A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

As Worries Over the Power Grid Rise, a Drill Will

Posted: Aug 17, 2013

New York City during a blackout in 2003. More than 150 companies and groups will take part in a drill that will simulate attacks on the power grid.


WASHINGTON — The electric grid, as government and private experts describe it, is the glass jaw of American industry. If an adversary lands a knockout blow, they fear, it could black out vast areas of the continent for weeks; interrupt supplies of water, gasoline, diesel fuel and fresh food shut down communications; and create disruptions of a scale that was only hinted at by Hurricane Sandy and the attacks of Sept. 11.


[When electricity stops, backup generators take over pumping water to homes--for a limited time, and many are old  and not not well maintained. So, when they stop, the water from the faucet slows to a dribble and then stops. Nothing--for weeks. Supermarkets empty in the first few days. Hopefully, National Guard troops control distribution of food that is trucked in. What's available. To some areas anyway.]

This is why thousands of utility workers, business executives, National Guard officers, F.B.I. antiterrorism experts and officials from government agencies in the United States, Canada and Mexico are preparing for an emergency drill in November that will simulate physical attacks and cyberattacks that could take down large sections of the power grid.

They will practice for a crisis unlike anything the real grid has ever seen, and more than 150 companies and organizations have signed up to participate.

“This is different from a hurricane that hits X, Y and Z counties in the Southeast and they have a loss of power for three or four days,” said the official in charge of the drill, Brian M. Harrell of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation, known as NERC. “We really want to go beyond that.”

One goal of the drill, called GridEx II, is to explore how governments would react as the loss of the grid crippled the supply chain for everyday necessities.

“If we fail at electricity, we’re going to fail miserably,” Curt Hébert, a former chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, said at a recent conference held by the Bipartisan Policy Center.

Mr. Harrell said that previous exercises were based on the expectation that electricity “would be up and running relatively quick” after an attack.

Now, he said, the goal is to “educate the federal government on what their expectations should or shouldn’t be.” The industry held a smaller exercise two years ago in which 75 utilities, companies and agencies participated, but this one will be vastly expanded and will be carried out in a more anxious mood.

Most of the participants will join the exercise from their workplaces, with NERC, in Washington, announcing successive failures. One example, organizers say, is a substation break-in that officials initially think is an attempt to steal copper. But instead, the intruder uses a USB drive to upload a virus into a computer network.

The drill is part of a give-and-take in the past few years between the government and utilities that has exposed the difficulties of securing the electric system.

The grid is essential for almost everything, but it is mostly controlled by investor-owned companies or municipal or regional agencies. Ninety-nine percent of military facilities rely on commercial power, according to the White House.

The utilities play down their abilities, in comparison with the government’s. “They have the intelligence operation, the standing army, the three-letter agencies,” said Scott Aaronson, senior director of national security policy at the Edison Electric Institute, the trade association of investor-owned utilities. “We have the grid operations expertise.”

That expertise involves running 5,800 major power plants and 450,000 miles of high-voltage transmission lines, monitored and controlled by a staggering mix of devices installed over decades. Some utilities use their own antique computer protocols and are probably safe from hacking — what the industry calls “security through obscurity.”

But others rely on Windows-based control systems that are common to many industries. Some of them run on in-house networks, but computer security experts say they are not confident that all the connections to the public Internet have been discovered and secured. Many may be vulnerable to software — known as malware — that can disable the systems or destroy their ability to communicate, leaving their human operators blind about the positions of switches, the flows of current and other critical parameters. Experts say a sophisticated hacker could also damage hard-to-replace equipment.

In an effort to draw utilities and the government closer, the industry recently established the Electricity Sub-Sector Coordinating Council, made up of high-level executives, to meet with federal officials. The first session is next month.

Preparation for the November drill comes as Congress is debating laws that could impose new standards to protect the grid from cyberattacks, but many in the industry, some of whom would like such rules, doubt that they can pass.

The drill is also being planned as conferences, studies and even works of fiction are raising near-apocalyptic visions of catastrophes involving the grid.

National Academy of Sciences report last year said that terrorists could cause broad hardship for months with physical attacks on hard-to-replace components. An emerging effort led in part by R. James Woolsey, a former director of the Central Intelligence Agency, is gearing up to pressure state legislatures to force utilities to protect equipment against an electromagnetic pulse, which could come from solar activity or be caused by small nuclear weapons exploded at low altitude, frying crucial components.

An attack using an electromagnetic pulse is laid out in extensive detail in the novel “One Second After,” published in 2009 and endorsed by Newt Gingrich. In another novel, “Gridlock,” published this summer and co-written by Byron L. Dorgan, the former senator from North Dakota, a rogue Russian agent working for Venezuela and Iran helps hackers threaten the grid. In the preface, Mr. Dorgan says such an attack could cause 10,000 times as much devastation as the terrorists’ strikes on Sept. 11, 2001.

Despite the growing anxiety, the government and the private sector have had trouble coordinating their grid protection efforts. The utility industry argues that the government has extensive information on threats but keeps it classified. Government officials concede the problem, and they have suggested that some utility executives get security clearances. But with hundreds of utilities and thousands of executives, it cannot issue such clearances fast enough. And the industry would like to be instantly warned when the government identifies Internet servers that are known to be sources of malware.

Another problem is that the electric system is so tightly integrated that a collapse in one spot, whether by error or intent, can set off a cascade, as happened in August 2003, when a power failure took a few moments to spread from Detroit to New York.

Sometimes utility engineers and law enforcement officials also seem to speak different languages. In his book “Protecting Industrial Control Systems From Electronic Threats,” Joseph Weiss, an engineer and cybersecurity expert, recounted a meeting between electrical engineers and the F.B.I. in 2008. When an F.B.I. official spoke at length about I.E.D.’s, he was referring to improvised explosive devices, but to the engineers the abbreviation meant intelligent electronic devices.

And experts fear government-sponsored hacking. Michael V. Hayden, another former C.I.A. director, speaking at the Bipartisan Policy Center conference, said that the Stuxnet virus, which disabled some of Iran’s centrifuges for enriching uranium, might invite retaliation.

“In a time of peace, someone just used a cyberweapon to destroy another nation’s critical infrastructure,” he said. “Ouch.”

[Although this article focuses on terrorist attacks, there are various natural and normal manmade facts that could trigger a catastrophic power grid failure. In 2003 the Northeast power outage lost power to 45 million people in 8 states and part of Canada. It was triggered by a minor problem in Ohio and cascaded from there. Many backup generator systems failed, but power was restored to most in 3 days. What scares experts is knowing just how easily it could have been far,  far worse.

It would be a good idea to add a couple gallons of bottled water to every grocery run, until a stock of 2 gallons/day/person for -- you choose your safety margin--is built up. Store them in the garage, under the house, or in the side yard if no other space available.  Leave a couple in the trunk of all cars.]


Grid could also be - damaged

[ In Reply To ..]
by massive solar flare and not functional possibly for years. Something else to worry about. *sigh*

Great. Anyone read - One Second After? Ugh.

[ In Reply To ..]

I have it on order. It's a thriller to think about, but - actually coming to cannibalization

[ In Reply To ..]
when the whole U.S. is knocked out is something for survivalists to style their whole lives in planning for. Our real challenge is just surviving a month without water coming out of the tap, all the local supermarkets nothing but empty shelves and broken glass, and waiting in long, long lines for FEMA handouts that probably will not be enough or in the right place for many of us.

Funny thing, though, we're looking for land in the Black Mountain area right now. That's not a scary area at all to someone who used to live in Los Angeles--surrounded by desert and ocean, with almost all water and food brought in from other regions to support some 13 million residents.

I'd love to be there now, though. Hear the weather's absolutely gorgeous. Weirdly cool for August, but lovely.

BIG, big difference between power down for 3 months - and end-of-world-as-we-know-it calamities.

[ In Reply To ..]
Long but temporary outages are what the experts are very worried about. It's not just possible but actually fairly likely to occur to some large area of our country. It's also something we can almost all survive with a little care until power is restored and we start returning to normal.

Dying or losing a child or elderly relative from a foreseeable disaster that could have been prepared for is stupid and irresponsible. Plan to stay safe at home. Along with food and water, plan for protection from extreme conditions, mainly cold if the power goes out in winter. Above all, stock water. It's very inexpensive and stores for a very long time. Healthy adults at least can live a pretty long time without food, children, of course, far more fragile.

Similar Messages:

Romney Wants To Give The Power To Explore And Drill...smAug 23, 2012
on federal lands to individual states rather than the federal government.  He also wants to repeal the Clean Air Act.  Thoughts? ...

WaPo Story Quickly Falls Apart After Investigation Of Power Grid HackDec 31, 2016
Go ahead, diss infowars. More information about the fake WaPo story will be forthcoming shortly. Please, libs, let's stop the fear mongering. It doesn't do anyone any good! Happy New Year! Peace and Love! ...

How Did Sheila Jackson Lee Rise To Power? Oct 14, 2013
Sheila Jackson Lee: The Race Card Hits Its Debt Limit Posted By Daniel Greenfield Two days after being sued for discrimination by a disabled aide, Representative Sheila Jackson Lee stood on the floor of the house and accused opponents of the debt limit hike of racism. The race card she was using had expired long ago, but the media has never gotten the message. Instead it’s pushing stories about the FBI investigating racist cartoons sent to Jackson Lee’s fax machine. It’s an old comforta ...

Drill Baby Drill? SmApr 29, 2010
Accidents like what is now happening in the Gulf of Mexico are why we need to be very cautious about where we drill for oil.  A spill at one oil rig out of thousands in this area is all it takes to have a major environmental disaster.  The shrimp, oyster, fishing industry in the entire gulf area will be severely affected for years to come. ...

Obama Lends $2 Bil In US Tax Dollars So Soros Can Drill In Brazil!!Apr 11, 2011
Obama lends $2 bil of TAXPAYER DOLLARS to Petrobas, which is largely owned by his billionaire buddy George Soros, so they can drill offshore in Brazil!! Meanwhile, all you libs who voted for the usurper: Enjoy your $5/gallon gas which will be here by Memorial Day!! See link to WSJ article below.   ...

Cost Of Green Electricity Driving Aussies Off The GridJul 30, 2017
When greenies get their way, poor people suffer. Global warming hysteria tends to be an affliction of the affluent, who don’t have to worry about where their next meal is coming from or how they will keep the lights on at night. But for those lacking the leisure to hypothesize a crisis that keeps getting stuck on pause, the costs of green energy can wreck lives. It is happening in Australia, in the State of Queensland, ironcally rich in coal deposits: The Sunday Mail of Brisbane explains ...

Cost Of Green Electricity Driving Aussies Off The GridJul 30, 2017
When greenies get their way, poor people suffer. Global warming hysteria tends to be an affliction of the affluent, who don’t have to worry about where their next meal is coming from or how they will keep the lights on at night. But for those lacking the leisure to hypothesize a crisis that keeps getting stuck on pause, the costs of green energy can wreck lives. It is happening in Australia, in the State of Queensland, ironcally rich in coal deposits: The Sunday Mail of Brisbane explains ...

The Deplorables Rise UpNov 14, 2016
Subject: The Deplorables Rise Up 60 Million+ Deplorables This wasn’t an election. It was a revolution. It’s midnight in America. The day before, sixty million Americans got up and stood in front of the great iron wheel that had been grinding them down. They stood there even though the media told them it was useless. They took their stand even while all the chattering classes laughed and taunted them. They were fathers who couldn’t feed their families anymore. The ...

This Is Obama's People (the LIV) And Their Rise Jan 07, 2013
Our tax dollars at "work".     ...

The Rise Of The 4th Branch Of GovernmentMay 25, 2013
The rise of the fourth branch of government Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro professor of public interest law at George Washington University. There were times this past week when it seemed like the 19th-century Know-Nothing Party had returned to Washington. President Obama insisted he knew nothing about major decisions in the State Department, or the Justice Department, or the Internal Revenue Service. The heads of those agencies, in turn, insisted they knew nothing about major decisions by the ...

...and The Dollar Continues To Rise This Week Against The....Dec 16, 2009
. ...

Medicare Part D Costs Will Rise By 3% According To The CBOMar 19, 2010
  http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/113xx/doc11355/Comparison.pdf ...

Poverty To Rise Under Obama Watch ..Sep 13, 2010
WASHINGTON – The number of people in the U.S. who are in poverty is on track for a on President Barack Obama's watch, with the ranks of working-age poor approaching 1960s levels that led to the national war on poverty.Census figures for 2009 — the recession-ravaged first year of the Democrat's presidency — are to be released in the coming week, and demographers expect grim findings.It's unfortunate timing for Obama and his party just seven weeks before important ...

Health Care Costs RiseSep 12, 2012
While annual health care premiums for job-based family plans rose a seemingly respectable 4 percent this year, premiums averaged $15,745, with employees picking up more than $4,300 of that tab, according to an annual employer survey released Sept. 11.  According to an Associated Press report, the costs are a reminder that the U.S.’s struggle with unaffordable medical care is still significant.  Overall, "it's historically a very moderate increase in premiums," said Drew Al ...

The Rise Of The Christian Left In AmericaJul 29, 2013
From the Atlantic Magazine [a moderate, widely respected publication] The Rise of the Christian Left in America The religious right has been in decline for years. Can progressives build a new "moral majority"? JONATHAN MERRITTJUL 25 2013, 6:00 AM ET   11in Share More Led by Jerry Falwell (right), the Moral Majority helped elect Ronald Reagan in 1980 and began decades of religious conservative dominance in politics. (Associated Press) In June 1979, a coalition ...

AP FACT CHECK: Premiums To Rise Under ObamaCareMar 17, 2010
WASHINGTON — Buyers, beware: President Barack Obama says his health care overhaul will lower premiums by double digits, but check the fine print. Premiums are likely to keep going up even if the health care bill passes, experts say. http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iVn9wrhB-3SF-Svo9kZyXd4bHRLAD9EG84VO0 ...

Cool Debt Clock. Watch Our Deficit Rise.Mar 23, 2011
On the left side is also more statistics on unemployment real and reported, births, etc. Near the bottom is corporate assets, small business assets, personal assets. There's also a lot more. Check it out. The moving numbers may get ya dizzy, though.    http://www.usdebtclock.org/ ...

Oil Prices Rise On Middle East, Bernanke CommentsMar 01, 2011
Yikes!  It's a good thing we're drilling for oil here in the U.S.!  Oh wait, never mind. Even still, I bet the rising oil prices are Bush's fault like before when oil prices went up.  Oh wait, he didn't ban off-shore drilling - never mind. "Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told Congress Tuesday that a prolonged rise in oil prices would hurt the U.S. economy."  Oh really? Doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that one out, does it? Duh. Th ...

Americans: Rise Up Against Entrenched Pieces Of Disgusting CrapSep 09, 2016
Let me explain this to sincere liberals who love this country: Your last hope is not Clinton, but Trump. Remove the party blinders. There have been nearly 70 years of liberal dominance in this nation's inner cities and other poor communities. There has been no shortage of money (almost $11 trillion). ...Now, if you DARE, take a drive around any inner city. Okay - did you survive? Great! And what did you see that the liberal philosophy has given us? Vote the same, get the ...

Flashback. Clinton Faults Obama For Rise Of ISISAug 12, 2016
have allowed Islamic terrorists to gain a better footing in the Middle East, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said this week. Clinton, a potential 2016 presidential contender, told The Atlantic in an interview published Sunday that the failure to build up Syrian rebels battling President Bashar Assad "left a big vacuum, which the jihadists have now filled." Some have criticized Obama for not helping Syrian rebels early on in the rebellion in order to combat al Qaeda-inspired terrori ...

U.S. Monthly Job Gains Largest In Three Years; Wages Rise. SmDec 05, 2014
Tell me how this is not good news. ...

Climate Change Directly Related To Rise In Terrorism.Nov 14, 2015
Can someone explain that as it totally went over my head. ...

Compensation For The Boards Of Directors Of The Nation’s Biggest Banks Continues To RiseApr 01, 2013
Excerpt from the NY Times: "Some Wall Street insiders also question the need to pay bank directors more than their counterparts at other big corporations, arguing that the increased regulation has actually limited bank boards’ ability to perform important tasks, like raising capital and issuing dividends. Even when it comes to paying senior executives, boards have less leeway because regulators have pressured boards to bring down executive pay. “About the only thing bank directors h ...

"Unfit For Work: The Startling Rise Of Disability In America"Mar 27, 2013
http://apps.npr.org/unfit-for-work   UNFIT FOR WORK The startling rise of disability in America By Chana Joffe-Walt In the past three decades, the number of Americans who are on disability has skyrocketed. The rise has come even as medical advances have allowed many more people to remain on the job, and new laws have banned workplace discrimination against the disabled. Every month, 14 million people now get a disability check from the government. The federal government spends mo ...

"Unprecedented" Rise In Food Stamps By Months Into Sep 18, 2012
Free stuff, free stuff!!  Obama stuff!  Obama money!!!    ...

What Do You Do When The Power Is Out?Jan 24, 2012
I always want a place with a wood burning stove, something for heat other then power, comes in very handy and is the main source of heat at this time.At this time I have enough gadgets and power for them to most likely last a week, and there are ways to cook, lighting, food, water stays on etc... so it is mostly an entertainment issue when the power goes out and with all these gadgets these days it is easier to stay entertained. Of course if the power goes out during the day I can still work on ...

The Power To Say NO Is Huge.Nov 01, 2010
As few as 41 senators, which could represent as little as 12.3% of the U.S. population, can make a filibuster happen.  The Republicans have been using the filibuster continually, even filibustering bills they previously were FOR, just because they believe it makes Dems look bad.  The Republicans currently have 41 senators and block everything.  The Democrats have 57 senators, so by the rules they cannot override the Republican obstructionism.   ...

Finally, it took many prayers and patience, but I have found a new job with what seems to be a wonderful company.  I had posted before about difficult financial situations for myself and so many others, but I finally feel relieved now that I have this new job with much better pay and good benefits.  I know that the prayers here and from so many others have made this happen.  I will keep praying for all the others that continue struggling like I was.  I know how overwhelming t ...

The Power Of WordsApr 22, 2011
This video really moved me.  Wanted to share with all.   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hzgzim5m7oU&feature=player_embedded ...

Power WindowsJul 26, 2010
A few days ago my driver's side window does not work.  My friend told me that she had the same problem some years back and had to take it to the dealer and it cost $300.00 to have it fixed.   My stepfather says it may be $400.00.  My inspection is due by August 31st.  Can someone please tell me if it is required to have it fixed for inspection?  I am just sick about this.  The last two years I paid $700.00 and then $500.00 for inspection;  first one ...