A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

GOP Senator: “[A government shutdown] would be committing ritual suicide


Posted: Sep 18, 2013

[Or as another GOP Senator who supports shutting down the government, no matter how many people it hurts, puts it: “It’s mostly symbolic,” Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma said recently. “We want to have something out there so people continue to talk about it.... That’s a way of keeping the issue alive.... Yes, the increasing acceptance of healthcare reform is a problem for them.]

A Friendly Reminder That Defunding Obamacare Won’t Stop the Law

September 17, 2013 | 9:03 p.m.

Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak)

With Capitol Hill wrapped up in a debate this week regarding looming fiscal fights and the possibility of a shutdown over the health care law, it’s worth remembering that shutting down the government would likely have little impact on the Affordable Care Act. According to a Congressional Research Service report released at the end of July, much of the law’s implementation is separate from annual discretionary appropriations.

The CRS report was issued at the request of Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., who has not been shy about his opposition to the shutdown strategy. “[A government shutdown] would be committing ritual suicide on an altar of bad strategy,” Coburn’s communications director, John Hart, told National Journal Daily. “The idea that we can fully defund Obamacare through the continuing resolution is a Washington gimmick to advance political funding goals.”

The report substantiates the argument that a shutdown would not be an effective tool to stop the law. This is because much of the law relies on mandatory funding and multiple-year and no-year discretionary funds, which are not beholden to annual budget debates.

In fact, a government shutdown is quite different from the way it is commonly viewed by the public. Although the lapse in discretionary budget authority would likely impact some day-to-day routine operations of the government—such as the National Park Service—essential and necessary functions of the government and ones that have relevant health-based concerns would continue. Social Security and Medicare would likely continue in large part because they are mandatory programs; health reform under the ACA would also be considered essential for public health and would largely continue to be funded.

“Funding for state-operated insurance exchanges [in the ACA] is a distinct mandatory funding source,” Center for Budget and Policy Priorities Senior Fellow Paul Van de Water said. “In the case of all the federal government’s direct activities—including funding for federally run exchanges—it looks like the bulk of it could continue with no obvious end in sight if there were a shutdown.” Although some smaller effects are possible, this means that the main elements of the law would continue for some time, including the insurance exchanges, subsidies, and the individual mandate.

Also, agencies have prepared contingency plans in the event of a government shutdown, and the Health and Human Services plan maintains funding for many of its programs. “The HHS shutdown contingency plan that was prepared in anticipation of a possible government shutdown in FY 2012 indicated that ACA implementation activities at CMS would continue because of the mandatory funding provided in the law,” the CRS report says. The only real way to strip the law of these mandatory funds would be to repeal the full law.

And while Congress has the power to precipitate a shutdown, much of the jurisdiction over how a shutdown would be implemented lies with the agencies and executive branch, and is written into these contingency plans. Even some Republicans supporting the strategy of tying Obamacare to the CR debate recognize that it would not have the practical effects they truly want. “It’s mostly symbolic,” Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma said recently. “We want to have something out there so people continue to talk about it.... That’s a way of keeping the issue alive.... It is something you have to keep doing because you have strong beliefs, and even if logically it isn’t going to work out the way you want it, you still try.”

;

Similar Messages:


What About Iraq War Veterans Committing Suicide??? May 29, 2012
I just watched a TV documentary about new war veterans coming back from Iraq.  They say that every day at least 28 veterans are committing suicide.  This is truly shocking news.  I am wondering if their statistics are really accurate.  They say that only 33% are approved to receive PTSD benefits.  There is not enough money in their budget to approve all the claims.  I used to transcribe Veteran's health care reports and know that there are many mental heal ...

Military Suicides: "Most Of Those Committing SuicideJan 15, 2013
On All Things Considered, NPR's Pentagon correspondent Tom Bowman tells co-host Audie Cornish that the figures represent "active duty and reserve ... the largest portion were the active duty Army; 182 took their own lives in 2012." Tom says the military's suicide problem is a complex one. "Most of those committing suicide are young men, 18-24," he says, who are worried that asking for help will undermine their career. While some of the deaths can be linked to the stresses of bei ...

No DHS Shutdown?Feb 25, 2015
Three days before a partial Homeland Security shutdown, lawmakers cleared the way Wednesday for Senate passage of legislation to fund the agency without immigration-related provisions opposed by President Barack Obama. Approval in the Senate would send the issue to the House, where some conservatives derided the plan as a surrender to the White House. Other Republicans predicted it would clear, but Speaker John Boehner declined to say if he would put it to a vote. "I'm waiting for the Sen ...

700,000 Suicide Bombers Apr 11, 2010
I saw this video on an Afghan newspaper then saw it was on YouTube. Thought you all would be interested. If not, fine.   http://www.khaleejtimes.com/DisplayArticle08.asp?xfile=data/international/2010/April/international_April594.xml&section=international ...

Uh-oh. Boehner Needs To Blame Shutdown On Oct 05, 2013
That's the one that says unless we have a minority of a minority vote, we cannot bring bills up for vote....even a minority of one.  Seems former SOH Dennis Hastert is trying to distance himself from this current debacle some are trying to carry out in his name.  Says the Hastert Rule "never really existed" (LOL).  It was characterized as a guideline he went by, and specified a simply majority of 218 being the number he worked with during his SOH tenure.  He went on to s ...

Here's How Republicans Rigged The ShutdownOct 14, 2013
House Republicans Changed The Rules So A Majority Vote Couldn't Stop The Government Shutdown Posted: 10/13/2013 11:27 pm EDT  |  Updated: 10/14/2013 12:40 pm EDT In its effort to extract concessions from Democrats in exchange for opening the government, the GOP has faced a fundamental strategic obstacle: They don't have the votes. A majority of the members of the House have gone on record saying that if they were given the oppo ...

The Bill That Ended The ShutdownOct 16, 2013
Enjoy. ...

More Quote Fun: The Post-Shutdown Oct 18, 2013
[These quotes were compiled by Mother Jones Magazine, which does graciously allow Senator Cruz the last word.] Fighting words on the right in the wake of the debt ceiling and government shutdown crises. —By Dana Liebelson | Thu Oct. 17, 2013 11:38 AM PDT 181 Mørkvoß/Flickr and Rona Proudfoot/Flickr The just-concluded government shutdown and debt ceiling crisisrevealed a deep and profound split within Republican ranks, as tea party crusa ...

No To Chemo, Yes To Assisted SuicideOct 28, 2009
That Oregon has had State run healthcare for 15 years, this is what could be heading our way ... Our lives in the hands of the government. Wow!Health plan denies Chemo Medicine, but Offers Assisted Suicide instead. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6ojBgTyA7I    ...

Robin Williams' SuicideAug 16, 2015
I saw this subject down near the bottom of the board and wanted to say that I saw a report where he had Lewy body dementia also and is very difficult to treat. Poor guy. Probably knew something was happening to him, but hallucinations, etc., aren't uncommon. Sounds very bad. "The report indicates that [Williams] was being treated for Parkinson's and that is one of the features of dementia with Lewy bodies," said Taylor. "Hallucinations are a core feature of Lewy body dementi ...

Help Fight Cancer And Stop The ShutdownOct 08, 2013
Petitioning The U.S. Senate  Help me fight cancer and stop the shutdown           Petition by Michelle Langbehn Auburn, CA   My name is Michelle and while the government is shut down, my cancer continues. When the government closed late Monday night, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) was set to review my medical files to possibly be entered into a clinical trial for a new medication that cou ...

Father Completed Suicide This WeekApr 20, 2014
She seems to be fine but I can't be sure how she is really doing, you know? She was the one who found him in their bed with the gun in his hand.  I cannot imagine.  She won't really leave home that much because she says she feels closer to him there.  One positive note is that she plans on going back to work Tuesday.  We have removed the other gun from her home just in case she gets sad or thinks about joining him but the police have the original gun, not sure if sh ...

Obama: Politics And Ideology Should Not Trigger ShutdownApr 05, 2011
 Note: During Boehner's statement, he said, "We don't have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem." Obama said they are close. There is NO agreement as of yet. Democrats are still at $33B. The White House is insisting the top number is $73B but that ALSO includes the $43B already cut in the short term budgets to keep the government running. The budget cuts the Democrats want are not cuts at all according to the Republicans. "It's just smoke and mirrors." It looks lik ...

Government Is Not The Solution To Income Inequality. Government Is TheJan 10, 2016
How I wish that people knew more about the history of this nation, and about the expansion of government with more agencies, more laws, more regulations, more inspections, and other impediments to personal success that has occurred especially since the 1930s, and in which NONE of the parties in power have been blameless. Folks, we now have officials shutting down lemonade stands and fining people for collecting rainwater from their own roofs.  If you have a koi pond in your back yard, the ...

Suicide Bomber Attacks U.S. Embassy In Turkey Feb 01, 2013
A Turkish guard was killed but no American was killed this time but how much longer is the government going to pretend these are random acts.    Watch the video:   http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/01/video-shows-aftermath-of-u-s-embassy-bombing-in-turkey/ ...

Robin Williams Has Died Of Apparent Suicide.Aug 11, 2014
What a tragic shock! ...

Fascinating To Speculate Who Would Commit Political SuicideJan 21, 2016
No Democrat legislator or governor who wants to stay in office would do it, that's for sure.  I'm guessing Sean Penn or Louis Farrakhan.  It's a tossup. ...

Chik-Fil-A Owner Pays Employees During A 5-month ShutdownAug 16, 2015
in Austin, Texas shocked his 50 employees by paying their full salaries during a five-month period when the business shut down. Jeff Glover, who has operated the Chick-fil-A for 15 years, wanted to remodel the building to accommodate more customers, but didn’t want to hurt his workers. So he continued paying them for the full five months. The restaurant, which reopened this week at West Braker Lane and U.S. 183, is now the largest Chick-fil-A in Austin–and surely the chicken retailer ...

8 Americans Killed By Afghan Suicide Bomber Were CIA AgentsDec 31, 2009
At least eight Americans were killed and six others injured when a suicide bomber penetrated the heart of a heavily fortified complex in eastern Afghanistan, according to multiple U.S. officials in both Afghanistan and Washington, and and a Congressional source told ABC News they were all connected to the CIA.   http://abcnews.go.com/WN/Afghanistan/american-civilians-killed-afghan-suicide-bomber/story?id=9450037 ...

Gov Shutdown Cost Economy 24 BILLION YEE HAW! Thank You SO CALLED Fiscal ConservativesOct 19, 2013
You aren't paying for it, taxpayers are. What a waste. What a sham. ptiypasi ...

John Boehner Says GOP Will Move Forward With Plan That Could Risk DHS ShutdownJan 08, 2015
After gunmen attacked a satirical French newspaper on Wednesday, House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) said Republicans won't back away from a fight over immigration that risks halting funding for the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. "I believe that the president's executive actions with regard to immigration are outside of the Constitution and outside of his powers, and I believe that we can deal with that issue in the Department of Homeland Security bill without jeopard ...

What Government Giveth, Government Taketh Away.Oct 13, 2013
Government: Must Worship the beast. I didn't care for Bush too much, but even HE wouldn't do something like this to poor families. He is beyond evil. He doesn't have to do this at all. He is a SUPER VILLAIN punishing innocent people, even children just to get his way. ‘Folks About to Riot’: Twitter Explodes with Outrage Over Electronic Food Stamp Shutdown Worship The Beast or Die A Time of Testing Someone has said that truth can be stranger than fiction. I ...

Senator Kyl Is Talking Down To Us----againNov 30, 2009
Obama’s Speech on Afghanistan to Envision Exit By PETER BAKER, ERIC SCHMITT and DAVID E. SANGERPublished: November 29, 2009 WASHINGTON — President Obama plans to lay out a time frame for winding down the American involvement in the war in Afghanistan when he announces his decision this week to send more forces, senior administration officials said Sunday.Although the speech was still in draft form, the officials said the president wanted to use the address at the United States Milit ...

Way To Go, Senator Coburn~ It Has Been Apr 06, 2010
senator has done anything to be happy about, but I am happy to see this man stand up and act like an adult.  Way to go, sir!  It is a lot easier to take a politician seriously when they don't act like children.  As a liberal, I am really, really glad to see this.  http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/?fbid=01Hd7w9PgE6 ...

I Appreciate Senator Tim Scott (R-SC)Jul 14, 2016
If you think African Americans are not targeted or racially profiled, listen to this guy, a black GOP senator who was stopped 7 times by cops last year. I have linked it, but also here is his statement yesterday. It is powerful because it is his personal experience.   Scott’s address on Wednesday came after four other senators urged their colleagues to take a vote on criminal justice reform ― something many lawmakers say is badly needed. “There is a deep divide between ...

Dem Senator: We ALL KnewNov 17, 2013
http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/11/17/Gillibrand-we-all-knew   Dem Senator: 'We All Knew' Obama Was Lying   Email Article Print article Send a Tip by Ben Shapiro 17 Nov 2013, 1:03 PM PDT 1727 post a comment On Sunday, appearing on ABC’s This Week with fill-in host Martha Raddatz, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) admitted that Democrats knew full well that Americans would be booted from their health insurance plans a ...

The Most Destructive SenatorMay 24, 2014
Mitch McConnel takes Senate to new low:  Obstructionism at ANY cost. ...

Senator Mobbed By ProtestorsMar 02, 2011
OK, this is getting WAY out of control.  And frightening.  This has got to stop.  Since when do we condone this type of behavior?  This is thuggery 101.  I can just imagine sitting around the dinner table, slicing the meatloaf and then the news comes on.  Little Jimmy:  "Look Mommy!  Daddy's on TV!  Ohhh, he looks angry!"  Nice example for the kids.  What a bunch of twits.  Where is the civility now?  Seriously.  No on ...

Another Republican Senator SupportingMar 28, 2013
Senator Murkowski of Alaska says her views are evolving, and she plans on reevaluating her stance on the issue (hooray for her!). "I think you are seeing a change in attitude, a change in tolerance," she said. "And an acceptance that what marriage should truly be about is a lasting, loving committed relationship with respect to the individual." As for why Murkowski is considering a change in position, she pointed to her two young sons, who she says give her puzzled looks when she asks them for ...

A Lobbyist And A Senator Walk Into A Oct 19, 2013
This is not about either dem or repub, it's how we pay for all their excesses. ...