A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

American Indians fight for land rights against Obama's executive


Posted: Dec 29, 2016

Betty Jones, an elderly Navajo medicine woman, grew up among the red rock canyons, mesas, and ancient cliff dwellings of Southeastern Utah. Now, a proposed national monument may prevent her from collecting traditional herbal medicines she’s gathered all her life. Her family believes Jones is in her mid-nineties, since her birth certificate was issued after her actual birth. The proposed 1.9-million-acre Bears Ears National Monument would potentially limit her access to sacred sites and impact herb collection. She also says that she is entitled to grazing rights on the land under an agreement with the federal government dating to the 1940s. “My late husband was promised access to the land for sheep grazing and it’s wrong for Washington to go back on its word,“ she says. Nearby, her daughter unrolled maps and opened old letters to prove the claim. The Bears Ears Inter-Tribal Coalition, a coalition of five tribal councils, with support from environmentalists, is pushing for the creation of the Bears Ears National Monument. Following a field hearing in Utah, Secretary of the Interior Sally Jules said she was “shocked” the area was not better protected. As a result, the Obama administration seems poised to create the new monument by proclamation — a power granted to the president under the 1906 Antiquities Act. The proposal takes its name for two 9,000 foot buttes that, from a distance, resemble bear ears. San Juan County is the largest county in Utah and also its poorest. The largest city in the county is Blanding, a town of 3,500 people. Locals feel it is outsiders who are pushing the monument proposal. Local Navajos disagree with the Navajo Nation, opposing the plan. Navajos who live in the area fear they will lose access to land that they have used for centuries for religious ceremonies, grazing, hunting, and wood-collecting. Members of the local Ute tribe share these concerns. Other opposition comes from civic groups and residents who worry about their own lost access and its economic impact. “This community would support a smaller monument,” says Jami Bayless, president of the Stewards of San Juan County. “However, the proposed monument is bigger than the State of Delaware. Any visitor here can see that this a beautiful area that is already protected by numerous laws and by locals who love this area.” Bayless’s Non-governmental Organization (NGO) was formed last month to ensure local residents had a say in public policy about the area. The Day The Feds Killed The Sheep Over eight decades later, Jones still remembers the day the federal government killed the sheep. In 1934, as part of former President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s New Deal, the government decided the Navajo had more livestock than the Southwest could support. According to some estimates, 80 percent of all Navajo livestock were killed, and thousands of Navajos impoverished. In traditional Navajo culture, sheep are virtually sacred, and both men and women maintain flocks. Throughout her life, Jones and her family have struggled to maintain their livestock. She believes the monument would be another blow to the Navajo way of life. “My husband and I would graze our flocks in the land that is now Bears Ears,” she says. Jones speaks only Navajo, and her objection to the monument proposal was translated by her daughter, Anna Tom, whose home Jones is visiting. The home is a three-room dwelling on the edge of the Navajo Nation in southern Utah. Only a few other Navajo homes are visible in the area, which is dotted with thorny bushes and dry gullies where water once flowed. A generator provides intermittent electricity. Like many on the reservation, she does not have access to running water. As Jones spoke, her relatives worked a dozen yards away to finish the roof of a Navajo hogan, or ceremonial lodge, ahead of a forecasted storm. In preparation for the storm, a small pile of wood is stacked next to a heating stove. A cardboard scrap will serve as kindling. The Bears Ears issue has divided the Navajo people, who refer to themselves as the Diné. The government of the Navajo Nation supports the monument. The Aneth Chapter and the Blue Mountain Diné, the two Navajo groups who live closest to the proposed Bears Ears Monument, both oppose it. The latter is also not an officially recognized entity within the Navajo Nation. “At one level, this is a struggle between the state of Utah and the federal government,” says Matt Anderson, an analyst at the Sutherland Institute. “That tension is paralleled among the Navajo. While the Navajo Nation supports the monument, the local Navajo oppose it.” Anderson believes the proposal is being pushed by outside interests, including outdoor recreation retailers. “The interest of retailers –who make stuff in China– are being privileged at the expense of local jobs and potential energy jobs.” The pro-monument coalition includes some tribal government groups, green advocacy groups and outdoor retailers, like Patagonia and Black Diamond Equipment. An investigation by Deseret News found that much of the funding of the monument campaign came from out-of-state, including a portion from the Leonardio Di Caprio Foundation. Peter Metcalf, the founder of Black Diamond Equipment, is a vocal supporter of the Bears Ears National Monument Proposal. “Utah is a Mecca for building strong, vibrant outdoor companies,” he wrote in a statement posted on Patagonia’s website. “Our politicians really don’t recognize that these iconic wildlands are not just about biodiversity or watersheds, but they are the backbone of one of the fastest growing economic sectors in the state.” Wood Cutter Worries Byron Clarke, the vice president of the Blue Mountain Diné, guides his pick-up truck up a dirt road into the high country around Blanding, Utah on a chilly evening in late November. Snow was visible on the slopes above. Two Christmas red permits, which give him the right to collect wood, were displayed on his dashboard. The bullet holes in a mile marker were the only visible sign of human impact in the woods along the road. Byron’s eyes scanned the alpine woods for deadwood he is allowed to collect. Finding some, he quickly got to work with his chainsaw. Local Navajo have hunted, collected firewood and gathered pinion nuts here for centuries — all activities that will be restricted or prohibited if the area becomes a national monument. A large sign at the nearby Arches National Monument makes it clear that wood collecting is prohibited there. “I take wood down to the reservation every winter,” Clarke says. “There are a lot of poor and elderly Navajo who can’t come down here and collect wood. Some of those elders depend on this wood to get through the winter.” On the Navajo Nation, the official poverty rate stands at 43 percent. While the monument agreement may include provisions to allow grazing and wood-collecting, for most locals its déjà vu. In 1996, former President Bill Clinton created the Grand Escalante Staircase National Monument, resulting in limited access to wood-collecting and grazing. An Area Already Rich In Monuments San Juan County already contains three national monuments, a national park, and a national recreation area. Locals worry that creation of a new national monument will have a devastating impact on the local school system. The state of Utah includes a patchwork of school trust lands held by the state to fund education. “The proposed Bears Ears Monument will mean the loss of 167,000 acres of school trust lands that, if we lose access to that, we will lose access to funding for our schools,” said Merri Shumway, vice president of the local school board. “If the quality of education suffers, we lose the best hope to improve the economy. There is also the indirect impact of the lost jobs. The government is the largest employer in the county.” The largest private employer in the county is Energy Fuels Resources. The company runs a uranium mill just south of Blanding and has mining claims within the area of the proposed monument. As recently as three years ago, the facility processed ore from an active mine on land that lies within the borders of the proposed monument. Then, uranium prices collapsed. Today, the market price for uranium is $18.50 a pound — roughly half of what it was a year ago. The Sierra Club has targeted the mine as one of the reasons it supports the Bears Ears National Monument proposal. Back on the Navajo Nation, Jones has her own ideas about how the land will be used if no monument is declared. “The land is precious. We have to take care of it, and Mother Earth. What I want to do is use the land the way that we have always used the land, and hopefully one day my grandchildren will as well.” Outside, her grandchildren brought a flock of sheep to a pen. The sheep huddled together, knowing the snowstorm was approaching, and their canine guardians plopped down nearby with tongues extended in exhaustion.;

Obama's scorched earth policy. Now he's ticked off - WWII vets, Israelis, Russians, now

[ In Reply To ..]
Indians...

Obama's paybacks show what this egotistical punk - is about. He only cares about himself.

[ In Reply To ..]
Go back to Kenya and take your dude wife with you!

Obviously Obama's loyalty is not to America.

Well that was certainly a racist remark. - nm

[ In Reply To ..]

You guys try to hide it, but it always comes popping out when you least expect it. We dems, however, always expect it to come popping out of the Repubs. It's hard-wired in them.

You want scorched earth? Look no further - than Trumps nuclear trigger finger.

[ In Reply To ..]



CCCCCC

1.6 million acres under stricker federal control! The National - Monuments Law was abused by Bill

[ In Reply To ..]
Clinton and now Obama. It was never meant to lock up vast tracts of millions of acres. It was supposed to be for very focused, very limited actions. Clinton locked up huge portions of Utah, too.

Clinton also sold land to the Chinese. Image if and - when they come to collect!

[ In Reply To ..]
x

National monuments - old and burned out

[ In Reply To ..]
The lands were designated national monuments to protect them from development. I think if Obama saved a kitten from drowning you would say he did it because he wanted to start a fur coat.

What BS! Most native Americans affected have been. sm - Navajo

[ In Reply To ..]
in favor of this for a very long time! This is the same land where white supremacist Bundy held his standoff.

No they haven't. Just one tribe is. It's still under - federal control.

[ In Reply To ..]
x

Not true. The land is now protected from development - in perpetuity, a good thing. nm

[ In Reply To ..]
.

It's a government land grab. - Period.

[ In Reply To ..]
Obama wants to feel like a man.

Sorry, Barry, it won't work.

Similar Messages:


Another Executive Order And More Control By Obama (s/l)Sep 09, 2012
link ...

It Is About Time--Obama Executive ACTIONSDec 31, 2015
Not enough, not soon enough, but a step in the right direction. If only he would "come for their guns." Alas--too busy sending federal aide for flood disasters. http://www.politico.com/story/2015/12/obama-guns-gun-control-217234 ...

President Obama's Executive ActionJan 05, 2016
Makes Absolute Perfect Sense.  ...

President Obama's Latest Executive Order . Jul 21, 2013
How could he sign another executive order while the both the House and Senate were in session?  The order was signed on July 15 and according to the schedule, both congresses were in session.   Section 1. Policy. Addressing the domestic HIV epidemic is a priority of my Administration. In 2010, the White House released the first comprehensive National HIV/AIDS Strategy (Strategy), setting quantitative goals for reducing new HIV infections, improving health outcomes for people living w ...

President Obama To Issue Executive OrderDec 01, 2014
President Obama wants transparency to ensure no military culture in community law enforcement, at least as far as military equipment.   Glad this is being addressed. ...

Obama Will Ask Trump To Keep Executive Orders In Place.Nov 10, 2016
dangerous and unfit to lead the nation, but he’ll ask the Republican president-elect Thursday not to wipe out his cherished, legacy-making executive actions on everything from the Iranian nuclear deal to Obamacare. In a meeting at the White House to prepare Mr. Trump for taking office, Mr. Obama will try to persuade the president-elect to honor what his aides call a “tradition” of preserving executive actions implemented by the departing chief executive. ...

Didn't He Criticize Obama For The Executive Orders?Apr 26, 2017
This one really is terrible.  Bye bye national parks.  Is this all just a game to him? ...

Goldman Sachs Executive Named To KEY Obama GovtApr 27, 2010
Wonder why the media doesn't want to bring this up...... Obama now has SEVERAL former high Goldman Sachs executives in his administration.... hmmmm?? http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2009/10/16/goldman ...

Court: Obama's 'Executive Action On Immigration Is Unconstitutional'Jan 20, 2015
Link:  http://cnsnews.com/news/article/terence-p-jeffrey/court-obamas-executive-action-immigration-unconstitutional ...

Outgoing DCCC Executive Director Moves To Obama's Jan 01, 2017
After two election cycles as the executive director of the House Democrats’ campaign arm, Kelly Ward has a new challenge: helping to lead a coordinated Democratic redistricting effort ahead of new map drawings following the 2020 census. Ward will be the interim executive director of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, a group led by President Barack Obama and former Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. A native of Las Vegas, Ward largely earned her chops in Arizona politics ...

King Obama Stepping Up The Pace Of His Executive Actions. (sm)Apr 22, 2015
I wonder if he prefers the term (Dic)Tator or King.   Link ...

Special Ops To Obama: Let Us Fight ISIS Already. May 24, 2015
forefront of the battle against ISIS. But U.S. special operators say the Obama administration’s restrictive rules of war are harming their mission. TAMPA, Florida — Fighting simmering frustration in their ranks over ISIS advances in Iraq and Syria, top U.S. special operations commanders say they are building forces for a multi-generational fight—not a war that will be won in the next few years. “We recognize this is a longterm prospect,” said Gen. Joseph Votel, the overall lead ...

Obama Seizes N.M. Land For National Monument In Bundy-like ShowdownMay 21, 2014
Yes, a national park sounds nice, but... "President Obama on Wednesday will declare a national monument in southern New Mexico, delivering a win for environmentalists but angering ranchers and local law enforcement, who say the land restrictions will end up creating a safe haven for drug cartels to operate within the U.S." Link: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/may/19/obama-designate-national-monument-new-mexico/ ...

Obama's Executive Amnesty Specifically Violates Clause Of ConstitutionJan 03, 2015
U.S. District Judge Andrew S. Hanen of the Southern District of Texas has scheduled a hearing for Jan. 9 on the request for an injunction filed by 24 states against President Obama’s immigration amnesty plan.  In a nationally televised speech on Nov. 20, Obama announced (and began implementing) the executive actions. The original lawsuit wasfiled on Dec. 3, and the states requested an injunction hearing by Dec. 31 “or as soon as practicable thereafter.&rdquo ...

Tax Fight Puts Schumer At Odds With ObamaDec 12, 2010
Tax fight puts Schumer at odds with Obama By Shailagh Murray Washington Post Staff Writer Friday, December 10, 2010; 12:00 AM President Obama is getting along better than ever with Capitol Hill Republicans. But his relationship with Democratic Sen. Charles E. Schumer has hit a rough patch. The newly appointed Senate Democratic "message" guru has emerged as the White House's chief antagonist over the tax cut deal Obama worked out with GOP leaders. To Schumer (N.Y.), Obama's deci ...

Obama Assembles Non-coalition To Fight Not-war Against ISISSep 12, 2014
(Don't let the initial picture scare you away. It's not one of his best.) ...

Obama's Bad Relationship With Military Is Hurting Fight Against ISIS.Nov 19, 2015
commanders. Our men and women in uniform are being humiliated, but the Pentagon brass sits mute. The administration's inability to “degrade and destroy ISIS,” or even to “contain” the terror plague, as President Obama so inappropriately claimed just last Friday, is an embarrassment. While inept guidance from Obama and his shrinking circle of confidants has caused headline-worthy failures in Syria, pushback from military commanders has been silenced by a distrustful White House th ...

Obama Asserts Fast And Furious Executive Privilege Claim For Holder’s WifeOct 23, 2014
. ...

Obama Faces Potential Rifts With Democrats In Mounting Immigration FightAug 17, 2014
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Barack Obama is facing potential rifts with members of his own party in tough re-election contests as he barrels toward a fall fight with Republicans over his ability to change immigration policies. If Obama takes the broadest action under consideration — removing the threat of deportation for millions of people in this country illegally — the short-term risks appear greatest for Senate Democrats in conservative-leaning states. Weeks before the Nove ...

Obama Lectures Kenyan President On Gay RightsJul 25, 2015
Kenyan President Uhuru Kenyatta about his country's gay rights record. "When you start treating people differently not because of any harm they are doing to anybody, but because they are different, that's the path whereby freedoms begin to erode," Obama said at a joint press conference with the Kenyan leader in Nairobi. "And bad things happen." Under Kenyan law, sexual activity between men is illegal and punishable with a maximum imprisonment of 14 years. Obama equated lega ...

Obama For Women's Rights! See Differences In Health Issues... (sm)Nov 01, 2012
OBAMA signed the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act to help women fight back against pay discrimination. He understands that when women are paid less than men for the same work, it hurts the entire family. ROMNEY refused to say whether or not he would have signed the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act into law, and Paul RYAN voted against it. OBAMA believes a woman’s health care choices are personal decisions, best made with her doctor—without interference from politicians. ROMNEY believ ...

Stonewall? Explaining Obama's Historic Gay-Rights Reference. (It Was IllegalJan 23, 2013
Okay, I was 17 when this happened, working the graveyard shift as a waitress in Harrah's Casino. My roommate and I didn't have a TV and her soon-to-be-ex-fiance was still proving, to himself at least, that he wasn't gay by bashing homosexuals every 20 minutes or so. So when President Obama mentioned this all I remembered, vaguely, was him ranting incessantly about this protest, without knowing a single thing about it. From NPR, and the link's to a really interesting story. " ...

Obama Calls Senate Rejection Of His Civil Rights Nominee 'a Travesty'Mar 05, 2014
This is proof that both sides can work together. The bad news is that B.O. is going to need those big boy pants PDQ. ...

Obama Directs HHS To Establish Rules Ensuring Hospital Visitation Rights For Gay, Lesbian CouplesApr 15, 2010
President Obama has signed a memorandum directing the Department of Health and Human Services to establish rules that would bar hospitals from denying visitation rights to partners of gay and lesbian patients. Many hospitals currently restrict hospital visitation to a patient's family members by blood or marriage. Because gay marriage is not legal in most states, partners are often unable to visit their loved ones--even in emergency situations. Any hospital that receives federal Medicare ...

President Obama's Mother Was An American And So Apr 07, 2011
President Obama was clearly born in Hawaii or else 2 hospitals and the Health Department were in some kind of conspiracy when he was a baby. Did they know that one day he would be president? His mother was an American and that makes him an American no matter where he was born, even though Hawaii was in America at the time he was born there. ...

Obama Says American Public Was Not Misled On HealthcareNov 17, 2014
President Obama dismissed the outrage over a consultant's remarks that the Affordable Care Act was passed using a "lack of transparency" that was benefited by "the stupidity of the American voter."  At a news conference on Sunday in Brisbane, Australia, Obama was asked by Fox News correspondent Ed Henry whether he misled the American public about aspects of the Affordable Care Act in order to get it passed.  “No. I did not," Obama responded, adding, "The fac ...

Under Obama, American's Way Of Life Continues To DeclineMar 11, 2015
Everything is worse.     ...

American Lung Association Applauds Obama Administration's Sep 20, 2013
WASHINGTON, D.C. (September 20, 2013)— Harold P. Wimmer National President and CEO of the American Lung Association who attended the speech by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Administrator Gina McCarthy at the National Press Club issued the following statement: “I was pleased to join Administrator Gina McCarthy today as she discussed the urgent need to address the health impacts of our changing climate. The American Lung Association is heartened to ...

Obama Equates American And Cuban Revolutions, ConfusingMar 30, 2016
Right before his first tango in Buenos Aires, President Obama addressed the Cuban people (and the world) in an instantly famous speech from Havana’s Grand Theater. Among the highlights: “Here’s my message to the Cuban government and the Cuban people: The ideals that are the starting point for every revolution, America’s revolution, Cuba’s revolution, the liberation movements around the world, these ideals find their truest expression, I believe, in democracy.” (U.S. President O ...

Obama On ISIS: "I'm Not Interested In American Leadership Or Nov 16, 2015
During a press conference detailing his administration’s strategy to destroy ISIS following several devastating terrorist attacks in Paris, President Barack Obama said he’s not interested in “pursuing some notion of American leadership or America winning." Obama’s remarks came several days after ISIS attacks in Paris that killed over 120 people and injured scores of others. Friday night’s attacks on France are believed to be the deadliest terrorist attacks in the country’s history ...