A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Guidelines for U.S. Troops


Posted: Dec 13, 2012

New Army manual tells G.I.s not to promote women's rights or condemn pedophilia

Published by: Robert Laurie on Thursday December 13th, 2012

Robert Laurie

By ROBERT LAURIE – Utterly disgusting guidelines for U.S. troops in Afghanistan

So far this year, 63 members of the U.S. led coalition in Afghanistan have been killed in so-called “Taliban insider attacks.” The deaths occur when members of the Afghan security forces – supposed U.S. allies - murder the American operatives who are training them.  Now, thanks to a proposed U.S. manual for troops serving in the region, we know why it’s happening.

Our troops are too quick to promote women’s rights, condemn pedophilia, and aren’t sensitive enough to Islamic cultural norms.

Yes, like seemingly every one of the world’s problems, the Obama administration is prepared to lay the blame upon the United States.

According to the proposed manual:

“Many of the confrontations occur because of [coalition] ignorance of, or lack of empathy for, Muslim and/or Afghan cultural norms, resulting in a violent reaction from the [Afghan security force] member”

This sort of “when in Rome” mindset might not be so bad, if it ended there.  After all, when your military is stationed in a foreign country, the ‘hearts and minds’ argument comes into play.  However, the journal includes a list of taboo topics that will likely make the average American’s blood boil.

According to one passage, U.S. troops should be careful about espousing their values.  The list of things that might get them killed includes: 

 “Making derogatory comments about the Taliban,” “advocating women’s rights,” “any criticism of pedophilia,” “directing any criticism toward Afghans,” “mentioning homosexuality and homosexual conduct” or “anything related to Islam.”

Seriously?  Our troops are too anti-pedophilia and too pro-women’s rights?

These aren’t simply “American values.”  These are obvious, rudimentary, human rights.  Clamping down the condemnation of child rape because of some idiotic cultural relativism is absolutely sick.

 If Afghanistan is so far gone that U.S. troops can’t voice their support for such basic standards, just what the hell are they doing there?

;

Well, maybe they aren't always too diplomatic? I can - well imagine what might happen here if

[ In Reply To ..]
an Afghani group criticized some of our good Georgia Bible Belt guys for pedophilia because they took a similarly mistaken notion that that was common here (it is not, here OR there). Bad things might happen. Especially if there was a history of misunderstandings.

Common sense dictates that - upon arrival in Afghanistan

[ In Reply To ..]
they check their freedom of speech at the door....that is, if they want to stay alive. Theirs is a military training mission, not one of Western cultural or religious prosthelytization. It's not as though military life, regardless of assignment location, does not ALREADY impose that standard on those serving in the military. In fact, those standard operating procedures are practiced on a minute-by-minute daily basis. If they cannot understand the basic nature of their own missions, the imperative of taking orders without question and feel the need to express their personal beliefs at the drop of a hat and impose them on others, they are in the wrong place.

The author's ethnocentric hubris reveals severe limitations on his ability to grok the bigger picture which, in this case, is to keep those troops ALIVE.

I learned a new word today. - Grok

[ In Reply To ..]
Thank you!

I was a huge Heinlein fan when I was a kid. Been a while, - but I recognized it immediately. :) nm

[ In Reply To ..]
x

The term is a bit dated and obscure, having its origins in - 1960s Sci-Fi jargon that was

[ In Reply To ..]
actually introduced as Martian language (!) in Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land, a book I remember fondly from my early teen years, just as I have never forgotten the "Gort! Klaatu barada nikto" phrase from The Day the Earth Stood Still, an earlier film and the first movie I saw as a Sci-Fi-Saturday rerun in a theater as an impressionable 6-year-old. Anyway, "grok" made the rounds through the transcendental 70s counterculture and eventually ended up essentially as a geek computer reference.

I thought it was especially appropriate to the context since it implies far more than cognitive understanding and conjures the actual syncretic transference of intellectual, philosophic, and spiritual identities and belief systems, a kind of fusion of separate parts and creation of a new singular "being." IMO this applies not only to the interpersonal relationships alluded to in the post amongst lower and upper US military ranks, as well as between training personnel and their Afghani counterparts, but also between the author and his chosen subject of commentary.

Similar Messages:


It's Possible We Could Use Some GuidelinesNov 18, 2013
with respect to discussion of sources. This has clearly become a hot topic, and I can't help but note that a lively discussion on the subject is gone from the board. I have said it before, and I will say it again: To my mind, there is nothing wrong with holding a source up to the light to see if there are holes in it, nor is there anything inherently malevolent about doing so. If this is inconsistent with the board's policies, can we get clarification, please. Thanks. ...

Funny GuidelinesOct 21, 2009
These are really funny.   http://pages.sbcglobal.net/kellyratzlaff/kellyratzlaff/dictationguidelines.htm     ...

Dictation Guidelines For DoctorsMay 11, 2013
I swiped this from the board a few years ago and felt it was time to bring it back - it just never gets old (especially for MT's who have doctors that strictly adhere to these guidelines - LOL!)   DICTATION GUIDELINES FOR DOCTORS: Adherence to these guidelines will assure the highest quality transcribed reports in the shortest amount of time. 1. At the beginning of the dictation, take as deep a breath as you can. Now, try to dictate the entire report before you have to inhale ...

Posting Guidelines - Bringing Back To BoardMay 06, 2013
I am bringing a topic back to the board, which I previously had deleted.  I was wrong in deleting this message and my apologies to the OP of the post.  This does indeed have everything to do with politics and I'd like to thank you for bringing that to my attention.  I do make mistakes, and this is one that I should have left as is, so I will copy here what the message had originally said.  If I've missed anything and you would like to add to it please do so. Your o ...

The Obama Girls Lunches Go Against Mooch's Guidelines.Oct 29, 2014
Hypocrites, liars, moochers.  We get the best, you get crap.  I wish these people would just go back to Kenya.   Link ...

Our TroopsMay 19, 2010
I need the energy and power of prayer!  The taliban attacked the base where my son is currently stationed.  I've seen what positive thoughts and prayer can do before and I ask for strength for the people serving at this base and their families.  I'm sure there are many men and women there who are terrified at this moment.  We have to send them our support! If you have a myspace or a facebook or any social network thing, please POST A MESSAGE OF PRAYER AND SUPPORT! ...

Tribute To The Troops.May 28, 2010
Memorial Day: A Tribute to the Fallen The Center for American Progress asks all Americans to support the veterans organizations that support our warrior heroes and their families. More: Honoring Our Heroes ...

Protecting Our Troops*Mar 12, 2013
James Wilkerson, a colonel in the Air Force, was convicted by a jury of aggravated assult and sentenced to 1 year in military prison. This sentence was overturned by Lt. Gen. Craig Franklin. "General Franklin’s decision to overturn Colonel Wilkerson’s conviction by a jury came after Colonel Wilkerson had failed a polygraph examination concerning the offenses, according to several people close to the case. General Franklin did not check with the victim before making his decision to d ...

ALL POSTERS: Please Read General Posting Guidelines Listed Above. NMDec 06, 2009
. ...

Why Obama Didn't Lie About Troops In IraqNov 09, 2009
This article goes to the campaign promise then-Senator Obama made concerning reduction of US forces in Iraq. Read it and you, too, will understand that the situation is not unilateral but bilateral. With this recent vote, now, troops will be withdrawn---after the Iraqi Jan. election. ======================= BAGHDAD — After weeks of political stalemate, Iraq approved a law on Sunday to administer a critical national election in January, a significant milestone for its fragile democracy an ...

The President Goes To Visit Troops In Afghanistan...Dec 03, 2010
Good for him!  Around the holidays is a a great time for face time with your commander-in-chief when you are deployed. ...

Bring Some Troops Home From IraqNov 13, 2010
From Mitch McConnell's home town newspaper. http://www.courier-journal.com/article/20101111/OPINION01/311110017 In his new memoir, Decision Points, the former president tells of a meeting he held in September 2006 with Mr. McConnell, then the Republican whip in the Senate. The occupation of Iraq was going horribly, American and Iraqi casualties were rising sharply, costs had mushroomed into the hundreds of billions of dollars, and Iraq was teetering on the brin ...

President Obama Has Sent Troops To JordanOct 10, 2012
U.S. Military Is Sent to Jordan to Help With Crisis in Syria By MICHAEL R. GORDON and ELISABETH BUMILLER Mohammad Hannon/Associated Press Refugee families arriving in Jordan in September. The United States military has secretly sent a task force to Jordan to help handle a flood of Syrian refugees and be positioned should the turmoil in Syria expand into a wider conflict.    (As you'll recall, on its other border, Syria has attacked refugees inside Turkey and confli ...

Pentagon Sends Troops To Jordan.Oct 10, 2012
nm ...

Putin Positioning Troops To Invade Mar 23, 2014
Yeah - those Obama sanctions really scaring the hell out of Putin.  Check the news all over the net today (while US still can access the net freely), and read the troop actions, pressure on Ukraine, hike in fuel prices.  Yeah Obama,  you got Putin on the run just like yo had Al Queada on the run.  Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Email Print Save March 19 (Bloomberg) -- Bloomberg’s Peter Cook discusses possible ramifications of U.S. ...

Romney Forgot To Mention Troops Because Speeches Sep 07, 2012
you "talk about the things you think are important."  Yep.  Said it clear as day in an interview with Flox.  He went on to explain that we were supposed to understand he was talking about them when he referred to the "military" (as in the Military Industrial Complex).  Oh, OK.  Silly us.  Well then, mister candidate, what did you say about the military?  Did you speak of the ultimate sacrifice made by the fallen, sympathize with grieving families, or address re ...

Talk About Supporting Our Vets And Troops Is Cheap. SmSep 19, 2012
Today the republicans in the senate prevented a veterans’ jobs bill from coming to a vote by forcing a budget point of order vote. Democrats came up 2 votes short of the 60 needed to defeat the GOP’s budget measure ...

Putin Pulls Troops From Ukraine BorderMay 31, 2014
Nevermind that Putin got exactly what he wanted at practically no cost, that he will never give back Crimea, or that Ukraine is now in a total state of confusion and chaos. Yay obama, you crafty, masterful statesman.   ...

Sending 3K Troops To West Africa To Help With EbolaSep 16, 2014
Can someone please explain to me why we are sending 3K troops to West Africa to help with ebola?  I guess it is the humintarian thing to do but as deadly as this is and the fact that those 3K will be returning to the states and could potentially bring this back with them.....call me crazy but I think this is just stupid stupid stupid. ...

President Obama Took Credit In 2012 For Withdrawing The TroopsJun 21, 2014
The last two paragraphs are the most interesting. This is why Obama may go down in history as a liar-in-chief. This just proves how he is so incompetent. Too bad the double standard only works for Democrats and too bad the Democrats can't see truth even when it hits them on the head. President Obama took credit in 2012 for withdrawing all troops from Iraq. Today he said something different. June 19 President Obama surprised a few people during a news conference Thursday by clai ...

AP Interview: Iraq Premier Nixes US Ground TroopsSep 18, 2014
Oh, look. The new leader of Iraq does not want and will not allow ground troops from other countries in Iraq. How can we continue to blame Obama for this the same way he is blamed for Bush's Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) to remove all ground troops from Iraq by 12/31/2011? According to the SOFA signed by Bush in 2008, a system had to be established for Iraqi approval of every single US mission. Every single time that US troops leave their bases, it has to be cleared by the Iraqis. Accor ...

Obama Sends Special Forces Troops To Russian BorderJan 04, 2017
as NATO is poised to strike back against Putin's "aggression." It's a little late to put your big boy pants on, Obozo. ...

Philippines Troops Backed By Attack Helicopters Battle IslamicMay 26, 2017
roops backed by attack helicopters battled dozens of militants linked to the Islamic State group holed up in a besieged city in the southern Philippines on Thursday after attempts to secure volatile areas met heavy resistance. Army tanks packed with soldiers rolled into the mainly Muslim Marawi City as gunfire and explosions rang out after militants linked to the Islamic State group torched buildings, seized more than a dozen Catholic hostages and raised the black flag of Isil. The army se ...

US Ground Troops Land On Iraq's Mt Sinjar To Evacuate Trapped YazidisAug 13, 2014
"More than 100 US marines and special forces landed on Mt Sinjar in Iraq on Wednesday to organise an escape route for 30,000 Yazidi civilians threatened by Islamic extremists and worn down by hunger and thirst." ...

Whatever Happened To "No Troops On The Ground"Oct 31, 2015
Obama is sending a "small" contingent of 30-50 Special Forces troops to Iraq and Syria.Did he ever pull the other 3500 to 5000 troops out?  You don't hear about them anymore. In June of last year, he sent 1500, which brought the number up to 2900 to Iraq. Then in June of this year, he supposedly sent another 450.  Isn't it funny that he kept saying there would be no troops on the ground year after year, month after month through his presidency, yet keeps putting troops on th ...