A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Do ILLEGAL Aliens have any rights?


Posted: Oct 14, 2010

Yes! The same as you and I.

I've read the reports and the conflicting testimony from some of the prosecutor's witnesses were different. "Gomez" stated in one report that he was confronted was one of these two guys when a group of defense witnesses stated he was with them somewhere that night and no where near "Gomez" or his truck. Even their friends that turned against them because they were threatened to get the same consequences had some conflicting testimony.

What these kids did was wrong and they should get jail time, but life without the possibility of parole?  Am I wrong to feel this way, especially since those adults who murder others usually get no more than 25 years and able to get parole? These were 18 and 19 year old kids.

SCRANTON, Pa. – A jury convicted two Pennsylvania men Thursday of a federal hate crime in the fatal beating of an illegal Mexican immigrant, finding they attacked the man primarily out of hatred for Hispanics.

An all-white jury in Scranton convicted Derrick Donchak and Brandon Piekarsky of violating the civil rights of 25-year-old Luis Ramirez, who died in July 2008 following a confrontation with a group of white high school football players in the former mining town of Shenandoah. The jury also convicted Donchak of two other counts related to a plot to cover up the beating.

Read more: http://www.theolympian.com/2010/10/14/1403995/pa-men-convicted-in-pa-hate-crime.html#ixzz12Nh1F5yw

;

Here's a report of the above story which gives a lot more to this story. - Backwards Typist

[ In Reply To ..]

http://standardspeaker.com/news/shenandoah-area-men-found-guilty-of-hate-crime-1.1048917

Sounds to me like the jury did a great job! - SM

[ In Reply To ..]
At 18 and 19 years old, these are not kids, they are grown men who should know better. They violated the civil rights of another human being, and now they are going to pay the price. Kudos to the jury that convicted them and the judge who sentenced them!

They weren't sentenced yet, but the prosecutors want - Backwards Typist

[ In Reply To ..]
life without the possibility of parole. I think it is kind of harsh considering those who commit premeditated murder get life and can get out on parole after 7 years if they qualify.

People complain that illegals shouldn't have the same rights as citizens, and those in Congress state they don't, yet here the government is prosecuting citizens because they "violated the civil rights of an illegal."

So, which is it? Do they have the same rights as citizens or don't they? Seems like they do according to this case, which means they have the right to the same programs/entitlements that the citizens have. Where does it end?

You are a real piece of work. - SM

[ In Reply To ..]
Forget the citizen BS. This was a human being who was murdered because a couple of bigoted rednecks didn't like the fact that he was Hispanic. Many of your posts deal with your disdain for Hispanics, so it is no surprise that you are siding with the murderers.
Really? Do you know the whole story? - Backwards Typist
[ In Reply To ..]

Are you reading the links I'm posting? I didn't think so, so I will help you out. BTW, some of the witnesses for the prosecution were lying. That is fact and in the testimony in the first trial compared to the second trial.

 "Six teens who got some booze after a town carnival type event were wandering around town. They came upon 25-year-old illegal alien Luis Ramirez in a park late at night, around 11:30PM, alone with a severely underage girl (13) who just happens to be the younger sister of Crystal Dillman. Dillman, who claims that Ramirez was her fiance and has two children with him and a third from a previous relationship, later received an undisclosed sum from People Magazine for a three page article and $25,000 from a victim's advocate fund. Testimony by Ramirez's friends say that he was drinking prior to going to the park. At the recent federal trial the 13-year-old girl was called Ramirez's "girlfriend" in court.




 The teens approached him asking the girl why she was out so late and what they were doing there. A fight ensued and slurs were thrown from both sides as it progressed. One teen, Brian Scully, who took a plea deal in the case says he punched Ramirez and knocked him to the ground and said that he was the one yelling "go back to Mexico". Scully says he heard no racial slurs from Piekarsky. Another teen, Colin Walsh, who took a plea agreement and is facing 9 years, with hopes to have his sentenced reduced to 4 for cooperating, claims that he also punched Ramirez. The teens then started to leave. During the fight Ramirez got up and had time to make phone calls to multiple people. He could have walked away. The teens walked away at this point. Scully testified that Ramirez then charged them from behind punched him in the head. A second fight ensued.  As it turns out, the phone calls were to his Hispanic friends but by the time they got there, the boys were gone.




 Walsh testified  "I took Ramirez down with a solid 'uppercut hook' and saw him hit his head". Ramirez hit his head on a curb.




 The charges of murder arose because Ramirez died two days later due to head trauma. However, at trial Dr. Daniel Brown, a neuropathologist who had examined Ramirez's body on Aug. 1, 2008, testified:




"I observed a blood clot between his brain and a protective covering, and blood in an area usually containing spinal fluid. The left side of his brain had extensive contusions and swelling. Because of motion of the brain, an injury to the back of the brain caused an injury to the front. No evidence of trauma to the right side of his brain."



Deaths happen all the time because of fights when one falls and hits his head on a curb or pavement. Are they indicted for murder? In fact, this injury was not caused by a kick to the right side of the head by the one teen as stated by the prosecutor.

 MALDEF, La Raza and LULAC all showed up and protested the first trial, which made tensions even worse between the population of the town.  I was a bit upset myself because they were only found guilty of simple assault. It should at least have been manslaughter.




 I have a problem with our government bending over backwards to radical groups.  I also have a problem with illegal immigrants getting the same civil rights as citizens.  If you don't see a problem with that, then open your eyes.  Our government doesn't think twice of prosecuting citizens if an illegal immigrant is involved.


 The picture below is okay to you?



A Car Window Calls For The Killing of Brandon Piekarsky and Derrick Donchak



 



Where does it end? Should the owner of this car be arrested for hate crimes? If the two teens were killed because of that message, do you think the government would have prosecuted the person who killed them as a hate crime?



Last year, 3 illegal Hispanics went into an all white bar and proceeded to take a baseball bat to the owner, bartender and a few patrons, all the while yelling "All whites will die tonight." The government was asked to prosecute and they refused. But that's okay with you because these guys were illegal, too?


Like Ii said, the kids should get prison but not life without the possibility of parole. That sentence is too harsh for something that started out as a fight and true murderers usually only get 25 to life with the ability to apply for parole after 7 years or so.


I am more interested in human rights. - SM
[ In Reply To ..]
As I said before, anyone who has read your posts in the past knows exactly how you feel about Hispanics. If a jury convicted these scumbags of a hate crime, so be it. Apparently, you are much more concerned about citizenship and civil rights than basic human rights.

That being said, I am done discussing this with you.
Well, how racist of YOU. She has a problem with - illegals, not Hispanics!..big difference.nm
[ In Reply To ..]
nm
The possibility of parole for federal crimes was abolished - in 1984 under
[ In Reply To ..]
President Ray-gun. As I recall, tough on crime, lock 'em up and throw away the key, just say no and zero tolerance were all the rage (still are) coming out of certain camps. This is what happens when we live in a black-and-white world where circumstances are not considered as mitigating factors, a worldview heavily favored by conservatives I might add.

I don't know on what planet murderers get 25-year sentences and are out in 7. Down in the Lone Star, they typically get life, and if parole is in the picture, they are not even brought up for before the board until they have passed the half-way mark, which translates to at least 20-25 years of hard time. More often that not, they get the death penalty and in Texas, it is enforced with a vengeance, the theory being that it is an effective do-as-I-say-not-as-I-do DETERRENT to serious crime. We can all see how well that is working out.

Hate crimes laws, enforcement and punishments are meant to send that same strong message. The problem you are having with digesting this is that when GOP policy underpins the process, things are all peachy-keen and dandy, but when progressives get in on the act (as they have with hate crime legislation and other civil/human-right initiatives), here you are screaming bloody murder. Can't have it both ways.

BTW, I too have observed the prejudice in your previous posts. The right to STAY ALIVE is not a civil right. It is a human right that transcends any one given body of laws, including those coming out of the American court system. Last time I checked, murder is a mortal sin recognized by religions worldwide. I applaud the jury and hope the haters rot in prison, far away from any future targets, legal or not.

PS: You should rejoice soon enough when the officers who conspired with the criminals in the cover-up get off scot-free.
The moral to this story is - be careful what you ask for. nm
[ In Reply To ..]
nm
tell me what in the world this has to do with "illegals" - see message
[ In Reply To ..]
I am incredulous.

An American citizen KILLS another human being, but we should not prosecute this citizen under the laws of these United States?

New flash: ALL of us American citizens are subject to the laws of this nation. Thankfully, the race or origin of the individual upon whom we perpetrate crime has NOTHING to do with the sanctions against the crime.

Perhaps you would enjoy moving to a more totalitarian society.

The penalty should be less for killing an illegal alien?

These are archaic, ulgy notions, and quite shocking.

The victim is dead, so breath a sigh of relief. He isnt entitled to - any programs. Your tax dollars are safe. nm

[ In Reply To ..]
nm

And, BTW, it was okay for the illegal to start the fight? - Backwards Typist

[ In Reply To ..]
He was engaged to one girl who already had a couple kids with him and messing (for want of a expletive word) around with her 15-year-old sister. These are facts people seem to forget. He was illegal, he started the fight, and he was messing with the sister of the girl he was supposedly engaged to.

Like I said, I don't think they should get the life in prison without the possibility of parole, but they should serve jail time....but what about the other two guys with them? One got jail time in a juvenile detention center until he's 21 and the other got off and joined the Navy.

http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2010/10/shenandoah_teen_testifies_on_f.html

How do you figure the victim started the fight and - what leap did you take to conclude

[ In Reply To ..]
that having a conversation with the WHITE sister of his fiance (his children's aunt) and mother of his children constitutes "messing with her" (with the parenthetical sexual implication you so judgmentally inserted)? Were you there as a witness?

The white boys approached Ramirez by butting into a private conversation and tried to make an issue out of something that was basically none of their business. Given the ensuing racial slurs, I hadly believe they were trying to enforce curfew or defend the honor of the 13-year-old FAMILY MEMBER.

Please post links to your sources or further explain where these wild conclusions of yours are coming from, keeping in mind that racial bias and prejudice is at the crux of this context in more ways than one.
You know very well that some newspapers don't keep archives on line that long - Backwards Typist
[ In Reply To ..]
The "WHITE sister" as you put it admitted under oath at the first trial that she was the girlfriend of Luis. Yet he was engaged to her sister. Yeah, let's keep it in the family.

The boys asked the "WHITE sister" what she was doing out at that time of night since she was only 13 at the time.

I certainly wish I would have kept the newspapers on this story. Then I could have scanned them for you.

So, you do think that photo I posted is a bunch of malarkey, huh? You never did answer that question.

You also didn't think the Hispanics threatening the white people in the bar a year or two later was significant since you make no comment on those.

It's not the only thing that happened after Luis' death but no other newspaper reported those stories. They were unimportant to them. I don't even believe they carried the story of the bar incident.

And, yes, I am against ILLEGAL immigrants as I said before, so therefore, you think I'm a racist. Think what you want if it makes you feel superior. I am not against LEGAL immigrants.

it's okay for ANYONE to start a fight... - see message

[ In Reply To ..]
Anyone is allowed to start an argument. No doubt, I have started a few in my day.

So, death by vigilante is an appropriate penalty for starting an argument?

Backwards indeed.

Similar Messages:


On The Subject Of Illegal Aliens. Did You Know This?May 09, 2010
I recieved this email today:  Bank of America, can I help you? Customer: Yes, I want to cancel my account. I don't want to do business with you any longer. The Bank: Why? Customer: You're giving credit to illegal immigrants and I don't think it's right. I'm taking my business elsewhere. The Bank: Well, Mr. Customer, we don't want to see you do that, but we can't stop you. I'll help you close the account. What is your account number ...

ID Cards For Illegal Aliens In NJMay 22, 2010
I find it wierd. Are they really going to sign up for these cards?   http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/17/nyregion/17idcard.html ...

Do You Think The ILLEGAL ALIENS Are Really Going To REGISTER?Nov 24, 2014
Will Obama be making another EO to block the IRS and Social Security Administration from performing their jobs?  The Dems are stating that the illegals have to REGISTER to get a work permit, pay fines, pay taxes, yada, yada, yada... Really? Didn't Obama state DHS will be covering and processing the paperwork for those that come out of the shadows? To work and pay taxes, they need a TIN, ITIN, or SSN.  That's what the IRS and Social Security Administration states: &nbs ...

Illegal Aliens Said To Get Tax Rebates.Feb 14, 2015
What Constitution? ...

Illegal Aliens Taken To HospitalNov 21, 2015
Four hurt in crash near Jamul border checkpoint http://www.cbs8.com/story/30577810/four-hurt-in-crash-near-jamul-border-checkpoint (Sent from CBS 8) Four hurt in crash near Jamul border checkpoint http://www.cbs8.com/story/30577810/four-hurt-in-crash-near-jamul-border-checkpoint ...

I Say Do Whatever It Takes To Keep ILLEGAL ALIENS From Voting.Apr 26, 2016
NC judge rules in favor of NC law requiring photo ID to vote. Now if we could only keep the felons from voting and put the biggest felon of all (HC) behind bars, life would beautiful! ...

Criminal ILLEGAL Aliens Released, Not DeportedAug 08, 2016
This is a must see, totally mind boggling, only 3-1/2 minutes. This message is very troubling! This is why Trump’s platform about illegal immigration is resonating with so many Americans. Watch this and pass it on, only 3½ minutes. It’s dated 4/28/2016 This is staggering. Absolutely unbelievable. And it gets NO press. Chairman Chaffetz Opener - Criminal Aliens Released by the Department of Homeland Security 4/28/2016. https://www.youtube.com/embed/2QOwAJ2ez6U ...

How America Treats Illegal Aliens Vs. VeteransMay 24, 2014
A government that fails to secure its borders is guilty of dereliction of duty. A government that fails to care for our men and women on the frontlines is guilty of malpractice. A government that puts the needs of illegal aliens above U.S. veterans for political gain should be prosecuted for criminal neglect bordering on treason. Compare, contrast and weep: In Sacramento, Calif., lawmakers are moving forward with a budget-busting plan to extend government-funded health insurance to at lea ...

Illegal Aliens Can Use Stolen SSNs To File Tax ReturnsApr 22, 2016
Be sure to read the comments after the article to get opinions from both sides. https://www.numbersusa.com/news/irs-commissioner-illegal-aliens-can-use-stolen-ssns-file-tax-returns ...

More Undocumented Workers (AKA Illegal Aliens) Moving Into ManagementMar 27, 2015
A growing number of undocumented immigrants are landing managerial positions. At the same time, fewer are doing jobs that require manual labor. Some 13% of undocumented immigrants had management or professional jobs in 2012, up from 10% in 2007, according to a new Pew Research Center report. Meanwhile, 29% held construction or production posts, such as a food processor, garment worker or machinist, down from 34% in 2007. The transition reflects a shift within the undocumented populat ...

State Dept: Illegal Aliens Have Applied To Bring 290 Of Their Children To U.S.Mar 26, 2015
While some of President Barack Obama’s unilateral amnesty programs are still awaiting the green light from the courts before being implemented, others are moving full-steam ahead, including the president’s Central American Minors Refugee/Parole (CAM) Program, which allows certain illegal aliens from El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras to petition for their children still living in these three countries to be brought to the United States. As of March 23, 248 cases representing 2 ...

Obama Administration To Build More 'family Friendly' Housing For Illegal AliensOct 13, 2014
...

Undocumented Immigrants (ILLEGAL ALIENS) Line Up For Door Opened By ObamaDec 15, 2014
LOS ANGELES — They pushed strollers, tugged toddlers and streamed into the convention center in the heart of this city on Sunday, thousands of immigrants here illegally and anxious to find out if they could gain protection from deportation under executive actions by President Obama. The crowd, waiting in a long snaking line to check in, was drawn by an information session organized by advocacy groups offering people initial assessments to see if they meet the requirements to apply to ...

US Border Advertizes "safe Zones" For Illegal Aliens.Aug 02, 2016
can avoid arrest by following these simple rules, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) advertises in a post on its website’s homepage. Providing a virtual "how-to" guide for illegal aliens in its “Sensitive Locations FAQs,” CBP explains that immigration laws are not to be enforced at any of a wide range of designated “sensitive locations” – so that illegal aliens may be “free” to live their lives “without fear or hesitation." ...

Stonewall? Explaining Obama's Historic Gay-Rights Reference. (It Was IllegalJan 23, 2013
Okay, I was 17 when this happened, working the graveyard shift as a waitress in Harrah's Casino. My roommate and I didn't have a TV and her soon-to-be-ex-fiance was still proving, to himself at least, that he wasn't gay by bashing homosexuals every 20 minutes or so. So when President Obama mentioned this all I remembered, vaguely, was him ranting incessantly about this protest, without knowing a single thing about it. From NPR, and the link's to a really interesting story. " ...

Illegal Immigrants Set Free And Their Charges Were Criminal, Not Just Because They Were IllegalMay 17, 2014
Even though this happened in 2013, how many have been released THIS year? ______________________ In 2013, ICE freed 36,007 convicted criminal aliens from detention who were awaiting the outcome of deportation proceedings, according to a document obtained by the Center for Immigration Studies. This group included aliens convicted of hundreds of violent and serious crimes, including homicide, sexual assault, kidnapping, and aggravated assault. The list of crimes also includes more than 16,000 dr ...

Anyone Want To Talk About Space, Aliens, And Such?Dec 03, 2010
Do you think the government should pay for stuff like this? NASA discovers new life.  http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/12/02/nasa-new-life-arsenic-bacteria_n_791094.html Mystery spacecraft http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/12/03/x-37b-spacecraft-returns-_n_791579.html ...

Anyone Watch Ancient Aliens???May 05, 2012
I started watching this about a year ago.  Even though I don't buy their theories about ETs causing a lot of our history -- that they created man and caused the extermination of the dinosaurs -- not a meteor as scientists have said for years and years.  I must admit it is fascinating and they never cease to amaze me.  Now ET's are time travelers and have come from our future to make changes on our planet.  They say ET's were the ones who destroyed all mankind i ...

The DHS Authority To Prioritize Removal Of Certain AliensDec 16, 2014
I'm posting the 3 elements of this report but not the report itself because it's 27 pages long. I am posting the link so you can read it yourself.   The Department of Homeland Security’s Authority to Prioritize Removal of Certain Aliens Unlawfully Present in the United States and to Defer Removal of Others  The Department of Homeland Security’s proposed policy to prioritize the removal of certain aliens unlawfully present in the United States would be ...

Pennsylvania To Pay U.S. $48.8 Million Over Benefits To AliensJan 17, 2015
Pennsylvania has agreed to pay $48.83 million to settle U.S. government claims it violated federal law by providing benefits to ineligible aliens under Medicaid and two other federal programs from 2004 to 2010. In a statement on Friday, the U.S. Department of Justice said the commonwealth provided improper benefits under Medicaid, the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, formerly known as food stamps. The Justice Department said Pe ...

I Firmly Believe In God, But Find Shows Such As Ancient Aliens Very Upsetting. Feb 22, 2012
It is very disheartening and upsetting that these shows are trying to disrupt the Christian world and poison us with their crazy theories about how life took shape on our planet.   I must admit I was fascinated with their show, but realized it is an Atheist's attempt to make Christianity seem like a fantasy and that God really does not exist.  These people are very clever and master manipulators of the truth.  They are very convincing and I find it very sad to think they prob ...

Requirements Are Not RightsOct 16, 2009
The 2004 article from Kenya’s oldest newspaper – The Standard – featured the headline which stated : Kenyan-born Obama all set for US Senate And the blogosphere went into hyper overdrive.  The first line of defense was that it was a fraud, and the second line of defense was to simply ignore the story.  As of today – according to the Google news search engine – not one major newspaper is reporting this story other than blogger Don Surbe ...

Constitutional Rights.......Apr 21, 2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lygeYhV8QV4&feature=related ...

Civil RightsMay 19, 2010
...

Reproductive RightsOct 21, 2012
  ...

This Is Why We Need The Voting Rights ActJun 28, 2013
Check out this literacy test given to black voters in Louisiana in the 1960s! ...

Wonder What You All Think Of This. Taking More And More Of Our Rights AwayApr 14, 2015
Can we try to keep this civil and have a conversation about our basic constitutional rights without needing our hard hats please. I personally do not like guns, don't own guns and never will, but I don't want the government taking the rights away of law-abiding citizens to own guns if that is their choice. Governemnt is getting way to big and I don't want them in my house, church or bedroom. I do like what this judge says though. If this is true this is scary that police c ...

Indiana's 4th Amendment Rights Taken AwayMay 17, 2011
Check out this link.  Apparently, it is now okay in Indiana for police officers to illegally enter someone's residence and the homeowner is not allowed to resist.  Gov. Mitch Daniels of Indiana is thinking about running for President.  It will be interesting to see if this comes up in debates if he does run.  Indiana is a very conservative state.  Who's next? http://www.examiner.com/finance-examiner-in-national/new-court-ruling-on-illegal-entry-could-have-last ...

Age Discrimination And Employment RightsMar 01, 2011
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/01/job-applicants-age-disclosure-requirement_n_829637.html We have had some discussion about the chipping away of child labor laws.  Here is an example of the chipping away of age discrimination laws.  Some people here have made the argument there are laws to protect us.  My answer--not if the Republicans have their way and defund and deregulate the concerned agencies that do the protecting.  A chip here, and a chip there. ...

You Can't Deny Women Their Basic Rights...Feb 21, 2012
.. ...