A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

"Billionaires Against Social Security." Should you find your


Posted: Oct 21, 2013

greedy grabbies impoverishing society through ceaseless taking, taking... remembering this will clue you in.

BTW, while reading what these libertarian billionaires're up to, keep this in mind from lower down: "The entire projected 75-year shortfall in the Social Security trust funds that conservatives make such a big deal about is around one percent of GDP per year. We could make it up with modest tax increases on wealthy people like Druckenmiller.

Since Social Security is financed by payroll taxes -- on wage and salary income -- the real Social Security crisis is the crisis of stagnant wages. If average wages had continued to track average productivity growth during the past three decades, as they did in the three decades after World War II, Social Security would be in perpetual surplus. [When our incomes started falling, so did the taxes we paid on them.]

Robert Kuttner

GET UPDATES FROM ROBERT KUTTNER

Billionaires Against Social Security

Posted: 10/20/2013 10:31 pm

 

America's very rich keep trying to start a movement among college students to blame senior citizens for the sorry state of the economy that kids will inherit. Specifically, the billionaires keep trying to scapegoat Social Security.

This is part of the public relations effort to create a "grand bargain" to cut America's (fast-declining) budget deficit. The Peter G. Peterson Foundation has spent about a billion dollars of Peterson's own money to create faux movements to get students to take up this unlikely cause.

The latest of the billionaires to try this gambit is Stanley Druckenmiller, net worth estimated at $2.9 billion, former head of the hedge fund Duquesne Capital. Druckenmiller's personal campus crusade has been the subject of two fawning profiles, one by Tom Friedman in Wednesday's Times, the other by James Freeman in Saturday's Wall Street Journal.

Druckenmiller's campus crusade is based on such preposterous economics that I hereby challenge him to a college debate or series of debates. Freeman's puff piece in theJournal begins thus:

Stan Druckenmiller makes an unlikely class warrior. He's a member of the 1% -- make that the 0.001% -- one of the most successful money managers of all time, and 60 years old to boot. But lately he has been touring college campuses promoting a message of income redistribution you don't hear out of Washington. It's how federal entitlements like Medicare and Social Security are letting Mr. Druckenmiller's generation rip off all those doting Barack Obama voters in Generation X, Y and Z. 

"I have been shocked at the reception. I had planned to only visit Bowdoin, " his alma mater in Maine, he says. But he has since been invited to multiple campuses, and even the kids at Stanford and Berkeley have welcomed his theme of generational theft.


The Tom Friedman column, titled, "Sorry, Kids. We Ate It All.," which I addressed in the American Prospect Thursday, Friedman wrote:

After we baby boomers get done retiring -- at a rate of 7,000 to 11,000 a day -- if current taxes and entitlement promises are not reformed, the cupboard will be largely bare for today's Facebook generation. But what are the chances of them getting out of Facebook and into their parents' faces -- and demanding not only that the wealthy do their part but that the next generation as a whole leaves something for this one? Too bad young people aren't paying attention. Or are they? 

Wait! Who is that speaking to crowds of students at Berkeley, Stanford, Brown, U.S.C., Bowdoin, Notre Dame and N.Y.U. -- urging these "future seniors" to start a movement to protect their interests? That's Stan Druckenmiller, the legendary investor...

Where to start? If you itemize all the reasons why recent college graduates face a wretched economy, Social Security doesn't even make the list. What does make the list are unreliable jobs that pay lousy wages, the aftereffects of a financial bubble created on Wall Street, and unaffordable college that leaves graduates starting life with more than a trillion dollars worth of debt.

The next generation, and the one after that, will have a shot at a decent life if we can get growth and a fairer distribution of earnings back on track. [The way it was when we were their age.] That project has nothing whatever to do with Social Security or the federal deficit. On the contrary, if we keep on the austerity kick and further cut social outlays that promote opportunities, growth will be even slower.

The biggest lie in Druckenmiller's crusade is the premise that the income distribution problem is somehow generational and that he, as a billionaire, has anything whatever in common with most college students or most recipients of Social Security. One of his pitches to students is that Social Security is excessive because he, a very wealthy man, receives it but doesn't need it.

But for the vast majority of the elderly, Social Security is a lifeline, and a meager one at that. Some two-thirds of all seniors depend on Social Security for half of their income. Fully 46 percent of elderly widows and other unmarried seniors depend on Social Security for at least 90 percent of their income.

The entire projected 75-year shortfall in the Social Security trust funds that conservatives make such a big deal about is around one percent of GDP per year. We could make it up with modest tax increases on wealthy people like Druckenmiller.

Since Social Security is financed by payroll taxes -- on wage and salary income -- the real Social Security crisis is the crisis of stagnant wages. If average wages had continued to track average productivity growth during the past three decades, as they did in the three decades after World War II, Social Security would be in perpetual surplus.

The real crisis facing the elderly is not that Social Security is excessive but that it's inadequate -- especially with the collapse of traditional pensions in favor of far less reliable 401k plans (another counter-revolution made on Wall Street.)

There is a certain moral blindness and chutzpah of very wealthy people trying to enlist students in a generational movement against the alleged affluence of their grandparents. The real issue here is not generation, but class, specifically Druckenmiller's class.

Contrary to the claim in writer Freeman's opening sentence -- that Druckenmiller makes "an unlikely class warrior," his crusade is precisely class war, of the sort we have been seeing for decades -- of the very wealthy against everyone else.

Happily, most of America's students don't seem to be taking the bait. None of Pete Peterson's front groups has had much resonance on campus -- not his "Fiscal Wake-Up Tour," nor "Fix the Debt," nor more far-fetched groups aimed a college students such as "America's Promise Alliance," nor the foundation's poetry contest aimed at battling deficits in verse.

However, these crusades do have a certain resonance among media elites and even in the Obama White House. As we go into the next phase of a trumped up budget crisis, with Social Security and Medicare as targets A and B, the politics and economics could not be more perverse.

So how about it Mr. Druckenmiller? If you are so sure of the righteousness of your cause, how about defending yourself in a campus debate?

Robert Kuttner's new book is Debtors' Prison: The Politics of Austerity Versus Possibility. He is co-editor of The American Prospect and a senior Fellow at Demos.

 

 

;

Thanks for posting this. sm - MT

[ In Reply To ..]
Very interesting, indeed. I never thought about part of the "manufactured" problem with SS being the horrible wages a lot of us make, particularly being a medical transcriptionist and going from $25 an hour to making minimal wage while the company I work for makes billions and sends our jobs to India. Great coverup for big (and small) business owners.

Similar Messages:


Social Security AgainJun 26, 2014
Ok, I found out last week that a friend of mine is collecting survivor benefits from 2 dead husbands at the same time.  Has anybody else heard of that?  I have a call in to social security to find out.  I am hoping that if that's the case I can start collecting on my late husband at 60 and then switch to my ex-husband's retirement when I'm 62 and keep working part time and collect from both of them.  It says you collect 50% of the ex-spouse's retirement be ...

Do You Need Your Social Security?Apr 14, 2017
Scarey stuff.  Many of us have been disappointed in our MT careers, on hard times, not enough in savings, outsourced, unemployed, dwindling paychecks, and entering that last 10 year (or so) push....need Social Security....now this.   The defunding of Social Security disguised as a tax cut.  Hope that @$2500 a year tax cut can be spun into gold! ...

Social Security DisabilityJul 11, 2010
Does anyone know what percentage of your income you receive if you are on Social Security Diability?  I am being encouraged to apply but not sure if I can afford it.  TIA! ...

Are We Going To Keep Social Security Or Abandon It?Sep 22, 2012
Social Security is a progressive entitlement program created by Republicans and Democrats working together. Those conservatives ideologically opposed have always tried to get rid of it, but voters wouldn't let them because it has always served its purpose of protecting us from the possibility of destitution when we're too old to work.  Now their tactic of destroying it by delaying necessary adjustments has successfully brought Social Security to the point of failure. Like a home ...

Interesting Social Security Info...Mar 09, 2010
Your Social Security Just in case some of you young whippersnappers (& some older ones) didn't know this. It's easy to check out, if you don't believe it. Be sure and show it to your kids. They need a little history lesson on what's what and it doesn't matter whether you are Democrat or Republican. Facts are Facts!!! Our Social Security Franklin Roosevelt, a Democrat, introduced the Social Security (FICA) Program. He promised: 1.) That participation in the ...

No Guarantee Social Security Checks Will Go OutJul 13, 2011
Obama says he cannot guarantee Social Security checks will go out on August 3 By Corbett B. Daly President Obama on Tuesday said he cannot guarantee that retirees will receive their Social Security checks August 3 if Democrats and Republicans in Washington do not reach an agreement on reducing the deficit in the coming weeks. "I cannot guarantee that those checks go out on August 3rd if we haven't resolved this issue. Because there may simply not be the money in the coffers to do it, ...

Social Security Quick CalculatorMar 21, 2014
http://www.socialsecurity.gov/OACT/quickcalc/ You can put in your salary and a projected retirement date and this will give you a monthly SS benefit estimate. An eye opener. ...

114th Attacks Social Security On First Day Jan 06, 2015
aimed at seniors and disabled (AKA "deadbeats") by imposing hindrance/prohibition on routine fund allocations unless benefits are cut or their payroll tax rates are hiked.  They are too cowardly to do it in broad daylight, so they've decided to take cover under the House rules guise.  The link further exposes GOP demonization of handicapped/disabled Americans.  They must have gotten bored with beating up on the poor and immigrants.   "Empathy," GOP style.   ...

Social Security Disability InsuranceJul 25, 2017
Seems I may be disabled according to grid guidelines (age, inability to use 2 limbs).  Watched the YT videos but am unable to find out the approximate time of when the medical examiner approves and the check arrives.  Am trying to save my home and believe bank will work with me if they knew my future held a reliable income.  I am unable to find a job in MT and have not had an income for 6 months. Running out of things to sell and am 2 months late on mtg. Does anyone have any expe ...

Trump's Plan To Privatize Social SecurityNov 16, 2016
nm  ...

No COLA For Social Security Recipients And DisabledOct 25, 2015
This should be determined on necessity prices, not general cost of living numbers. Low gas prices will prevent seniors from eating. https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=919387074782964&pnref=story ***Low gas prices have skewed the cost of living numbers; however, the low gas prices do not have much to do with the necessities of seniors, disabled and disabled veterans. They do not get a cost of living increase based on the statistics being skewed down by low gas prices. ...

Social Security, Bernie Sanders, And Rocket ScienceAug 25, 2011
Bernie Sanders, Ind/Dem/Socialist, plans to propose legislation that would strengthen Social Security without cutting benefits to any of its beneficiaries. Sanders’ legislation would eliminate the income cap that currently exists in the payroll tax that does not tax income above $106,800:*****To keep Social Security strong for another 75 years, Sanders’ legislation would apply the same payroll tax already paid by more than nine out of 10 Americans to those with incomes over $250,000 ...

GOP Resurrects Ws 2005 Plan To Privatize Social SecurityJun 10, 2011
Rep Pete Sessions (R-Texas) is responsible for the Second Coming.  Under the guise of "voluntary" choice, The SAFE scheme would quietly transition to full diversion of employer matching contributions into such private accounts over a 15 year period.   Would everyone who trusts Wall Street and bankers to manage their retirement funds please raise their hands?  Caution:  Watch out for those familiar smoke and mirrors and bait and switch hazards dead ahead.& ...

Feds Paid $1 Billion In Social Security Benefits ToFeb 22, 2017
The Social Security Administration paid $1 billion in benefits to individuals who did not have a Social Security Number (SSN), according to a new audit. The agency’s inspector general found errors in the government’s documentation for representative payees, otherwise known as individuals who receive retirement or disability payments on behalf of another person who is incapable of managing the benefits themselves. The audit released Friday found thousands of cases where there was no SSN ...

Debt Commission Report Targets Social Security And MedicareNov 11, 2010
As I told my little Republican friend, biotch, vote and ye shall receive! For some reason, I don't think all the old people that voted in numbers this last election were actually planning for their Medicare to be cut! Today's upcoming report by the White House's fiscal commission is expected to include recommendations to raise the retirement age for Social Security and cut Medicare benefits -- two policy prescriptions that will be met with deep opposition from Democrats a ...

NO COLA Raise For Social Security/Disabled Recipients Next YearOct 12, 2010
Seniors and disabled Americans looking forward to the annual increase in their Social Security check will be disappointed this year. Officials with the Social Security Administration have informed aides in Congress that the decision will be announced on October 15, just two weeks before the election, according to staffers and people familiar with the SSA's plan. This will be the second year in the History of SS that we won't be getting a cost of living raise. ...

Executive Order Makes Immigrants Eligible For Medicare, Social SecurityNov 27, 2014
The approximately 5 million undocumented immigrants [AKA illegal aliens] who are eligible for deferred deportation and work permits under the president’s recent executive action could also become eligible for Medicare and Social Security, the White House told a Washington Post reporter on Tuesday.     Link:  http://finance.yahoo.com/news/executive-order-makes-immigrants-eligible-201500725.html ...

ABC News Spin Meter: Obama & His Social Security Warning, Aka Replacing CluelessJan 17, 2013
Came across this little how-Washington-works explanation of the "firemen first" tactic. Note that stopping SS checks IS definitely among Obama's options, with the desirable results of allowing all other bills to be paid without fuss and making people very angry with the party they would blame most (insert your favorite here, but his is the GOP).  SPIN METER: Obama and His Social Security Warning By CALVIN WOODWARD WASHINGTON abcnews.go.com   ...

Billionaires. Jul 18, 2012
The United States is home to more billionaires than any other nation (425), according to Forbes magazine.  Credit given to the performance of the US stock market.   ...

Billionaires And Super PACsSep 27, 2012
"Remember when President Obama’s re-election campaign and its allies complained about billionaire Sheldon Adelson giving cash to Republican super PACs? They apparently have no such qualms about radical left financier George Soros doing the same thing. Today, news broke that Soros is handing $1 million to Priorities USA Action, President Obama’s chief super PAC. It is no coincidence that this week, President Obama refused to meet again and again with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. ...

Social HXDec 08, 2010
The doc doing HPI:  "The PT is very intoxicated ............................ He gets to SOCIAL HX:   The PT states he is a social drinker  "YA RIGHT-----Oh transcriptionist take that out of the report the Ya right thing". ...

Social Groups??Mar 12, 2013
I have been working at home as a transcriptionist for about 20 years - give or take a temp job from time to time. I would like to know if there are any social groups anyone knows of for those of us who work at home. I got into this field because I have a special needs child and needed to work at home. I have a hard time with the isolation of working at home and it seems like it would be great to work in an office, etc., but then I wouldn't have the flexibility and the other advantages of ...

WikiLeaks - The MSM And National SecurityJul 27, 2010
By Howard Kurtz Washington Post Staff Writer Tuesday, July 27, 2010; 10:03 AM Question of the day: Should the New York Times, the Guardian and Der Spiegel have done it? Should they have collaborated with the organization known as WikiLeaks in publicizing 92,000 pages of secret documents about the war in Afghanistan? The White House wasted no time in denouncing the leaks as "irresponsible." The news organizations can argue, above all, that these documents provide vital information about ...

CBS Says: Obama’s Security BreachSep 18, 2012
In Libya Is Ignored By American Media. Some things you can't cover up. http://washington.cbslocal.com/2012/09/17/obamas-security-breach-in-libya-is-ignored-by-american-media/ ...

Why Is The Department Of Homeland SecurityMar 03, 2013
What is it for??  http://www.areweawareyet.com/tag/civilian-national-security-force/ WHAT THE HECK IS CIVILIAN NATIONAL SECURITY??? Looks like war with the people and the government. ...

Does Anyone Have A Home Security SystemOct 07, 2013
We are looking at maybe getting a home security system.  Not that we have anything worth taking (except our lives), but we live in an area where more and more crime and home invasions are going on.  I heard my neighbor screaming for her life, she turned on the back light and there was someone getting ready to break into her house.  Police said more drug seekers are breaking into people's homes and in the paper crimes/particularly home invasions are on the rise.  So we we ...

Home Security SystemsMar 10, 2016
Do you have one? If so, which one? Monthly cost? Would appreciate recommendations. TIA ...

Question About Soc. Security & MedicareDec 16, 2016
To those of you who are single, receiving Social Security and Medicare, do these numbers seem too high to you?  The amount taken out of my monthly social security check for Medicare is $140.  The amount taken out monthly for Part B insurance is $73, and for drug plan is $21 (total of $94 a month).  So each month $234 dollars are being taken out of my social security check to pay for health care.  Does this seem excessively high to you, or is this a normal-sounding amount? ...

Social JUSTICE Is *not* The Same As SOCIALISMMar 13, 2010
The Beckster and his $upporter$ are desparately trying to equate the two in an attempt to have people reject the concept of social justice. He'll be successful to some degree; fortunately the vast majority of Americans know a skunk when they smell one.  or is that a FOX? lol ...

All The Dust-up On Social Media About How The DNC (sm)Jul 26, 2016
didn't have any US flags visible at the convention, and  how in 61 speeches ISIS was never mentioned.  Well, Dana Perrino overheard someone yelling to get the speechwriters and get some flags.  lOLOL   - Also Eric Trump tweeted that flags are now being put up all over. What a bunch of losers these Democrats are.  ...