Understanding the Roots of the War on History - Shocker: Most College Students Think Posted: Nov 29th, 2019 - 7:10 am In Reply to: capitalism - - Is there anything
America Invented Slavery....
In the early 20th century, a group of historians connected with the progressive movement declared war on traditional history. In 1921, husband and wife Charles A. and Mary R. Beard co-authored a high school textbook simply titled The History of the United States, a work that detailed the progressive movement’s plan to revolutionize teaching history. An online version of this important work can be found here. The volume’s introduction stated: “If the study of history cannot be made truly progressive [or organized] like the study of mathematics, science, and languages, then the historians assume a grave responsibility in adding their subject to the already overloaded curriculum.” Their approach expunged “The time-honored stories of exploration and biographies of heroes” and “all descriptions of battles” as unnecessary and even detrimental.
The Beards listed seven changes to the traditional narrative approach to history. First, their curriculum was topic-based. Second, these topics revealed how each had contributed to the nation’s development. Third, their approach “dwelt fully upon the social and economic aspects” of American history. Fourth, the causes and results of wars and the problems of financing and sustaining armed forces replaced military strategy. Fifth, discovery and exploration were omitted to make room for citizenship. Sixth, although recognizing America’s uniqueness in some areas, they believed attention must be paid to diplomacy, foreign affairs, world relations, and the influence of other nations. And seventh, they claimed that their approach would stimulate students to think and analyze, resulting in graduates ready for the modern world. Like Weems, the Beards believed historical instruction could mold the character of future citizens. We heard the fruit of the Beards' philosophical approach in Barrack Obama’s famous Berlin speech, where an American president declared himself a citizen of the world.
Other progressive historians reinforced this view of history in which economic factors drive history. In particular, the Marxist notions of property and class struggle began to gain favor. These authors and their works shaped several generations of students, who would, in turn, become authors and teachers. While the Beards and most progressive historians have largely been relegated to historiographic reading lists, their influence on the modern history profession cannot be overstated. The popularity of Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States demonstrates how widely accepted and entrenched the progressive interpretation of history launched by the Beards has become.
This economic approach to history has been popular on campuses and in textbooks for years. Examples are familiar: the American Revolution was a war for economic independence; the Founding Fathers were rich white men who established a government to protect their own interests; the nation was built by the labor of workers who toiled for the benefit of slave owners and industrialists; the Westward Expansion stole land at the expense of Native Americans and Mexicans; and women and minorities endured a menial and minimal existence. Words such as liberty or freedom masked bigotry and greed. Heroes were not the misguided men who fought for kings and capitalists on faraway battlefields but those who struggled in factories and fields against oppression. It was a world that cried out for fairness and change as well as a world, too, in which the individual triumphed only if assisted by the power of the government, the basic tenet of progressivism. The case can be made that all historical interpretations have a political agenda at heart. However, progressive historians created a world view designed to help politicians reconstruct society.
5 Reasons to Celebrate Columbus Day as a Symbol of Diversity
Victimhood is key to the progressive interpretation of history. Basically, if someone gains then someone else loses. Thus, history becomes a scorecard for identifying winners and losers. Those with wealth and power use it to oppress others. The goal of progressive history is not to understand the past but to identify guilty parties. Assigning roles of oppressor and oppressed (i.e., victim) signal which past wrongs must be righted. Since the guilty culprits are dead, the responsibility to make things right rests with their progeny. The beneficiaries aren’t the original victims but their descendants. An economic redistribution of wealth is usually suggested to demonstrate contrition.
To modern progressives, no narrative can exist other than the claim that powerful groups oppress less powerful groups, which supports the moral, legal, and political implications that history’s victims deserve restitution. Progressive history strikes at the very root of the early American republican historical narrative by rejecting the notion of American exceptionalism. Rather than acknowledge and celebrate the Founding Fathers and other early heroes, progressive historians denigrate them and work to remove them from the public discourse. Look no further for an explanation of what is happening to statues deemed offensive and guilty of some past injustice.
Why do historical interpretations matter? The boundary between history and politics is razor-thin and too many practitioners claim to be historians when in fact they are political operatives. I am not referring to just the academic voices in the classroom crying for social justice but the advocational historians who strive to maintain their group heritage and/or identity. Both can be extreme in their own way, picking the historical “facts” that support their view of the past. Moreover, the struggle for control of the historical narrative has made the field unappealing to the public in general and students in particular. It is an unhealthy situation for both the profession and the society it professes to serve.
We have all heard the well-worn rejoinder, "Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it." Nevertheless, many in our society go about their daily lives with little or no regard for history or those who write it. It is enough to beg the question, "Is history obsolete?" The answer, of course, is no. However, it is time that those in the profession reevaluate how we present history to the public and adopt strategies to address the problem of societal disinterest. If no remedy is found, it is historians themselves who face becoming irrelevant.
LINK/URL: Understanding the Roots of the War on History
Post A Reply Reply By Email Options
Complete Discussion Below: ( marks the location of current message within thread)
- Feeling thankful for my education - And abilities...capitalism is racist (Views: 578, 2019-11-28, 8:34 am)
- capitalism - - Is there anything (Views: 354, 2019-11-28, 10:01 am)
-
Understanding the Roots of the War on History - Shocker: Most College Students Think
- Cleaning black money +256700756692 in Uganda,South Sudan,Congo,Burundi
- +256700756692 Gold nuggets for sale in Luxembourg,USA,UK,Dubai,Ireland,Netherland,Singapore,Malaysia
- Buy real and fake Passports (WHATSAPP : +1(740)280-2019) ID card, driving license, green card, resid
- DBP Transcription
- Financial Services business and personal loans no collateral require
- FINANCIAL SERVICES BUSINESS CASH LOAN COMPAN GRANTED ME A BUSINESS LOANS
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHE
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy Pain killers | Mdma,2CB,A-PVP,3CMC | OZEMPIC | STEROIDS (Ecstasy/Nembutal) | Heroin Cocaine (Tel
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- Buy Pain killers | Mdma,2CB,A-PVP,3CMC | OZEMPIC | STEROIDS (Ecstasy/Nembutal) | Heroin Cocaine (Tel
- Buy 100% undetectable counterfeit money grade AAA+ | SSD CHEM | CLONED CARDS FOR SALE @(infodocument
- LOAN OFFER WITHOUT STRESS WE GIVE OUT LOAN FROM $5000 TO $500,0000
- LOAN OFFER WITHOUT STRESS WE GIVE OUT LOAN FROM $5000 TO $500,0000
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- LOANS FOR 3% INTEREST RATE PER YEAR PERSONAL LOANS & BUSINESS LOAN OFFER APPLY NOW
- IN SEARCH OF URGENT LOAN, PERSONAL LOAN, STUDENT LOAN, PRIVATE LOAN, CAR LOAN?
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- WE OFFER ALL TYPES OF LOAN (BUSINESS LOAN, PERSONAL LOAN, CONSOLIDATION LOAN, FINANCIAL LOAN
- Auckland- New Zealand +256747234371 Death Spells/ Voodoo Love Spells In Wellington, Revenge Spell C
- jaja kevin....+256747234371 Am African best spells, and I am Spiritual Healer,
- Get an Instant Personal Loan with Quick Approval – Apply Now!
- Financial Services business and personal loans no collateral require
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- DO YOU NEED A LOAN APPLY NOW LOAN OFFER AT 2%
- Financial help Money Lender Get Loan
- Invest on bitcoin mining and earn more profit
- URGENT LOAN OFFER FOR BUSINESS AND PERSONAL USE
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- IN SEARCH OF URGENT LOAN, PERSONAL LOAN, STUDENT LOAN, PRIVATE LOAN, CAR LOAN?
- LOANS FOR 3% INTEREST RATE PER YEAR PERSONAL LOANS & BUSINESS LOAN OFFER APPLY NOW
- format question
- Financial Services business loan and personal loans no collateral require
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- WE OFFER QUICK LOAN PERSONAL LOAN, BUSINESS LOAN, AND DEBT CONSOLIDATION LOAN
- DO YOU NEED A PERSONAL LOAN / BUSINESS LOAN AT 3% INTEREST RATE? APPLY
- Smart Prep with Updated Appian ACD101 Exam Questions
- FINANCIAL SERVICES BUSINESS CASH LOAN COMPAN GRANTED ME A BUSINESS LOANS
- Quick Financial Services business Loan and personal loans Online with Direct Lenders
- +27764410726 PENIS ENLARGEMENT CREAM & PILLS in BARBERTON, BETHAL, STANDERTON, MALALANE, ACOR
- [+27764410726] PENIS ENLARGEMENT CREAM & PILLS in South africa, SECUNDA, OGIES, KWAGGAFONITEN,
- PENIS ENLARGEMENT +27764410726 Early ejaculation in South africa, SECUNDA, OGIES, ERMELO,KWAGGAFON
- PENIS ENLARGEMENT [[[+27764410726]]]⓶ CREAM & PILLS in PRETORIA, SOSHANGUVE, MAMELODI, HAMMANS
- Powerful {+27764410726 } ENLARGEMENT CREAM FOR PENIS In LIMPOPO, GIYANI, POLOKWANE, MALAMULELE, BOTC
|