.”

— Wilson, on Fox News, Jan. 12, 2012

“Without Photo ID, let’s be clear, I don’t want dead people voting in the state of South Carolina.”

— South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley (R), in an interview that aired on Fox News, April 21, 2012

We don’t normally delve into statements so long after they were made, but this is an unusual case, brought to our attention by a reader.

Take a look at the rather definitive statements made by South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson, such as “we know for a fact that there are deceased people whose identities are being used in elections in South Carolina.”

This was a rather shocking claim, which stemmed from allegations made by Kevin Schwedo, executive director of the South Carolina Department of Motor Vehicles. (“Well over 900 individuals appear to have voted after they died.”) One state lawmaker famously declared: “We must have certainty in South Carolina that zombies aren’t voting.”

Haley did not entirely jump on the same factual bandwagon, though she made her statement on a Fox News program devoted to voter fraud. The Fox correspondent immediately followed her statement with these words: “Authorities say there is evidence that dead people voting is a real problem, according to a statewide investigation by South Carolina’s Department of Motor Vehicles. In January, it found that 953 ballots were cast by voters who are deceased.”

The allegations emerged as South Carolina officials sought to impose a new voter photo ID law during the 2012 election; a federal court delayed it from taking effect until 2013. 

Claims of voter irregularities often generate big headlines, but the follow-up generates much less attention. Believe it or not, the results of the full investigation into these claims has only now been revealed. So was any of this true?

The Facts

The State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) conducted an extensive probe, which was completed May 11, 2012. But the final report was just made public this month after a 13-month review by Wilson’s office. In fact, the report was only released after Corey Hutchins of the Columbia (S.C.) Free Times submitted an open records request under the Freedom of Information Act. He received the report the day before the 4th of July holiday — perfect timing for news designed to be buried.

 We have embedded below a copy of the report. 

..... [see link]

SHORT VERSION:  "It turns out the claims of 953 votes by dead people actually involved not one election but 74 elections over a seven-year period.

So SLED’s investigation centered on 207 votes that allegedly were made by dead people in the Nov. 2, 2010 election — when a total of 1,365,480 votes were cast — after officials concluded that that batch constituted a “representative sampling” of the alleged voting irregularities. (Note that the number of alleged dead votes was less than 2/10,000th of all of the votes cast in that election.)

The report confirms what the State Election Commission had found after preliminarily examining some of the allegations: The so-called votes by dead people were the result of clerical errors or mistaken identities.

For instance, sometimes a son had the same name as a deceased father, and poll workers mixed up a dead father with a living son. (This happened 92 times in the initial probe, and then further investigation found seven more examples.)

In 56 cases, there was “bad data matching,” in which the DMV records had the Social Security of a dead person associated with a living voter. The living voter — with a different name and birth date — properly cast a ballot. Thirty-two votes attributed to dead people were simply the result of too-sensitive scanners.

In one case, someone cast an absentee ballot before dying; their vote still counts under the law. In two other cases, people requested an absentee ballot, but died before returning it, so no harm was done. In other cases, the wrong voter was marked as having cast a vote, and then the marks were not completely erased. There were several other types of clerical errors, too numerous to mention. In other words, no zombie voters..."

In OTHER words, this whole thing is part of an ongoing plan to steal elections by subverting the right of people to vote. 

Entire article at link. 

 

 

;

Washington Post and Fox News? Thanks but no, thanks. - nm

[ In Reply To ..]

(?) The Post's fact check is refuting Fox propaganda - (not supporting it)

[ In Reply To ..]
maybe you misunderstood.

Huh? NM, neither make sense, but in any case, this is - about the attacks on your right to vote. What

[ In Reply To ..]
has been happening in South Carolina is happening in many states across the country.

Similar Messages:


I Wonder If South Carolina Republicans...Oct 05, 2015
...will ask the federal government for disaster-relief funds in the wake of the severe flooding in their state. Nearly all of the South Carolina's Republican delegation opposed funding for flooding victims of Hurricane Sandy.  ...

I (heart) South Carolina!Aug 12, 2010
Great beaches and great peaches! Just thinking today, how fortunate I am to live just one state *north* of SC (as I sliced and diced my way through a $6 half bushel of perfectly ripe and juicy peaches, shipped just up the road). My account is a hospital where I get reports about "blueberry workers," which I had never heard of. We have to pay some serious money for blueberries down here, but I imagine "up there" they are plentiful and cheap. The cheapest I have seen here recen ...

South Carolina Will Become First State To Jan 24, 2014
My state has spent over $300 million of state taxes and only 44 have signed up for AHC.  It is not working in our state. We sure could have used $300 million to help the homeless or redo our severely crippled bridges, but noooooo, we had to spend it on ridiculous useless crap to get 44 people signed up and those people's deductibles are so high that they are still paying out of pocket for their care.  ...

Radioactive Plume In South CarolinaJan 17, 2014
Just in the last few weeks an oil train blew up in North Dakota, a toxic chemical spill poisoned the water of over 300,000 people in West Virginia (and is still spreading), and who can forget BP oil pouring oil in the Gulf a few years ago, and now this, but what did Republican leader Boehner recently say? “I am entirely confident that there are ample regulations already on the books to protect the health and safety of the American people. Somebody ought to be held accountable here. What we ...

South Carolina Special Election Was Also Won By A Republican.Jun 21, 2017
Expect to hear more tantrums from the butt hurt snowflakes. ...

Supreme Court Sends Redistricting Law Back To South Carolina. SmApr 20, 2015
A big victory for voting rights and against gerrymandering of voting districts! ...

"Tea Party" Senator Jim Demint Of South Carolina ResigningDec 06, 2012
Wall Street Journal: "Mr. DeMint, the South Carolina junior senator, had said he wouldn't run for another term in 2016, but his announcement Thursday was a surprise. Mr. DeMint is a tea-party icon who has long argued that GOP leaders have pursued compromise at the expense of ideals." "Mr. DeMint's departure comes as the Republican party has becoming increasingly divided between conservatives and moderates, and shortly after elections that saw the Democrats expand their seats in the Se ...

North CarolinaJul 11, 2011
We're planning on heading down to North Carolina in a few weeks to look at some colleges there and along the way.  We've been to SC, but never North.  We wanted to stay in Charlotte.  Can anyone suggest a good reasonably priced hotel.  Also, my husband is worried that the kids are going to get bored.  The youngest is 8 and my oldest is 17.  Any ideas.  We were thinking water parks, amusement parks, etc.  Thanks for any suggestions you can give me ...

Thank You North Carolina Apr 06, 2016
Thank you North Carolina for keeping our values in check and for using common sense. ...

BC/BS Compensation In North Carolina ONLYApr 04, 2010
[My comment: If the CEO's would drop their salaries even 1% and/or other 'compensation', do you realize how many people could afford insurance without HCR? They are no better than company CEOs in the banking industry, or even in the public sector.) The compensation packages are for the executives in 2009. http://pulse.ncpolicywatch.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/bcbs-Supplemental-Comp-Exhibit-12-31-09.pdf I may be duplicating info here from my last posting, but thought some pla ...

Interestingly, North Carolina Tables Passing WhatJul 25, 2013
bill in the nation. They started pushing this masterpiece forward immediately after the Supreme Court ruling on the Voters' Rights Act, and it was set to sail through both state houses and be signed by the governor--today. Newly worried about what the Justice Department might do or just deciding to wait until the extraordinary national scrutiny this "worst of the worst" has drawn to die down before sneaking it through on a holiday weekend? Among other things, State-issued photo ID would be ...

North Carolina Mob Attacks Female Truck DriverSep 21, 2016
desperate calls to chopper. Following an officer involved shooting in Charlotte North Carolina yesterday a mob of angry protestors assembled. Immediately the protesting mob began attacking police officers and vehicles. The mob clashed with police and riot squads were called, tear gas deployed. ...

Only In S. Carolina. Sheriff Refuses To Fly Flag At Half-staff In Memory Dec 08, 2013
Sheriff cites that Mandela was not an American.  Half-staff is also designated as a respect to the memory of someone who made a profound mark and impact on this world.  It's obvioius the sheriff didn't agree with Mandela's ideals or think they were a good thing because being an American is not a requirement for deserving half-staff respect.   ...

Gorgeous Day In The South!!!Jun 03, 2011
I just love love love summer!  I hope everyone has a great weekend! ...

Anyone Know South Beach?Sep 14, 2013
After living in SW Florida for some time, I have decided to visit South Beach Miami on my own.  Cannot work out schedule with any friends.   It will be a day trip for me - about 2-hour drive each way.  I just want to walk on the beach and see the art deco buildings, maybe spend 3 or 4 hours there.   I have Googled information but really can't find any specific about public parking.  Am I going to have a hard time finding a place to park my car?  Will it cost an ...

What Happened To The Sunny South???!!!!Oct 12, 2009
Anyone else live in Georgia and sick of the rain??!!!???  Seriously, I am thankful to have some, especially after the drought, but I am beginning to think that we need to build an Ark, lol.  Weatherman said possibly up to 1 inch today, currently we have had 1-3/4 inches, it is STILL raining and more tonight and tomorrow!!  :( ...

South Asians For HillaryJul 28, 2016
This just shows which side her bread is buttered. ...

Looks Like Us Poor Dumb-sters From The South Nov 12, 2012
http://pittsburgh.cbslocal.com/2012/11/08/upside-down-flag-protests-over-election-sparking-controversy/ ...

Teachers With Guns In South DakotaMar 12, 2013
There, don't you all feel safer now that teachers are doubling as armed guards?   ...

6.1 Magnitude Earthquake Centered Just SouthAug 24, 2014
nm ...

How Thanksgiving Dinner Differs From North To South...Nov 10, 2009
I live in the south.  How does Thanksgiving dinner differ from the northern states to the sourthern ones?  From east to west?  Here in the south we have the usual turkey like everyone does.  We have the cornbread dressing (stuffing), chicken and dumplings, veggies, no steamed ones though, we don't eat much steamed veggies around here.  They are boiled with meat seasoning such as bacon or ham, etc.  We have the broccoli casserole.  We also have baked ham.& ...

North Korea Bombs South Korean IslandNov 23, 2010
JUST TO BE SURE, I CHECKED OTHER SITES. LOCAL NEWS IS NOT STATING MUCH. North Korea bombs hit borderline Bombay News.NetTuesday 23rd November, 2010   Dozens of homes have been destroyed by artillery on the South Korean island of Yeonpyeong. Reports from authorities in the area have confirmed the incident occurred when North Korea fired on the island. It is believed South Korean soldiers were injured in the blasts. South Korea has issued its highest non-wartime alert in response to wha ...

Some South Florida Docs Decline To Accept ObamacareJul 14, 2014
After being without health insurance for two years, Miranda Childe of Hallandale Beach found a plan she could afford with financial aid from the government using the Affordable Care Act’s exchange. Childe, 60, bought an HMO plan from Humana, one of the nation’s largest health insurance companies, and received a membership card in time for her coverage to kick in on May 1st. But instead of being able to pick a primary care physician to coordinate her healthcare, Childe says she repeat ...

This Whole Wiretapping Claim Seems To BeMar 06, 2017
To me, if there truly was wiretapping, there were reasons for it, although it was not ordered by Obama, if it even happened.  If it didn't happen, it would show how Trump, like his supporters, rely on fake news, and that is just another nail in his coffin.  He really should learn how to act like a president but he can't help himself, he's not presidential material, just an incompetent idiot. ...

Once Seen As White House Triumph, South Sudan Descends Into War, MiseryApr 19, 2016
Just five years ago, celebrities such as George Clooney and Don Cheadle hailed the creation of a new African nation as one of President Obama’s foreign policy success stories, but now South Sudan is looking like a failed state. More at link. ...

What Do You Think Of This Claim By The Romney Campaign?Apr 30, 2012
Romney camp takes bailout credit: An adviser to Romney said Saturday that the president followed the former Massachusetts governor’s advice during the auto bailout. “His position on the bailout was exactly what President Obama followed. I know it infuriates them to hear that,” adviser Eric Fehrnstrom said at a Washington Post panel. “The only economic success that President Obama has had is because he followed Mitt Romney’s advice.” In his 2009 NYT op-ed, &l ...

Challenging The Claim Of Media BiasOct 01, 2012
Author raises intelligent points regarding claims of liberal bias in the media. (Preview: "Many Republicans see bias lurking in every live shot, but the growing hegemony of conservative voices makes manufacturing a partisan conspiracy a practical impossibility.") ...

Anyone Know Elwood? Proof To Back Up ClaimJun 18, 2013
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=m0uedSCARlc ...

Fox's Greta Van Susteren Issues Correction For False ClaimMay 07, 2015
Fox's Greta Van Susteren Issues Correction For False Claim That White House Didn't Call Texas Shooting Terror From the May 6 edition of Fox News' On The Record with Greta Van Susteren, Greta corrects her mistake. (see link) Credit where credit is due to Greta Van Susteren of Fox News. As I pointed out yesterday in the OP where I reported this as yet another Fox News lie, Greta totally got that one wrong. She did, however, step up to correct her mistake. Since it is a conserv ...

Hillary Finally Stakes Her Claim: Class Warfare.Jul 13, 2015
She thinks the government creates economic growth.   She thinks the "rich" aren't paying enough taxes (about 50% of the country pay none while the top 5% pay 80% of the taxes already), etc. This has to be the most stupid woman on the face of the planet.  Go for it, Dems.  I want to see you eat dirt.   ...