Problems with your reasoning - sm

Posted: Oct 3rd, 2017 - 3:46 pm In Reply to: What is so difficult about requiring mental health exam? - Physical exams and drug testing

What other Constitutionally protected rights require physical exams and drug testing?

Would you require drug testing and mental health exams for voting? Public speaking? Before allowing people to practice a religion? Prior to meeting together?

Bottom line, you can have a mental health issue and not be dangerous. You can not have a mental health issue and still be dangerous. You can not have a mental health issue, not be dangerous, and then snap.

Post A Reply Reply By Email Options

Use Rich Text Editor with Full Options CLOSE

Edit/Delete Message

Report this message

X CLOSE

Complete Discussion Below: (

marks the location of current message within thread)

Nothing changes unless we change it - Sm (Views: 1171, 2017-10-02, 10:50 pm)
- One question - sm (Views: 646, 2017-10-03, 12:11 am)
- Well said. - nm (Views: 303, 2017-10-03, 1:58 am)
- It's human nature that needs to change. People still - use knifes, glass, bombs (Views: 406, 2017-10-03, 5:32 am)
  - Correct, can use fertilizer and suicide bombs. - It's evil people. (Views: 371, 2017-10-03, 8:29 am)
  - Chemical weapons too. The left as expected is - politicizing this event to push (Views: 363, 2017-10-03, 9:02 am)
  - Note how Pubs/NRA always turn to semantics and hyperbole? - sm (Views: 429, 2017-10-03, 9:24 am)
- The argument "Can't do anything because gun was legal." - Repeal and Replace (Views: 447, 2017-10-03, 7:54 am)
  - That's a slippery slope. If the Bill of Rights is changed, then - which one is next? First amendment? (Views: 348, 2017-10-03, 8:42 am)
    - Yes, this is not about guns. You don't reduce traffice deaths by - outlawing so called "dangerous" (Views: 450, 2017-10-03, 11:05 am)
      - Certain vehicles are outlawed on streets and people are medically denied licenses - Answer this (Views: 454, 2017-10-03, 12:13 pm)
        Driving is a privilege, not a right. The Constitution makes - gun ownership a right. sm (Views: 460, 2017-10-03, 12:58 pm)
        Truthhurts says automatic weapons are outlawed - that's okay? (Views: 416, 2017-10-03, 1:29 pm)
        Yes. All of your protections allow a "nutcase" to buy 40+ weapons - and try to kill sm (Views: 355, 2017-10-03, 1:56 pm)
        What do you mean I said "automatic weapons were outlawed -- that's okay?" - Truthhurts (Views: 347, 2017-10-03, 2:01 pm)
        Quote about 4 posts down "automatic weapons were outlawed years ago" - (slightly edited) sm (Views: 447, 2017-10-03, 2:10 pm)
        The British tried to disarm citizens before the Revolutionary War. - That's why the gun is #2, it's (Views: 409, 2017-10-04, 8:39 am)
        If he had used a twin engine plane loaded with fuel - and maybe other explosives, (Views: 292, 2017-10-04, 4:18 am)
        The comments here just prove that the Cconstitution isn't - taught anymore. It LIMITS (Views: 343, 2017-10-04, 4:11 am)
        Are gun shops now supposed to be psychiatrists? - Truthhurts (Views: 395, 2017-10-03, 1:50 pm)
        What is so difficult about requiring mental health exam? - Physical exams and drug testing (Views: 357, 2017-10-03, 2:19 pm)
        Problems with your reasoning - sm
        Problems with your - comparisons! (Views: 372, 2017-10-03, 4:06 pm)
        True. They're not lethal - but they are rights sm (Views: 409, 2017-10-03, 7:03 pm)
        That's discrimination! - sm (Views: 370, 2017-10-03, 4:11 pm)
        The same reason - we deny (Views: 387, 2017-10-03, 4:34 pm)
        It's not the same reason - sm (Views: 375, 2017-10-03, 6:54 pm)
        Excellent suggestion - Patriotic Republican (Views: 364, 2017-10-03, 5:15 pm)
      - This is not about guns. Something is wrong in our society, - the whole world really. (Views: 325, 2017-10-04, 4:59 am)
  - What right to healthcare? That's not in the - constitution. (Views: 358, 2017-10-03, 9:01 am)
    - Are automatic/semi-automatic muskets in the constitution? - nm (Views: 313, 2017-10-03, 9:15 am)
      - Automatic guns were outlawed years ago during - Truthhurts (Views: 1469, 2017-10-03, 10:43 am)
        CBS fired executive for tweeting she was not sympathetic - to victims of the shooting because (Views: 413, 2017-10-03, 10:51 am)
        She'd better hope that if something happened to her, there are - mostly "repugs" in the crowd to save (Views: 316, 2017-10-03, 10:52 am)
        CBS? Read she was CNN legal analyst. (nm). - Truthhurts (Views: 335, 2017-10-03, 11:06 am)
        Semi-automatics and "enhancing" kits should be outlawed - but change the subject (Views: 364, 2017-10-03, 12:18 pm)
    - Neither is the "right" to healthy foods - hawkmt (Views: 358, 2017-10-03, 11:06 am)
      - I grow my own healthy foods and make that choice. It - doesn't depend on others' work (Views: 346, 2017-10-04, 4:01 am)
- Do you suggest banning guns? Because that's all that's left to do. - Truthhurts (Views: 398, 2017-10-03, 10:52 am)
  - To kill a snake you have to cut the head off. - We should ban corporate - sm (Views: 476, 2017-10-03, 12:09 pm)
    - Machine guns are already illegal, but you prove a point - Truthhurts (Views: 570, 2017-10-03, 1:40 pm)
  - Black market only goes as far as Indiana and Wisconsin . - We can do something. (Views: 321, 2017-10-03, 12:30 pm)
    - Sorry, I'm confused about your statement "Black market only goes as far as - Indiana and Wisconsin" (Views: 415, 2017-10-04, 1:34 am)