A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Deficit Commission Final Vote


Posted: Dec 3, 2010

Guess it's back to the drawing board.

It's true that a commission that began with only limited authority failed in its most significant goal, which was to win at least 14 votes among the 18 members. Fourteen votes were needed to send the package to Congress as an official recommendation and force a vote on the proposals.

It's also true that prominent members of Congress on the committee took a walk on the commission report. That group included Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wisc.), who will chair the Budget Committee in the next Congress, and Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.), the current chairman of the Finance Committee.

But that doesn't begin to evaluate the commission's work. Andy Stern, the former president of the Service Employees International Union, who happened to vote against the plan, may have put it best when he said, "We have changed the issue from whether there should even be a fiscal plan for this country to what is the best fiscal plan for this country, and that is an enormous, tectonic, paradigm shift that I think is enormously important."

The final vote-11 ayes and 7 nays-represented a significant victory for co-chairs Alan Simpson, the former Republican senator from Wyoming, and Erskine Bowles, who was White House chief of staff in the Clinton administration.

Winning 14 of 18 votes equates with a 77 percent supermajority. Winning 11 of 18 means that the panel achieved a 60 percent supermajority, significantly better than the doubters had predicted not so long ago. The bipartisan outcome should send a powerful signal to President Obama and members of Congress to start tackling the deficit problem beginning next year rather than continuing to ignore it.

 

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/12/03/AR2010120303778.html

;

Deficit Commission --thought this was interesting - sm

[ In Reply To ..]
Obama established the Commission by Executive Order 13531. In the absence of special legislation, the Commission's proposals are not guaranteed to be considered by Congress in a single up-or-down vote.

Commission members

The Commission includes 18 members â six appointed by the president, six members of the U.S. House of Representatives, and six members of the U.S. Senate â 10 are Democrats and 8 Republicans. The first vote on the final recommendations will come on December 1, 2010. In order for a final report to be agreed to, 14 of the 18 members will have to vote to approve the report.

(Wiki)

Hmmm. Did not know Andy Stern was on the commission. - sam

[ In Reply To ..]
interesting.

Similar Messages:


Bipartisan Deficit CommissionFeb 06, 2010
Last month, a bipartisan commission went down in flames in the Senate after 7 republicans who sponsored the bill voted against it. Now, Obama is putting together a bipartisan commission and the republicans are still complaining it's not good enough. Obama is telling them to come to the table and present their ideas. They are saying no. And then accusing him of not listening. The problem seems to be that the republicans expect Obama to follow their platform (tax breaks for big busines ...

U.S. Deficit Commission Recommends Changes To SSNov 10, 2010
(The true suggestions will be coming out on Dec. 1.) U.S. Deficit Commission Recommends Changes to Social Security A draft proposal by the deficit commission suggests curbing Social Security benefits and raising the retirement ageto 68. It is currently 67 years for retirees to receive full benefits. The panel leaders also propose reducing the annual cost-of-living increases in Social Security. The increase to age 68 would be implemented by 2050 and then would increase again to 69 by 2075.&n ...

This Letter To The U.S.Civil Commission Says It AllJul 08, 2010
I am trying to see both sides of the story but when I find this letter from the Black Panthers, I am apalled. It is in PDF and I hope everyone can read it and give your opinion. http://www.newblackpanther.com/usccr%20phony%20case%20statement.pdf ...

9/11 Commission Chairman Says Would-be Plane Bomber 'did Us A Favor'Jan 05, 2010
(Probably will "boost" McCain's campaign, as well, in his next campaign. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/jun/24/johnmccain.uselections2008) By John ByrneMonday, January 4th, 2010 -- 8:56 am The Republican chairman of the Bush Administration's 9/11 Commission declared Sunday that the would-be-terrorist who tried to blow up a plane en route to Detroit "probably did us a favor." The GOP chairman's quote raised eyebrows; by his logic, the Sept. 11, 2001 attackers may also have ...

Former Federal Election Commission Chairwoman Ann M. RavelApr 18, 2017
on social media. She presented her remarks in a speech at UC Berkeley, calling for regulations against “fake news.”  Speaking at an event called “Future of Democracy,” Ravel argued the proliferation of “fake news” and political advertising on platforms like Facebook influenced elections. She warned that the lack of disclosure by the creators of these campaigns was becoming a huge problem... During her tenure as the chairwoman of the FEC, Ravel previously called for right-lean ...

Debt Commission Report Targets Social Security And MedicareNov 11, 2010
As I told my little Republican friend, biotch, vote and ye shall receive! For some reason, I don't think all the old people that voted in numbers this last election were actually planning for their Medicare to be cut! Today's upcoming report by the White House's fiscal commission is expected to include recommendations to raise the retirement age for Social Security and cut Medicare benefits -- two policy prescriptions that will be met with deep opposition from Democrats a ...

The U.S. Civil Rights Commission Is Not Letting The Black Panther Case Go AwayJul 08, 2010
Those who don't like Fox News will miss a really good report by Megan Kelley with Ashley Taylor, a member of the U.S. Commission of Civil Rights. and also a former DOJ from VA. The video is there of their chat. It is important to hear and to keep following up this story that MSM does not report. "The bipartisan panel investigating allegations that the Justice Department wrongly abandoned a case against the New Black Panther Party plans to issue a new round of subpoenas and call for a separ ...

It's Final!!May 05, 2011
Well - for those of you who followed my thread 1-2 months ago - my divorce was finalized yesterday (on what would have been our anniversary).  It was a very quick process - 8 weeks from finding out he was cheating on me.  The tears are coming a little less frequency and i'm trying every day to let the anger part go.  He has taken a job 3 states and 900+ miles away.  For that i'm sad for my 10 year old boy.  I'm a single child and my parents live 4 hours aw ...

Final Day May 21, 2011
Since this is the End of the World, I thought I would say goodbye to all my friends and frenemies.  Prognostication: Those  of you who have spent your final precious earth days fomenting hatred against President Obama and his party are going to be getting mighty, mighty toasty this evening.   ...

The Final InspectionFeb 04, 2010
http://www.wrensworld.com/soldierheaven.htm ...

Final StagesApr 09, 2013
You do know that so-called stand-your-ground, concealed-carry, "castle-doctrine," and many other laws and regulations having to do with arming the population to the teeth have been pushed by corporatist business cartels like ALEC, and the gun industry, and the myriad astroturf front groups and think tanks they fund, right? http://www.dailykos.com/story/2013/04/08/1200000/-You-do-know-they-want-people-to-shoot-each-other-dead-right-I-m-just-checking   ...

As A Final Act Of DefianceJan 24, 2017
Oblunder sent $221 million to the Palestinians in direct opposition to the GOP. I guess his fellow Muslims needed the money more than Americans (particularly homeless vets). So glad he's gone! I wonder what the Palestinians will use the money for. Of course, they will say one thing, but do another. IMO, it will probably go toward funding more radical Muslim extremist group(s). ...

This Should Be Final Word On The ProsserApr 08, 2011
Nickolaus apologized Thursday for the error, saying the most significant error occurred when she entered but did not save totals from the city of Brookfield, a suburb of Milwaukee. "This is not a case of extra votes or extra ballots being found," Nickolaus said. "This is human error, which I apologize for." Kloppenburg's campaign manager, Melissa Mulliken, demanded a full explanation of how the error occurred and said an open records request for all relevant documents would be filed. Ram ...

Final Year In PhotographsDec 31, 2016
Pete Souza the president's official photographer released his favorite photos of the year and they are fantastic.  I think my favorite is the one of the little boy looking up at Obama with shining eyes.  It make me think about the photo of Clinton with Kennedy.  I wonder if this moment was a life changer for the little boy.  ...

Final Health Bill Omits Some Of PO's PromisesMar 25, 2010
  http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/20/final-health-bill-omits-s_n_507063.html     ...

Hillary's Disgusting Past Exposed Before Final DebateOct 21, 2016
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4LUmSOEY6NM David Knight breaks down Hillary's divide-and-conquer strategy and the racist past of the democratic party before the final presidential debate in Las Vegas "That guy is great 'off the cuff.' Not easy to do in front of a camera. He's well spoken and frankly nailed it!" ...

Deficit QuestionDec 14, 2016
can anyone explain why the deficit/debt got so much worse while obama was president?   ...

Republicans Trying To Deepen DeficitJan 06, 2011
Health-Law Repeal Would Deepen Deficit, CBO Estimates January 06, 2011, 10:33 AM EST By Anna Edney Jan. 6 (Bloomberg) -- Repealing the health-care overhaul law would deepen federal budget deficit by $145 billion from 2012 to 2019, the Congressional Budget Office estimates. Individual insurance premiums would be “somewhat lower” than under current law, while coverage obtained through large employers would be “slightly” higher under an overhaul repeal, the CBO, the ...

Taxing The Richest And The DeficitNov 12, 2010
From Robert Reich-Christian Science Monitor The economics are clear: First, the top 1 percent spends a much smaller proportion of their income than everyone else, so there’s very little economic stimulus at these lofty heights. On the other hand, giving the top 1 percent a two-year extension would cost the Treasury $130 billion over two years, thereby blowing a giant hole in efforts to get the deficit under control. Alternatively, $130 billion would be enough to rehire every teach ...

Tackling The Deficit-Fix-It WeekJun 29, 2010
The first of the series this week. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/31510813/#37983994 ...

CBO Deficit Projections That Just May Suprise You.Jul 14, 2010
Here is a graph depicting baseline deficit as affected by the economic downturn with comparisons made between the percentages of projected impacts (2009 to 2019) of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, the Bush tax cuts, Obama's recovery measures, TARP, Fannie and Freddie.  Can you guess which one has the broadest and most far reaching damaging impact?  Fascinating stuff.  http://www.cbpp.org/cms/index.cfm?fa=view&id=3036     ...

11 Things The GOP Doesn't Want You To Know About The Deficit...smSep 08, 2012
1.  The deficit has grown mostly because of the recession. (The deficit has ballooned not because of specific spending measures, but because of the recession.  The deficit more than doubled between 2008 and 2009 as the economy was in free fall and laid-off workers paid less in taxes and needed more benefits.  The deficit then shrank in 2010 and 2011.) 2.  The stimulus cost much less than Bush's wars and tax cuts.  (Republicans frequently have blamed the $787 billio ...

Candidates' Deficit Plans Don't Add UpOct 01, 2012
As the government closes the books Sunday with a $1.1 trillion deficit for the year, which required borrowing 32 cents for every dollar it spent, budget analysts have little confidence in either presidential candidate's plan to address the accumulating debt, now at about $16 trillion. The Republican nominee promises to balance the budget in eight years to 10 years, but he also offers a mix of budgetary contradictions: higher Pentagon spending, restoring cuts that Democrats made in Medicare ...

Anyone Have A Child Or Know About Attention DeficitOct 20, 2014
Was just talking with my friend tonight. I have known as she has also for years that her 1st grader was not 100% "right," something was off with him. Tonight she tells me someone is finally maybe listening to her about him. He is in his own little world. I do not think autism because of the fact he will halfway interact "sometimes," does not reject a hug or kiss and maybe I am wrong but I thought autistic children were like that. I could be wrong. His teacher is every day trying to tell the moth ...

Comission Gives More Details On Cutting The DeficitNov 11, 2010
I have a feeling these suggestions won't go very far....especially the gas tax. If it isn't the people against some of the cuts, it will definitely be the federal employees against a wage freeze. I think the Congress will also be against their pet earmarks.  In my opinion, I think the federal employees could and should allow a wage freeze. The rest of America had to swallow it, why shouldn't they? As for earmarks, I think only the frivolous ones, like the ones stu ...

More Good News! Jobs Up, Deficit Down!Oct 07, 2012
The Congressional Budget Office has released its estimate for the fiscal year 2012, just ended on September 30 and the news is good. The federal deficit was just under $1.1 trillion, compared to just under $1.3 trillion at the end of fiscal year 2011, a reduction of $207 billion. As a percentage of the GDP, the 2012 deficit dropped to 7.0 per cent, down from 8.7 percent in 2011 and 9.0 percent in 2010. The actual deficit numbers will be released later this month by the Treasury DepartmentThe Sep ...

Budget Deficit Shrinks By $200 BillionOct 13, 2012
It starts with the figures released in 2009, when the deficit reached a record high of $1.4 trillion. Why is the column in red? Because, thanks to fiscal years, Obama inherited a deficit of nearly $1.3 trillion from Bush/Cheney the moment he took the oath of office. This year, however, according to the official data published by the Treasury Department, the deficit is 1.089 trillion.   A big number, but going down--no thanks to those helpful Republicans in Congress. ...

A Progressive Deficit Reduction Plan....smNov 29, 2012
A Progressive Deficit Reduction Plan Repeal all of the 2001 and 2003 Bush tax breaks for the top two percent.  Repealing the 2001 and 2003 tax breaks for the top two percent would reduce the deficit by about $1 trillion over the next decade.  After President Clinton increased taxes on the top two percent, the economy added over 22 million jobs.  After President Bush reduced taxes for the rich, the economy lost over 600,000 private sector jobs.  Create an emergency de ...

Some Interesting Articles On Cutting The Budget DeficitNov 28, 2010
All these articles are quite long but are worth reading every word. Remember, nothing is written in stone. All can be tweaked. I found some of the ideas very good, and some 'not so good.' All in all, it's good that there's plenty of input happening and hopefully, our government will READ (if that's possible) them and debate/compromise on them. The first one is from the Brookings Institute which gives quite a few plans from various Senior Fellows: http://www.brookings.e ...

Bernake Sounds Warning On Growing DeficitApr 14, 2010
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke warned Wednesday that Americans may have to accept higher taxes or changes in cherished entitlements such as Medicare and Social Security if the nation is to avoid staggering budget deficits that threaten to choke off economic growth. "These choices are difficult, and it always seems easier to put them off -- until the day they cannot be put off anymore," Bernanke said in a speech. "But unless we as a nation demonstrate a strong commitment to fiscal re ...