A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Age of America Nears End


Posted: Apr 26, 2011

This column has been updated to include a reaction from the IMF.

The International Monetary Fund has just dropped a bombshell, and nobody noticed.

For the first time, the international organization has set a date for the moment when the "Age of America" will end and the U.S. economy will be overtaken by that of China.

And it's a lot closer than you may think.

According to the latest IMF official forecasts, China's economy will surpass that of America in real terms in 2016 — just five years from now.

Put that in your calendar.

It provides a painful context for the budget wrangling taking place in Washington right now. It raises enormous questions about what the international security system is going to look like in just a handful of years. And it casts a deepening cloud over both the U.S. dollar and the giant Treasury market, which have been propped up for decades by their privileged status as the liabilities of the world's hegemonic power.

According to the IMF forecast, which was quietly posted on the Fund's website just two weeks ago, whoever is elected U.S. president next year — Obama? Mitt Romney? Donald Trump? — will be the last to preside over the world's largest economy.

Most people aren't prepared for this. They aren't even aware it's that close. Listen to experts of various stripes, and they will tell you this moment is decades away. The most bearish will put the figure in the mid-2020s.

But they're miscounting. They're only comparing the gross domestic products of the two countries using current exchange rates.

That's a largely meaningless comparison in real terms. Exchange rates change quickly. And China's exchange rates are phony. China artificially undervalues its currency, the renminbi, through massive intervention in the markets.

The Comparison That Really Matters

In addition to comparing the two countries based on exchange rates, the IMF analysis also looked to the true, real-terms picture of the economies using "purchasing power parities." That compares what people earn and spend in real terms in their domestic economies.

Under PPP, the Chinese economy will expand from $11.2 trillion this year to $19 trillion in 2016. Meanwhile the size of the U.S. economy will rise from $15.2 trillion to $18.8 trillion. That would take America's share of the world output down to 17.7%, the lowest in modern times. China's would reach 18%, and rising.

Just 10 years ago, the U.S. economy was three times the size of China's.

Naturally, all forecasts are fallible. Time and chance happen to them all. The actual date when China surpasses the U.S. might come even earlier than the IMF predicts, or somewhat later. If the great Chinese juggernaut blows a tire, as a growing number fear it might, it could even delay things by several years. But the outcome is scarcely in doubt.

This is more than a statistical story. It is the end of the Age of America. As a bond strategist in Europe told me two weeks ago, "We are witnessing the end of America's economic hegemony."

We have lived in a world dominated by the U.S. for so long that there is no longer anyone alive who remembers anything else. America overtook Great Britain as the world's leading economic power in the 1890s and never looked back.

And both those countries live under very similar rules of constitutional government, respect for civil liberties and the rights of property. China has none of those. The Age of China will feel very different.

Victor Cha, senior adviser on Asian affairs at Washington's Center for Strategic and International Studies, told me China's neighbors in Asia are already waking up to the dangers. "The region is overwhelmingly looking to the U.S. in a way that it hasn't done in the past," he said. "They see the U.S. as a counterweight to China. They also see American hegemony over the last half-century as fairly benign. In China they see the rise of an economic power that is not benevolent, that can be predatory. They don't see it as a benign hegemony."

The rise of China, and the relative decline of America, is the biggest story of our time. You can see its implications everywhere, from shuttered factories in the Midwest to soaring costs of oil and other commodities. Last fall, when I attended a conference in London about agricultural investment, I was struck by the number of people there who told stories about Chinese interests snapping up farmland and foodstuff supplies — from South America to China and elsewhere.

This is the result of decades during which China has successfully pursued economic policies aimed at national expansion and power, while the U.S. has embraced either free trade or, for want of a better term, economic appeasement.

"There are two systems in collision," said Ralph Gomory, research professor at NYU's Stern business school. "They have a state-guided form of capitalism, and we have a much freer former of capitalism." What we have seen, he said, is "a massive shift in capability from the U.S. to China. What we have done is traded jobs for profit. The jobs have moved to China. The capability erodes in the U.S. and grows in China. That's very destructive. That is a big reason why the U.S. is becoming more and more polarized between a small, very rich class and an eroding middle class. The people who get the profits are very different from the people who lost the wages."

The next chapter of the story is just beginning.

U.S. Spending Spree Won't Work

What the rise of China means for defense, and international affairs, has barely been touched on. The U.S. is now spending gigantic sums — from a beleaguered economy — to try to maintain its place in the sun.

It's a lesson we could learn more cheaply from the sad story of the British, Spanish and other empires. It doesn't work. You can't stay on top if your economy doesn't.

Equally to the point, here is what this means economically, and for investors.

Some years ago I was having lunch with the smartest investor I know, London-based hedge-fund manager Crispin Odey. He made the argument that markets are reasonably efficient, most of the time, at setting prices. Where they are most likely to fail, though, is in correctly anticipating and pricing big, revolutionary, "paradigm" shifts — whether a rise of disruptive technologies or revolutionary changes in geopolitics. We are living through one now.

The U.S. Treasury market continues to operate on the assumption that it will always remain the global benchmark of money. Business schools still teach students, for example, that the interest rate on the 10-year Treasury bond is the "risk-free rate" on money. And so it has been for more than a century. But that's all based on the Age of America.

No wonder so many have been buying gold. If the U.S. dollar ceases to be the world's sole reserve currency, what will be? The euro would be fine if it acts like the old deutschemark. If it's just the Greek drachma in drag ... not so much.

The last time the world's dominant hegemon lost its ability to run things singlehandedly was early in the past century. That's when the U.S. and Germany surpassed Great Britain. It didn't turn out well.

Updated With IMF Reaction

The International Monetary Fund has responded to my article.

In a statement sent to MarketWatch, the IMF confirmed the report, but challenged my interpretation of the data. Comparing the U.S. and Chinese economies using "purchase-power-parity," it argued, "is not the most appropriate measure because PPP price levels are influenced by nontraded services, which are more relevant domestically than globally."

The IMF added that it prefers to compare economies using market exchange rates, and that under this comparison the U.S. "is currently 130% bigger than China, and will still be 70% larger by 2016."

My take?

The IMF is entitled to make its case. But its argument raises more questions than it answers.

First, no one measure is perfect. Everybody knows that.

But that's also true of the GDP figures themselves. Hurricane Katrina, for example, added to the U.S. GDP, because it stimulated a lot of economic activity — like providing emergency relief, and rebuilding homes. Is there anyone who seriously thinks Katrina was a net positive for the United States? All statistics need caveats.

Second, comparing economies using simple exchange rates, as the IMF suggests, raises huge problems.

Currency markets fluctuate. They represent international money flows, not real output.

The U.S. dollar has fallen nearly 10% against the euro so far this year. Does anyone suggest that the real size of the U.S. economy has shrunk by 10% in comparison with Europe over that period? The idea is absurd.

China actively suppresses the renminbi on the currency markets through massive dollar purchases. As a result the renminbi is deeply undervalued on the foreign-exchange markets. Just comparing the economies on their exchange rates misses that altogether.

Purchasing power parity is not a perfect measure. None exists. But it measures the output of economies in terms of real goods and services, not just paper money. That's why it's widely used to compare economies. The IMF publishes PPP data. So does the OECD. Many economists rely on them.

;

And China will beat us down without ever firing - a shot. nm

[ In Reply To ..]

Similar Messages:


Only In America May 17, 2012
Saw this posted on a political board - sorry, can't remember where:   1) Only in America could politicians talk about the greed of the rich at a $35,000 a plate campaign fund raising event.2) Only in America could people claim that the government still discriminates against black Americans when we have a black President, a black Attorney General, and roughly 18% of the federal workforce is black. 12% of the population is black.3) Only in America could we have had the two people most ...

In America! How Did We Let It Come To This?Nov 24, 2012
My brief, backbreaking, rage-inducing, low-paying, dildo-packing time inside the online-shipping machine. A journalist reports what it's like on the job in a warehouse filling on-line orders; 31 years old and she hurts bad after 2 mandatory-overtime days, link to a very interesting and eye-opening article at bottom.   "I'm assigned a schedule of Sunday through Thursday, 7 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. When additional overtime is necessary, which it will be soon (Christmas!), I shoul ...

We Have A New Ms America And She Is Sep 15, 2013
of India descent. ...

Is This What We Want For America?Nov 18, 2016
A translator at refugee camps in Germany has claimed Muslim migrants hate Christians and want to Islamize the country. The woman, 39, from Eritrea, came to Germany as a refugee herself in 1991, before volunteering at asylum centers to “give something back.” But the Arabic speaker said what she discovered when working with migrants over the last five years shocked her. During her time at a number of centers across the country, she said she discovered Muslim refugees preaching “pure ...

Only In AmericaOct 26, 2015
This is an attempt to trump Trump.  Trump and others have accused him of being too calm and too soft-spoken, so he is trying to prove and remind people that he has had a temper in the past --- perhaps before anti-anxiolytics?   Please, people, you must go with Rubio.  Will the Republican party wake up and realize the joke is on them soon enough.  The pathology of the Trump and Carson phenom must be revealed. ...

Let Us Take Back AmericaDec 18, 2009
"All I ask is that you consider the suggestion here.   The entire Congress of the United States is corrupt. And I mean both Houses and I mean both major parties..   I realize that a few Members of each House are trustworthy, but, as a group they are absolutely the most corrupt bunch to ever disgrace our Nation.   In November of 2010 the entire House of Representatives will stand for re-election; all 435 of them. One third of the Senate, a total of 33 of them, will also stand ...

Air America Is Shutting Down...Jan 21, 2010
It's been a good week.   http://www.cbsnews.com/blogs/2010/01/21/politics/politicalhotsheet/entry6126410.shtml ...

Wake Up AmericaMar 24, 2010
“The danger to America is not Barack Obama but a citizenrycapable of entrusting a man like him with the presidency.It will be easier to limit and undo the follies of an Obamapresidency than to restore the necessary common senseand good judgment to a depraved electorate willing to havesuch a man for their president. The problem is much deeperand far more serious than Mr. Obama, who is a mere symptomof what ails us. Blaming the prince of the fools should notblind anyone to the vast confedera ...

PBS - God In America SeriesOct 12, 2010
http://video.pbs.org/video/1610726967   A documentary of 400 years of religion and political history of the the United States.  First episode very interesting.  You could make many comparisons between the Irish Catholic experience and the current Muslim experience.  ...

Decency In AmericaSep 24, 2010
After reading the problems with neighbors on here I'd like to input one of my pet peeves.  Men or women who cuss in public loud enough for everyone to hear.  I was at the mall and this guy was on the cell phone Fing this and Fing that.  I gave him "the look" and he just got louder.  What ever happened to common curtousy.  Like saying excuse me in the  store when you walk in front of someone?  Like the teenagers who throw stuff out of the car and the people ...

America's Got TalentAug 11, 2010
Did you see the little girl from Pittsburgh last night?  It actually almost freaked me out, hearing an adult voice coming out of a child.  I expected her to be an excellent singer, but I did not expect her to sound like a 30-year-old!  Then, of course, there was the dental floss and Howie Mandell thing . . . . ...

Can America Survive?Jul 27, 2010
Hello to all you great MTs: I am trying to get my hands on the book, "Can America Survive?" It is by John Hagee, yes he is a minister, doctor, author, even termed..great visioner..or whatever. I have read and heard some parts of the book and let me tell you, it is sound, truly believable, and well, scary. It put me in the "know" about what is going on in our world today. I have to admit, I am mad, but I have come to the conclusion that I must not get this way. Who wants to feel this way after r ...

Obesity In AmericaJun 12, 2012
People wonder sometimes why some peole are obese.  One reason is because the food that we can afford is doing it, like potatoes, pasta, and rice.  All of which are cheaper and great fillers.  Not necessarily overeating sugar is doing it.  What do you think? ...

Obama's America Is Quite A Hit - Considering (sm)Aug 25, 2012
many people are having to travel quite a distance to find a theater where it's playing or just can't because of distance.  I know a girl near the border in Massachusetts, and she cannot find it anywhere.  It was #1 in box office on Friday. Posted a link ...

Good Bye America. - (sm)Nov 07, 2012
Never thought I'd live to see the day that the majority of citizens think the American dream is take from those who worked their butts off.  Never thought I'd see a time where laziness and scamming the system were the new moral code, and seeing how much you can get for doing nothing was the hardest work some people will ever do. This marks the beginning of the end of the good ole USA ...

America Is Headed For ThisNov 29, 2012
Report: Nearly Two Thirds of UK Millionaires Fled Country After Tax Hike According to the Telegraph, âin the 2009-10 tax year, more than 16,000 people declared an annual income of more than £1 million.â After Gordon Brown introduced 50% tax rate before the last general election, that number dropped to a mere 6,000. In addition, the tax increase actually âcost the UK £7 billion in lost tax revenueâ as wealthy Britons moved their wealth abroad. Foreign entities even engage ...

Wake Up, America!Aug 10, 2016
Dr. John Coleman's talk on the Committee of 300. Did you know that every U.S. Secretary of State since 1919 has been appointed out of London?  (Royal Institute for International Affairs) Dr. Coleman reveals this and other facts. A lot of good info is also in the Ring of Power video in the "GOOD STUFF" post below.   ...

America Is Great BecauseAug 03, 2016
If you watch this video of a Muslim-American (comedian) saying goodbye to America at the RNC (because of Trump's purported measures to ban Muslims and make a Muslim registry) you will see that the people he meets there are so nice and loving. I am just amazed that they go for Trump, who is certainly not a good person at all. I just think this video represents the repeated claim that there are not as many differences in people as there are similarities, that Americans on the whole ARE good ...

STEALING AMERICAJul 07, 2016
Please wake up, people. ...

The Illegals May Sue America!Jul 11, 2014
Illegal immigrants pouring across the border could trigger a wave of lawsuits flooding the U.S. court system for years and costing taxpayers millions, according to legal experts. ...

How To Renounce America And Still Be Jul 17, 2014
This story is about a gilded class of people and corporations enriched by the new American economy while the rest of its citizens pay the tab. The protagonists could be any number of institutional elites, but this column happens to be about a Democratic senator from West Virginia, Joe Manchin, and his daughter, Heather Bresch, the chief executive of Mylan, a giant maker of generic drugs based outside Pittsburgh. Her company's profits come largely from Medicaid and Medicare, which means ...

Invasion Of AmericaJul 28, 2014
. ...

Al Jazeera AmericaAug 30, 2014
Is reporting that the Saudi king is warning ALL western leaders regarding attacks by IS within one month in Europe and within another month in the US. ...

America On EdgeSep 09, 2014
And everyone accuses Fox News of sensationalism...   (Post edited from original content.) ...

Pray For AmericaOct 12, 2014
i'd say we had better pray for our country. Not only are we faced with ISIL, but with Ebola and the awful mess with kids getting that virus. What next will happen. Scare me a whole lot. Seems no one is really trying to protect any citizen in this country. There is no excuse Mr. O or anyone else can give, i.e. the CDC director or anyone trying to calm our fears. I'd say this is all beyond their control and they have no clue as to what to do other than what they have done i ...

Hillary's AmericaOct 15, 2016
I just got done watching the movie, "Hillary's America," which just was released on DVD, Blu-ray and available for download/rental through Vudu. Talk about a history lesson and what the Dems REALLY represent!!! it was truly an eye opening movie and showed how much of our history is really "skewed." ...

What Is Happening To America?Apr 04, 2017
Donald Trump gives cold shoulder to our long time allies but praises dictators. ...

More From Trump's AmericaMay 23, 2017
  http://www.rawstory.com/2017/05/watch-walmart-shopper-goes-on-crazed-racist-rant-after-latina-woman-politely-asks-her-to-move-cart/     http://fortune.com/2017/05/23/walmart-customer-slur-woman-assistant-manager/   "We have no tolerance for the language or actions of this customer and are proud that our assistant manager responded appropriately by asking her to leave the store," Walmart said in a statement."      But, yet, she was allowed to stay. &n ...

Half Of America In Poverty?Jan 02, 2012
Recent reports suggest that almost 50% of Americans are in poverty or at a "low income" level. The claim is based on a new supplemental measure by the Census Bureau that includes health care, transportation, and other essential living expenses in the poverty calculation.The concept of "low income" is controversial. It has been defined as earnings between 100 and 199 percent of the poverty level, a claim which, if true, would place every American family making $50,000 or less at a near-poverty le ...

One Reason America Is So Special.Oct 13, 2009
The US is special because a decendant of a slave or a poor immigrant can make it into the White House. My own family, decendants of poor Italian immigrants, has its share of successes (although no one in the White House). Very interesting story about Michelle Obama's ancentry. ...