A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

The Freelancers Union for **independent contractors** is one of the nation’s


Posted: Mar 24, 2013

 

The New York Times


 

SOON after landing a job at a Manhattan law firm nearly 20 years ago, Sara Horowitz was shocked to discover that it planned to treat her not as an employee, but as an independent contractor.

Reworking Labor

Articles in this series examine the changing face of labor as the nation's unions and collective bargaining rights decline.

Andrew Quilty for The New York Times

Freelance Union employees working on a spreadsheet at headquarters. The union and the insurance company together employ a staff of 80 people.

“I saw right away that something wasn’t kosher,” Ms. Horowitz recalls. Her status meant no health coverage, no pension plan, no paid vacation — nothing but a paycheck. She realized that she was part of a trend in which American employers relied increasingly on independent contractors, temporary workers, contract employees and freelancers to cut costs. Somewhat bewildered, somewhat angry, she and two other young lawyers who were also hired as independent contractors jokingly formed what they called the “Transient Workers Union,” with the facetious motto, “The union makes us not so weak.”

Ms. Horowitz’s grandfather was a vice president of the International Ladies’ Garment Workers’ Union, and her father was a labor lawyer. So it was perhaps not surprising that she responded to her rising outrage by deciding to organize a union. What she organized, however, was a newfangled version. The Freelancers Union, with its oxymoronic name, is a motley collection of workers in the fast-evolving freelance economy — whether lawyers, software developers, graphic artists, accountants, consultants, nannies, writers, editors, Web site designers or sellers on Etsy.

Today, the Freelancers Union is one of the nation’s fastest-growing labor organizations, with more than 200,000 members, over half of them in New York State. Ms. Horowitz, who has never lacked audacity, says she expects to expand the organization to one million members within three years. For some perspective, the United Automobile Workers union currently has 380,000 members. Of course, while hundreds of thousands of auto jobs have disappeared, the country is awash in freelancers and other independent workers. Studies by the Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Government Accountability Office show that there are more than 20 million of them. Many companies, including The New York Times, employ these workers.

The Freelancers Union, which is based in Brooklyn, doesn’t bargain with employers, but it does address what is by far these workers’ No. 1 concern, by providing them with affordable health insurance. Its health insurance company covers 23,000 workers in New York State and has $105 million in annual revenue. Impressed by that success, the Obama administration recently awarded Ms. Horowitz’s group $340 million in low-interest loans to establish cooperatives in New York, New Jersey and Oregon that will provide health coverage to freelancers and tens of thousands of other workers.

Having health insurance makes it far easier to be a part of what Ms. Horowitz calls the “gig economy.” But many freelancers would prefer not to participate in that economy at all. They would rather have regular jobs, but companies will often hire them only as independent contractors. Companies find these workers less painful to dismiss and generally less costly because they rarely receive severance pay or benefits like health insurance or paid vacations.

“There are some freelancers for whom this is great — they love the flexibility,” Ms. Horowitz said. “And there are some freelancers for whom this is the worst thing in the world.”

While being an independent worker allows certain advantages — you can go to yoga class or on vacation whenever you want — it also means economic vulnerability. An internal Freelancers Union survey found that 58 percent of the group’s members earn less than $50,000 a year from freelancing and that 29 percent earn less than $25,000. The survey also found that 12 percent of members, many of them college graduates in their 30s and 40s, received food stamps during the recession.

“In today’s economy, there’s a huge chunk of the middle class that’s being pushed down into the working class and working poor,” Ms. Horowitz says, “and freelancers are the first group that’s happening to.”

Historically, through the power of collective bargaining, labor unions helped reverse that equation, enabling many unskilled workers to earn middle-class incomes. But as traditional labor unions have steadily declined in size and power, groups like the Freelancers Union, the New York Taxi Workers Alliance and Domestic Workers United have stepped up, trying to give collective voice and power to often-marginalized workers.

Some union old-timers argue that the Freelancers Union is more like an association than a union and will not be able to achieve truly significant gains for workers. Its members don’t pay union dues, which means that joining requires no sacrifice, and the Freelancers Union doesn’t negotiate contracts with employers or represent freelancers when they have grievances. (Under the National Labor Relations Act, freelancers are considered independent contractors, not employees, and employers thus have no obligation to bargain with them, even when they form a union.)

Ms. Horowitz, 50 and a Brooklyn native, insists that her organization is indeed  a labor union because, like other unions, it is a large, influential, self-supporting organization of workers that pushes to advance their interests, although its members work for numerous employers in many industries.

;

Freelance Union - Sunshine

[ In Reply To ..]
Needed now in the medical transcription business...this is the only thing that will save medical transcription jobs in America. The pay has been decreased to 1/2 the pay with SR and the medical transcriptionists need more money with benefits especially the independent contractors to survive.

Umhm. And our employers aren't about to just double - it on demand. But this is a step by some. nm

[ In Reply To ..]
x

Similar Messages:


Independent ContractorsJan 16, 2013
I am seeking full time medical transcription work. I have been offered a position as an independent contractor and have never worked in this capacity before. What are the pros/cons of working this way. I live in Ohio and wondered about taxes. Any info would be appreciated. ...

Compensation For The Boards Of Directors Of The Nation’s Biggest Banks Continues To RiseApr 01, 2013
Excerpt from the NY Times: "Some Wall Street insiders also question the need to pay bank directors more than their counterparts at other big corporations, arguing that the increased regulation has actually limited bank boards’ ability to perform important tasks, like raising capital and issuing dividends. Even when it comes to paying senior executives, boards have less leeway because regulators have pressured boards to bring down executive pay. “About the only thing bank directors h ...

Obamacare Contractors Paid To Do NothingMay 14, 2014
  Link: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/report-obamacare-contractors-paid-to-do-nothing/ ...

Outsourcing War To Private Contractors Resulted In $60 BillionAug 31, 2011
The Commission on Wartime Contractingin Iraq and Afghanistan was created in 2008 under W with broad bipartisan support.   Membership on the commission consisted of 4 democrats and 4 republicans, appointed by Pelosi, Boehner, Reid and W.   http://www.trivalleycentral.com/articles/2011/08/31/front/doc4e5e645007cde227434173.txt ...

State Department Leaves Contractors In Afghanistan WithoutAug 15, 2016
Surrounded by increasing violence and instability, U.S. contractors left behind in Afghanistan are raising alarm about the potential for another Benghazi tragedy, saying the State Department isn't sharing with them a plan to evacuate if insurgents launch a debilitating attack. The concerns are heightened by the fact that many of those civilians doing the security and nation-building work of the U.S. government hold sensitive security clearances, making them an attractive target for the e ...

Multi-million Dollar Lien Placed Against Trump For Nonpayment Of Contractors On Trump Hotel. In DC.Jan 08, 2017
Derp ...

Santorum Is Out. Who Will The Independent Apr 10, 2012
. ...

This Independent And Her Entire Family Are VotingAug 19, 2016
There is one overriding consideration in our family, and that is the urgent need to break the strangle-hold that the "elite", the "insiders", the "establishment" have had on government for too long. In other words: The "old-boy" (or "old-girl") network. Money, and its illicit influence. Back-room deals and corrupt arrangements. Had Sanders not sold out and broken off an independent candidacy, our family frankly would have been split, but unfortunately Sanders proved to be just another P ...

Conservative Entertainers / Independent ArtistsOct 14, 2011
Whether you are conservative, independent, or liberal.. we are all Americans. There is an artist joedanmedia and he has posted some really inspiring videos on youtube.  You can search on youtube or google for joedanmedia and you'll find them. I'm not promoting anyone but I've watched these all day and he is really good. I wont post external links as they are not permitted but if you google joedanmedia you'll find these. God bless America. God bless our American MTs... be ...

Independent: Why Romney Closed The Deal With MeOct 23, 2012
1.  There was only one "presidential" personality on the stage last night. 2.  I became convinced that Romney is the one who can work across the aisle and get things done. 3.  Obama continued to refuse to own up to any of his obvious economic and foreign policy blunders.  Instead he was arrogant and snarky. 4.  The keys to an effective foreign policy are exactly what Romney identified:  a strong economy and a strong military. 5.  All that Obama could offer ...

Good Article By The Independent JournalJan 25, 2014
http://www.ijreview.com/2014/01/110234-majority-say-obama-administration-incompetent-president-obama-even-paying-attention/     ...

Independent Contractor/health IssuesMay 01, 2016
I've been an IC for a few years for one company.  I have several health issues, which they were aware of when they took me on.  It seems like the last 6 months or so, I'm getting threatened with termination.  Due to health conditions, I am UNABLE to make production requirements.  I am also UNABLE to work 40 hours a week.     I'm not sure what to do.  My doctor only lists me as PARTIALLY disabled.     Really stuck between a rock and ...

Yea! Independent Theater Owners Were Heros Yesterday....smDec 26, 2014
when they agreed to show "The Interview".  It turned out to be one big Christmas party in small theaters across America.  Score one for small business owners! ...

Trump Leads Hiliary By 60 Points, Independent StudyAug 07, 2016
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uUh8ad67RBU ...

Sanders Leaves The Democrat Party...back To Being An Independent.Jul 27, 2016
Chameleon Sanders.  Having only gorged himself at the public trough since 1979, he wants another term as an independent.  37 years isn't enough, I guess.  Wonder if Hillary will stump for him. But hey -  when you're as good at pulling the wool over so many people's eyes as Sanders has proven to be, there's not much else you can be but a politician.  That, or a used car salesman. ...

From Nasa.climate.gov: 1300 Independent Scientists From Around The Planet AgreeJan 12, 2013
A blanket around the Earth Share on tweetTweet 6 Most climate scientists agree the main cause of the current global warming trend is human expansion of the "greenhouse effect"1 -- warming that results when the atmosphere traps heat radiating from Earth toward space. Certain gases in the atmosphere block heat from escaping. Long-lived gases, remaining semi-permanently in the atmosphere, which do not respond physically or chemically to changes in temperature are describe ...

Rent-a-unionFeb 25, 2011
Come one, come all!  Get yer free boxed lunch and poncho (don't want to get wet)!  We'll even reimburse wages!  Doesn't that sound like fun?  Oh, and don't forget the vulgar signs.  Bring the kiddies along too!  It'll be a blast!  No, this really is THE grassroots movement - nothing like those Tea Party astroturf people.   http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2011/02/nj_labor_unions_expected_to_ra.html   There appears to be eff ...

I Was In A Union As An In-house MT.Feb 23, 2011
We were lumped in a group with the housekeepers and the nurses. Union membership was mandatory for employment and dues were taken directly out of our paychecks. Our local reps said they could only negotiate for 1 group a year out of our 3 departments, but every time our turn came around the nurses weren't happy and the union would negotiate for them again. Of course this was 10 years ago, but we made from $8.10 per hour to a max of $12.39 per hour, but we did only have to pay $50 a ...

Not Your Father's UnionApr 19, 2012
These people are dangerous.  This is not your father's union, that's for sure.  Since the Dems are so closely tied with the AFL-CIO and plan to spend $400 million to re-elect Obama, will anyone in the Democrat leadership condem this violent rhetoric?  No, I doubt it. http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2012/04/19/walker-springfield-protest Tuesday, over 2000 union protesters rolled into Springfield, IL, to protest Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker, speaking at the Il ...

Those Nasty Ol\' Union Thugs!May 17, 2011
WASHINGTON -- In recent months, the management at Salinas Valley Memorial Healthcare System has approached workers with a set of proposals that include layoffs and cuts to pensions and health benefits.  . . .  But rather than roll over, the union of nurses, technicians and other hospital workers has rejected management’s proposal, instead launching a counter attack on the executives themselves. The hospital\'s top officials now face a firestorm in the local media and an aud ...

State Of The Union AddressJan 28, 2010
Whoa! I think he pulled a shocker on some of the Republicans by the look on their faces! ...

Does Anybody Watch State Of The Union On CNN?Mar 30, 2010
I absolutely hate remote controls. They wear out too quick!  LOL I'll have to start watching. The transcript is up from her Sunday show. I found it interesting. I must warn you, though. It's very long. Her guests were David Axelrod, Barbara Mikulski, and Lamar Alexander.   http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1003/28/sotu.01.html ...

Union Thuggery And TheatricsApr 08, 2010
http://biggovernment.com/libertychick/2010/04/08/union-thuggery-and-theatrics-when-is-enough-enough-already/#more-103174 ...

Those WI Union Thugs Are Out For BloodDec 11, 2012
Have you seen the violence? Sucker punches, tearing down a tent structure with people inside, etc. Check out Steven Crowder's video. I see why they're called thugs. ...

Wisconsin Union Law UpdateJan 19, 2013
U.S. Appeals Court Upholds Wisconsin Union Law http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/sns-rt-us-usa-wisconsin-laborbre90h1en-20130118,0,812918.story ...

State Of The Union Brought To You ByFeb 12, 2013
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/11/ted-nugent-state-of-the-union_n_2663651.html   Maybe most folks will agree with me that having Ted Nugent attend the State of the Union is not only disrespectful to the President (given what the Nuge has had to say about him in the past), disrespectful to any of those affected by the Newtown shootings who might attend, and disrespectful to this country by turning it into a circus side show, but for those of you who agree with Rep. Stockman and ...

I Saw On TV That Union Workers In Chicago AreJul 29, 2014
because the company had begun limiting each worker to only 6 minutes in the bathroom PER DAY.  They had also installed swipe cards that timed the breaks.  Sounds familiar, doesn't it?   ...

The GOP Candidates Have Just Formed A Union Against The RNCOct 31, 2015
Very interesting. ...

Good State Of Union AddressJan 24, 2012
I am a responsible home owner.  One of his suggestions is to allow people like me to refinance and save $3000 a year. Hope this becomes reality.  Boehner licking his lips constantly.  I think he felt kind of dry and needed a drink.  Eric Cantor looked like he had a fecalith right at the anal verge that was worrying him terribly.  Did not see any secret messages unless there was something to the fact that Joe and Boehner had coordinating blue and white ties.    ...

Walker Blinks First On Union NegotiationMar 09, 2011
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/03/08/wisconsin-governor-proposes-union-compromise-e-mails/?test=latestnews   Man, does it kill me to post this but I would love some feedback on this story.  I heard the news in my car today and I could not believe it.  The newscaster was trying to spin this as a good thing, but I know once Walker starts giving in the democrats are not going to stop until Walker gives them everything.  It seems to me Walker had the upper hand ...