A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

Nonprofit hospital systems belie their title, make


Posted: Aug 11, 2013

This article is from CBS News, one of many on the subject around the country. An earlier post by one of our members indicates the right wing is attempting to save the corruption of our once-great nonprofit system from Obamacare reform. I thought it might be helpful to realize what's been happening.

One of my accounts (I AM an MT/ME)  is officially a nonprofit that, while raking in big profits by providing luxury services to wealthy, and/or just well-insured patients  - and very few others - is also supported by our tax dollars for their "charitable" "nonprofit" mission.

Many famous names show up here, but googling its own name brings up horror stories by ordinary people who cluelessly ended up there, often going there as the nearest ER, then getting the megabills this nonprofit charges everyone. By law it has to treat uninsured or underinsured people who are brought there, but few are, and those who are well enough to be transferred out, to another hospital that will accept them, are. The doctors are "soooo nice," though, as described by well-heeled patients.

I'm also posting separately a NY Times article on luxury hospitals evil ol' Obamacare plans to remove from the public dole AND stop their part in driving up the price of healthcare. 

(CBS News) The University of Pittsburgh Medical Center -- named one of the ten best hospitals in the nation by U.S. News -- cares for the sick and saves lives.

As a nonprofit organization, it also receives a tax break. But in recent months there have been questions raised as to whether the hospital acts more like a corporation, reaping big profits and driving up health care costs.

According to an audited financial statement, UPMC made $948 million in profits from 2011-2012. And while tax returns show it spends just two percent of its yearly budget on charity care, the hospital receives a state and federal tax break of about $200 million, according to city estimates. Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl is suing to revoke its nonprofit status. His city stands to gain $20 million a year.

"I think they're going to be hard pressed to prove how they're operating the same way as the Little Sisters of the Poor or the Catholic Church, true genuine nonprofits. UPMC? I'm afraid not," Ravenstahl told "CBS This Morning."

The mayor said he was also surprised to learn that UPMC's CEO, Jeffrey Romoff, makes almost $6 million a year. That makes him the highest paid CEO of any large nonprofit hospital in the U.S., according to a recent analysis by TIME. Romoff also has more than a dozen administrators that take in annual salaries of over $1 million, and according to the city, he has access to a private chef, chauffeur, and a jet, as well as one of the most expensive office spaces in Pittsburgh.

Professor Martin Gaynor of Carnegie Mellon has published papers on hospitals that enjoy nonprofit status but do not always function like charities.

"There's a lot of concern here in the community," Gaynor told "CBS This Morning."

"They've taken some actions that don't appear to be consistent with an organization whose mission is to benefit the community."

Some of UPMC's funds are directed at facility improvement, but Gaynor has concerns about even some of that spending. He likened the new, state-of-the-art pediatric center to a palace.

"It's a tremendous asset to the community," he said. "On the other hand...one has to ask whether it was so important to make it so beautiful, or whether some of those dollars could've been used to better purpose -- to offer lower prices to members of the community, to offer more charity care."

While nonprofits are required to serve the community, UPMC has closed hospitals in poorer neighborhoods and opened them in more affluent ones, claiming the hospitals they closed were underutilized.

Some of the concerns in Pittsburgh have been echoed across the country. America's hospitals have been growing. The bigger they get, the more power they have -- to set prices and force insurers to pay more. Patients foot the bill via higher premiums, copays, and deductibles. It's one factor behind the nation's increasing health care costs.

"At the end of the day, when hospitals charge higher prices, who pays for them?" Gaynor asked. "Dollar for dollar, the rest of us."

UPMC declined an interview request from "CBS This Morning" as part of this report. After the story aired, hospital spokesman Paul Wood claimed on the radio station KDKA that there is no chauffeur or private chef, and that the local tax break is actually $15 million. Their own website however, references an "executive kitchen," that serves thousands of guests every year.

Hospital spokesman Paul Wood also responded on YouTube to the mayor's lawsuit challenging its nonprofit status. He argued that more than 2 percent of UPMC's budget goes to charity, if research and Medicaid patients are included in the calculation.

;

My "nonprofit" suburban hospital closed and reopened - in the region's wealthiest neighborhood.nm

[ In Reply To ..]
x

Similar Messages:


Will Nonprofit Hospitals Disappear Under Obamacare?Aug 10, 2013
Will nonprofit hospitals disappear under Obamacare? Lewis and Roca LLP D. Douglas Metcalf USA April 1 2013 Author page » It seems everyone has an opinion on Obamacare, officially the Patient Protection Affordable Care Act. The good, the bad and the ugly have been exposed at the individual patient level. But as the January 1, 2014 implementation date approaches, how will the law affect hospitals, and what ramifications will it have on their patients and communities? Some Wall ...

Americans For Prosperity Is A Social Welfare NonprofitMay 13, 2013
I posted a link that was written back in Aug 2012, but it provides a lot of context to the current IRS targeting story.  I'm not by any means defending the IRS.  Targeting based on any predjudice is unacceptable (i.e., churches during Bush Adm that were audited for sermons that were interpreted as anit-war).  I was warned when I itemized one year that claiming a home office was an IRS red flag and to be absolutely within the defiition of a home office because they have progr ...

Home Security SystemsMar 10, 2016
Do you have one? If so, which one? Monthly cost? Would appreciate recommendations. TIA ...

Proud Americans..16 Top Healthcare SystemsJul 04, 2017
Didn't see the US...yeah, neither did I. http://www.businessinsider.com/healthiest-countries-in-the-world-2017-1/#4-japan-the-countrys-life-expectancy-837-is-the-highest-on-the-planet-that-has-caused-demographic-issues-in-the-country-with-its-population-ageing-rapidly-13 ...

The Fix Is In. 16 States Will Use Voting Systems Run By Soros’ Board MemberOct 17, 2016
http://truthfeed.com/breaking-the-fix-is-in-16-states-will-use-voting-systems-run-by-soros-board-member/29891/ HILLARY IS TRYING TO RIG THIS ELECTION BECAUSE SHE KNOWS IT’S THE ONLY CHANCE SHE HAS! ...

Another Quickie. Fave Book? Again, One Title InDec 13, 2010
x ...

Audiophiles! Songs With Numbers In The Title!Apr 18, 2012
...

Song Or Movie With Day Of Week In TitleApr 18, 2012
cc ...

Name A Song Title With Body Parts In It. Jul 07, 2013
I Left My Heart in San Francisco.  ...

Obama And Melania - Suggest A Title..Jan 23, 2017
...

Your Fave Song? Please, Jusst One Title In Subject Dec 13, 2010
x ...

Movies Or Songs/Mode Of Transporation In TitleMay 02, 2012
nm ...

Movie Or Song With State Or Country In TitleMay 08, 2012
nm ...

Movie Or Song W/animal Type/name In TitleMay 14, 2012
nm ...

Movie Or Song With (don't Laugh) Food In TitleMay 18, 2012
nm ...

In The Ic Room Of HospitalAug 13, 2017
When my mother inlaw in the IC room of the hospital after the by pass surgery,and conected to the oath unit ,the alam sound few times, and the young new RN resetting the path unit, the next bed RN said to her RN,[ it may sound all night, in the field, you need to compromised some time, set at 65,],   any one can tell me what that means?   ...

Songs Or Movies W/Season In Title (Winter, Spring,etc)Apr 20, 2012
nm ...

Rush Limbaugh Taken To Hospital.Dec 31, 2009
HONOLULU —  Conservative radio talk show host Rush Limbaugh was taken to a hospital with chest pains on Wednesday, a Honolulu television station reported. He was seen golfing at Waialae Country Club earlier this week. The country club is next to the Kahala Hotel and Resort.The radio show host had been in the islands during the holidays. Coincidentally, his visit comes at a time when two of the nation's most powerful Democrats, President Barack Obama and House Speaker Nancy ...

I Was Just Discharged From A Hospital Stay AboutSep 14, 2012
an hour ago.  Aside from feeling good to be home, I also feel protected because I have Medicare. If Romney were the president, I'd be out on the street with no insurance for instances like this because he hates Medicare. This is my 14th hospitalization since 2006 for the same problem, which is very painful and caused by a genetic disease I inherited. My disease is incurable. I WILL NEVER VOTE FOR ROMNEY NOR ANYONE ELSE  WHO IS REPUBLICAN. I will always vote my best intere ...

Hillary Clinton In The Hospital?Dec 31, 2012
I guess I've been out of the loop! ...

Seattle Children's Hospital - See MsgNov 05, 2013
Seattle Children’s Hospital ranks No. 11 on the U.S. News & World Report best pediatric hospital list. When Obamacare rolled out, the hospital found itself with just two out of seven insurance companies on Washington’s exchange. Seattle Children’s is the only pediatric hospital in King County, and offers keys services, such as cancer care, which are not available anywhere else in the region. So if you sign up for Obamacare, good luck surviving. Fortunately, that represents ...

Illegal Aliens Taken To HospitalNov 21, 2015
Four hurt in crash near Jamul border checkpoint http://www.cbs8.com/story/30577810/four-hurt-in-crash-near-jamul-border-checkpoint (Sent from CBS 8) Four hurt in crash near Jamul border checkpoint http://www.cbs8.com/story/30577810/four-hurt-in-crash-near-jamul-border-checkpoint ...

Movie Or Song Title Referencing Love Or Term Of Endearment: My One And OnlyMay 10, 2012
/ ...

FIL Is In The Hospital, And It's Just A Matter Of Time Before He PassesMar 25, 2010
He's not on any life support and is resting comfortably. To make a long story short, apparently he ran through all their retirement money and now she has no savings. On top of that, he ran up about $60,000 in credit card bills that she knew nothing about, because the bills were sent to our house.He's been living a pretty secretive live for years, telling her he was working out of town when in fact he was right here in town, but living elsewhere. We don't know where he was living. ...

OMG! Pray For Joplin, MO And Those In The Hospital There Due To TornadoMay 23, 2011
The news said the top two floors of the hospital are gone! Horrible!  ...

Funny Hospital Chart BloopersMay 21, 2010
My sister sent me an email yesterday with these.  I thought you all might enjoy reading them.  I told her this is stuff I get with ASR every day.  I, of course, do not know if they are ASR or not, but it sure looks like a lot of stuff I get on that.  Hope it gives you a smile: HOSPITAL CHART BLOOPERS> (Actual writings from hospital charts)> > 1. The patient refused autopsy.> > 2. The patient has no previous history of suicides> > 3. Patient has left whit ...

Eye-opening Information On Hospital Costs.Jul 05, 2012
I watched Dr. Sanjay Gupta's piece on CNN this week where he was explaining why hospital costs were so high.  Of all the bills collected by the hospital from all sources they only end up actually collecting 4%, that's 4 cents for every dollar billed!  To compensate, they bill accordingly so they come out even or ahead, $800 for a disposable chest tube that in reality costs less than $50 from the supplier.  This was really shocking to me!  To be fair, labor need ...

More Emphasis Being Placed On Multiple Hospital Admits?Jun 13, 2014
I'm an acute care MT. I have been taking notice lately of the emphasis on how many hospitalizations a patient has had within the prior 12 months from the most recent visit. All for seniors (over 60) and seemingly with an effort, urge or suggestion to transition to DNR/DNI status. Are the death panels auditing these hospitals? Is this what was being talked about regarding the ACA limiting how many times a hospital can admit a patient before being penalized? Don't get me wrong, my family ...

Legionairre's Disease In Indiana HospitalApr 04, 2016
This is the hospital I worked in for years. I also was a patient over the years. Sometimes our little hospital has to send people there if they cannot provide the right services (ours a little hospital). Latest on this is that the person got Legionnaire's from the hospital. They were not at all sure of how he acquired it. On the local news, they said no one would say the condition of the man, but that he had been extremely sick. Said the tests won't come back for at least 10 days, ...

Fox Host's Book Title Implies Swift Boat Veterans Were LiarsDec 10, 2009
Conservatives have long railed against media turning 'swiftboat' into pejorative or 'hate term' As former President George W. Bush attempts to salvage his tarnished legacy, Fox News Radio host John Gibson has eagerly joined in the effort to rehabilitate the previous administration's image. Gibson, the author of Hating America and The War on Christmas, has a new book out titled How the Left Swiftboated America: The Liberal Media Conspiracy to Make You Think George W. Bu ...