Tax Myths of Warrenomics. Her advisers make three huge - errors in denying the rich pay the Posted: Oct 18th, 2019 - 6:53 am
government more.
Economists Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman of the University of California, Berkeley are advising Elizabeth Warren’s presidential campaign and drawing generous media attention for their assertion that the U.S. tax system is flat—that the middle class and poor pay as great a share of their income in taxes as the rich. They’re wrong, and three huge mistakes underlie their analysis.
The biggest mistake is to focus on gross, not net, taxes. They ignore transfer payments, like Social Security, which are disproportionately paid to the poor. In doing so, they mistake language for economics.
To see the problem, consider a simple thought experiment. Joe, a minimum-wage employee, earns $15,000 a year. The government taxes Joe $1,000 and transfers him $600, so that he pays $400 on net. In another scenario, Joe pays $10,000 in taxes and collects $9,600 in transfer payments. Again, he pays $400 on net. But in the first scenario, Messrs. Saez and Zuchman would report Joe’s gross tax rate as a reasonable 6.7% ($1,000 over $15,000). In the second, they’d call it an onerous 66.7%.
The flaw in their method is even more obvious when you consider that American tax laws incorporate benefit subsystems, and benefit laws incorporate tax subsystems. The federal personal income tax, for instance, includes the earned-income tax credit, a major transfer program. The Social Security benefit system includes the earnings test, a major tax. If the focus is on gross taxes, should the EITC be excluded and Social Security’s earnings test included? Economics can’t say. What it does say is look past the language and measure net, not gross, taxes.
Messrs. Saez and Zucman’s second mistake is measuring progressivity on a one-year rather than a remaining-lifetime basis. That ignores the fiscal system’s double taxation...
LINK/URL: Tax Myths of Warrenomics. Her advisers make three huge
Post A Reply Reply By Email Options
Complete Discussion Below: (  marks the location of current message within thread)
- I particularly like the snippet of Obama.
- Fresh off the press, current news
- Posters read
- capitalize the mainland
- Your Handy-Dandy Survival Guide to Life Under Social Justice Mob Rule
- A Touching
- St. Louis police release surveillance video of 7 'persons of
- Lol...conservatives all over supposed
- Divisive Insurrectionists Have Brought The Nation To The
- I don't like Trump, I don't like Biden.
- The Roots of Black Lives Matter
- Well, well...even the NFL is coming around
- A note from my friend
- Employee, MLS/Speech Recognition Editors -
- Celebrities Show Solidarity With Protesters By Burning
- Remember the riots over Tony Timpa's death at the hands of police?
- NOTICE HOW BLM, ANTIFA,
- In Show Of Solidarity, COVID-19 Vows Not To Infect
- The Art of The Comeback?
- Antifa: "Practice things
- Boston man accused of shooting at 21 police officers during
- Mayor Bowser Is Kicking The Utah National Guard Out Of All DC Hotels
- Any information on MnD Scriberz, LLC?
- My Name is
- ophthalmology help, please?
- Drew Brees was bullied into taking back his patriotic remarks.
- Violent, armed looters overrun Santa Monica Music Center:
- NYC looters seen escaping in Rolls-Royce SUV worth at
- LEGO stops marketing police-themed toys 'in light of recent events'
- Re: One Transcription Services
- Minneapolis: Do the rioters
- After telling GOP to downsize convention due to COVID-19, N.C.
- Los Angeles to slash up to $150M from LAPD budget, reinvest into
- Obama-era ex-intel official secures bail for NYC lawyer suspected
- More and more victims of Trump's revolving
- BOYCOTT ETSY AND DOORDASH
- Anybody working for Imedx?
- Other officers charged. Chauvin charge upgraded to 2nd degree murder.
- ‘BLM Is a Joke’: Black DC Resident Tells Far-Left Group ‘Go to Chicago’
- Rioters Stole Puppy & Abused It On Live TV. It’s Now Confirmed Dead–
- Apple is disabling and tracking some looted iPhones
- President Obama speaks
- USPS Mail Carrier Charged with Fraud After Allegedly Tampering with
- The lying about Donald Trump is now completely out of control
- Back to NJA already??
- HAD ENOUGH OF THE LIBERAL FASCIST LIES, BLM LIES
- In the last 96 hours...
- USPS in Chicago is suspending service and limiting
- Bogdan Vechirko made a delivery to a black-owned gas
- Armed man arrested for allegedly impersonating National Guard;
|
