A community of 30,000 US Transcriptionist serving Medical Transcription Industry

A few thoughts about the political discourse on this board


Posted: Jun 30, 2015

1.   Pigeonholes, prejudices and labels:  It's the natural tendency of the human mind to simplify reality.  This is an adaptive mechanism by which we seek to make sense of a world that is overwhelmingly complex and constantly changing.  Even our physical sensory organs (and their respective brain centers) are designed in a way to filter OUT the vast majority of the millions of bits of sensory data that impinge on us constantly. If not, we'd be so inundated with sensory information that we'd be completely unable to function.  As such, the sensory filtering mechanisms have been given top priority in the chain of processes that, taken together, comprise our physical awareness.  Filtering OUT sensory data has priority.

In the realm of abstract ideas, we simplify complexity primarily by creating mental models.  These models try to explain to ourselves "the way things work."  Models are always incomplete (that's why they're models), sometimes crude (unrefined) - and not infrequently inaccurate, or at least unreliable.

With equal naturalness, because these models represent "reality" for us, we defend them vigorously, and very often with a degree of ferocity and deadly determination that, frankly, they may not merit.  We cannot tolerate threats to our models of reality.  And so, we elevate them to the level of our sensory filtering mechanisms - giving them top priority in the chain of processes that comprise our abstract notions of "reality".

As such, they become filters that are then FURTHER SIMPLIFIED as pigeonholes, or prejudices, and their respective labels - which are often words that have very nebulous meanings ("conservative", "liberal", "socialist", "communist", etc.) - IF THEY HAVE ANY MEANING AT ALL. 

Hang a label on something (an idea or a person) and bada-boom bada-bing, you've explained them - or so your mind wants you to believe.  Reality has been filtered.  The work of thinking has been short-circuited, energy and time saved.  Move on, nothing to see here!

Behind these filters, the world of complexity is reduced to very simple terms - even down to binary terms.  And there's nothing wrong with simple models, per se.  As I said, this is an adaptive mechanism that's evolved in the human brain over eons of time, and even a nodding acquaintance of evolution would suggest that simplification must be highly useful.

The funny thing is, even binary models can lead to different results.  I see lion tracks going this way.  I immediately go the other way as fast as I can.  My model works and I survive.  Another sees lion tracks and follows them.  His model works, and he kills the lion that's been killing his cattle.

Einstein himself advocated simple models - but, as he himself said, the model MUST NOT BE OVERLY SIMPLE.  Put another way, we must remember, with some humility, that we DO use simple models to describe reality, that our models DO have limitations, AND that as such their reliability is NOT to be trusted implicitly.

I see a lot of labeling and a lot of simple modeling on this board - which doesn't surprise me because I know how our minds work (mine not excluded).  But what I do NOT see is much in the way of intellectual humility when it comes to "our" modeled perceptions of reality, almost nothing in the way of willingness to examine our models for their flaws, and absolutely nothing whatsoever in the way of desire to correct, expand or modify our models.

2.  "Special pleading" - unacknowledged limits and limitations:  Every idea, and every ideal, has both logical limits and practical limitations.  We all know this, but some of us conceal these limits and limitations not only in our arguments, but we conceal them from ourselves - and this is called "special pleading" by deliberately ignoring anything that might be unfavorable to our point of view.

Special pleading might seem to make our case stronger, but in fact it usually weakens our position.  Far better is to acknowledge limits and limitations rather than to ignore or, worse, deny them. 

Let's have some honest intellectual humility about our notions of "reality", less pigeonholing and labeling, and more acknowledgment that every position has its limitations - even our own.

3.  Kindness, charity and courtesy:  If you ever, EVER find yourself expressing your ideas in terms which are unkind, uncharitable or discourteous, you need to take stock of both you yourself, and your ideas.

 

 

;

That is a great idea, but have you actually - tried to "talk" to people on this board?

[ In Reply To ..]
I have used many of these ideal approaches and they are met with banal criticism, tangential remarks (I guess that is deflection), and mostly silence.

For the most part the audience does not enjoy the approach you have outlined, apparently.

A nation divided against itself cannot stand basically what you see - on a small scale played out here

[ In Reply To ..]
on a daily basis. The USA is going where the rest of the West is going.

It's a foregone conclusion that America will do all the - WRONG things politically and

[ In Reply To ..]
socially. You haven’t seen anything yet. This is only the beginning.

Similar Messages:


Some Thoughts About This Board, Etc. Mar 18, 2012
I respect everyone’s right to their opinions.    We have a 2-party system in this country, thankfully, although  at times I wish it were more, and if we all thought the same, or weren’t allowed to disagree, we would probably not be living in a democracy.    This is my issue.   When I hear, for example, some conspiracy theory on how Obama’s (or it could be anyone) agenda is to ruin the country, turn it into a socialist state  (wh ...

Messages On The Political BoardMar 27, 2012
Reading through the posts I would like to ask everyone again to please stick to issues and discuss politics and leave out the name calling and insulting.  The posts are getting personal again.  People can get into heated discussions.  That is understandable, but would like to remind everyone this board is for discussing politics, not insulting other posters.  If there is a post that has nothing to do with the topic being discussed, but is just to inflame other posters those ...

I'm Not Sure I Can Handle A Political Board, LOLApr 21, 2011
I always enjoy dropping by here for a break, between tasks. I'm learning that I get cranky about politics. Obviously I need an outlet from stressful work, but I'm just not sure I can handle politics. I'm never cranky around people that I see in person. Why is it so hard to do on forums! I admire those who are able to be statesmanish, even on forums such as this. That is a goal I am setting for myself. ...

Not Political, But Applicable To This Board.Mar 13, 2013
A short article highlighting how rude comments tend to polarize and make people dig into their opinion even more, a phenomenon which we probably all know quite well!     More than 1,000 subjects reviewed the blog post from a Canadian newspaper that discussed the water contamination risks of nanosilver particles and the antibacterial benefits. Half saw the story with polite comments, and the other half saw rude comments like, "If you don't see the benefits of using nanotechnolo ...

Should This Board Be For Political AND Social Issues? Dec 11, 2012
x ...

I've Noticed On This Board Regarding Political TopcsJan 07, 2013
If a conservative posts an article or a concern the liberals will ridicule and make fun of the poster or article instead of ether not contributing or not shutting up (i.e. if you can't contribute intelligently to the conversation then don't contribute at all). The conservatives/indpependents on this board seemt to the be only ones able to handle differences of opinion with intelligent conversations. Conservatives bring up issues that are of real concern.  They are faced with rid ...

Can Anybody Give Me Any Thoughts About Some Health Symptoms I'm Having....any Thoughts Would BeMar 31, 2011
Hello all.  I have been an MT for 20 plus years, yet not being a doctor, I can't seem to put a finger on what may be going on with me, but I do have some ideas.  Ten years ago I had a bowel resection for an obstruction and have since developed 4 massive incisional hernia in my abdomen.  They don't hurt, but occasionally flareup and change and it sends me to the ER everytime because Im afraid they may have gotten incarcerated.  Over the past 6 months I have noticed t ...

To All My Political Friends-not Political But I WishOct 26, 2012
and hope all of you stay safe up and down the East Coast during Sandy's battering. If it's as bad as last year, it's gonna be a lot of trouble for a lot of people. In some places, there are still a lot of leaves on the trees and Halloween last year brings back some ugly memories. Take precautions and stay safe. ...

Do I Have The Right Board? Is It A Politics Board For Adults? (sm)Aug 12, 2012
Oh, teacher, teacher, he was mean to me.  I can't even believe this.  I was going to say a bunch of lightweights, but I'll change to whiners.    Wow. ...

My ThoughtsFeb 12, 2017
He has classic signs of insanity. ...

Thoughts OnFeb 04, 2017
There are actually two things in this article.  I am a believer in the second ammendment and a democrat.  However, I also believe there are people out there who should not own guns.  Perhaps this bill was vague (I haven't seen the actual bill), but I do believe people with severe mental illness with violence tendencies should not own guns. The other issue is the last paragraph:  "The goal of the rule was to minimize coal mine pollutants in waterways and would have requ ...

A Few Thoughts FromMay 16, 2017
see article ...

Some Conservative ThoughtsOct 22, 2009
If a conservative doesn’t like a news organization or a talk show host, he switches channels. Liberals demand that those they don’t like be shut down.  If a conservative decides he needs health care, he goes about shopping for it, or may choose a job that provides it.  A liberal demands that the rest of us pay for his.  If a conservative doesn't like guns, he doesn't buy one.  If a liberal doesn't like guns, he wants all guns outlawed.  If a ...

Some Liberal Thoughts Oct 25, 2009
If a conservative doesn’t like a news organization or a talk show host, he goes on multiple chat boards and blogs and does everything he can to discredit them. Liberals just don't invite them in.  If a conservative decides he needs health care coverage, it is after he has taken advantage of the system by not carrying it; making payments to healthcare providers who are not in the business of lending money, and sometimes he has filed bankruptcy.  A liberal recognizes that eve ...

Your Thoughts Re: DiabetesAug 15, 2011
My mother has type 2 diabetes (uncontrolled because she is noncompliant. ).  I have been experiencing some symptoms that are concerning me and I wondered if I should get tested.  I probably am going to go ahead and call the doctor, but wanted to hear some other thoughts and opinions. #1 I am always thirsty and seem to always have the munchies. #2 I have been having intermittent bouts of nausea and sweating/claminess. #3 Swelling in ankles and feet. #4 ? of blurry vision.  I am ...

Election Day Thoughts ...Nov 02, 2010
I used to vote for who I wanted in office because we had credible, responsible candidates - promising, at the least.  Now I vote to keep out the lesser of the evils. All that aside, my thoughts for the whole nation on any election day: 1.  May we all vote in peace, without threat or harm or intereference. 2.  May all who are able to vote soberly cast their vote. 3.  May we be able to pull together and get behind those who prevail and make the best of the process, regardle ...

Moving ThoughtsAug 02, 2010
Need some advice.  I have a 13 yo son whom I have moved states with a few times.  Everytime I move he comes with me!  We have lived in Wisconsin and Iowa.  He has had to switch schools a total of 2 times.  I have a wonderful opportunity to move out of state and have been getting NOTHING but grief from EVERYONE.  My parents say I am selfsih.  Problem is it is only because I am not DOING WHAT THEY WANT ME TO DO.  If this was their plan it would be different ...

Random ThoughtsJun 01, 2010
I would like to take this opportunity to thank my mother for my oddly longer second toe that sticks out of sandles and peep toes like a monkey's finger.  THANKS MOM!  ♥ ...

2016--thoughtsMay 06, 2015
Just heard prediction there could be as many as 21 Republican candidates.  I wonder how bad they are going to tear into one another.  This has, in the past, made it very difficult for the candidate to recover from some of the accusations.  Of course, depends on the accusation. On the other side, Democrats, with 2, not as certain there will be more.  I think Sanders will argue on the issues.  I think Clinton will give thought to the those issues/accusations and answer.&n ...

Thoughts And PrayersNov 11, 2016
I'm not even sure where to begin.  I have so much anger and frustration inside me right now that I am tense and achy, depressed and sad.  I am isolated from adults, only kids at home since my husband admitted to cheating and moved in with her.  I do go to church; however, everyone at the church knows my husband and me and it is difficult for me to tell them what has happened because he was thought to be such a wonderful Christian man.  Hate the sin, not the sinner.   ...

Random ThoughtsNov 29, 2015
Post your random thoughts here! Doesn't necessarily mean you need to respond to anyone and everyone, you can if you want to, but post whatever's on your mind. My random thought: Post your random thoughts here! Doesn't necessarily mean you need to respond to anyone and everyone, you can if you want to, but post whatever's on your mind. My random thought: Just got home after sitting an hour and a half in a coffee joint to figure out I had my sweater on backwards.  ...

Some Thoughts, Please See MessageMay 20, 2017
I Submit That The Media Be Prosecuted For TREASON, For Creating A Completely FALSE Narrative About Our President Trump. I Have NEVER Seen Such Vitriol & Hatred! We Finally Have A Commander In Chief Who Is Doing GREAT Things To SAVE This Country, Yet All MSM Wants To Talk About Is Impeachment! WHAT A JOKE... What About:1. You said nothing when Obama used drone strikes to execute people abroad.2. You said nothing about Russia for 50 years until Trump was inaugurated.3. You said nothing about H ...

My Thoughts On The Post About The GOP PlanNov 10, 2009
Firstly, I am *not* opposed to a GOP plan - and to be fair I don't have enough details about what it would and would not do (which I plan to remedy).  I read the following post to get more information, but much of it is opinion - or vague -and did not explain how it is better than the current bill(s) under consideration.  Let me be specific:  OP:  This is what I like about the GOP plan:Instead of govt insurance it reforms the system. 1.  How is the "Pelosi's ...

What Are Your Thoughts On This Bill Being PassedDec 15, 2011
could now be in even greater jeopardy of being arrested and imprisoned indefinitely, with no right to a trial?  Pretty scary.  And note, this is neither a Repub or a Dem issue, this is an issue that goes against the Constitution.  Apparently at the last minute, it's being realized that language was taken out of the original bill, clarifying that US Citizens could not just be swept off the streets and imprisoned without due justice and a trial.  Now the ABSENCE of that pa ...

Asking For Some Prayers And Positive ThoughtsMar 24, 2012
I am asking for prayers and good thoughts concerning a possible job opportunity.  I lost my job at the end of February (due to my own stupidity) and have been having a hard time finding work since.  I have applied for unemployment, however, it is the process of being appealed right now, so basically, I am down to nil nothing as far as a cash flow is concerned. At my age (56), I am too old to consider retraining for another career field and I was born slightly cerebral palsied, where s ...

Obamacare Passed . . . What Are Your ThoughtsMar 21, 2010
Well, healthcare (Obamacare) passed. What are your thoughts and how do you think it will affect the healthcare industry from the workers' point of view (not only MT but everyone).   ...

Interested In Your Thoughts/feelings AboutJun 29, 2010
This is not exclusively political, but since it pertains to current national events, I am posting here.  I am interested in hearing any and all thoughts/feelings/ideas/frustrations regarding the Gulf oil disaster.    I myself am stunned that we have been unable to prevent the oil from making land-fall.  I am not a babe in the woods, but I do believe that America brings huge resources to the table in terms of brain power and horse power.       ...

RANDOM SILLY THOUGHTSJul 13, 2010
OMG!! I love the game Bookworm!  I think I'm an addict!  Somebody get me a dictionary, quick!!!!! ...

My Thoughts Non Jobs And Hiring. SmJun 03, 2012
A while back president Obama proposed a small business hiring income tax credit.  Since it still hasn't been voted on, I think small businesses might be holding off on hiring waiting for it to pass so they can take advantage of the credit.  What do you all think?  I am going to write my congressmen and tell them to get this bill on the fast track now when we need it the most.  I think that this is a bipartisan issue that everyone should be able to agree on. ...

Did Anyone On Here Ever Use Bilberry Extract And What Are You Thoughts On This.Sep 23, 2012
I have elevated IOPs and would like to try this. ...