A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Interesting perspective. I don't totally agree with all of it, but couldn't agree more...


Posted: Oct 14, 2013

with the points about real voting rights, nonpartisan redistricting, and abolishing the senate filibuster.

 

The South is holding America hostage

The Tea Party's not crazy -- they had a plan. Now liberals and progressives need one, too

  

TOPICS: SOUTHCONSERVATISMTEA PARTYLABORU.S. ECONOMYUNEMPLOYMENTUNIONSCONFEDERACY,EDITOR'S PICKS

The South is holding America hostage 
When I have described the well-considered, coherent political and economic strategies of the conservative white South, as I have done herehere and here, I am sometimes been accused of being a “conspiracy theorist.” But one need not believe that white-hooded Dragons and Wizards are secretly coordinating the actions of Southern conservative politicians from a bunker underneath Stone Mountain in Georgia to believe that a number of contemporary policies — from race-to-the-bottom economic policies to voter disfranchisement and attempts to decentralize or privatize federal social insurance entitlements — serve the interests of those who promote them, who tend to be white Southern conservatives.

Just as a strategy is not a conspiracy, so it is not insanity. Ironically, American progressives, centrists and some Northern conservatives are only deluding themselves, when they insist that the kind of right-wing Southerners behind the government shutdown are “crazy.” Crazy, yes — crazy like a fox.

Another mistake is the failure to recognize that the Southern elite strategy, though bound up with white supremacy throughout history, is primarily about cheap and powerless labor, not about race. If the South and the U.S. as a whole through some magical transformation became racially homogeneous tomorrow, there is no reason to believe that the Southern business and political class would suddenly embrace a new model of political economy based on high wages, high taxes and centralized government, rather than pursue its historical model of a low-wage, low-tax, decentralized system, even though all workers, employers and investors now shared a common skin color.

So the struggle is not one to convert Southern Baptists to Darwinism or to get racists to celebrate diversity. The on-going power struggle between the local elites of the former Confederacy and their allies in other regions and the rest of the United States is not primarily about personal attitudes. It is about power and wealth.

For some time, the initiative has rested with the Southern power elite, which knows what it wants and has a plan to get it. The strategy of the conservative South, as a nation-within-a nation and in the global economy, combines an economic strategy and a political strategy.



The economic strategy is to maximize the attractiveness of the former Confederacy to external investors, by allowing Southern states to out-compete other states in the U.S., as well as other countries if possible, in a race to the bottom by means of low wages, stingy government welfare (which if generous increases the bargaining power of poor workers by decreasing their desperation) and low levels of environmental regulation.

The political strategy of the Southern elite is to prevent the Southern victims of these local economic policies from teaming up with allies in other parts of the U.S. to impose federal-level reforms on the Southern states. Voter suppression seeks to prevent voting by lower-income Southerners of all races who are hostile to the Southern power elite. Partisan gerrymandering of the U.S. House of Representatives by conservatives in Southern state legislatures weakens the votes of anti-conservative Southerners, if they are allowed to vote.

If voter suppression and vote dilution strategies fail, the Southern conservatives can still try to ward off unwelcome federally-imposed reforms that might weaken control of the Southern workforce by Southern employers and their political agents, by policies of devolving federal programs to the states, privatizing federal programs like Social Security and Medicare, blocking the implementation of new federal entitlements like Obamacare or a combination of these strategies.

To date the response of progressives and centrists, as well as moderate conservatives in the North (who have a quite different tradition) to what might be called the Southern Autonomy Project has been feeble and reactive. The South acts, the rest of the country reacts.

Here Midwestern Republican legislatures or governors try to copy the South’s anti-labor “right-to-work” legislation, and labor activists and liberals react.  The legislatures in the South and their allies elsewhere pass voter suppression laws, and civil rights groups scramble to counteract them. Now the Southern-dominated Tea Party in the House shuts down the government and threatens to force the federal government into default. In this game of “Whack-a-mole,” the Southern right and its neo-Jacksonian allies in other parts of the country always has the initiative.

Instead of waiting for the next Southern conservative outrage, and treating it as a single, isolated example of inexplicable craziness, the rest of America from center-left to center-right should recognize that it is dealing with different aspects of a single strategy by a regional elite — the Southern Autonomy Project. It is time for the non-Southern American majority, in alliance with many non-elite Southerners of all races, to target and attack every element of the Southern Autonomy Project simultaneously. If the neo-Confederates want to wage political and economic war, their fellow Americans should choose to respond with political and economic war on all fronts, not on the terms and in the places the Southern conservatives choose.

Setting political difficulty aside, it is intellectually easy to set forth a grand national strategy that consists of coordinated federal policies to defeat the Southern Autonomy Project.

A federal living wage.  At one blow, a much higher federal minimum wage would cripple the ability of Southern states to lure companies from more generous states which supplement the too-low present federal minimum wage with higher local state or urban minimum wages.  (Strong national unions could do the same, but that is not a realistic option at present.)

Nationalization of social insurance.  Social insurance programs with both federal and state components, like Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”), allow Southern states to be stingier than many other states, creating more desperate workers who are more dependent on the mercy of employers and elite-dominated charities. Completely federalizing Medicaid (as President Ronald Reagan suggested!) and other hybrid federal-state social insurance programs would cripple the Southern Autonomy Project further.

Real voting rights.  Using the authority of the Fifteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, Congress should completely federalize voting requirements for all federal, state and local elections, making it as easy as possible for U.S. citizens to vote — over the objections of kicking and screaming neo-Confederates.

Nonpartisan redistricting.  Partisan redistricting by majorities in state legislatures should be replaced by nonpartisan redistricting commissions, as in California, New Jersey and other states.  The redistricting commissions should be truly nonpartisan, not “bipartisan” arrangements in which incumbent Republicans and incumbent Democrats cut deals to protect their safe seats from competition. (Electoral reforms like instant run-off voting and proportional representation are struggles for a more distant future).

Abolish the Senate filibuster.  The filibuster is not part of the U.S. constitution. It has been used by Southern white conservatives from the nineteenth century to the twenty-first to preserve Southern white power and economic privilege. This relic of premodern  British parliamentary politics should be abolished. Democracy means majority rule. If the Southern Right loses a battle in Congress, it can try to round up allies and win next time. It should no longer be able to paralyze the Senate, the Congress or the federal government as a whole.

Abolish the federal debt ceiling completely.  The federal debt ceiling is another institution like the filibuster which has now been ruined by being abused by Southern conservatives. Now that the Southern right is trying to turn it into a recurrent tool of hostage-taking when it loses votes in Congress, the federal debt ceiling should be abolished. The federal government should be authorized to borrow any amount necessary to fund spending appropriated or authorized by Congress, if there is any shortfall in tax revenues.

Put all these policies and perhaps others together, and you have a National Majority Rule Project capable of thwarting the Southern Autonomy Project. The best defense is a good offense.

Does saying this make me, a white Southerner, a traitor to the South? Among the beneficiaries of a National Majority Rule Project, if it succeeded, would be middle- and low-income white Southerners, whose interests have never been identical with those of the local oligarchs. Particularly among the Scots-Irish of Appalachia and the Ozarks, there have always been many Southern white populists and radicals — from the West Virginian and Kentucky Unionists of the Civil War to New Deal liberals in Texas — who have understood the need to ally ourselves with non-Southerners in national politics to defeat the local Nabobs, Bourbons and Big Mules. The true Southern patriots are those of us who want to liberate the diverse population of the South from being exploited as wage earners and from being disfranchised or manipulated as voters. Another term for the National Majority Rule Project might be the Southern Liberation Movement.

Will the initiative remain with aggressive Southern reactionaries, as their fellow Americans try to appease them or react on a case-by-case basis against a feint here or a diversion there? Or will an aroused national majority, tired of being pushed around by a selfish Southern minority of the shrinking American white majority, finally fight back?

;

Liberals/Progressives need a plan? Are you serious? - I posted their plan above.(sm)

[ In Reply To ..]
your president's "fundamental changing of America". Read it. You might learn something.

We are living in a post-constitutional republic. - That is his fundamental changing, sadly..

[ In Reply To ..]
xxx

Similar Messages:


Couldn't Agree With Brooksie More---rememberJun 02, 2015
DAVID BROOKS: First, if the allegations about the contact with the boys are true, well, we have seen that with the Catholic Church. We have seen a disturbing undercurrent in American life, I guess, and maybe in world life, of this sort of thing. I am struck, as Mark just mentioned, the whole litany of people, especially of that era, who were involved in some scandal or another. Some of it was sexual. Some of it was more financial, even Tom DeLay’s, Speaker Wright. And it was just all concentra ...

A Comment I Totally Agree WithJul 01, 2010
Look at it this way...if Hoover dam were to rupture, then everything down river would flood. The homeowners begin to bail water and try to get life back to normal, but their houses keep filling up with water. They call their insurance companies to begin the rebuilding process, but that can't happen until the houses stop filling up with water. The Government sends in millions of dollars to help rebuild communities, but the rebuilding can't begin until the houses stop filling up with w ...

What's Your Opinion On This Article? Agree Or Not Agree With The Opinions Expressed?Dec 16, 2009
Am not sure what to make of this article? Link below!! Do all men think like that about the issue of circumcision? Do they regret having been circumcised? Reason I ask is I had my son circ'd and now this article kind of has me wondering if I did the right thing :( ...

Whether You Agree With Apr 07, 2017
Trump acted illegally!  What he did was the actions of a dictator.  He broke the constitution and attacked without congressional approval.  We live in a democracy and one of the rules on an attack like this is that it needs congressional approval. Do you not remember what Bush went through before we invaded Iraq?  It took a long time for him to get approval but he did.  Trump is a loose cannon and acted on his own and broke our laws of democracy. In the few post below, ...

How Do You Support Someone You Don't Agree With?Jan 09, 2010
My little sister got married young (18), even after we said she should probably wait... was only with the guy for like 8 months but he was joining the military and being deployed, so they got married.  Four years later, she has a gorgeous 16 month old, but apparently is no longer "in love" with hubby.  she says she has felt this way for 3 years.  to make a long story short, she basically doesn't want to stay in the marriage.  My parents who are very conservative tell h ...

Finally, Something They Agree On...well AtApr 09, 2011
Maybe there IS hope. ...

Never Thought I Would Agree With Jun 14, 2016
But I do, as does any sane person. These AR 15 rifles have to go. The fact you can get one with NO waiting period, as opposed to a handgun (why pray tell?) is just obscene. ...

Now Here's An Article I Think We Might All Agree OnJun 28, 2014
Written by a very wealthy "job creator" - he makes the case quite intelligibly for better conditions for the middle class.  Capitalism is not the problem. His message to his fellow zillionaires: "Dear 1%ers, many of our fellow citizens are starting to believe that capitalism itself is the problem. I disagree, and I’m sure you do too. Capitalism, when well managed, is the greatest social technology ever invented to create prosperity in human societies. But capitalism left unchecke ...

I Have To Agree With TrumpFeb 16, 2016
I think he is unstable. ...

Could Not Agree More...Trump, HisMay 18, 2017
Donald Trump exudes white privilege. Without it, he wouldn't be President of the United States. No black man in America could ever have said and done the things he has said and done (don't make me list them ) without an advanced degree or a single day of elected experience no less, and rise to the highest office in the land. Never! That's an exclusively white male opportunity. White privilege seeps out of the very pores of this administration. It's how Betsy DeVos could be ...

More And More I Agree...let 'em Bring OnJul 15, 2017
It will wake up the masses and then we will fight for our country.  You Republicans will strip every bit of life from enough people that the tables will turn, and they will take you down.  Glad it is well in advance of 2018 and 2020...get their true colors out there.     http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/calling-their-bluff-a-seattle-doctor-pegs-what-the-gop-health-bill-is-really-about/ ...

Is There Any Chance That We Can Kind Of AgreeJan 12, 2010
collectively to try to avoid the hit and run, nee ner nee ner neeeee ner (sorry, hope you get the point-that is not something I have ever even thought about trying to spell before now) type of comments that we are ALL guilty of and just calmly discuss our views on their merits?? No more of the "if so-and-so were a dem" or "if so-and-so were a Repub" and other silliness like this?  If it appears, can we all just ignore it?  Lets not add fuel to the real "trolls" out there from either si ...

I Actually Agree And Disagree With Both SidesJul 16, 2011
I do believe that we need to bring in more tax revenue.  I agree with the pres on that one.  However, I don't believe raising the taxes on the rich is the answer.  That alone still will not cover the amount of money we are spending.  I also think that the initial step in bringing in more tax revenue is to close loopholes in the tax code.  We are in major need of tax reform here.  What good is taxing the rich more when you have big companies like GE not paying A ...

Future Of The GOP: Big Changes Are Inevitable, But All Agree ItNov 05, 2012
The GOP would have walked away with this election if it hadn't alienated Hispanic and other minority voters. Minorities are key to the future of the GOP. Birth rates of hispanics alone are above the national average, but  per Pew Research, the GOP is 90% white. From the Associated Press, "...that's a problem for the GOP. Steep racial divisions this year that put overwhelming numbers of minority voters in President Barack Obama's camp mean the Republican Party must ...

I Agree With The Zimmerman Verdict, But (sm)Jul 15, 2013
all you people screaming "racist, racist", do you honestly believe that all 6 women picked for the jury were racists?   Really?  If so, it's no wonder this country is in the mess it's in. ...

ALL Women In Senate Agree - Go Get ThoseMay 06, 2014
From the man who GOT bin Laden!IF we have to spend resources, I'd MUCH rather see it for THIS reason than for NONEXISTANT WMDs...    ...

I Never Thought I Would Agree With Hillary, But I Do.Aug 13, 2014
with regard to Obama's handling of Syria. ...

Why Haven't We Heard From Liberals Who Agree (sm)May 01, 2013
with supplying morning after pills without a rx and without parent supervision?  Is this okay with you guys?  Do you have any daughters?  This reminds me of Nazi rule.  Killing babies from botched abortions and now since we don't want the kids punished with a baby, just let them take these drugs without parents knowledge.  A-OK.  This country is circling the drain.  I'm just kind of surprised.  You liberals are usually so vocal about your "causes ...

Obama Is A Very Sick Man. I Agree Wholeheartedly.Jul 19, 2014
or drugs. Link ...

M.D. Thinks Obama Is A Psychopath. I Agree, Mar 25, 2015
link ...

More Congressional Republicans Agree To Break Tax PledgeNov 27, 2012
Interview with Senator Jeff Sessions. Interesting.   http://video.foxnews.com/v/1989466433001/more-congressional-republicans-agree-to-break-tax-pledge ...

Turks Can Agree On One Thing: US Is Behind Failed Coup.Aug 03, 2016
official had helped orchestrate a violent conspiracy to topple the Turkish government from a fancy hotel on an island in the Sea of Marmara, near Istanbul. The same newspaper, in a front-page headline, flat-out said the United States had tried to assassinate President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on the night of the failed coup. When another pro-government newspaper asked Turks in a recent poll conducted on Twitter which part of the United States government had supported the coup plotters, the C.I.A. ...

A Little More PerspectiveNov 06, 2013
  The Health-Care Trilemma: How Obamacare is changing insurance premiums By Ezra Klein, Published: October 29 at 2:28 pmE-mail the writer The White House's biggest frustration right now is that Obamacare's technical failures are obscuring its great success: Premiums are much lower than the Congressional Budget Office estimated when the law first passed. In a new report for the liberal Center for American Progress, Topher Spiro and Jonathan Gruber qu ...

A Different Perspective On The Jul 19, 2014
My own grandmother came over from Poland at the age of 15 (in about 1915) with her 3 YOUNGER brothers. I wonder if she was a "legal" immigrant such as it was in those days. I wonder if she was subjected to such nastiness and hate as we are seeing now. My other branch of the family was from Ireland, fleeing the potato famine, and we know they were demonized. My Polish grandma cleaned houses, was a governess, and eventually ended up with her own family and a nice house. She was a registered Repu ...

Republicans Agree It's The Wrong Time For Immigration ReformApr 28, 2010
By Heather Monday Apr 26, 2010 5:00pm Mitch McConnell and Saxby Chambliss were both reading from the same script when asked about Arizona's new "show me your papers" immigration law. Mitch McConnell claimed he "hadn't studied it" and Saxby Chambliss called it a state's rights issue. Both of them claimed that the Congress just can't deal with immigration reform because there are too many other things they need to get done. Yeah, so few days, so many more bills and nominations ...

From Nasa.climate.gov: 1300 Independent Scientists From Around The Planet AgreeJan 12, 2013
A blanket around the Earth Share on tweetTweet 6 Most climate scientists agree the main cause of the current global warming trend is human expansion of the "greenhouse effect"1 -- warming that results when the atmosphere traps heat radiating from Earth toward space. Certain gases in the atmosphere block heat from escaping. Long-lived gases, remaining semi-permanently in the atmosphere, which do not respond physically or chemically to changes in temperature are describe ...

Some Canadian Perspective On HC-theirs AndMay 17, 2010
http://www.care2.com/causes/health-policy/blog/health-care-reform-on-the-road-conversations-in-canada/ ...

"I Agree - The Gosnell Trial Does Deserve More Coverage...as An Indictment Of The OutcomeApr 12, 2013
The Anti-Choice Monster Blog ››› April 12, 2013 1:28 PM EDT ››› ARI RABIN-HAVT Kermit Gosnell, currently on trial for murder, appears to be a monster. There are no adjectives strong enough to describe the horrors that a grand jury says took place at the Women's Medical Society. In recent weeks, anti-choice media figures have been agitating for more coverage of the Gosnell trial in the mainstre ...

Some Perspective,,,2008 Gas And Oil Prices Mar 13, 2012
Here is a link to how gas prices fluctuated during the last presidental election in 2008.  I am not drawing any conclusions and leave you to draw your own. http://www.treehugger.com/corporate-responsibility/2008-us-gas-price-year-in-review.html ...

Putting The 2nd Ammendment Into PerspectiveApr 23, 2013
. ...