A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

The Rise of the Christian Left in America


Posted: Jul 29, 2013

From the Atlantic Magazine [a moderate, widely respected publication]


The Rise of the Christian Left in America

The religious right has been in decline for years. Can progressives build a new "moral majority"?
More
Led by Jerry Falwell (right), the Moral Majority helped elect Ronald Reagan in 1980 and began decades of religious conservative dominance in politics. (Associated Press)

In June 1979, a coalition of conservative religious leaders led by a Jewish Howard Phillips, Catholic Paul Weyrich, and evangelical televangelist Jerry Falwell banded together to wage a political "holy war" against the liberal establishment. They called their organization the "Moral Majority" to signify the large number of social conservatives they believed were being ignored across American culture.

Forming a political action committee, the organization registered 4 million votersin 1980 and purchased $10 million in radio and television ads questioning President Carter's patriotism and Christianity. Its message struck a chord with a large swath of Americans, and their efforts are credited with helping to elect Ronald Reagan. More importantly, the birth of the coalition began of a period of political dominance for the religious conservatives that would span at least three decades.

But according to a new survey by the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) in partnership with the Brookings Institution, the religious balance of power is shifting in ways that could make the religious left the new "Moral Majority," figuratively speaking. If current trends persist, religious progressives will soon outnumber religious conservatives, a group that is shrinking with each successive generation, the data show.

PRRI reports that 23 percent of 18- to 33-year-olds are religious progressives, 17 percent are religious conservatives, and 22 percent are nonreligious. By contrast, only 12 percent of 66- to 88-year-olds are religious progressives, while about half are religious conservatives. The survey used a religious-orientation scale that "combines theological, economic, and social outlooks."

"What you clearly see in the data when you move from the oldest Americans to youngest Americans is a stability among religious moderates and decreased appeal in religious conservatism," says PRRI CEO Robert Jones.

One might assume that the increasing diversity of the population is a driving factor in the shift, but Jones says this is not the case. African-Americans tend to be theologically conservative -- 49 percent, as opposed to 14 percent who are liberals -- but are more progressive on economic and social issues. Hispanic Americans are far more likely to be religiously moderate, and they don't tip the scales one way or the other. "It's mostly age," Jones says. "Younger whites, whose parents were far more conservative, are the ones who look significantly different."

Progressive religious leaders seem predictably pleased. David Gushee, a professor of Christian ethics at Mercer University and author of The Future of Faith in American Politics who describes his political instincts as center-left, says he is neither surprised nor disturbed by younger generations' progressive tilt.

"I am generally glad, at least in terms of hope for progress on justice and peace issues that I care a whole lot about," Gushee says. "Much of what goes out under the name of Christian conservatism I find odious, so there is not a lot of grief in this office today about the new data."

Gushee believes conservative evangelicals need to come to terms with their fading constituency and with the "impossibility of 'taking back America' for their vision at least as it currently exists."

Lisa Sharon Harper, director of mobilizing for Sojourners, a progressive Christian organization, says shifts are due to young people choosing to identify with Jesus and his teachings as opposed to a particular political party. Harper believes the GOP is being pulled to the far right by extremists on issues like abortion, thus forgetting and alienating those whom Jesus affirmed and advocated for: poor people, ethnic minorities, and women.

"I think the focus on the person of Jesus is birthing a younger generation inspired by [Jesus' Sermon on the Mount]," she says. "Their political agenda is shaped by Jesus' call to feed the hungry, make sure the thirsty have clean water, make sure all have access to healthcare, transform America into a welcoming place for immigrants, fix our inequitable penal system, and end abject poverty abroad and in the forgotten corners of our urban and rural communities."

Though Harper might dispute it, many would argue her list sounds like a liberal wish list. It's certainly at variance with the agenda of many conservative Christians, which would include opposing abortion and gay marriage and protecting religious liberty. It is also perhaps emblematic of the way the growing numbers of religious progressives are thinking.

So how can we expect these shifts to affect American public square? Will religious progressives cohere into a political movement like their conservative counterparts did in the late 1970s and 1980s? Will the religious left become the next "Moral Majority"?

Jones says it's too early to tell. A constituency in itself does not a "movement" make. The latter depends on infrastructure, organization, and leadership, elements that American religious progressives have not been able to produce -- despite various attempts -- on the scale that the religious right has.

Religious progressives face three hurdles to morphing into a true movement, Jones says. They are more ethnically diverse than conservatives, so they have fewer natural affinities than their counterparts on the right. They are also more geographically dispersed across America. Conservatives, on the other hand, are heavily concentrated in the South and Midwest, which makes for easier mobilizing. And finally, progressives are more religiously diffuse, which is to say that religion is only one of many influences shaping the way progressives think and behave.

Meanwhile, it's difficult to interpret the erosion of conservatism among young religious whites as anything but bad news for the latter-day leaders of the religious right like Ralph Reed and Tony Perkins who rely heavily on that demographic. If the data are correct, these leaders' dominant days may be ending sooner than expected.

Not every conservative religious leader is sweating it. Russell Moore, the recently elected president of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention, says he doesn't put much stock in surveys like PRRI's. He believes that the type of religion that survives and shapes cultures shows up in local congregations.

"Congregationally speaking, Protestant liberalism is deader than Henry VIII. While survey after survey shows a secularizing American population, this hasn't helped the growth of liberal Protestant churches," he says. "Where are the Unitarian mega-churches, the Episcopalian church-planting movements?"

Moore doesn't believe religious conservatives, particularly Christians, are fading. But he does think they will be culturally marginalized in the future.

"We will seem increasingly conservative," he says, "not because we are passing out voter's guides but because we believe in such culturally incredible things as that every life matters, that marriage is a permanent one-flesh union of a man to a woman, and, above all, that Jesus of Nazareth is alive, and Lord."

Moore's predictions may be right, but for now we only have data. And the data indicate that the growth of religious progressives may soon shift a balance of power that has existed for more than a quarter century. The conservative faithful will continue to have a voice in the public square, at least for some time. But now they'll have to learn to sing in harmony, rather than solo.

;

Similar Messages:


No Room In America For Christian Refugees.Sep 06, 2015
survivors of Europe’s Holocaust found that nearly every door was closed to them. “Tell Me Where Can I Go?” was a popular Yiddish song at the time. Decades later, the Christians of the Middle East face the same problem, and the Obama administration is keeping the door shut. America is about to accept 9000 Syrian Muslims, refugees of the brutal war between the Assad regime and its Sunni opposition, which includes ISIS, Al Qaeda, and various other militias. That number is predicted to inc ...

"Unfit For Work: The Startling Rise Of Disability In America"Mar 27, 2013
http://apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work   UNFIT FOR WORK The startling rise of disability in America By Chana Joffe-Walt In the past three decades, the number of Americans who are on disability has skyrocketed. The rise has come even as medical advances have allowed many more people to remain on the job, and new laws have banned workplace discrimination against the disabled. Every month, 14 million people now get a disability check from the government. The federal government spends mo ...

Why Religious Freedom Laws Like Indiana's Are A Bad Idea For Left AND Right, Christian Or NotApr 01, 2015
Let me first say, again, I strongly believe in protecting civil liberties, but not promoting them. This means regardless of whether I agree or disagree morally, I do NOT agree with extremists, right or left, hellbent on forcing opinion into law. Recently, this has been done by both sides, either by enacting deceptive state law that "pretends" it doesn't discriminate, or by filing deceptive lawsuits that "pretend" they're with whomever refused them, rather than finding the perfect sit ...

Radical Left Oregon Official Who Fined Christian Bakery Into ShuttingNov 15, 2016
Commissioner of the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries Brad Avakian gained infamy when he fined a Christian bakery with $135,000 for refusing to bake a wedding cake for a lesbian couple. The owners of the bakery, Aaron and Melissa Klein, turned down baking a cake to a lesbian couple as it would violate their Christian beliefs. Avakian claimed that the Klein’s refusal to bake the cake were not protected under the 1st Amendment, and labeled it illegal discrimination. The Klein’s were for ...

The Deplorables Rise UpNov 14, 2016
Subject: The Deplorables Rise Up 60 Million+ Deplorables This wasn’t an election. It was a revolution. It’s midnight in America. The day before, sixty million Americans got up and stood in front of the great iron wheel that had been grinding them down. They stood there even though the media told them it was useless. They took their stand even while all the chattering classes laughed and taunted them. They were fathers who couldn’t feed their families anymore. The ...

This Is Obama's People (the LIV) And Their Rise Jan 07, 2013
Our tax dollars at "work".     ...

The Rise Of The 4th Branch Of GovernmentMay 25, 2013
The rise of the fourth branch of government Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro professor of public interest law at George Washington University. There were times this past week when it seemed like the 19th-century Know-Nothing Party had returned to Washington. President Obama insisted he knew nothing about major decisions in the State Department, or the Justice Department, or the Internal Revenue Service. The heads of those agencies, in turn, insisted they knew nothing about major decisions by the ...

...and The Dollar Continues To Rise This Week Against The....Dec 16, 2009
. ...

Medicare Part D Costs Will Rise By 3% According To The CBOMar 19, 2010
  http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/113xx/doc11355/Comparison.pdf ...

Poverty To Rise Under Obama Watch ..Sep 13, 2010
WASHINGTON – The number of people in the U.S. who are in poverty is on track for a on President Barack Obama's watch, with the ranks of working-age poor approaching 1960s levels that led to the national war on poverty.Census figures for 2009 — the recession-ravaged first year of the Democrat's presidency — are to be released in the coming week, and demographers expect grim findings.It's unfortunate timing for Obama and his party just seven weeks before important ...

Health Care Costs RiseSep 12, 2012
While annual health care premiums for job-based family plans rose a seemingly respectable 4 percent this year, premiums averaged $15,745, with employees picking up more than $4,300 of that tab, according to an annual employer survey released Sept. 11.  According to an Associated Press report, the costs are a reminder that the U.S.’s struggle with unaffordable medical care is still significant.  Overall, "it's historically a very moderate increase in premiums," said Drew Al ...

How Did Sheila Jackson Lee Rise To Power? Oct 14, 2013
Sheila Jackson Lee: The Race Card Hits Its Debt Limit Posted By Daniel Greenfield Two days after being sued for discrimination by a disabled aide, Representative Sheila Jackson Lee stood on the floor of the house and accused opponents of the debt limit hike of racism. The race card she was using had expired long ago, but the media has never gotten the message. Instead it’s pushing stories about the FBI investigating racist cartoons sent to Jackson Lee’s fax machine. It’s an old comforta ...

AP FACT CHECK: Premiums To Rise Under ObamaCareMar 17, 2010
WASHINGTON — Buyers, beware: President Barack Obama says his health care overhaul will lower premiums by double digits, but check the fine print. Premiums are likely to keep going up even if the health care bill passes, experts say. http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iVn9wrhB-3SF-Svo9kZyXd4bHRLAD9EG84VO0 ...

As Worries Over The Power Grid Rise, A Drill Will Aug 17, 2013
New York City during a blackout in 2003. More than 150 companies and groups will take part in a drill that will simulate attacks on the power grid. By MATTHEW L. WALD Published: August 16, 2013 FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ SAVE E-MAIL SHARE PRINT SINGLE PAGE REPRINTS   WASHINGTON — The electric grid, as government and private experts describe it, is the glass jaw of American industry. If an adversary lands a knockout blow, they fear, it could black ou ...

Cool Debt Clock. Watch Our Deficit Rise.Mar 23, 2011
On the left side is also more statistics on unemployment real and reported, births, etc. Near the bottom is corporate assets, small business assets, personal assets. There's also a lot more. Check it out. The moving numbers may get ya dizzy, though.    http://www.usdebtclock.org/ ...

Oil Prices Rise On Middle East, Bernanke CommentsMar 01, 2011
Yikes!  It's a good thing we're drilling for oil here in the U.S.!  Oh wait, never mind. Even still, I bet the rising oil prices are Bush's fault like before when oil prices went up.  Oh wait, he didn't ban off-shore drilling - never mind. "Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told Congress Tuesday that a prolonged rise in oil prices would hurt the U.S. economy."  Oh really? Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that one out, does it? Duh. Th ...

Americans: Rise Up Against Entrenched Pieces Of Disgusting CrapSep 09, 2016
Let me explain this to sincere liberals who love this country: Your last hope is not Clinton, but Trump. Remove the party blinders. There have been nearly 70 years of liberal dominance in this nation's inner cities and other poor communities. There has been no shortage of money (almost $11 trillion). ...Now, if you DARE, take a drive around any inner city. Okay - did you survive? Great! And what did you see that the liberal philosophy has given us? Vote the same, get the ...

Flashback. Clinton Faults Obama For Rise Of ISISAug 12, 2016
have allowed Islamic terrorists to gain a better footing in the Middle East, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said this week. Clinton, a potential 2016 presidential contender, told The Atlantic in an interview published Sunday that the failure to build up Syrian rebels battling President Bashar Assad "left a big vacuum, which the jihadists have now filled." Some have criticized Obama for not helping Syrian rebels early on in the rebellion in order to combat al Qaeda-inspired terrori ...

U.S. Monthly Job Gains Largest In Three Years; Wages Rise. SmDec 05, 2014
Tell me how this is not good news. ...

Climate Change Directly Related To Rise In Terrorism.Nov 14, 2015
Can someone explain that as it totally went over my head. ...

Compensation For The Boards Of Directors Of The Nation’s Biggest Banks Continues To RiseApr 01, 2013
Excerpt from the NY Times: "Some Wall Street insiders also question the need to pay bank directors more than their counterparts at other big corporations, arguing that the increased regulation has actually limited bank boards’ ability to perform important tasks, like raising capital and issuing dividends. Even when it comes to paying senior executives, boards have less leeway because regulators have pressured boards to bring down executive pay. “About the only thing bank directors h ...

"Unprecedented" Rise In Food Stamps By Months Into Sep 18, 2012
Free stuff, free stuff!!  Obama stuff!  Obama money!!!    ...

How Christian Were Our Founders?Feb 15, 2010
As text books and curriculum are written and planned in Texas, any thinking person should be shuddering about HOW these tasks are undertaken, and the influence that a very intent group of fundamentalists will have in rewriting American History.http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/14/ma...exbooks-t.html"Following the appeals from the public, the members of what is the most influential state board of education in the country, and one of the most politically conservative, submitted their own proposed cha ...

Pakizstani ChristianMar 11, 2015
Hello, I am a Pakistani Christian male looking for medical transcription work.  Please pray for me.  I am more interested in orthopedics and spine. ...

Do We Really Believe Obama Is A Christian After This????Sep 18, 2015
Some of the things he does makes a lot of people wonder if he's really a Christian. Really - I thought everyone argued against separation of church and state; IOW, NO PRAYER in school is allowed, yet this was allowed. Why? Are the Muslims exempt from following that law? Or is only the Christian religious prayer not allowed?  This is another glaring example of the double standard in this country.Prayer vigil held for Mohamed, clock ‘bomb’ boy: What are they praying for? And ...

Solzhenitsyn: The Courage To Be A Christian...Oct 20, 2013
the power of secular fundamentalism appears to be on the rise and in which religious freedom seems to be imperiled, it is easy for Christians to become despondent. The clouds of radical relativism seem to obscure the light of objective truth and it can be difficult to discern any silver lining to help us illumine the future with hope. In such gloomy times the example of the martyrs can be encouraging. Those who laid down their lives for Christ and His Church in worse times than ours are bea ...

Republicans Are Trapped By Christian May 27, 2015
The problem for Republicans is that they seem to believe that God is on their side, so they believe they are above the law. Their religious beliefs are above the law. Is this not the same argument they have been making about Muslims imposing Sharia Law? It is. The Republican candidates need to come out strong against the Duggar actions. They need to disown them, cut them off and be rid of this pariah, both politically and morally. Huckabee has kissed his candidacy "Good Bye." The ...

Possibly One Of The Most OFFENSIVE Christian Things EVER!Aug 31, 2011
Is this guy serious? Comparing atheists to the KKK and sex offenders? ===================== Florida pastor, Michael Stahl has suggested that an organization and website be created that would keep track of known atheists. The website would list by city and state all atheists with their photos and some personal information such as place of business. It would not include a physical address which seems to contradict one of the main purposes of the site. Pastor Mike compares atheists to &ldq ...

Gay Scientists Have Isolated The Christian Gene!Aug 22, 2011
Link below. ...

If Gay Marriage Is Legalized And Christian ChurchesApr 29, 2015
if they fail to perform marriages, does this include Muslim mosques too or just the Christians? ...