A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Stealth Multilateralism: U.S. Foreign Policy Without Treaties—or the Senate


Posted: Aug 23, 2013

 

 

The U.S. Senate rejects multilateral treaties as if it were sport. Some it rejects outright, as when it voted against the Convention on the Rights of Persons With Disabilities in 2012 and the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty (CTBT) in 1999. Others it rejects through inaction: dozens of treaties are pending before the Senate, pertaining to such subjects as labor, economic and cultural rights, endangered species, pollution, armed conflict, peacekeeping, nuclear weapons, the law of the sea, and discrimination against women. Often, presidents don’t even bother pushing for ratification, since they know the odds are long: under the U.S. Constitution, it takes only one-third of the Senate to reject a treaty.

The United States’ commitment problem has grown so entrenched that foreign governments no longer expect Washington’s ratification or its full participation in the institutions treaties create. The world is moving on; laws get made elsewhere, with limited (if any) American involvement. The United States still wields influence in the UN Security Council and in international financial and trade institutions, where it enjoys a formal veto or a privileged position. But when it comes to solving global problems beyond the old centers of diplomatic and economic power, the United States suffers the self-inflicted wound of diminishing relevance. Administrations operate under the shadow of Senate rejectionism, harboring low expectations that their work will be ratified.

The foundation of the Senate’s posture is the belief, widespread among conservative Republicans, that multilateral treaties represent a grave threat to American sovereignty and democracy. Treaties, they argue, create rules that interfere with the democratic process by allowing foreigners to make law that binds the United States. These “sovereigntists” portray treaties as all constraint, no advantage, as Jon Kyl, Douglas Feith, and John Fonte did recently in these pages (“The War of Law,” July/August 2013). These Republicans automatically resist, in the words of the 2012 GOP platform, “treaties that weaken or encroach upon American sovereignty.” And because such a small group of senators can block any given treaty, they essentially control ratification...

Regrettably the rest of the article is only available to subscribers to this expensive publication. Below is discussion of it, though, by a reader. The good news is that some work does get done anyway. The bad news is it's kept as quiet as possible to avoid turning action into raw meat thrown to the GOP base, who these days can be counted on to be outraged at everything and anything they don't understand.

David Kaye on “Stealth Multilateralism”

by Chris Borgen

The new issue of Foreign Affairs has an article by David Kaye, entitled “Stealth Multilateralism.”He begins the piece by describing the point of view of the “sovereigntists,” (often conservative Republicans) who view treaty-making as a threat to national sovereignty.  (See, for example,  this recent post by Peter on sovereigntist views.)

After arguing that treaty-making is actually an expression of sovereignty, Kaye closes the introductory section in this way:

Yet rejection is just the beginning of the story. Over the past two decades, the executive branch has developed and expanded a variety of lower-profile methods for asserting the country’s interests abroad in ways that do not require Senate involvement. The Clinton, Bush, and Obama administrations figured out that on some issues, they could circumvent the Senate entirely, and they developed new ways to participate in international forums, sometimes even exercising leadership in institutions that the Senate had refused to allow the United States to join.

Call it “stealth multilateralism.” Using a patchwork of political and legal strategies, the United States has learned how to respond to the global problems that are pulling it into the world even as Senate Republicans are trying to hold it back. As sound and effective as such measures can be, however, stealth multilateralism has its limits, since treaties establish more stable, transparent, and predictable relationships than political commitments. Both the United States and the rest of the world would benefit from a return to responsible multilateral engagement in which treaties regain their central role.

What follows for the rest of the article is a careful examination of the foreign policy costs of near-wholesale treaty rejection, the “subtle form of rejection” in the U.S. practice of treaty reservations, and, how Presidents have found work-arounds, such as non-binding agreements, to remain engaged in a policy area despite the Senate’s refusal to ratify. Crucially, Kaye explains the limits of those tactics and why the American public loses when we do not have a real discussion of the pros and cons of a particular treaty.

Kaye’s essay is a great primer on the interplay of U.S. domestic politics with international treaty-making. Check it out.

;

Most of us here are women. How many of US, left or right - would oppose treaties

[ In Reply To ..]
on the following issues because WE OURSELVES would be bound by them?

Helping persons with disabilities?
Nuclear test bans?
Torture?
Labor abuse?
Economic and cultural rights?
Endangered species?
Pollution?
Peacekeeping?
Stopping armed conflict?
The law of the sea?
Discrimination against women?

Today's Senate refuses to commit to supporting ANY of these even when we write the treaties ourselves, because it would...what? Limit our own right to discriminate against women here and abroad?

Conservatism as practiced these days has lost its way. We USED TO lead the world in these issues.

Similar Messages:


Foreign PolicyNov 23, 2010
http://www.americanthinker.com/2010/11/has_us_foreign_policy_ever_bee.html ...

Foreign PolicySep 18, 2012
Does anyone really believe that Obama's foreign policy is working?  How can anyone argue that, in the last 3-1/2 years, things have gotten better in the Middle East?  I think the era of pandering is over since that was a huge failure.  Let's try something else, shall we?      ...

What Does US Foreign PolicyFeb 20, 2013
Kerry Gives First Foreign Policy Speech … on Climate Change http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/kerry-gives-first-foreign-policy-speech-climate-change_703024.html ...

For A Foreign Policy DebateOct 22, 2012
Obama sure mentioned "roads and bridges" a lot. His default setting. :) ...

BO's Weak Foreign Policy??Apr 26, 2014
Obama's hashtag diplomacy with Russia sparks new criticism about weak foreign policy   This is the wave of the future??? ...

Foreign Policy ExpertsJan 31, 2017
have written a letter to Trump explaining why his travel ban will imperil American security rather than enhance it.  Do you think the Orange Doofus will listen? ...

Question: Since When Does Foreign Policy Mar 03, 2015
"run through the Executive Branch?" This is what Obama stated today in his press conference after Netanyahu's speech.Since when it is ONLY the President who makes decisions on foreign policy? Hasn't it always been Congress to decide and isn't it their job to decide funding, arms, or anything else with regard for foreign policy? This is the impression I got on that statement. Is he now planning to take over that part of congressional policy for more power?BTW, he stated he did ...

CURRENT U.S. Foreign Policy ProposalOct 29, 2009
It's been on CNN.com for at least a day - how many hear have heard or read about this: U.S. set to pay Taliban members to switch sides http://www.cnn.com/2009/POLITICS/10/28/afghanistan.taliban.pay/index.html This is nothing new - We bring in suitcases full of cash to get what we want - the problem is it usually backfires because we are 'buying' temporary loyalty. When you hear me gripe here on the board about lousy U.S. policy, here's an example of it:  Using YOUR t ...

Romneys Foreign Policy And Influence Sep 11, 2012
President Vladimir Putin said Tuesday that a comment made by U.S. presidential candidate Mitt Romney has made Russia feel justified in opposing America’s missile defense plans in Europe. Romney has branded Russia the “No. 1 geopolitical foe” of the United States. Putin said in remarks carried by Russian news wires that Romney’s statement has “strengthened Russia’s positions in talks on this important and sensitive subject.” ...

A Reminder On Foreign Policy And Obama.Oct 23, 2012
Remember 2008? One of Obama's weak points was foreign policy....he had NO experience in foreign policy. A lot of people don't want to vote for Romney because he doesn't have any foreign policy experience. To those people, I would love to know why they would vote for a candidate that had no foreign policy experience one year and four years later refuse to vote for someone because they don't have any foreign policy experience? Doesn't make sense to me. This post really d ...

See Top Of Drudge Page For Obama's Foreign Policy. Warning (sm)Oct 22, 2012
all you can see is his butt as he prostrates himself.  He makes me sick. ...

Tools Of Foreign Policy. Short, Simple. Read And The LastSep 10, 2013
[Note a president's 3 tools to conduct foreign policy below: Diplomacy, foreign aid, military force. We think we know about the diplomacy and military force in play right now. If we don't also somehow help Syria pay for compliance, directly or indirectly (foreign aid), I'll eat my W2.] The term foreign policy refers to a state’s international goals and its strategies to achieve those goals. Foreign policymakers follow the same five steps with which public policy g ...

Obama Has Not Right To Tell Scott Walker To Bone Up On Foreign PolicyApr 08, 2015
He hasn't done a good job at foreign policy himself. In response to Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s criticism of his Iran policy, President Obama suggested that the presumed candidate for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination “bone up on foreign policy.”   In other words, anyone who disagrees with the president on Iran’s nuclear program, or any other national security issue, is just not knowledgeable enough to understand. Of course, there is a very ...

Senate Foreign Relations Committee Passed Sep 04, 2013
with one "present" vote, authorizing limited miltary action.  It authorizes up to 90 days of military action and bars troop deployment.  The White House is required to send lawmakers a plan for diplomatic solution to violence in Syria within 30 days of resolution enactment. They rejected Rand Paul's effort to impose further restrictions on the War Powers Act by a 14-4 vote.   http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/officials-press-lawmakers-to-approve-syria-str ...

Etiology Of Cain's Brain Freeze And Flatulent Foreign Policy IsNov 15, 2011
which he perceives as "all this stuff  twirling around in my brain."  Symptomatic tardive dyskinesia in the form of facial twitching, rolling his eyes at the ceiling, squirming around in his seat, grasping at straws, ummm, I mean his water bottle, adjusting his coat, and yanking at his tie, were observed when questioned about his stance on Libya.  Plan:  Consider possible adjustment in medication dosage and observe for reduction in involuntary movements.   &nbs ...

Donald Trump In 1988 On Oprah Show Talking Foreign Policy (sm)Aug 20, 2015
and on what conditions he would run for President.   Link ...

Salt Lake City Tribune: Obama’s Foreign Policy Record Is Perhaps His Strongest Suit, EspeciaOct 22, 2012
Excerpt from the SLC Tribune's endorsement of President Obama for reelection: "Obama’s foreign policy record is perhaps his strongest suit, especially compared to Romney’s bellicose posture toward Russia and China and his inflammatory rhetoric regarding Iran’s nuclear weapons program. Obama’s measured reliance on tough economic embargoes to bring Iran to heel, and his equally measured disengagement from the war in Afghanistan, are examples of a nuanced approach to i ...

Obamacare's Stealth Payroll Tax IncreaseJan 10, 2011
did anybody else's? ...

CNN Stealth Edits Article That Orginally Made False ClaimOct 31, 2016
multiple times. Early this evening, CNN tried to catch Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump in a heavily compromising position over comments he made at a rally in Colorado. There was only one catch — Trump didn’t say what they thought he said. And, when the network realized the mistake, they tried to stealthily cover it up. In the online story of the rally, CNN used a headline that stated that the real estate mogul urged his supporters in the state to vote multiple times. Check ...

Daily Show Mocks Obama Over ’stealth Care Reform’Jan 09, 2010
Video can be found at: http://rawstory.com/2010/01/daily-show-slams-obama-for-not-keeping-promises/   ...

Foreign DiplomacyNov 17, 2009
Here is a good article about "the bow."  Next we'll be hearing that the President doesn't follow the unwritten, but oh so official, presidential behind-wiping protocol.    8-) President Obama's bow to Japanese leader has critics bent out of shape By Associated Press November 17, 2009, 4:53AM Foster Klug / Associated Press WASHINGTON -- Some conservative commentators seized on President Barack Obama's deep bow to Japan's Emperor Akihito over the weeke ...

Article Regarding US Foreign Aid...May 24, 2011
Not really surprising how much of it goes to Muslim or Arab countries, but what the money is actually used for was an eye opener for me.  Most Arab countries are oil rich....so my question is, why can't they take care of their own military and police forces and let us put some of those billions against reducing the deficit? Or...why not use that money to fund some of the programs people seem to think they can't live without within THIS country instead of ADDING to the deficit? ...

Buy A $15K Policy Or Go To JailNov 07, 2009
Nobody can tell me that she cares about the American people.  How is someone supposed to dole out 15K when they are out of work and don't have enough money to eat. Pelosi disgusts me!!!!   http://republicans.waysandmeans.house.gov/News/DocumentSingle.aspx?DocumentID=153583     ...

Buy A $15,000 Policy Or Go To JailNov 09, 2009
PELOSI: Buy a $15,000 Policy or Go to Jail http://republicans.waysandmeans.hous...umentID=153583JCT Confirms Failure to Comply with Democrats’ Mandate Can Lead to 5 Years in Jail Friday, November 06, 2009 Today, Ranking Member of the House Ways and Means Committee Dave Camp (R-MI) released a letter from the non-partisan Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) confirming that the failure to comply with the individual mandate to buy health insurance contained in the Pelosi health care bill (H.R. 3 ...

Do You Speak A Foreign Language?Mar 02, 2012
   ...

Foreign Corrupt Practices ActMar 07, 2017
I think we are going to hear a lot more about this in the future regarding the Trump Organizations business dealings with foreign governments. ...

Trump To Cut Foreign Aid But Palestinians Will Apr 27, 2017
TEL AVIV – The Trump administration is gearing up for major cuts in U.S. foreign aid across the world with the notable exception of the Palestinian territories, which will receive increased funding, State Department documents obtained by Foreign Policy magazine show. The documents, part of an internal budget proposal for 2018, seem to confirm the State Department and USAID’s 28 percent budget cut announced in March. While many countries will suffer from major cutbacks or else have aid cancel ...

More On The Foreign Workers Doing JobsAug 01, 2017
These workers are hired on B1/B2 visas and told what to say to immigration officials when arriving to this country and given letters to give to immigration officials.  Apparently, this type of visa allows you to work in the USA in a supervisory capacity, but they are not.  Mercedes-Benzi states that it "contractually requires all of its contractors to comply with all applicable laws, including those laws and regulations related to immigration, safety, wages and hours."  Of no ...

What If You Could Buy A Health Insurance Policy...Jan 16, 2016
that was cheaper than the one you have now, with no deductible, including dental, lower drug prices, with little or no copays? Impossible you say? Maybe not! ...

Oklahoma State Question 755 To Ban Foreign LawMar 03, 2011
Interesting to see where this goes.   OKLAHOMA CITY -- State Representative Sally Kern (R-OKC) is behind a new bill that deals with foreign laws in Oklahoma courts. Rep. Kern says the bill prevents a state court in Oklahoma from using foreign law in a case, if in that case, the foreign law would violate either of the parties' constitutional rights.   http://www.kfor.com/news/local/kfor-news-new-bill-to-ban-international-law-story,0,973133.story ...