A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

How would you have handled this?


Posted: Nov 10, 2014

A few days ago, I called my niece Janice to chat.  While on the phone, she asked, "You aren't on Facebook, are you?"  I told her no, and she went on to extend an invitation to me that she had originally posted on Facebook to other friends and family members to attend her 30th birthday party that was being held at a painting studio in which guests would create their own painting under the instruction of an art teacher.  I said, "Great.  Send the details to me via email."  She wrote to me and included the date, the time, and the name of the studio.  I responded that I would definitely be there.

Later on that day, I was corresponding with another niece Katie (not Janice's sister) and told her I was really looking forward to Janice's birthday party.  Katie wrote back and said she was excited, too, and suggested we go together and that she wanted to pay for me.  I didn't really understand right away what she meant by "pay," but I subsequently found out from another family member (huge family) that when Janice posted the invite on Facebook, she also posted that each person had to pay to attend.   I never found out exactly how much, but it's somewhere in the range of $35-$45.  This includes all the art materials, the art instruction, and beverages.  The studio does not provide food.  I was told that Janice did emphasize on the Facebook post that she did not want any presents and wanted only to enjoy the company of her family and friends for her birthday.  By the way, Katie probably offered to pay for me because I often go over to her house and take care of her dog when she is away, and even though she always offers to pay me, I always refuse because she's my family, and I do it because I love her.  

Like a lot of people who currently work in this industry, my income is below the max poverty line.  I cannot afford to pay my bills as it is, so there is certainly no extra for entertainment.  When I initially spoke to Janice on the phone and then received her email invite, I was relieved and happy that I would actually be able to go because I had a gift to give her.  Recently, I was given a gift card for WalMart, but due to ethical issues I have with that retailer, I knew I would not be using it.  I thought of giving it to someone who actually shops there, rather than tossing it, because I would hate to have WalMart make a profit like that without having to give up any inventory.  Had I not had the gift card in mind to give to Janice as a birthday gift, I would have declined the invitation.  

First off, I have never heard of someone throwing themselves a birthday party and asking their guests to essentially pay for it.  I find it a little disturbing.  Secondly, the fact that Janice, in her Facebook post, seemed to be reminding everyone that she did not want any presents, but looked forward to only the warmth of her loved ones seems a little disingenuous when she is not paying for the party.

I thank God that I found out about this ahead of time because I could have shown up without any money and been refused entry.  My siblings are aware of my financial situation, and I am okay with that.  My many nieces and nephews, however, are not privy to that information, and I don't want to share it with them.  They are not my contemporaries.  Since I both spoke on the phone to Janice AND received info via email, I cannot understand why that little bit of information was left out.  Maybe it slipped her mind, maybe she's embarrassed, etc.

Anyway, I wrote to her the next day and mentioned that another niece had said something about 'paying??'  She has not written back to me yet.  I know I will not be attending because I simply do not have the money, but I feel like none of this would have happened if I'd had all the facts when the invitation was extended.

Am I just old-fashioned thinking it's odd that someone is throwing themselves a party and asking others to pay for it?  I don't think it would be unusual to suggest a non-occasion get-together like this one (painting party) where everyone pays for themselves.  I'm also bothered that she was not up front with me about the money.

Any thoughts?  

;

Maybe she does have a little insight on your financial - situation and did'nt mention...

[ In Reply To ..]
the cost because she hadn't planned on charging you? If you have to pay at the door, that's a pretty BIG detail to leave out. So it's possible she had no intentions charging you to begin with?..just a thought.

P.S. maybe thats why she has not responded yet - because she feels bad? SM

[ In Reply To ..]
And people throw parties for themselves all the time that they want you to pay to attend. It's not unheard of, it does happen. Especially with the younger generation.

These parties are the big social thing, now. - IMANMT2

[ In Reply To ..]
sometimes they are held in restaurants/bars. You can buy entry to one off of Groupon for less than half price. A lot of time they are people you don't know. If she has enough family members to fill it then hers might be private.

If it's art then it might be at a studio someplace... it's a way for them to drum up business, too. Marketing.

It started in bigger cities and is working it's way out.

If you can scrounge up the money you should go or let the other niece pay your way, offer to do something for her. Give her the Wal-Mart card (you'll still have to pay for your drinks).

If she is doing this for her birthday, she doesn't want a conventional party (an adult maybe?) and gifts. It's something different, its getting out, going someplace, and its en vogue, and she's taking her family with her because she thinks it will be fun and it will be.

35 bucks for a night out is cheap entertainment for people who have jobs that actually pay. I, myself, couldn't afford to attend one right now.

I hope you get to go.

handle this - JeezLouise

[ In Reply To ..]
So your other niece offered to pay for what sounds like a wonderful evening with girls you are apparently fond of. It's like she is giving you the gift yet it's her birthday. And you think it would be more proper to give her a Walmart card that you were going to discard anyway? They are not your generation, they do things differently. Personally I would accept the invitation in the spirit it was intended and go have a wonderful time. Honestly, I don't understand the things people gripe about anymore.

My Take - see msg

[ In Reply To ..]
It is possible that your niece was talking so much about it on Facebook, that she didn't realize she didn't mention it to you. Kind of like she forgot who she told what. I am not on Facebook, and I often get e-mails from relatives as if I should have known something---like a piece of the story is missing or there's an inside joke or something.

I would not cut off your nose to spite your face. I would take the other niece's offer and let her pay. As to the Walmart card, give it to the niece who is paying your way. It will even things up, since you feel bad having her pay for you.

I'm afraid I would have said exactly what I thought.... - sm

[ In Reply To ..]
that is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard...making people pay to attend a birthday party. That is the utmost in no manners!!!

Agree - From "My Take"

[ In Reply To ..]
I think it's ridiculous, too, but since the situation is here, she may as well go an enjoy herself on someone else.

I'm not from this generation. I'm 59. Back in the day, if you had a party you paid for everything--and if people wanted to bring a gift, fine. If not, fine too, but it would be proper to bring something at least small. We didn't "charge" anyone to come to a party. It's like giving yourself a party and having others pay for it.

If I was taking care of someone's dog... - wheres_my_job

[ In Reply To ..]
...I would let them pay for me to attend the painting party. People like to do things for other people...I know I do. Especially when they've been helpful to you, it's nice to reciprocate. That's all it is...reciprocation.

It sounds like it will be a lot of fun. Maybe everyone else, that dollar amount is well within their budget. Not everyone realizes how hard someone else is having it.

My advice: Just go with the flow. Accept the bounty of the universe when it is offered you.

What I would do - Anonymous one

[ In Reply To ..]
First, you do not have to attend the party just because you were invited. Give your niece the gift card at a different time, maybe the 2 of you can do something together to celebrate her birthday that would be less expensive. However, someone is offering to do something nice for you by paying for you to attend, graciously accept that and reciprocate when you are able. If you had shown up without any money, trust me they would not have turned you away. By e-mailing your niece and making an issue of finances, she is probably going to feel guilty, I know I would. Actually, the guests are not paying for the party, they are paying to defray the instructor's fees and the cost of the art supplies. If the hostess had to pick up the cost, it would be very expensive for her; it seems to me the only one making a profit is the instructor. All I can compare it to are those Mary Kay and Tupperware parties that a lot of us got sucked into back in the day. It sounds like people are doing the art class in lieu of a gift, which would cost that much anyway. If you don't want to go, decline gracefully and drop it, just say no. If you want to go, accept Katie's offer and leave it at that. Yes, your niece should have been up front about it but she probably didn't realize that some people would have a problem with it. Much ado about nothing, IMO.

Art parties - sm

[ In Reply To ..]
We have a place here that we can throw parties and you create a piece of art also. The way this place does it is you basically purchase the birthday party (art included) for however many guests you plan to have attend. So, when I did my daughter's party, I could have up to 20 people and it cost me $200 bucks. I had to also furnish my own cake and they furnished the drinks. I would never imagine asking guests to pay their own way.

Similar Messages:


The "non-ransom" Money Transfer To Iran Was HandledAug 04, 2016
HOW STUPID DO CLINTON AND THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION THINK WE ARE???!! If you don't know when your intelligence is being insulted, you will buy anything. Unmarked aircraft.  Pallets loaded with cash.  Landing in the middle of the night...and just COINCIDENTALLY timed to the release of American hostages. There comes a time when party can no longer be the primary consideration with respect to the electorate.  There comes a time when misdirection, misinfformation and outright ...