A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Right-wing movement growing to kill perhaps most important


Posted: Aug 19, 2013

War on the Core

I respect, really I do, the efforts by political scientists and pundits to make sense of the current Republican Party. There is intellectual virtue in the search for historical antecedents and philosophical underpinnings.

Tony Cenicola/The New York Times

Bill Keller

Opinion Twitter Logo.

Connect With Us on Twitter

For Op-Ed, follow@nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal, follow @andyrNYT.

Readers’ Comments

I understand the urge to take what looks to a layman like nothing more than a mean spirit or a mess of contradictions and brand it. (The New Libertarianism! Burkean Revivalists!) But more and more, I think Gov. Bobby Jindal, Louisiana’s Republican rising star, had it right when he said his party was in danger of becoming simply “the stupid party.”

A case in point is the burgeoning movement to kill what is arguably the most serious educational reform of our lifetime. I’m talking about the Common Core, a project by a consortium of states to raise public school standards nationwide.

The Common Core, a grade-by-grade outline of what children should know to be ready for college and careers, made its debut in 2010, endorsed by 45 states. It is to be followed in the 2014-15 school year by new standardized tests that seek to measure more than the ability to cram facts or master test-taking tricks. (Some states, including New York, introduced early versions of the tougher tests this year.)

[Note:

1. NOT a federal program. Arises from participating states.
2. NOT a national curriculum. Rather, a set of standards, especially for reading and problem-solving.

3. NOT a list of textbooks or books to read.

 4. NOT an experiment. Tried and true basics.]

This is an ambitious undertaking, and there is plenty of room for debate about precisely how these standards are translated into classrooms. But the Common Core was created with a broad, nonpartisan consensus of educators, convinced that after decades of embarrassing decline in K-12 education, the country had to come together on a way to hold our public schools accountable. Come together it did — for a while.

The backlash began with a few of the usual right-wing suspects. Glenn Beck warned that under “this insidious menace to our children and to our families” students would be “indoctrinated with extreme leftist ideology.”

(Beck also appears to believe that the plan calls for children to be fitted with bio-wristbands and little cameras so they can be monitored at all times for corporate exploitation.)

Beck’s soul mate Michelle Malkin warned that the Common Core was “about top-down control engineered through government-administered tests and left-wing textbook monopolies.” Before long, FreedomWorks — the love child of Koch brothers cash and Tea Party passion — and the American Principles Project, a religious-right lobby, had joined the cause. Opponents have mobilized Tea Partyers to barnstorm in state capitals and boiled this complex issue down to an obvious slogan, “ObamaCore!”

There are Common Core critics on the left as well, who argue that the accountability movement makes teachers scapegoats for problems caused mainly by poverty. As one educator put it, less than half in jest, “The problem with national testing is that the conservatives hate national and the liberals hate testing.” Discomfort with the Core may grow when states discover, as New York did this month, that the tougher tests make their schools look bad. But overwhelmingly the animus against the standards comes from the right.

Some of this was inevitable. Local control of public schools, including the sacred right to keep them impoverished and ineffectual, is a fundamental tenet of the conservative canon. In an earlier day, more thoughtful Republicans — people who had actually read the Common Core standards and understood that the notion of a federal usurpation was a boogeyman — would have held the high ground against the noisy fringe.

Such conservatives still exist. William Bennett, President Reagan’s secretary of education and now a stalwart of right-wing radio, hasdefended the Common Core. So has Mike Huckabee, the former Arkansas governor who is a favorite of religious conservatives. Several Republican governors (including Jindal, though he seems to be wobbling) have stood by the Common Core. Conservative-leaning think tanks like the Manhattan Institute and the Fordham Institute have published sober, sensible arguments for the standards.

But today’s Republican Party lives in terror of its so-called base, the very loud, often paranoid, if-that-Kenyan-socialist-in-the-White-House-is-for-it-I’m-against-it crowd.

In April the Republican National Committee surrendered to the fringe and urged states to renounce Common Core. The presidential aspirant Marco Rubio, trying to appease conservatives angry at his moderate stance on immigration, last month abandoned his support for the standards. And state by red state, the effort to disavow or defund is under way. Indiana has put the Common Core on hold. Michigan’s legislature cut off money for implementing the standards and is now contemplating pulling out altogether. Last month, Georgia withdrew from a 22-state consortium, one of two groups designing tests pegged to the new standards, ostensibly because of the costs. (The new tests are expected to cost about $29 per student; grading them is more labor-intensive because in addition to multiple-choice questions they include written essays and show-your-work math problems that will be graded by actual humans. “You’re talking about 30 bucks a kid, in an education system that now spends upwards of $9,000 or $10,000 per student per year,” said Michael Petrilli of the Fordham Institute.)

The Common Core is imperiled in Oklahoma, Utah, Alabama and Pennsylvania. All of the retreat, you will notice, has been in Republican-controlled states.

;

Similar Messages:


Guns And Intrinsic Danger. Or, "guns Don't Kill, People Kill"Dec 15, 2012
If I were at a party, left the adults and put a nerf ball in the familiy room where the children were playing, nobody'd think anything of it. If I put a loaded gun in there, every adult would rush to get it before the children did. THAT IS BECAUSE GUNS ARE INTRINSICALLY DANGEROUS. The only thing that changed was the presence of a gun, but no one would claim it was actually the children who were dangerous. Suicides by gun are much more likely to result in death than ANY of the other usual ...

Help Growing AvocadosJun 13, 2011
Does anyone have experience growing avocados from seeds?  I thought you put toothpicks in the seed, suspended it the flat side in water and waited for it to sprout.  I did this and have waited and waited and waited and still no sprouts.  Then I tried a one with the pointy side down in water, waited and waited and still no sprout.  Finally I just gave up and threw them all away!   I know I can do this because I grew a couple a while back ago, but cannot for the life of m ...

Advice On Growing BerriesMay 09, 2012
I live in a shady area with wild blackberries growing around. I would like to plant something different. Anybody familiar with gooseberry, juneberry or lingonberry or can you recommend something else? I'm not into canning, just want something to nibble on right off the bush. ...

Time Is Growing Short.Sep 23, 2012
This November, please take the time to re-think your positions and be very sure you are really voting for the credentials of the man and not his personality. This country is so deeply in debt, about half of Americans are on some form of public assistance, one in six is in poverty. Our foreign policy is not working or nonexistent. We are falling, falling, falling off the world stage. We are going to be in the same situation as Greece before long. We need hope and change this time in a very b ...

Woodward's Growing List Of ColleaguesFeb 28, 2013
for reporting on something that's unflattering to the Obama Administration. They're treating him like elephants treat their elders - pushing him out. Scroll down for the actual tweets. http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Journalism/2013/02/28/Rogues-Gallery-Journalist-Side-with-obama-over-woodward ...

Pew Study: Growing Support Of Same-sex MarriageMar 21, 2013
This study was released yesterday and oh yes, there are graphs.   Of the reasons why people have changed their minds, they were as follows: 32% said they knew someone who was homosexual. 25% said they got older and more open-minded/grew up/had more time to think about it. 18% said it's inevitable/the world is changing. 18% said everyone is free to choose love & happiness/government should stay out of it. 8% said because they believe in equal rights. 5% said because of moral ...

Hillary's Nose Is Growing By The Minute. Not Only (sm)Apr 17, 2015
did she lie about her grandparents immigrating here from other countries, which was a lie, now it has been revealed that she once told Sir Edmund Hillary when she met him that her mother named her after him because he was such a hero climbing Mt Everest and all.  Come to find out, he climbed MT. E 6 years after she was born.  So then when she was confronted about this lie, she said, (paraphrasing) that her mother must have made it up because she admired Sir E H so much that she probabl ...

Ten Ways The Occupy Movement Changes EverythingNov 14, 2011
Before the Occupy Wall Street movement, there was little discussion of the outsized power of Wall Street and the diminishing fortunes of the middle class. The media blackout was especially remarkable given that issues like jobs and corporate influence on elections topped the list of concerns for most Americans. Occupy Wall Street changed that. In fact, it may represent the best hope in years that “we the people” will step up to take on the critical challenges of our tim ...

No Racists In The Tea Party Movement???Jul 19, 2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRJ2UmyHhxI ...

Any Home Remedies For Getting Rid Of Green Stuff GrowingFeb 29, 2012
I guess you would call it mold or mildew, but I thought that stuff was black.  It is growing on my porch railings, porch steps, and on the side of the house.  I guess there is not enough sun there.  What can you use to get rid of it, and perhaps deter it from coming back quickly.  Will bleach discolor the vinyl siding, which is not white? What do you do? ...

When Potatoes Start Growing Roots, Are They Still Edible?Feb 17, 2012
I just found a bag of russet potatoes in the back of my kitchen cupboard that I forgot I had.  Was thinking I'd bake them for dinner tonight, but noticed they're not so firm anymore - kind of soft - and have roots sprouting from them.  I thought I heard a long time ago that potatoes with roots aren't edible.  Should I toss them, or bake them?  =^^=  ...

Bernake Sounds Warning On Growing DeficitApr 14, 2010
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke warned Wednesday that Americans may have to accept higher taxes or changes in cherished entitlements such as Medicare and Social Security if the nation is to avoid staggering budget deficits that threaten to choke off economic growth. "These choices are difficult, and it always seems easier to put them off -- until the day they cannot be put off anymore," Bernanke said in a speech. "But unless we as a nation demonstrate a strong commitment to fiscal re ...

The Left's New Answer To The Tea Party MovementMar 17, 2010
http://www.facebook.com/coffeeparty ...

It Appears The Dominionist Movement Is Using The Tea PartyNov 05, 2013
If it can, of course. We all know the Tea Party has been without a clear leader and direction for some while. The change in the TP's tone from the fixing of what needed to be fixed of its formation to now has been gradual, but today what we hear from them is increasingly fear and disrespect of a national government that is portrayed as their enemy, patriotism seemingly dead. When the Tea Party formed without leadership and specific goal, DH and I speculated whether it would be taken over ...

The Movement To Give The Vote To Noncitizens Jul 05, 2014
It looks like our sovereignty is for sale. ...

Concerns Growing Over Soros-Linked Voting MachinesOct 24, 2016
that voting machines in a significant number of states will be controlled by a company tied directly to billionaire leftist George Soros and his personal quest to create a nationless, borderless global state. Smartmatic is providing machines to Arizona, California, Colorado, Washington, D.C., Florida, Illinois, Louisiana, Michigan, Missouri, New Jersey, Nevada, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin. ...

Police Chiefs Around US Testify About Growing ISIS Threat.Feb 03, 2016
Not too worry, though, it's apparently his first time. ...

😷ILLARY Started The Birther Movement In 2008.Sep 16, 2016
Oh, boy. This is about to explode in 😷ILLARY'S face. She's going to need more than a mask. ...

Comparing Tea Party Movement To Radical LeftMar 08, 2010
Article by David Brooks thought provoking.  He presents a compelling argument that the tea partiers are copying the same tactics as the  70s radicals.  Like anyone thought the conservatives could come up with anything new or different . . . although now that dick armey has praised Alinsky, those one-note posters here will need to put a new string on their violin playing "oh the country is being destroyed by the liberals."  To read article just google his name- it is ...

Pelosi Faces Growing Doubts Among Dems After Georgia LossJun 21, 2017
She needs to go to Harry's Retirement Home. ...

MSNBC Confirms Hillary Started Birther MovementSep 17, 2016
http://fusionlacedillusions.com/index.php/2016/09/16/breaking-msnbc-confirms-hillary-started-birther-movement/ ...

SOS (Stop Operation Soros) Movement Explodes In MacedoniaJan 23, 2017
AWESOME news! First Hungary, now Macedonia. When will liberal Americans wake up to this man's evil? http://pamelageller.com/2017/01/stop-operation-soros-sos.html/ ...

Conservative Group Links Gay-rights Movement To Islamic TerrorismNov 10, 2009
http://rawstory.com/2009/11/group-links-gayrights-terrorism/   ...

As Immigration Crisis Grows, A Protest Movement Gains SteamJul 18, 2014
It would be nice to see a protest in every city across America this weekend! ...

Is It Just Me Or Does Someone Saying This Just Kill The Kindness?Sep 28, 2014
I recently got a gift from some people, who then said "we just ask that you pay it forward."  That seems kinda tacky to me. ...

It's Being Reported That The Clinton Campaign Is Growing "edgy" Over TheJul 30, 2015
Get your popcorn ready! LOL ...

Bill Gates Wants To Kill You And Your ChildrenJun 23, 2011
Hear it in his own words -- more than once. Vid is 1 minute, 37 seconds. ...

Candy: Internet Kill SwitchJun 18, 2010
there is another source: http://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/68003  I am very much afraid if this goes through, transcriptionists would  be severely affected.  The way it is now, it's almost like construction, no work no pay. ...

Drone Strikes Kill 4 Americans, But (sm)May 22, 2013
they can't kill the 18 terrorists in Libya who are responsible for the attacks on the consulate.  Holder DOESN'T HAVE ENOUGH EVIDENCE.  He also wants them to have a criminal trial over here - what??  - because he can't send them to Gitmo, because, oh who knows, maybe because Gitmo was supposed to be closed by now.  I think it's just because he doesn't like killing Muslims.  Americans, okay.  This team of thugs and incompetents really ne ...

How Fast Can He Kill The Economy? Take A Guess.Jun 25, 2013
A poll of sorts.  Who needs Congress anyway?  Most dictators don't even HAVE a Congress. Link ...